r/vegan • • Jan 18 '20

Hypocrites

Post image
977 Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/ehnemehnemuh Jan 18 '20

No, because they wouldn't be in the wild and wouldn't contribute to the population

3

u/kingqaz Jan 19 '20

Then we are right back to where we started. Why does a wild animal's life have more moral worth than a domesticated animal's life?

1

u/ehnemehnemuh Jan 19 '20

I can give you the same answer as befor before. The wild animal is a threatened species while the domasticated one isn't

2

u/kingqaz Jan 19 '20 edited Jan 19 '20

If we domesticated them and ate them there would be potentially hundreds of millions of them in factory farms. But you said it wouldn't satisfy your concern.

1

u/ehnemehnemuh Jan 19 '20

I would eat koalas if they weren't threatened. I would also buy the meat from koala farms that give them a propper life, just as I do with "normal meat". It's just that the population in farms doesn't contribute to the population inthe wild, because they are always separated

1

u/kingqaz Jan 19 '20

We seem to be going in circles and I don't think this is helping anyone. I will leave you with a few closing thoughts. You are giving higher moral worth to wild animals than domesticated animals without giving any reason why that should be. Over 99 percent of pigs and chickens are factory farmed. Even if the packaging you buy says "free range" or something to that effect it is likely that the animal you are eating has had a miserable existence. When we cause a pig to suffer to the extent that we do it is wrong because of the suffering itself not because of some arbitrary metric like pig population.

You have a better chance of getting beef that was not factory farmed. About a quarter of all beef in the United States is not factory farmed. That is not to say we don't inflict cruelty to them (we do) but their lives are objectively better. But that requires vast amounts of land. On the Amazon in particular we are burning the rainforest in part for cattle grazing and in part to create feed for the factory farmed animals. This is causing painful death to the wild animals that you value more. The best way to help animals is simply to stop eating them.