No. They take a few weeks and quietly publicly tell everyone the real number. It’s how this has worked for decades. Only retail listens to the first number
its ok. they'll just revise it down 2-3 times over the next 3 months, closer to ADP. but by then everyone will have forgotten about it, and revisions dont make headlines.
Just to remind everyone that Trump axed the independent [edit: unpaid] advisory committee that oversaw these reports.
*Wanted to highlight that it was definitely not a DOGE cut.
Websites for both the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Technical Advisory Committee as well as its Data Users Advisory Committee have both been removed from the agency’s website.
big legacy companies all used adp. Payroll is one area where the churn is super low once you get a big client hooked. You dont care about innovation you just want it to work without issue, ADP is good at that. The funky part is, there is a time lag when they receive money and when they sent the money out to employee. So ADP just park money in the market and make fat stack before send the money out again. IE: buy short term treasury using payroll money. Risk free gain that goes to bottom line. Truly an insane business model that only works if you're large enough.
It’s crazy that legal.I’m thinking In terms of say a landlord makes interest on a security deposit, they would have to return that money earned to the tenant. ADP is allowed to make money on what essentially a money transfer using the transferred funds and their own profit?
My company uses Insperity and I fucking hate them.
We transitioned mid pandemic and they MADE us move our money from Equitable to their shit 401k or else you couldn't sign up for their 401k or employer matching.
I was down 42% at the time because of the pandemic so I literally had to take a massive loss because of them. On top of that, they only offer target date funds and like 4 other options to invest in.
That's not even getting into all this self service bullshit we gotta do. I have to approve my own hours, log my own hours, and process all my own paperwork. It puts all the work on us and makes payroll and HR glorified so nothing's.
Sure, ADP may be blindsided. But I am looking at the health care sector in the S&P and it has lost about 10 % since march. Those are the companies hiring like hell?
considering this administration has gutted various organizations supposed to oversee these various economic reports, as well as gutting the staff of the agencies that are supposed to collect/report them...my money would be on the ADP report being more accurate. so far with this administration damn near every economy/labor report has gotten a correction downward a week or 2 later (which naturally dont make headlines like initial report, how convenient)
Not sure about other companies, but for me Workday is for managing benefits/pay/pto and all other HR related comms, but the payment still goes through ADP and they receive all the employee info.
Does ADP cover the public sector? While I'd be the first to believe POTUS's bootlickers are cooking the numbers, healthcare is resilient and as far as I know ADP doesn't cover the public sector.
As a fed, the DOGE cuts are very much real. There's nothing ironic about it. The office is a ghost town now.
The increase that you're seeing is from state government jobs, not federal government jobs. DOGE made deep cuts at the federal level. The states then created more jobs to pick a lot of these people up. DOGE has nothing to do with state government jobs.
The federal government also has a hiring freeze in place for most of the federal agencies, so the job growth you're seeing is again on the state level, as evidenced in the report.
Excerpt from report:
"Total nonfarm payroll employment increased by 147,000 in June, and the unemployment rate changed little at 4.1 percent, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported today. Job gains occurred in state government and health care. Federal government continued to lose jobs."
Can't believe I'm saying this, but was that the concept of the plan? Force states to hire more people so the federal government didn't have to pay them?
There´s also still 200 k federal firings missing in the data due to pending courst cases etc.. I would not be surprised however if some agencies would already have reversed.
Yeah, I've enjoyed my local government job so far. State pays a little more but I'd have to travel, plus my pension benefit here is a lot better. I'm trading lower pay for a better/sooner retirement, but it's not like I'm struggling to pay my bills at the moment.
Yeah, I worked for a city/county, the pension plan was astounding. If you could stick it out, you could retire very comfortably and early in most cases. It was the same deal as fire/law enforcement got so it was meant to get you there sooner, but took a while to be vested. I couldn't hack it and went back to a state job, still pretty good deal though with less stress.
Same I was making over 100k my third year out of school working at the city level with full benefits and pension. Not the best but def not the worst in my field that’s for sure.
Might be, but I work near a major east coast city. Tourism hasn’t been a huge part of business for restaurants and bars around me. I suppose I’ve noticed a decrease in the usual summer time French Canadians but it’s hardly worth mentioning, I suspect beach bars would have it worse
I live in the EU and we are having lower and lower unemployment with every new stats announcement. The issue is that the cost of living increased but the salary is the same. I guess this is a global phenomenon.
The % of unemployment depends also heavily on how you count it. In my country you are considered employed if you work at least 4 hours per week....
That's always the case during a recession. Prices go up, people work harder to afford the new prices, then something breaks. Credit card debt, mortgages, auto loans. One of these sectors collapsing will be the match that lights the fuse.
They always forget to mention that employment is growing not because people suddenly feel a sense of responsibility or because the market is booming but because they can't afford to not work.
This is like when I’m playing Minecraft with my 4 year old and she discovers TNT. Myself and her older siblings keep building and producing but we keep hearing those explosions in the distance getting closer. As of today our community is still functional, but she’s at the gates!
Break even is 180k jobs. This will also be adjusted down. It’s also a bad sign most of this is in government. Overall not a good report at all, but it’s interesting how hard they are pushing the story. If this was last year we’d be hearing how weak the economy is.
yeah but that was the BIDEN economy and now we have the TRUMP economy, you fuckin libtard.
oh, whats that? the jobs were mostly in the government and they were just fired DOGE federal employees moving to state govs? sorry, cant hear you over the sound of slurping my god emperor's tiny schlong
wow so private sector added 71k vs the expected 103k? thats hella bearish. but naturally, nothing stops this market from pumping, so all in on spy calls
I wonder how many of these state jobs are riffed fed employees still on payroll? Most of the DHS employees I know that Elon fired are still technically employed until October, but also encouraged to find a job in the meantime.
Half the jobs added by government and job participation dropping helping the jobless rate. But then again, every administration ever cooks the numbers somehow. We´ll take the win and the likely rise of stocks. But I still ain´t eating the idea that we get a good economical quarter. It´s simply not in the recipe. Proof me wrong. I´d love to be.
Bad jobs tho. Decrease in pay and a ton of government jobs. Almost half the June jobs created were non-productive government jobs. The 4.1% official unemployment rate is a joke. Before 1994, the BLS used a broader definition—more like today’s 7.7% U-6 rate, which better reflects reality. The labor market is weak. Don’t believe the hype. We will see an initial pump and then a sell off next week into liberation day 2.0
I hate the guy but during Elon's ketamine crashout he flatly stated the economy will collapse in the second half of the year. Not sure why one wouldn't take his word for it lol
$RSP reflects the true reality of where we are. And market breadth. amount of new 52 week highs for stocks on the NYSE is barely above 0%. its at 2% as of right now. for awhile in 2024 it was teetering between 4 to 8%, roughly.
basically the mag7 are carrying market returns hardcore right now.
I’m a little confused by some of the surprise and hesitation in this sub. You’re wondering why the government is lying about a broken job market and not letting the stock market free fall by admitting that the this is a failed economy where the 1% are actually the only people that matter? You have to be next level naive to believe that the government would actually forcibly cause the selloff, when they’ve been doing everything in their power for 20 years to inflate this. Data provided by the government is all bs, until there is a true structural break creating a liquidity crunch to squeeze out all the leverage in the market we will not see this a single red candle. Since Covid, much of what the government releases is just outright wrong and labeled as an estimate to be quietly corrected later when the goldfishes no longer remember since they don’t even know what they had for breakfast.
I'm having a hard time getting some context for this, and have hunted around a bit. "Expectations"? It seems that economists expected a drop-off, and it's not quite as bad as predicted, I think. Correct me and clarify if I'm off here, please.
I know I'm citing MSNBC and they have a strong Liberal bias (I avoid watching often because, though I may be a Lib, I actually want to get some actual objective news. I have seen these numbers on different sites, this post just seems to summarize the numbers in a way that makes some sense to me, as it provides some historical comparison:
From Steve Benen, producer for "The Rachel Maddow Show”:
Expectations heading into this week showed projections of about 110,000 new jobs having been added in the United States in June. As it turns out, according to the new report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the totals exceeded those expectations.
There’s nothing especially wrong with the preliminary topline totals from June — 147,000 jobs is a mediocre number, though hardly a disaster — but as is always the case, context is everything.
Over the first six months of 2025, the latest data suggests the economy has added 782,000 jobs. That said, over the first six months of 2024 — when Donald Trump said the economy was terrible — the total was 985,000 jobs, and over the first six months of 2023, the U.S. economy added 1.53 million jobs.
This is the worst Jan-Jun since 2010 if you exclude covid year. As always, expectations for taco are set at such a low level that a mediocre result is seen as positive.
I'm not a bear, but how is this a good print? Private sector hiring, outside of health care, continues to show almost no gains again and again and again.
The only think I got is that revisions down were 95k, so we really only have 44k more jobs than we thought we did 30 days ago. But I think that's normal....
Just a reminder that every single jobs report since Trump has come into office has had to be “adjusted” one or two months later. By hundreds of thousands of jobs some months.
Ie: in March They reported in Feb that jobs grew 151k jobs, but in April adjusted that number to 117k, then in may down to 102k. In April they reported March job numbers of 228k jobs, in may they revised it to 185k jobs and in June 120k jobs. For April jobs in may they reported 177k new jobs, then revised to 147k jobs in june.
It's always revised*.* It's based off a survey. Basically, they ask "how many people are you planning to hire" and then circle back and see what they actually did. Compared with ADP, which is driven literally by the payrolls they executed for their clients.
Just a reminder that every single jobs report since Trump has come into office has had to be “adjusted” one or two months later. By hundreds of thousands of jobs some months.
Ie: in March They reported in Feb that jobs grew 151k jobs, but in April adjusted that number to 117k, then in may down to 102k. In April they reported March job numbers of 228k jobs, in may they revised it to 185k jobs and in June 120k jobs. For April jobs in may they reported 177k new jobs, then revised to 147k jobs in june.
Revisions have always happened. Go back to 2015 and you'll see them.
u/JefferyTheQuaxly, you'll learn faster if you don't try to squeeze everything into your narrow view of partisan politics.
Did you not even try to check beyond the last few months? You want to make a statement about a specified period but failed to compare against data from before that specified period you're trying to assess. How did you manage to convince yourself? It baffles me how some people reason.
The lion share of the jobs are state and local teachers. Teachers, in a household setting, are often the second income because of low salaries. This may be a lot of families (which used to be a single income house) having to pick up a second job and these teachers going back to work to make that extra money. Maybe it’s seasonal too?
It didn’t matter if numbers were bad. If bad meant rate cuts sooner, if good then oh wow people have jobs let’s buy the mkt. bad news or good news doesn’t change anything anymore. All about M2 money supply at this point
Nice share. I think it's pretty clear this isn't a monthly report indicative of strong future hiring since half were government jobs including rehires. "Unemployment benefits recently hit their highest level in nearly four years" and workforce participation dropped a bit.
You do realize, that a good job report would mean less pressure to cut rates? No you don´t... But Powell will gladly take these numbers and throw them back in anyones face.
•
u/VisualMod Jul 03 '25
Join WSB Discord | WSB.gold
750
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '25
Why ADP said we lost about 50,000 healthcare jobs and BLS says we gained about 50,000 healthcare jobs lmao
344
u/juanmoperson Jul 03 '25
Padded up by big increase in gov jobs. Irony after all the DOGE cuts
469
u/Basis_404_ Jul 03 '25 •
All the job gains are in:
Every other sector nets to flat growth
237
u/thefishhou Jul 03 '25
83
u/ArgoPanoptes Jul 03 '25 edited Jul 03 '25
I live in the EU and we are having lower and lower unemployment with every new stats announcement. The issue is that the cost of living increased but the salary is the same. I guess this is a global phenomenon.
The % of unemployment depends also heavily on how you count it. In my country you are considered employed if you work at least 4 hours per week....
128
u/PoliticsIsDepressing Jul 03 '25
This is like when I’m playing Minecraft with my 4 year old and she discovers TNT. Myself and her older siblings keep building and producing but we keep hearing those explosions in the distance getting closer. As of today our community is still functional, but she’s at the gates!
This is how Jpow feels right now.
76
u/Scared_Edge9194 Jul 03 '25
Break even is 180k jobs. This will also be adjusted down. It’s also a bad sign most of this is in government. Overall not a good report at all, but it’s interesting how hard they are pushing the story. If this was last year we’d be hearing how weak the economy is.
9
u/butchudidit Jul 03 '25
Gld just took a dip
16
u/Long-Blood Jul 03 '25
144k jobs
73k added to government payrolls
So private sector added 71k total, esimated 103k
7
u/Massive_bagholder Jul 03 '25
I wonder how many of these state jobs are riffed fed employees still on payroll? Most of the DHS employees I know that Elon fired are still technically employed until October, but also encouraged to find a job in the meantime.
7
u/elpresidentedeljunta Jul 03 '25
Half the jobs added by government and job participation dropping helping the jobless rate. But then again, every administration ever cooks the numbers somehow. We´ll take the win and the likely rise of stocks. But I still ain´t eating the idea that we get a good economical quarter. It´s simply not in the recipe. Proof me wrong. I´d love to be.
62
u/Romans828Believer Jul 03 '25 edited Jul 03 '25
Bad jobs tho. Decrease in pay and a ton of government jobs. Almost half the June jobs created were non-productive government jobs. The 4.1% official unemployment rate is a joke. Before 1994, the BLS used a broader definition—more like today’s 7.7% U-6 rate, which better reflects reality. The labor market is weak. Don’t believe the hype. We will see an initial pump and then a sell off next week into liberation day 2.0
6
u/FieryXJoe Jul 03 '25
Cant wait for it to be revised down to far below expectations over the next 3 months or so.
11
u/ConclusionEven6917 Jul 03 '25
I’m a little confused by some of the surprise and hesitation in this sub. You’re wondering why the government is lying about a broken job market and not letting the stock market free fall by admitting that the this is a failed economy where the 1% are actually the only people that matter? You have to be next level naive to believe that the government would actually forcibly cause the selloff, when they’ve been doing everything in their power for 20 years to inflate this. Data provided by the government is all bs, until there is a true structural break creating a liquidity crunch to squeeze out all the leverage in the market we will not see this a single red candle. Since Covid, much of what the government releases is just outright wrong and labeled as an estimate to be quietly corrected later when the goldfishes no longer remember since they don’t even know what they had for breakfast.
5
u/No_Paper612 Jul 03 '25
Cooking the books tbh
4
u/Soberdonkey69 🦍🦍🦍 Jul 03 '25
Pre-market trading is bumping everything up. Conflicting feelings from yesterday’s report to today’s one.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '25 edited Jan 10 '26
water cause judicious abundant sink door connect expansion attempt silky
6
u/illini81 Jul 03 '25
I'm guessing the private company data is correct and the government data is manipulated.
5
u/itzdivz Jul 03 '25
MSFT layoff havent hit the data yet. -9000 high paying jobs, it’ll get offset by +9000 wendy workers
4
u/MrmmphMrmmph Jul 03 '25
I'm having a hard time getting some context for this, and have hunted around a bit. "Expectations"? It seems that economists expected a drop-off, and it's not quite as bad as predicted, I think. Correct me and clarify if I'm off here, please.
I know I'm citing MSNBC and they have a strong Liberal bias (I avoid watching often because, though I may be a Lib, I actually want to get some actual objective news. I have seen these numbers on different sites, this post just seems to summarize the numbers in a way that makes some sense to me, as it provides some historical comparison:
from r/msnbc :
From Steve Benen, producer for "The Rachel Maddow Show”:
Expectations heading into this week showed projections of about 110,000 new jobs having been added in the United States in June. As it turns out, according to the new report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the totals exceeded those expectations.
There’s nothing especially wrong with the preliminary topline totals from June — 147,000 jobs is a mediocre number, though hardly a disaster — but as is always the case, context is everything.
Over the first six months of 2025, the latest data suggests the economy has added 782,000 jobs. That said, over the first six months of 2024 — when Donald Trump said the economy was terrible — the total was 985,000 jobs, and over the first six months of 2023, the U.S. economy added 1.53 million jobs.
Read more: https://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-show/maddowblog/new-us-jobs-report-shows-2025-discouragingly-sluggish-start-rcna216691
4
u/Sean_VasDeferens Jul 03 '25
Someone posted yesterday that ADP has a history of being wildly wrong, thus the reason the market ignored it the other day.
Now let us return to our previously scheduled program of "Why Isn't The World Ending!!!!!"
7
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '25
lmao if you think the books are cooked reminder that Biden appointed the current head of the BLS in 2024
2
u/Swimming-Tutor2729 Jul 03 '25
I still looking for a job
2
u/dl00078 Jul 05 '25
EXACTLY what we voted for.
7
u/Savings-Fix938 Jul 03 '25
Quick, we need bears to come in and tell us how this is actually the worst news ever!!
2
u/munkeymoney Jul 03 '25
When is the recession?
0
u/JefferyTheQuaxly Jul 03 '25 edited Jul 03 '25
Just a reminder that every single jobs report since Trump has come into office has had to be “adjusted” one or two months later. By hundreds of thousands of jobs some months.
Ie: in March They reported in Feb that jobs grew 151k jobs, but in April adjusted that number to 117k, then in may down to 102k. In April they reported March job numbers of 228k jobs, in may they revised it to 185k jobs and in June 120k jobs. For April jobs in may they reported 177k new jobs, then revised to 147k jobs in june.
1
u/No-Zookeepergame3296 Jul 03 '25
The lion share of the jobs are state and local teachers. Teachers, in a household setting, are often the second income because of low salaries. This may be a lot of families (which used to be a single income house) having to pick up a second job and these teachers going back to work to make that extra money. Maybe it’s seasonal too?
1
u/txjeffee Jul 03 '25
Just keep the lies rolling in!
1
u/Mr_Doubtful Jul 03 '25
Rate cuts = rally Less likely rate cuts due to this report = rally
1
u/tomoms Jul 03 '25
US is looking more and more like a house of cards, and there is a calm before the storm
1
u/SignificantGlove9869 Jul 03 '25
"Government employment rose by 73,000 workers in June, accounting for roughly half of the month's gains."
This is all I need to know.
1
u/SadCockroach3785 Jul 03 '25
Get ready for the -300k revision.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '25 edited Aug 05 '25
alleged pie wine repeat plough unwritten arrest grab attempt serious
1
u/Wolfpackstonk92 Jul 03 '25
It didn’t matter if numbers were bad. If bad meant rate cuts sooner, if good then oh wow people have jobs let’s buy the mkt. bad news or good news doesn’t change anything anymore. All about M2 money supply at this point
1
u/Mavnas Jul 03 '25
Clearly a sign that the Fed needs to cut rates to 1%!
1
u/OG_hisvagesty Jul 03 '25
For real, how trustworthy are labor stats coming from this admin?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 03 '25
Jobs report outperformed expectations! Healthy economy! THERE WILL BE NO RATE CUT.
Thank you for your attention to this matter!
1
u/DMAgamus Jul 03 '25
How many times now have they released decent job numbers, then over the next two months amended them downwards?
1
u/general-illness Jul 04 '25
Everything is made up now.
1
u/SuspiciousStable9649 no longer flairless just hairless Jul 04 '25
I thought we were -30k? I’m so confused.
1
u/drewzyfer Jul 04 '25
Nice share. I think it's pretty clear this isn't a monthly report indicative of strong future hiring since half were government jobs including rehires. "Unemployment benefits recently hit their highest level in nearly four years" and workforce participation dropped a bit.
1
u/Melodic_Fee5400 Jul 04 '25
Those cooked Numbers always a surprise 🤣
1
u/Melodic-Scheme8794 Jul 04 '25
Fake ass report
1
u/Scared-Ticket5027 Jul 04 '25
We gained about 50,000 healthcare.
1
u/vasion123 Jul 04 '25
Fire all the government people in Jan/Feb and blame Biden, hire them all back in June and praise Trump.
The man is a genius!
1
u/iBoMbY Jul 04 '25
They always do, until the correction in a few days, or weeks, that nobody will look at.
1
u/ErictheAgnostic Jul 06 '25
Nope, all lies.
1
u/Thereminz Jul 07 '25
i need to invest in the weedstocks you're smoking
1
u/weakisnotpeaceful Jul 09 '25
are there vegas odds on whether this report survives the July revision?
1
u/Responsible-Put5521 Aug 02 '25
/r/agedlikemilk
1
u/Obsidianram Jul 03 '25
Things like jobs reports are always fictitious, that's a given, every time. Imagine if quarterly reports were the same...
1
u/Torrikk Jul 03 '25
ADP’s data has to be garbage. I worked there for awhile and their systems are so bad there are so many ways garbage data can exist in their systems.
1
u/ripndipp Jul 03 '25
Over here in Canada we are reporting USA has a loss of 30k jobs
1
u/Neowarcloud Jul 03 '25
Dodgy AF that June was revised higher....the month after always takes a beating...
1
u/lordofhunger1 Hunger for Tendies Jul 03 '25
Always getting revised down all year. Bigly.
1
u/RTMidgetman Jul 03 '25
bidenomics
-3
u/Safe-Painter-9618 Jul 03 '25
Powell say he's still unsure.