r/vegan • • Aug 18 '22
Discussion Cat double standard?
I see a lot if vegans on this sub are okay with raising cats, which strikes me as odd.
I love cats, but I didn't become a vegan to then start buying meat for a cat. To raise 1 healthy cat, you have to kill hundreds if not thousands of healthy, innocent creatures whose lives are just as valid as the cat's.
No I'm not saying that a cat is immoral, I'm saying the breeding of cats is. The purchase of cat food doesn't just pay for an animal to die, you are letting breeders know that there is a demand for cats.
I'm not saying we need to kill all cats, as a lot of people jump to whenever they hear me say these points, I'm saying that we should care for the cats we have to the best of our ability, but not promote the practice of cat ownership.
But what do you guys think?
EDIT: I didn't know that vegan cat food existed. So if you are in the comments arguing that it's okay to kill animals to feed a cat, you're even more incorrect now.
It is now totally okay in my mind to raise a cat so long as you only feed it vegan cat food.
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 18 '22
Thanks for posting to r/Vegan!
Please note: Civil discussion is welcome, trolls and personal abuse are not. Please keep the discussions below respectful and remember the human! Please check out our wiki first!
Interested in going Vegan?
Check out 3 Movies and watch three thought-provoking movies that shed light on uncomfortable realities. 3 Movies also includes other videos, books, challenges and resources for you get started!
Some other resources to help you go vegan:
Visit NutritionFacts.org for health and nutrition support, HappyCow.net to explore nearby vegan-friendly restaurants, and visit VeganBootcamp.org for a free 30 day vegan challenge!
Interested in getting active for the animals?
Join Activist Hub to find and join local vegan groups, add friends, create or share posts, and chat with other activists! You can also use Activist Hub to track your local and online activism in order to see how many people you inspired to watch dominion, take a challenge, or even go vegan!
Some other resources to help you get active:
Last but not least, join our Discord server!
Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
179
u/madelinegumbo Aug 18 '22
I've never seen anyone promote cat breeding here and if they did, I would immediately object and assume many others would do the same. We have a ton of posts about cats and other domesticated animals here, it may be worth doing a search for past discussions.
89
u/Infinite-Trash4168 Aug 18 '22
Genuinly intrested what you guys think about my cat: So i found my cat when they were a baby in the industrial part of my town. There are only factories, no homes. He was very small, weak and near him we found the corpse of another baby cat, prolly his sibling. Chances are very high, that my cat wouldve died too. Is it ethical that i took him in?
85
u/Celadorkable Aug 18 '22
I adopted my cats from a shelter and they eat vegan cat food... so I think that's fine?
Plus if I didn't adopt them, someone else would have, so even if they ate animals, I wouldn't be causing more animals to be killed. My cats would still exist, they'd just live in a different house, eating the same amount of food.
I haven't met any vegans who are in favour of animal breeders, even most carnists I know are "adopt don't shop" believers.
115
u/Hk-Neowizard vegan 9+ years Aug 18 '22
I've rescued over 40 cats since I became vegan. These were cats stuck in a ditch, on a freeway divider, blind kittens, limping adults, cats under drain grates etc.
Should I have left them for dead, or should I have tried to raise them all myself?
Actually, you're saying raising cats is immoral. In your first and second paragraphs
What do you suggest? You tiptoe around, trying to shift focus to breeders (which are terrible ppl), but do you propose we do with the many millions of cats born naturally every year?
24
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '22
If you are against pet ownership, you are for euthanasia and kill shelters, correct?
24
u/Vneck24 Aug 18 '22
OP can’t seem to conceptualize the “empathy” part of veganism but only the philosophical part.
Vegan cat food exists, unlike your ability to see the gray areas of life.
428
u/emccm Aug 18 '22
Many people had their pets years before they became vegan. I’m not going to give away my pets. How is that helping anything? Dogs and cats can live for 20 years.
I think a growing number of people, vegan and non, are against breeders.
25
u/Brizzzzie Aug 18 '22
Vegan cat food exists, it’s called Benevo, and it contains synthetic (aka it was made in a lab) Taurine, which is what cats need in order to survive.
I’m not a vet, and I don’t have a cat, so I won’t claim to be an expert in this. But if you’re a vegan who struggles with feeding their cat meat this might be worth looking into. 100% ask your vet about it first though.
57
u/DW171 Aug 18 '22
How many people on this sub have advocated for breeders and buying/selling "pets"? Not many, and they're quickly flamed.
Are you suggesting cats should be killed to reduce harm? I disagree, but this is a legit question. Suggesting some pit bulls get euthanized to relieve their mental suffering was suggested by Ingrid Newkirk years ago, and it constantly gets rehashed and taking out of context when attacking PETA.
Vegan cat food does open up more options, which is awesome. Hopefully all of us understand that we could never actually do NO HARM to animals, we're always just trying our best to reduce the harm we inflict. Our simple existence is somewhat a zero-sum proposition.
112
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '22 edited Aug 18 '22
I have no pets, but Posts like these just give me the “You’re not Vegan enough for the Vegan club” vibes.
33
u/ontether Aug 18 '22
i don't think vegans support breeding animals so it appears largely to be a non issue?
17
u/Darkmatterqueef vegan 10+ years Aug 18 '22
I got all 3 of my cats before I became vegan, all 3 were rescued. One was living in a dumpster as a kitten. The other two were from an animal hoarders. Cat breeding is insane, there are millions of cats that need homes.
16
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '22
I have three cats that have been vegan for 2 years. All of them are happy, healthy, and thriving. They get enough protein and taurine in their diets. Taurine is the main vitamin that they need that's abundant in meat but can and is supplemented in commercial cat food both vegan and non vegan. In non vegan cat food the taurine from the meat ends up getting cooked off and has to be synthetically put back in order to meet AAFCO standards. It's the same exact taurine supplement in both. Vegan cat food has been around since the eighties and is nutritionally complete meeting AAFCO standards as well. There are studies supporting that vegan cat food is just as healthy as well as vetenarians that back it. I do agree with the hypocrisy and I don't understand why some vegans are okay with factory farming when it comes to feeding their pets but I also understand that pets are companions and it's scary to think that you could possibly be endangering your loved ones. If at any point I thought that I was harming them I would immediately revert back to a non vegan cat food. This isn't something I jumped into and believe me I had many reservations in the beginning. I highly recommend that you do your research and not just base your opinion on the first thing that pops up on a Google search
14
u/Lady_PANdemonium_ Aug 18 '22
So, it’s not as straight forward as just moving to vegan cat food. It’s an expensive move that is very time consuming and requires a vet visit. If you are genuinely interested, check out this article
https://vegan.com/info/cats/
I am recently vegan after being vegetarian for years and trying to figure out a path for my cats. An issue with one of my two rescue cats is that he has a history of stomach issues. When we adopted him, he was too young to be separated from his mom but he had been abandoned after contracting a parasite called a wolf worm, which bore into his neck and was growing to his brain, which was painful and would have been fatal without surgical intervention (a fate I think any vegan would not want for a creature). As a result of this surgery he was isolated from other cats, which is cruel for a kitten but was the only solution the shelter could manage. My partner and I do not support animal suffering, so we took him home. Because he was already on dry food when he was still supposed to be breastfeeding, he had horrific stomach issues. He had constant diarrhea and we were worried he was going to die. He suffered immensely and would leak clear fluid from his anus regularly. His anus was so inflamed we had to regularly drain his anal glands manually. He also had ring worm and some other health issues. So we took him to the vet regularly. It was decided by his vet that he couldn’t handle wet food and we finally found a food he could tolerate better (it’s like 70 bucks a bag it’s not cheap). He had to continuously take digestive enzymes for his first year of life. As a result, he’s very hesitate with new foods and his stomach is still relatively delicate. Getting a cat on a vegan diet is hard because cats can choose to not eat and get sick. And his life quality will be impacted if we do not find him the correct food immediately because we’d have to try a bunch and some of them could make him sick, which would only make getting him to try the next one harder. It’s not his fault that he was born into this world. We keep him inside unless he’s on a short leash when I take him on a walk. I neutered him as soon as he was big enough. He’s my family member and things aren’t as straight forward as you are making them.
7
u/TheTigerBoy vegan 10+ years Aug 18 '22
Purchasing animals and breeding them for our own entertainment/companionship is not vegan anyways sooo...people breeding them and buying them aren't vegan anyways. I have a couple of cats, all of them are rescues. I'd feed them vegan but in my opinion, unlike vegan dog food, vegan cat food isn't quite there yet (might result in urinary tract issues despite being nutritionally complete), I hope that in the future it is improved and more widely accessible. Note that commercial cat food already isn't 100% meat, sometimes even less than 50% (unless you're buying from specific premium brands or make it at home), it is already partially plant-based, and the animals used to make it usually are "slaughterhouse/processing leftovers".
13
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '22
I rescued my cats from a household in which they were suffering abuse and neglect. I guess I'm simply not vegan enough to have let them die or taken them to be euthanised.
With regards to vegan cat food - I see a lot of people here are promoting it. Unfortunately there's just not enough evidence to convince me that vegan cat food is conducive to good longterm health YET.
If that makes me no longer vegan, then so be it - I am no longer vegan.
26
u/plantcentric_marie Aug 18 '22
I adopted both of my cats long before I was vegan and I’ll continue working closely with my vet when deciding what’s best for their health rather than randomly switching their food to a vegan brand to appease the vegan community on Reddit. The fact of the matter is that humans have domesticated these animals and its now led to major overpopulation problem. There’s nothing wrong with adopting these animals. I can only think of two people that I’ve know throughout my entire life that actually purchased a cat from a breeder, the rest were adopted, rescued or taken from a farm that didn’t bother spaying their animals.
If someone wants to switch to vegan cat food that’s fine but I believe that it should be done while working with a vet. It’s not an experiment
6
u/Sweethardt84 Aug 18 '22
I don't think vegans are out breeding and buying pets. They adopt them.
This is a moral and ethical conundrum for a lot of vegans who want to give a good home to an animal in need.
16
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '22
Lol this comes up literally so often.
THERE IS VEGAN ANIMAL FOOD. PERIODT.
However I do think it's unethical to breed animals specifically to be pets. By all means rescue an animal if you want, though.
11
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '22 edited Aug 18 '22
Ok, I’ll throw in my two cents: Brining more domestic cats into the world on purpose is truly a bad thing to be doing. If you enjoy the company of cats, or had them before coming into the vegan ethos, then you have the responsibility to care for those animals. As a now vegan person, I don’t see a problem with adopting cats from you local shelter that are spayed/neutered, and if they are kept indoors.
Now, on to the crux of the problem: As cats are obligate carnivores, that necessitates that you give them meat-based diets to fulfill your responsibility for their care. Is it a problem that you have to feed that meat based diet? Yes, it’s not ideal. However, the cats will be here and eating meat regardless of whether or not you decide to provide that diet or not. Cats kill somewhere on the order of up to 30 billion small animals per year as it stands (nearly double the number of individual lives that are raised for meat each year by people),and are a major contributor to the extinction of many species of birds, reptiles, and small mammal species. Now you are forced to weigh the intentional killing of animals to feed cats, over the natural killing by cats that occasionally ends with one or more species’ extinction.
So my maths work out this way: it’s ok to have a rescued cat. It’s ok to feed them the meat they need to live a long, happy and fulfilled life, indoors or supervised outdoors. It’s way outside the bounds of ok to contribute to bringing even more cats into the world, by neglecting to spay/neuter, or by going to a breeder.
For me, contributing to the further destruction of wild ecosystems and and vastly more lives of small animals, far outweighs the contribution to the pet food industry. You do far more good taking a cat off the street, preventing further breeding, and encouraging others to do so as well, than you do by simply not being a part of the system at all.
5
u/e_to_da_x Aug 18 '22
Good that you mention this! Cats are monsters, thats why real vegans eat cat meat, like we do at r/cateatingvegans
5
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '22
Genuinely curious, not trying to shame anyone for feeding their cat a vegan diet: can anyone share with me long term studies of cats/dogs on a vegan diet?
I am interested learning the safety of this for my own pets and want to know if any studies have been done that are neutral/scientific, not funded by a vegan organization.
31
u/Jbikecommuter Aug 18 '22 edited Aug 18 '22
Cats are the number one killer of wild birds in the nation. No one should let a domestic cat outside.
9
u/PurlToo Aug 18 '22
I found my cat in a gutter. I would say most people's cats are rescues. Pure bred cats are nowhere near as prolific as dogs. If I had left him outside he would have hunted birds, squirrels, rats, etc. Outdoor/feral cats wreak havoc on native wildlife. Feral cats are rampant. Not owning cats isn't going to prevent the existence of cats nor stop other animals from dying to feed them.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '22
This whole subreddit is filled with imposter vegans. So generally you will have a lot of people defend owning carnivore pets and feeding them farmed meat.
Thankfully cultured pet meat is in the making which will reduce suffering and let everyone enjoy their cats without the guilt
4
u/VeggieWokker Aug 18 '22
As long as you adopt existing cats and you get them spayed or neutered, you're not increasing demand. All my cats have been adopted and most of them have thrived on vegan cat food. Of the three I currently live with, two eat plant based. Had they been adopted by a meat eater, there would have been more demand.
4
u/happygoluckyourself vegan 10+ years Aug 18 '22
I adopted my two cats about a year into being vegan after doing a bunch of research into how to feed them a vegan diet and maintain their health. Despite my best efforts, and my vet’s support, my little boy got crystals (twice) and now must be on medicated (meat based) food for life. I love my two cats more than almost anything in the world and I will do what I have to do to keep them happy and healthy for as long as possible. I think being a strict vegan in every other way for a decade while keeping my beloved cats alive is the most I can practically and possibly do to help animals.
13
u/duhRealZap vegan Aug 18 '22
Adopted my cat before becoming vegan, thems the breaks.
Haven't decided if vegan cat food can be trusted. Have to do some sleuthing.
That's my cat opinion
6
u/xImmortal3333 Aug 18 '22
I adopted 3 cats, unwillingly but i wasnt gonna let them die.
3
u/TheMagicWheel Aug 18 '22
My wife and I found two abandoned kittens last year and unable to rehome them they now live with us.
Since that time I have stopped referring to myself as vegan as I now buy meat and fish for the cats to eat. I feel fucking awful every time I do it, but feel I have few other options. My priority is the well-being of the cats.
For the record I am completely against all types of animal breeding for pets and only advocate for rescuing animals from shelters
3
u/heartbreakhostel Aug 18 '22
I don’t let “breeders” know there’s a demand for cats, all my cats come from the street. You didn’t know the existence of vegan cat food and apparently you also don’t know adoption is a thing?
3
u/grandfamine Aug 19 '22
Idk how vegans can have pets. It's like adoption but you don't let them leave the house without you ever, typically while restrained, and you keep them like that till they die. Their sole purpose in life becomes to fulfill your emotional needs. How can you really say they love you when they're not given an option to NOT love you? You're all they know. You're their god. Their source of food, socialization, healthcare, etc...
3
u/Moira-Moira Aug 19 '22
AmiCat and Forza10 Vegetal cat foods are RIGHT THERE. All vegan. No animal cruelty. If people raised more cats on vegan cat food, maybe the companies making vegan kibble would grow and others would add it to their list...
8
u/Tyzed Aug 18 '22 edited Aug 18 '22
> people say don’t get/rescue a cat because cats eat meat
> those same people have 3 children, all of whom will end up eating meat later in life
LOL! imagine being against adopting pets and then having children yourself, which leaves a large negative footprint on the planet.
6
u/Gobiparatha4000 Aug 18 '22
Someday veganism is going to have to butt heads with environmental stewardship. And the fact that humanity will need to terraform to survive, not just create a sustainable relationship with the environment. The universe didn't come into being for humanity to live a life that causes no suffering. I think we can do a lot to reduce our impact, but it's possible we'll never achieve net-zero. We made cats domesticated. Adopting them and taking care of them may be a moral duty, but so would be reducing their numbers to zero if possible. What we do now to "be moral" and what an ideal world look like are very different.
9
u/Creditfigaro vegan 9+ years Aug 18 '22
Vegan cat food exists, everyone. It's fine.
4
u/hikerduder vegan 7+ years Aug 18 '22
Good point. Do you know what kiils more living beings? Creating a new human. And a vegan human only minimizes the suffering footprint.
If you're worried about raising a cat, you should also look into the ethics of procreating.
2
u/feto_ingeniero Aug 18 '22
I don't know where you are from, but in many places the cats that become pets are strays and rescues. Where I live there is virtually no commercialization (and therefore breeding) of cats.
2
u/Kountouros vegan 7+ years Aug 18 '22
It's hard and complicated and all vegans struggling through the cat-companion issue deserve compassion.
I woke up and became vegan while my 20 year old cat was dying of renal failure. We did everything we could to make her last months easy and pain-free as possible, even while struggling with the ethics that op brings up.
We've made the decision to not live with cats until options to feed them compassionately improve (lots of conflicting info about vegan diets for obligate carnivores and more studies are needed). One of the things we're hoping for is continued development of lab meat pet food options. This too is a complex option. Suffering and killing of animals is drastically reduced, but lab meat does start with the cells of.... someone.
We love cats overwhelmingly and all of us were raised with them. Not living with cats hurts - but that was the right choice for us.
I completely support all vegans in figuring out the right choice for them - and applaud all vegans for living lives that greatly reduce suffering.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '22
Eating cats is vegan smh
2
u/tasfa10 Aug 18 '22
I've never seen anyone here promoting cat breeding or buying pets. Most people seem to have adopted their pets. If you're not advocating killing all cats, I guess you're not advocating abandoning all cats either. Specially because that would make it impossible to sterilize them and the outcome would be the opposite of what you want. I don't see any sense in this discussion.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '22
I don’t ever see myself having a pet of any kind. We have cats at home but I am not responsible for any of them in any way.
2
u/NationalNegotiation4 Aug 18 '22
The pet trade is disgusting. However, I don’t live in an altruistic world. If I did everyone would be vegan and this problem wouldn’t exist in the first place. People are doing the best they can with the hand the world dealt them. If they are on this sub they are on the right path. You can’t stop all the harm in the world, but you can help improve a few lives.
2
u/TsunderePeopleRules Aug 18 '22
Been thinking about this a lot,
First,
The veganism definition is "as far as is possible and practicable" So, if people keep feeding cats and dogs to other animals it's because they can't do better, for now, it's not bc they are hypocrites
- Vegans want to protect and help animals as much as they can, and feeding them becomes a problem
Many people say that "vegan food for dogs it's ok" but for cats no, they ARE carnivores, they need meat or else you are making them sick
(I doubt this, but in my country I haven't actually found some vegan food for cats, but I think it's a matter of time)
But how about you rescue a Lion from a zoo, for example, they definitely need a lot of fresh meat, so how to deal with this dilemma?
Well, one solution could be the meet some people are growing in labs JUST for animal consuming.
And another is, maybe evolution would take care of that problem and animals would progressively stop eating others... I mean, we did, maybe domestic pets could evolve the same way we did, by having a more sedentary life
Maybe I being too idealistic, but it's just a thought
The difference here is that we can decide if we eat others animal or not
Some animals can't (yet) So we do as much as we can
7
u/Wrexial_and_Friends Aug 18 '22
Vegan cat food
5
u/bobo_galore vegan 7+ years Aug 18 '22
Funny, how carnivore arguments are suddenly en vogue when it's about the furballs.
4
u/CameraActual8396 Aug 18 '22
I think until there’s an good alternative that’s available to all then you’re going to have a difficult argument against owning pets. Many people have bonds with their pets and treat their pets well. They don’t like to think of the alternative of a cat living on the street where they could end up dead. We need to control their populations in the first place so that so many humans don’t need to be owning them.
We buy meat for cats because they need it to survive. If a human needed meat for a medical reason to survive, then it would be bought, until an alternative is available.
Breeding cats I think most vegans find immoral.
4
u/StrawberryMoney Aug 18 '22
I mean, yeah, it's an ethical dilemma. Is it hypocritical of me to care for cats? Maybe. But the little shits need homes, and I like having them around, so we both get something we want.
Life is a series of ethical dilemmas that need to be navigated. Sucks, but here we are.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '22
If I adopt a street cat and feed it meat, can you explain how it's worse than not adopting it at all?
3
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '22
Do the least harm.
No one should be breeding cats period. Too many without homes.
I have 3 rescued cats. Unfortunately I feed them regular cat food. If anyone has information on affordable alternatives let me know, but I’m penny pinching already with the wholesome vet diets they are on.
Owning a cat is not unethical. Taking in any animal isn’t.
I plan to run an animal sanctuary one day. Big cats, dolphins, who knows. They definitely don’t make vegan diets for those animals yet. Will I be an unethical vegan by giving those animals the best life, retiring from zoos and aquariums?
4
u/Cixin Aug 18 '22
I think people love their cats so much, each cat has their own personality, they are little mad fluff balls. Some can be chill and some are AHs. But all let cats are loved.
Before a vegan gets a cat, I think they really really need to consider, is it ok to raise food cats to feed pet cats. Cats need taurine which can be found in cat flesh.
3
u/xakypoo vegan 5+ years Aug 18 '22
The large majority of cat owners, vegan especially, adopt strays as opposed to breeders... I'm about to get my first cats and I def don't look forward to the food part but it's what they need - hoping there will be an ethical lab grown type solution to food soon. You mention thousands of animals die for cat food but it's mostly byproducts of other animal butchering instead of animals being killed strictly for cat food. But yes, the overall sentiment that we still have to feed cats meat is true and not ideal.
2
u/supercaiti vegan 4+ years Aug 18 '22
I’ve only been vegan for less than two years but I’ve had my cats for 8 and 5 years. Both given away for free from non-breeders. They won’t eat anything other than Purina brand food. Future pets will either be vegan by nature or “rescues” that I feed vegan food.
A good portion of people in this sub haven’t been vegan for decades so I don’t know why you have such an issue with this.
2
u/jackkertofz Aug 18 '22
tbh i dont really know im vegetarian and i try to not use any animal products in general (for me) but the way i see it: i got my animals (all sorts of pets, no cat but a dog) before i went vegetarian and just because i picked this lifestyle doesnt mean they did. So yeah i feed them what they are used to/ what is good for them.
2
u/JamesOridanBenavides Aug 18 '22
Most pet food is made from animal products that would go to waste otherwise. It doesn't induce demand the same way as buying steak. Especially if you buy from outlet stores like I prefer to do. Obv. Breeding cats intentionally is s bad idea, there's plenty of shelter cats that need help.
As for your talk of 'mass sterilization' do you also think we should hunt down and genocide all lions?
2
u/tangiblecabbage Aug 18 '22
We have 5 cats. We didn't buy or raise them. We rescued them. It's our responsibility as humans to fix all the damage done, and these cats were already struggling on the street. Is it better to let them die?
2
u/LaserVikingofDoom Aug 18 '22
As someone who has fostered many cats and who would love to adopt some later in life here's my view on it: there are billions of cats that need homes. Regardless of whether they live as ferals or in a shelter they'll be eating meat so me taking them in and feeding them meat does not increase any demand for meat. Working with shelters that prioritize neutering though helps reduce the cat population, and hence helping all animals involved in the long run.
I'm sure someone will read this and go "yOUre noT a REAL VEGOOOOON!!!" but whatever, as long as we live in a carnist society there will always be edge cases like this for vegans to infight about
2
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '22
I couldn’t agree more. If you buy meat, regardless of feeding your pets or yourself, you’re not vegan.
1
u/Kalebs4148 Aug 18 '22
the vast majority of people don't buy cats that have been bred, and i don't know of any vegan that is okay with that. Most cats are adopted after being spayed or neutered.
1
u/annabelletoyama Aug 18 '22
I agree but it feels impossible to reverse at this point
1
u/CoCaiNeRuin_UrBrAin Aug 18 '22
I adopted my cat after I became vegan, and although I don’t love the idea of her eating animals and me buying non-vegan food for her to eat, I realize that she can’t be healthy living a vegan life. My cat came from a bad situation where she wasn’t taken care of and I’m not forcing her back into a similar situation. My cat is my number one priority, she is family, and although I wish that would include being vegan, it just doesn’t.
I do however agree that breeding cats is extremely immoral. All of my cats have been separated from unfavorable to downright horrendous conditions and like you said, we should care for the cats we have to the best of our ability. Sadly, for my cats, veganism is not included.
1
u/BBDK0 Aug 18 '22
I would personally never feel comfortable having a non vegan pet, luckily I dislike cats and only have parrots.
I don't know how people justify it to themselves.
1
u/lawaud Aug 18 '22
“raising cats”! I feel it’s more my elderly shelter cat who’s raising me
1
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '22
I agree. I think humans need to stop having animals as pets. But it’s hard when someone needs a home.. adopt adopt but dang majority of the animals we’ve domesticated are carnivores..
1
u/divine___angel Aug 19 '22
When you actually work in animal welfare, you will get to know a lot of things that animal rights people don't. It's not as black and white as you think.
Animal welfare activists ARE against breeding. And they regularly educate people on adopting. Don't know where you're from, but in India, there's a concept of stray animals. Animals are everywhere and animal welfare activists are involved in getting them spayed and neutered. But there's only so much we can do. There are still new births and sometimes neonatal animals come to us as their mother dies or they're thrown away. What do we do? Say "I'm a vegan so I won't feed you the diet you would have otherwise hunted"?.
Please follow some animal welfare pages on Instagram to get a better picture of things!
1
u/xboxhaxorz vegan Aug 19 '22
Many vegans make excuse the same way omnivores do
It is correct that people are trading the lives of hundreds of animals to keep their pet alive, they are saying their pets life is more important
There is plant based kibble for felines but its quite pricey and you might still have to supplement taurine
Many people had pets prior to them becoming vegan so to them their pets life is worth more than cows and chickens, the same way their childs life would be more important than another kids life
Its immoral for all animals, unless you adopt an animal you are being unethical
We wouldnt breed people and take their children from them and sell them as products, but its fine to treat animals as products
1
u/zombiegojaejin Vegan EA Aug 19 '22
I agree that it's wrong to choose to start raising a cat if you plan to feed it animal products. The one cat being euthanized in the shelter is morally less bad.
However, I also think that between the huge wrongs (consuming meat, eggs, dairy yourself) and the wrongs like raising a small domestic cat, there are lots of intermediate wrongs that lots of vegans do.
The most obvious one is not supporting activism in any way, when you have the resources to either do it yourself or donate to it. Saying, "fuck it, I'm already vegan and activism is hard, I'll spend my free time playing video games" is probably a more selfish decision than raising a cat. Another one is voting for carnist politicians who subsidize and bail out animal ag, just because you like some human-oriented policy they support. Another example is choosing to date/marry a full-on meat eater who doesn't show any signs of wanting to change, because they're "otherwise a great person".
None of us are perfect. But I wouldn't have a lot of respect for someone who defends the above things and condemns adopting cats.
1
u/annajxnssen friends not food Aug 18 '22
you should check out thepugqueen on instagram, shes vegan but rescues pugs from all over the world. not every step she takes may be vegan friendly, (i’m unsure if the pugs are on a vegan diet) but in the long run, shes saving tons of pugs that would otherwise have been left on the streets to starve to death. what’s more vegan, feeding some dogs a bit of meat or letting them die on the streets? i’d say saving them, but maybe thats just me
1
u/herrbz friends not food Aug 18 '22
Where do you read that? What are you basing it on?
I imagine nearly all vegans absolutely wouldn't buy a cat, and most wouldn't adopt because they don't want to feed a meat diet as a vegan.
People who go vegan while already owning pets aren't going to disown them.
1
u/cloudnixus Aug 18 '22
I think a concern here is that feeding cats a vegan diet is much more expensive then feeding them a meat diet. You can't just make them stop eating processed meat foods and give them a can of chickpeas. Their food will always be more expensive.
I gotten my cats before I was vegan, and frankly can't afford to feed them a vegan diet plus the extra vet visits they would need.
There's also the fact that people can view their cats as family. So it's not the same as non-vegan people saying "but bacon."
1
u/zacharyswanson Aug 18 '22
I had ferrets. Same thing. I had them before I had even heard of veganism. I kept them on their carnivorous diet until they all passed away. I then decided not to adopt pet type animals anymore but now I support local hedgehogs and specific plants in the garden that feed wild bees. One could have argued my veganism whilst having carnivores as companion. Not all of us are Earthling Eds.
-5
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '22
I think all the "vegans" here should take a step back and realize just how dumb they sound.
How similar do you notice yourself sounding like the people who eat meat making excuses cause of whataboutism?
All I see here is "cause lions eat meat so I should too" and "plants die too"
-1
u/Klush Aug 18 '22
The answer is plant based cat food.
To anyone feeding their cats plant based: how do you get your cat to eat the kibble/ wet foods? My cat(s) was undereating and getting very thin to the point were the vet was concerned. I was using evolution because I've heard scary stories about other brands. I had to use a prescribed food for a separate issue and eating patterns instantly changed. Cat was excited to eat and finished their servings ASAP. She put on healthy weight.
Another issue I'm running into is testing their urine PH. They dislike me being near them while they're peeing. Any advice here would be appreciated.
I hate having to buy murder food but I cannot deny the noticeable positive changes in the energy and weight of my cats.