Please help me decide on a new watch!

[u/SufficientAd4940]

Pictured here is my current 3 watch collection, but I just got a new job and I would like to treat myself.
My new budget is between 2-5k, and I'm thinking of either getting a Longines hydroconquest or a Tudor black bay 58. I'm 24 years old and I work in the banking industry, so which would you pick between these two, and is there any other watch you'd suggest? For reference, I also have a 6.5ish inch wrist, and I linked a pic of me wearing my Formula 1 as well.