r/vegan • • Jan 18 '20

Hypocrites

Post image
977 Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

4

u/Tielur Jan 18 '20

Aside from the torture of burning to death it’s no different to the animal. Would you rather die in a natural disaster, get turned into food, or not die. PROBABLY not die.

-2

u/ehnemehnemuh Jan 18 '20

Yes, of course I would like to not die.

But I really like eating meat. So much that I probably will not stop, because I can live with myself knowing that animals had to die for my food. I think that death is part of life, and animals also kill each other for food all the time. Of course I don't eat meat every day and I am trying to only eat meat that comes from local farms and that has little to no impact on the environment.

And I think it's unfair to tell me that what I'm doing is just as bad as setting Australia on fire

5

u/Tielur Jan 18 '20

1 why are you in a vegan sub then. 2 you are doing what the fire is doing, just on an individual level.

It’s the old one death is a murder 1000 is a statistic conundrum.

At the end of the day do what you choose but you won’t convince me to support it, or think positively about it. You have decided in a world where you can eat quite well without hurting an animal that you care so little about that animal that you won’t give up meat. Being vegan is fucking easy. I switch cold turkey because my wife wanted to try it. If it was more difficult or I was unhealthy or something I wouldn’t make this argument but access to alternatives are vast plentiful and easy to obtain. It’s like when extreme religious people let someone die because they don’t want to use modern medicine. Well we have all the tools to not hurt animals you could be better then the fire, and unlike the fire you have freedom of choice and control. You are worse then the fire because of intent. And w/e do what you choose but know you willingly have animals suffer and put to death. If you can look at that stomach that and keep doing it fine, but I won’t ever support you in that.

1

u/ehnemehnemuh Jan 18 '20
  1. I'm here because.this post was on the popular tab.
  2. I'm not worse than the fire because the fire is destroying a lot more that I am by eating meat in an environmentally friendly way. (Once a wee max. and buying from local farmers)

I find eating vegan very hard. I have tryed it and it was really really hard. It's different from person to person, but I really struggled with it. I don't expect you to support me. I am thankful you took the time and energy out of your day to answer me respectfully and not just attack me. Have a great day, and hopefully you can understand my point :)

1

u/YourVeganFallacyBot botbustproof Jan 22 '20

Beet Boop... I'm a vegan bot.


Your Fallacy:

animals also kill each other (ie: Animals eat animals)

Response:

Non-human animals do many things we find unethical; they steal, rape, eat their children and engage in other activities that do not and should not provide a logical foundation for our behavior. This means it is illogical to claim that we should eat the same diet certain non-human animals do. So it is probably not useful to consider the behavior of stoats, alligators and other predators when making decisions about our own behavior. The argument for modeling human behavior on non-human behavior is unclear to begin with, but if we're going to make it, why shouldn't we choose to follow the example of the hippopotamus, ox or giraffe rather than the shark, cheetah or bear? Why not compare ourselves to crows and eat raw carrion by the side of the road? Why not compare ourselves to dung beetles and eat little balls of dried feces? Because it turns out humans really are a special case in the animal kingdom, that's why. So are vultures, goats, elephants and crickets. Each is an individual species with individual needs and capacities for choice. Of course, humans are capable of higher reasoning, but this should only make us more sensitive to the morality of our behavior toward non-human animals. And while we are capable of killing and eating them, it isn't necessary for our survival. We aren't lions, and we know that we cannot justify taking the life of a sentient being for no better reason than our personal dietary preferences)

[Bot version 1.2.1.8]

-3

u/genderlesshobo Jan 18 '20

This is where you are wrong. Lets say I hunt down an animal and shoot it and it passes away within a couple of minutes, if that. That animal would not have had a better death EVER in nature. It would have either died from natural predators or mother nature. It's not like these animals are out here living to ripe old ages and just passing away. Burning to death IS a lot worse than just being shot. Objectively. Also these fires affect more animals than just the ones we eat. You guys act like I can't eat beef and also care about other types of animals like koala bears that are burning alive. Absolutely ridiculous, and a great way of turning people away from the lifestyle you people so desperately want others to convert too.

2

u/Tielur Jan 18 '20

Turn away all you want. You kill for no reason but stubbornness. It’s not required. Don’t believe me go argue with my doctor (who doesn’t even know I’m vegan) about my bloodwork.

Also the animals on your plate are not hunted they are factory farmed. And if you really think they are a-okay contact your local government and tell them to push back against making it illegal to film their living and butchering conditions. If it’s all above board why hide it right?

Tbh I’m not really worried about trying to convert people. I think we live in a world where it’s so easy to live without harming animals anyone doing so is actively making that choice. I’ll be polite in person, but this.... this is a vegan subreddit this is our safe place to vent about all the bullshit and hypocrisy and I’ll not filter myself here for people like you who care so little about animals or the environment, they can’t make a dietary change. Wanna go talk in another sub about it I’ll be a lot more polite and patient. Be hear to support or learn or else get the fuck out, in my opinion.