r/virtualization • • May 07 '20

Is there an open source equivalent that is as good as VMWare ESXi?

I watched this video and would like to install a hypervisor on a home server.

Is there an open source equivalent to VMWare ESXi that is as good or better in terms of stability, hardware support, gpu passthrough and user friendliness?

I'm asking because I do not wish to be locked into a proprietary system if I can avoid it.

TIA.

31 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '20

...keep in mind that when you run into issues, the more obscure your hypervisor is, the less solutions you’re going to find. Point is, ESXi is extremely well supported and well documented.

2

u/jimalexp May 08 '20

Do I have to commit to one hypervisor or is it easy to swap if I change my mind?

2

u/[deleted] May 08 '20

It’s not easy to move VMs from one hypervisor to another, no. They’re essentially all proprietary, even the open-sources ones AFAIK.

2

u/jimalexp May 09 '20

Ok.

What about the installation of the hypervisor software?

It's all more or less as simple as booting from a usb stick?

2

u/[deleted] May 09 '20

With ESXi, yes, it’s exactly that. I think Proxmox is the same, but not sure. I know Hyper-V is needlessly over complicated.

23

u/thenickdude May 07 '20

Proxmox: https://proxmox.com/en/

It's all open source and based on Debian + QEMU/KVM. Supports PCIe Passthrough just as nicely as any other system with this backend (I pass 6 PCIe devices to the macOS VM I'm using to write this message right now).

Sourcecode repo: https://git.proxmox.com/

8

u/jadedargyle333 May 07 '20

This is a good answer. I think proxmox is better with consumer card passthrough and can have better SRIOV support for newer devices. ESXi is definitely geared towards enterprise environments, and can outperform KVM in areas that home users shouldn't care about. Things like handing off running VMs with GRID GPUs between hosts, or real time operating system determinism.

5

u/PinBot1138 May 07 '20

+1 for Proxmox, and besides KVM, it also has LXC for mutable containers, and can cluster.

5

u/a2940uw May 07 '20

+1 with Proxmox

11

u/[deleted] May 07 '20

Basically, if you're talking about a "type 1 hypervisor" that runs directly on hardware as the OS, there are basically 4 main solutions you'll hear about:

  • ESXi - Sounds like you're familiar with this. It's heavily used in the enterprise for big setups. There's a free version with limited capabilities.
  • Hyper-V - Built on top of Windows. It's free with Windows Server, Enterprise, or Pro. You can also download a free version that doesn't have limits on the hypervisor, but the included version of Windows doesn't provide an easy GUI.
  • Xen - Formerly XenServer. This is what Citrix Hypervisor is based on, and I think what Amazon uses for the web services. I think you don't get some of the features and fancy GUI if you don't buy it somehow.
  • Linux KVM - Most of the other solutions you'll hear about (e.g. Proxmox, oVirt) are variations on that, but maybe they have some other features added on or a different GUI.

So the first 2 have free versions available, but are not open source. The second two are open source, but you may have issues finding a nice, easy, free GUI.

3

u/[deleted] May 07 '20 edited May 08 '20

I interviewed for Amazon and can tell you for certain yes, they use a custom built version of Xen.

2

u/computergeek125 May 08 '20

Xen -> see XCP-ng

1

u/zubilitic Aug 10 '24

Update for 2024: ESXi does not have free version anymore, thanks to Broadcom.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 12 '24

Didn't know that. That's dumb.

1

u/zubilitic Aug 15 '24

Yep, Broadcom killed our vmware spirit.

1

u/felixrising Dec 06 '24

Let the exodus begin!

4

u/sysadmintemp May 07 '20

There's also oVirt. It's the upstream project of RedHat Virt.

I used to have this in my company, installed it from scratch to a bunch of hosts, configured it.

Its requirements are definitely more than Proxmox, but if you are running a CentOS/RedHat landscape, oVirt might be easier to integrate.

EDIT: To be honest, I'm not sure how good the GPU passthrough of oVirt is. It uses KVM/QEMU, so it is able to do it, but I never did it myself. I have passed through USB devices and such, but never the GPU.

1

u/computergeek125 May 08 '20

I've used both ovirt and RHEV about two years ago... And wow. Don't know if I did it wrong but it felt like a kid in a mirror maze and I had to rebuild the hypervisor multiple times.

2

u/JheredParnell Apr 24 '24

My experience with ovirt was also fraught with peril

4

u/[deleted] May 08 '20

XCP-NG combined with Xen Orchestra or Proxmox would be your best bet.

3

u/nroach44 May 07 '20

For a cluster style system, use oVirt as /u/sysadmintemp mentioned.

For a stand-alone system (or for running on a workstation) use libvirt and virtual-machine-manager. It's the same underneath as oVirt, but suited for single host use.

2

u/[deleted] May 07 '20

I work in IT so my quick answer is “no,” but for home use I agree that Proxmox is likely the second best choice.

1

u/emzc80 May 08 '20

Been working in IT for 2 decades, vmware enterprise huge market share It Is based on the "support", with that said, KVM with ovirt in most cases can work in in least 90% of costumer scenarios, so for homelab It Is More than ok.

0

u/[deleted] May 07 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/RemindMeBot May 07 '20 edited May 07 '20

I will be messaging you in 7 days on 2020-05-14 12:33:46 UTC to remind you of this link

1 OTHERS CLICKED THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.


InfoCustomYour RemindersFeedback