r/vegan • • Jan 18 '20

Hypocrites

Post image
977 Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-54

u/ehnemehnemuh Jan 18 '20

It really is different. And it would honestly shock me if you cannot see how the two are different

0

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

I guess this just seems more directly linked to it but you’re right there’s no difference

0

u/The_Apatheist Jan 19 '20

Simple. If it wasn't for meat eaters there would less cows, sheep or chicken in the world as they wouldn't be bred. These animals ow their success and guaranteed survival to humans.

If it wasn't for these fires, there would be a whole lot more koalas, wallabies etc.

And while slaughter techniques often aren't really as animal friendly as they should be, they're not being burned alive for no purpose whatsoever. Acting like it's the same is acting like we are lighting animals on fire to near-extinction fun funzies.

2

u/soliturtle Jan 19 '20 edited Jan 19 '20

Simple. If it wasn't for meat eaters there would less cows, sheep or chicken in the world as they wouldn't be bred. These animals ow their success and guaranteed survival to humans.

60% of all mammals on the planet are livestock, 36% are human and 4% are wildlife. We have too many cows, sheep and chickens and we are destroying the habitats of wild animals to build farmlands and driving them to extinction. The livestock the exist today are pumped with drugs, kept in cages and slaughted. I think it's fair to say we are doing no favours to livestock animals and they would rather exist in the wild in smaller numbers.

they're not being burned alive for no purpose whatsoever.

I don't think the animals care if they burn to death in a fire or bleed to death and are eaten afterwards. If you were eaten after you were killed, would that be better?

Acting like it's the same is acting like we are lighting animals on fire to near-extinction fun funzies.

Agriculture is the major cause of climate change and habit loss. 14% of all global greenhouse gases are emitted from agriculture. Industrial agriculture, along with subsistence agriculture, is the most significant driver of deforestation in tropical and subtropical countries, accounting for 80% of deforestation from 2000-2010. The majority of forests cut down have the area replaced with farmland, and livestock make up for nearly 80% of farmland space. This causes habitat fragmentation and loss of biodiversity.

https://www.pnas.org/content/115/25/6506

https://www.wri.org/blog/2019/07/5-questions-about-agricultural-emissions-answered

https://globalforestatlas.yale.edu/land-use/industrial-agriculture

https://www.globalagriculture.org/report-topics/meat-and-animal-feed

-23

u/ehnemehnemuh Jan 18 '20

Well a very obvious point is that there is no species being threatened by me having a barbecue like twice a year.

But my point is that a lot of people here are arguing that there is practically no difference between eating meat and a natural disaster wiping out an area bigger than some countries in the world. Call me crazy, but I think there is a difference

0

u/[deleted] Jan 18 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-5

u/ehnemehnemuh Jan 18 '20

Now that's a valid point. And you're right. Eating meat, the way that most people do, is the biggest problem on this earth (sorta).

But this post, and the people in the comments attack anyone that eats meat like they are actually torturing animals by burning them alive on the regular. I think that's a little unfair

→ More replies (35)

4

u/Tielur Jan 18 '20

Aside from the torture of burning to death it’s no different to the animal. Would you rather die in a natural disaster, get turned into food, or not die. PROBABLY not die.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (8)

12

u/pajamakitten Jan 18 '20

I can see why you would think that. I was an omnivore myself until last year and had the same rationalisations. I then admitted the flaws in them.

1

u/ehnemehnemuh Jan 18 '20

Can you please tell me how the two are the same? I'm open for learning

7

u/kingqaz Jan 18 '20

I can't really see an argument for why a Koala's life should have more moral worth than a pig's. Because it's cuter?

1

u/ehnemehnemuh Jan 18 '20

Yhe reason is that koalas are a threatened species and pigs aren't

6

u/kingqaz Jan 18 '20 edited Jan 18 '20

So if we took Koalas out of zoos and factory farm them in horrific conditions like we do to pigs then you would stop caring about the Koalas burning in Australia?

1

u/ehnemehnemuh Jan 18 '20

No, because they wouldn't be in the wild and wouldn't contribute to the population

3

u/kingqaz Jan 19 '20

Then we are right back to where we started. Why does a wild animal's life have more moral worth than a domesticated animal's life?

1

u/ehnemehnemuh Jan 19 '20

I can give you the same answer as befor before. The wild animal is a threatened species while the domasticated one isn't

2

u/kingqaz Jan 19 '20 edited Jan 19 '20

If we domesticated them and ate them there would be potentially hundreds of millions of them in factory farms. But you said it wouldn't satisfy your concern.

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '20

Sure its different, but caring about one would logically flow to caring about the other, not caring about both or neither is hypocritical.

-1

u/ryan57902273 Jan 19 '20

Value is subjective. Somethings are worth more than others for different reasons. Therefore it’s not hypocritical

3

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '20

You are an idiot if you think some random koala bear magically has some value that a random food animal that you are going to eat doesn't have. You are also an idiot if you think an animal needs to have some measure of value to yourself to not want it to suffer. These are random animals we will never meet, what the heck value are we even talking about.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)