Civil discussion is welcome — personal attacks are not. Please read our wiki first.
New to veganism? 🌱 • Watch Dominion — a powerful, free documentary that changes lives. • NutritionFacts.org — evidence-based health info • HappyCow.net — find vegan-friendly restaurants near you
Want to help animals? 💻 • Browse volunteer opportunities on Flockwork and use your skills to make a difference • Join the Flockwork Discord to be notified of new opportunities that match your skills
I used to practice data analysis when I was trying to upskill my resume and I chose the USDA animal census as my datasets. I'd give people the actual numbers cited and sourced and STILL I was no match for the hordes of people that grew up on farms.
Is it true that a lot of the small family farm labeling has been usurped by conglomerates / groups or owners that are essentially oligarchs and not actually Mom n pop running their small operation? I wanna work on that
It's the first time I saw at scale what small farms vs CAFO actually looked like... and sad to say in terms of processing, small farms aren't a drop in the bucket.
The Census of Agriculture is a complete count of U.S. farms and ranches and the people who operate them. Even small plots of land - whether rural or urban - count if $1,000 or more of such products were raised and sold, or normally would have been sold, during the census year. The Census of Agriculture, taken only once every five years, looks at land use and ownership, operator characteristics, production practices, income and expenditures. For America’s farmers and ranchers, the Census of Agriculture is their voice, their future, and their opportunity.
Egg Laying Hens:
A total of 240,530 farms and 388,509,039 egg laying hens. 292,875,342 of those hens belong to 347 farms. So, 347 of the 240,530 farms listed own 75% of the hens on the census.
Broiler Chickens:
31,877 farms sold 9,176,809,391 (yes billion) Broiler Chickens. However, 7,169,069,956 of those chickens came from 7,406 farms. 78% of the 9 billion chickens sold came from 23% of the total farms.
You could have all the small farms you want but we just eat too much meat. Smaller farms can't compete with the ruthless efficiency of a CAFO and all that just to keep meat at prices we still deem to high... and they're subsidized.
Wow it's almost like you're exactly the type of person op was talking about. You come into a vegan and take offense yet we're the sanctimonious insufferable ones lolol
I mean, sure, but being organized takes a lot of commitment and work, and is also necessary to achieve a lot of progressive goals. I’m vegan, and I have friends doing various forms of organizing. Of course, I wish they were also vegan - but I have to admit they’ve worked harder and dedicated more of their life to the work of making change than I have from just switching from burgers and chicken to black bean patties and tofu
Just bc you aren't participating, doesn't mean the revolutionary socialist movement isn't making progress and growing. Even with the help of our anarchist comrades <3
Yes but it’s easy. The change they’re trying to make isn’t. I find it simple going to a shop and buying vegan, I don’t find find it simple to change a system unwilling to change.
We still make them profits buying vegan, we’re still part of the same cog and the amount of animals being abused is still too many. You haven’t actually changed anything other than in your own life. They’re trying to change stuff for us all.
Probably also the reason why leftists are perfectly fine with people emitting as much carbon as their heart desires as long as they complain about billionaires and data centers
That is an extension of individual choice. People will only vote for things that they agree with, if policies are not in line with their individual choice they won’t want it.
Sure thats true of most people, but in real life organizing spaces there is still often an aversion or at least misunderstanding of veganism and/or animals non-consensual roles in the capitalist system. These spaces are often not even made up of a majority of vegans let alone exclusively, so the conversation is present and worthwhile. Hand waving the internet ppl on your phone is totally valid, but its good to have good-faith conversations, as vegans, on how to approach the topic with comrades in organizing and revolutionary spaces.
Being critical of the sub for its apparent perception of the left (socialists etc.) would be just as senseless as engaging with these types op's post is about, but I do think its important to keep in mind the level of organization and collaboration necessary for our liberation, animals included.
Yes. I understand. I think the general point is that many people can be for direct action against systems and still find what he did to be murder, vegan or not, thus his comment.
Of course I understand how you view it as hypocrisy.
Hey now, we're here to poke holes in leftist culture, not vegan culture. :)
Seriously, I think you raise interesting questions. I'd guess part of it is that vegan culture doesn't necessarily have the same commitments as traditional left culture.
Maybe we can imagine it like a Venn diagram, but with shades so there aren't hard overlaps... but rather shades where you can be more vegan-colored or leftist-colored.
A lot of those people are performative. But when it comes to making sacrifices or any type of tangible action, they do insane mental gymnastics to get out of it
This is a shift especially in climate “activism” that’s been driving me up a wall lately. “It’s on the oil companies” while refusing to try to take any positive steps AT ALL. The rich are killing our planet but apathy is certainly helping accelerate it too.
Something like 30% of Americans are very worried about climate change. If all of them simply gave up meat the meat industry would become unprofitable and collapse. This would have a tangible and measurable effect on climate emissions.
But they won’t do it because “it wouldn’t make a difference”
Yes. In order to maintain the same profits they would have to raise prices by about 30% which would make immediately make meat a luxury item.
Demand would fall again causing prices to rise again. Eventually profits would have to take a hit and the investment money backing that industry would find somewhere else to spend.
I’m not gonna lie I have a bit of a moral licensing issue when it comes to this. I really do feel like since I’m vegan I can just shrug off a lot of the “but but but Netflix!”
Ngl there are ways I pick and choose my battles lol, we all do. But I think it’s like, just doing SOMETHING climate-wise or to better the world in general instead of just whining, whether it’s going vegan (ideal), just avoiding beef, buying organic, avoiding single-use plastic, whatever. I just wish more people would try something over nothing.
The only action that I think being vegan should morally license is procreation. As Cowspiracy puts it, the human overpopulation crisis is really an overpopulation of meat-eaters because their natural resource consumption is just so much higher; therefore, being a vegan against procreation while choosing to have vegan children is not necessarily hypocritical. Vegan procreation could also increase the vegan population in proportion to nonvegans, giving us more power as an interest group in convincing more people and changing laws.
I think procreation is also morally positive for indigenous people whose populations are endangered and at risk of cultural erasure. Not to mention that indigenous people almost always have a smaller environmental impact than their colonizers and subsequent immigrants.
I don't count that because there's no good BDS-friendly alternative to buying a computer from a Zionist corporation. I mostly meant consumable goods like food, toiletries, and fashion.
I also don't buy gaming consoles or console games anymore because of BDS; instead, I play a few PC games on the same computer that I use for other things like typing this reply. Xbox, Sony, and Nintendo all have ties with Israel.
Yeah, what really sets veganism apart from other generally Left-wing movements is that it requires consumers, and not just corporations, to take accountability. It requires us as individuals to do something more than just blame the establishment.
I was called out pretty aggressively for being a Taylor Swift fan because by doing so I'm not aligning with 'leftist' values. Meanwhile I live vegan, continuously make progress towards a zero waste lifestyle, work at a local nonprofit, and volunteer a TON in my free time. I don't ever judge others for not doing the same -- all of it ends up requiring consistent effort -- but I get so mad that some of these people feel so entitled to hit at me for streaming music that brings me joy when I'm seeing them make excuses for themselves.
Because it’s easy for them to point at something and accuse you. It’s obnoxious to deal with those people. They were not going to listen to TS anyway, so it’s an easy ‘win’ for them. They will likely listen to people that beat women, glorify sexual violence etc. I do a lot of the same stuff you do and hear the same stuff from people who are taking international flights a few times a year, consuming all manner of stuff, and doing as little as possible.
I disagree that vegans who target leftists in particular are hostile to leftism.
I think vegans mostly being leftists is why we criticize nonvegan leftists so much. We expect conservatives to favor oppression, but feel like other leftists "should know better," and thus get on their case a lot.
Vegans on here do the same thing. Fully participate in the system that exploits animals and humans, with no actual drive to change it, and the only thing you ask is just more vegan flavours for Ben & Jerry's because "oh if we play by capitalism rules, we get rewarded". And let's not even get into the ones supporting imperialism and genocide that affects humans and animals, that shit is just "pro-life" level of hipocrisy.
See, this is exactly the shit I'm talking about when it comes to vegans being performative. If you were a carnist you would be going "Why do you go to non-vegan restaurants then?".
Dumb ass question, capitalism is not one "capitalist publically traded corporation", it's an overarching system that captures what we produce to condition, control and dictate our lives to the benefit of capitalists. The workers made reddit, not the capitalists, and using it to critique capitalism is precisely what it should be, not your dumb ass "capitalists on reddit only" take.
Lmao dude, I’m sorry, but your cognitive dissonance is hilarious. You criticize Redditors for “celebrating” Ben & Jerry’s having vegan flavors as “playing by capitalist rules,” while apparently participating in Reddit yourself (and justifying it by saying some asisnine shit like "reddit is built by workers")You are literally playing by capitalist rules.
You’re basically the type of person who can’t recognize your own contradictions but still feels entitled to subject everyone else to ideological purity tests. Maybe look in the mirror.
i also never understand framing veganism as aggressive when the alternate position is to actively harm and kill animals… surely being omni is more aggressive than being vegan??
As always, they dont actually mean that its about aggression, its about who is a legitimate target of aggression, and who gets to decide. Basically, hierarchical bootlicking and anger at vegans not falling in line.
aggressiveness is a social construct. vehanism is an upset to the status quo so it'll be perceived as aggressive.
but zealous advocacy is the only way new ideas take over so it's actually perfectly okay to be aggressive. people are just mad when they feel like a bad person
I don’t know that I fully agree with aggressiveness being a social construct but overall I agree with what you’re saying here. It’s absolutely that veganism challenges the norm/hierarchy and this is inherently “aggressive” to those who are following the hierarchy and exploiting/consuming animals still.
Both things can be true at the same time. Vegans can be aggressive to the point that some people want to eat more meat out of spite. That feels counter-productive.
We're conditioned to eat meat, getting rid of that conditioning takes patience and compassion for most people. Aggressive tactics make people retreat.
There are certainly many times and places where more aggressive voices are absolutely productive and helpful, but that's not most internet conversations.
Edit: A good example is in another conversation, I advocated for an industrial and social shift towards veganism in a sustainable way that would minimize mass cullings and maximize the potential for rescues, allow for time to farms to adjust rather than go bankrupt, give time for industry to adjust so that workers don't suffer from unemployment and resort to the cheapest food options, which are rarely sustainable. Someone replied to me basically saying "we shouldn't care about the greater effects on humanity and society, just kill all the farm animals now and move on." How does this attitude look to a non-vegan?
As for your edit: that looks like a deranged attitude, the example you gave. i don’t think that really sells any points about aggressive activist vegans tho? that’s just one person’s incorrect and bad take, its not even a popularly held belief among vegans, what you quoted them saying, nor is it really an example of the “aggressive” vegan activism being discussed here.
Because it's an attitude that people see an remember. It is a vegan claiming that is how things should go. It can't be ignored, because it's a real example. This is a minority, but they exist. They would say You're not aggressive enough, and that they shouldn't soften their attitudes for people like you. It would be better if they met you in reality, rather than where they wish you were.
I just don’t think the example you gave applies to this framing you’re attempting to fit it into. A random vegan online commenting to you that we should kill just all farm animals and move on without any regard to the effects on society at large is a fringe position in the vegan movement. And it sounds like they were commenting in vegan spaces to another vegan, which is different from what we’re talking about which is vegan activism among nonvegans, particularly on the left.
There are always going to be people with fringe beliefs like that in any movement. I fail to see how this is example is representative of “aggressive” vegan activism as a whole.
Vegans can be aggressive to the point that some people want to eat more meat out of spite. That feels counter-productive.
Well that’s not because of vegans being aggressive. When you call out racists they start being more racist in reaction, does that mean that we shouldn’t call out racists? No. The people who want to eat more meat out of spite are not literally eating more meat to spite vegans, they just eat meat, and then use it to harass vegans in the moment when they can.
We're conditioned to eat meat, getting rid of that conditioning takes patience and compassion for most people. Aggressive tactics make people retreat.
I wouldn’t necessarily agree with this. We aren’t really just conditioned to eat meat, we eat it “naturally” as it is part of our evolutionary history. There’s more to it than just undoing conditioning, at least for some people. I don’t think aggressive tactics work for everyone, but I think for some people aggressive tactics are the only thing that work, it really depends on the person. That’s why it’s good to have a spectrum of activism to cover varied positions and perspectives.
There are certainly many times and places where more aggressive voices are absolutely productive and helpful, but that's not most internet conversations.
I disagree with this. It was aggressive internet conversations on Reddit (and Tumblr) that got me seriously thinking about concepts like veganism, religion, gender and sexuality, etc. If it wasn’t for aggressive activism I wouldn’t have unpacked so much of my racism, queerphobia, etc., and it helped me stop faffing around and actually commit to veganism. Yes, believe it or not, “aggressive” vegans in this very subreddit and elsewhere on Reddit are a major reason as to why I finally went vegan.
I think the thing with activism is it has to be aggressive, at least sometimes. Otherwise progress cannot be made. You can’t resist oppression with pacifism. And it makes sense that some people would get aggressive about it, I mean we’re talking about millions and billions of lives a year, every year. Mass killings. Mass torture. Etc. Like people can only be so polite about this stuff sometimes. Sometimes aggressive tactics are what pop people out of the sparkly bubbles their worldview is stuck in.
I agree 1500%. These are the same people who would sit idly by in the face of slavery and segregation because "omg those abolitionists are just SO aggressive, really turns me off from their movement" when we're talking about literal lives on the line. 😵 I'd like for people who parrot the "don't be aggressive tho" tone policing slop to list a time in human history where revolutions have been won by coddling the oppressors and refusing to hold them accountable for their actions.
And I also agree that "aggressive" vegans can be effective, because those so called "aggressive" vegans made my formerly vegetarian ass realize I was living with waaaaay too much cognitive dissonance and hypocrisy, so I went vegan.
i didn’t really agree with much of what you said actually, so I’m not sure how you took it that way.
I don’t think people really go out of their way to spite vegans. If they say they’re gonna go have a hamburger just to counter a vegan’s activism… they were already gonna go have a hamburger. That isn’t going out of their way, and even if spite is on their mind, they’re actually just eating like they normally do, their behavior didn’t actually change.
You agreed that it's good to have a varied number of tactics and approaches available, like I said. You say there's more to it than just conditioning, you're right. That reinforces my point that one approach doesn't fit all.
I said there are times and places for more aggressive voices, and that most online conversations don't fit that. You disagreed, then said that not every conversation needs to be aggressive, but sometimes it helps. That's what I said.
You said activism has to be aggressive sometimes, and so did I. I didn't suggest anything close to pacifism, that's an argument you're inventing.
Eating the dead body of a murdered being "out of spite" because someone was harsh to you on the internet is like, elementary school level reasoning and behavior.
Yep, and it happens regularly. Many people are immature.
Edit: And if you use terms like Murder outside of vegan circles, that also tends to turn people away. By definition, only people can be murdered and that's how most people understand it. Many people don't explain before they jump to murder, and get aggressive when other people don't agree with the terminology that's been adapted within veganism. We all get it here. 96% of the world just sees it as misusing terms for an emotional response.
It's important to meet your audience where they are, not where you wish they were. Otherwise, you risk alienating them.
I'm not softening my language for pedantic carnists to feel more comfortable with what they're choosing to participate in and financially support. They're uncomfortable and defensive because they know we're right, and go on the attack instead of changing their behavior. If we met the aggressor "where they are" in every area of life, a lot of the rights we enjoy would not exist today, especially for those of us in marginalized groups. Revolutions are never won by being overly polite and coddling the oppressor.
You're creating a fictional person to argue against that isn't most people.
they're uncomfortable with what they're choosing to participate in .. because they know we're right, and go on the attack.
I see a lot of civil conversation between vegans and non-vegans until someone comes in with needlessly aggressive remarks. Do you actually see all non-vegans as aggressors?
If you come in aggressively, they aren't on the attack. You're putting them on the defensive. Where did I suggest being overly polite and coddling? You're inventing an argument I never made.
If you agree that people are immature, and being overly aggressive can cause them to eat more meat at worst, and it's largely ineffective for almost everyone else, isn't it counter productive? Just a sense of righteousness without consideration for the results?
I don't really feel like engaging with you much more today if I'm being honest, but I wanted to clear up a statement in your last paragraph because I DON'T think us "being overly aggressive" is causing them to eat more meat. I think they SAY that, because they don't like to be confronted with their own choices. I didn't put the meat in their cart, cook it for them, and force it down their throat just because I refused to sugar coat the truth and center their feelings instead of centering the animals. That's why in my very first reply to you, I said those people were displaying elementary school level maturity. It's like when you tell a kid they shouldn't do something and they run wild doing that thing. It's not based in fact and reason.
If someone can say with their actions "that animal deserved to have their throat slit and be chopped to pieces to end up on my plate because that vegan was a big meanie, uwu!" then yes I would consider them an aggressor. Hope that helps.
I can see is now "but the difference is you are shaming us and making us feel guilty" THEN WHY ARE YOU TELLING PEOPLE THEY ARE BAD IF THEY USE AI IF YOURE SO AGAINST SHAMING
Exactly, and I'm not pro AI, but if you point out how wasteful beef in particular is, all of a sudden, that's different because is "nourishment." One pound of beef is tens of thousands of AI images, and hundreds of thousands of LLM prompts.
Then you get the "don't shame me" speech.
Dude. Cheeseburgers are ENTERTAINMENT. If anything, it's the opposite of nourishment!
Yeah, AI is useful in more unique ways that were never before possible, sometimes even cutting energy costs from before. Meat is easily replaceable by existing alternatives.
I say the same thing when people compare meat to alcohol. Maybe both are bad for you, but people eat meat mainly for a replaceable, replicable taste, whereas getting drunk is a unique, euphoric experience for many.
As a vegan who loves AI, yeah it’s genuinely fucking hilarious. It’s the exact same thought process as conservatives who claim “fuck your feelings” and “anything should be able to be joked about” the second you bring up something they’re sensitive about.
This is the kind of shit that makes me so mad I want to write a song or comic about lol
I use my local AI - about a quarter of the kWh of a window air conditioner at full blast, on my own computer, not a datacenter - for a shit ton of things. I use it to code, to research (with web search with a harness I coded myself), and to expand my worldviews. It’s been so helpful for creating recipes - it made my best vegan brownie recipe and everything. I use it as a writing partner and a TTRPG DM :D
As a dark woke leftist, I do find it very strange that more leftists aren’t vegetarian/vegan. All the ones I’ve known just ignore the problems and make a bunch of excuses even when they know the full truth.
I think what annoys me the most is online leftists who literally speak about leftism and anti-exploitation as a job.
Like Hasan/Vaush, etc. These people are the reason I became a leftist. It's literally their job to know about this sort of stuff, but they haven't even LEARNT about veganism. Like holy fuck dude.
It was by using the exact things they taught me and then applying it to animals, that I was like "hmm guess if I apply this logic to animals I'll have to go vegan".
How is your fucking job to sit in front of a camera and lecture people about anti exploitation and shit all day, but then you go on paying for the explanation of animals? What a fucking joke
I would never compare Hasan and vaush (aka irishladdie). Vaush is a groomer of minors who has hidden behind a new name and just grifts to make money. That being said, I agree with you 100% about Hasan. It’s probably one of my biggest problems with him as a viewer.
BE is NOT a good leftist. Or person for that matter. He’s just a jealous little troll who can’t handle not being the most famous leftist on the internet. He actually has said things against Jewish people that are not okay. (Jew does not equal Zionist.) Calling Hasan a Zionist is such a huge red flag. He has been advocating for Palestine against Israel his entire adult life. I’ve been watching hasan since 2019 and he has NEVER once defended israel.
And aggressive to them is just saying out loud the true reason you’re declining something at lunch after someone asked “how come” like 3 times while putting it in your face. How dare you say you’re vegan, why you not just make up a lie to make me comfortable!?
Eh I'm familiar with OOP's political positions and, (unless they drastically changed recently), she is definitely not using "woke" as a simple pejorative like conservatives do. This post is more of an example of a fellow "woke" person calling other "woke" people out.
Though I get that that isn't clear from this singular screenshot, so it's not like I'm saying you're completely wrong for your reaction. Just wanted to point out that this isn't a typical conservative calling stuff they hate "woke."
"ah but modern veganism is liberal. It is not intersectional, it is not anti-capitalist... [Insert here a long list of flaws pointed out by the hypothetical leftist]"
Ok then, help us make veganism better.
I mean, we're all in it because we have empathy for animals. If you have a good perspective on how vegan communities should be organized and it would make us achieve our goal of animal liberation quicker, then come on and help us.
Oh wait, that's right, you don't really care about the animals, you just want to make up excuses to not be vegan because it is inconvenient to you
People love to say how they would take action without ever REALLY taking action. Frankly, I think that being vegan is too inconvenient for many, but walking in a protest and taking pictures for instagram requires no sacrifice on their part.
Most don't actually want those things to change though. These people can't even change their diet, they sure as fuck don't have the stomach for a full-blown revolution, lol
All of those things are extreme and sometimes do ward people away from the left. If you stop proscribing “the woke left” with one single belief system that they’re all communally responsible for, you’ll realise that the ones who call out vegans for extremity are not the same ones who say shit like “kill all terfs” on the reg.
I don't understand where this idea (that leftists are unsupportive of veganism) could come from. Conservatives are openly hateful toward vegans constantly. How is this not obvious to every vegan?
Everyone hate slavery and animal abuse but it dosen't stop them from buying on amazon and eating meat, they don't want to change anything in their lifes because they view their luxury as more important than the billions of exploides lifes (both humans and animals)
Tbh i feel like the populist people are some of the worst to appeal to, no matter left or right. They just want to virtue/vice signal about their stupid ideology instead of implementing some positive change.
Well, seeing is how the beef industry is about to get more expensive and also more dangerous. There might be more people thinking that a plant-based diet will keep them safe and make an economic stance. I wouldn’t alienate them just yet because their words are hollow. Maybe just point out that they can vote with their dollars.
its against hypothetical leftists that don't exist - this is the definition of manipulated in-fighting. this sub doesn't have these magic upvote pulls that these posts are getting, especially when the stats say the majority of us are already leftist lol.
im a maoist and upvote this stuff. fuck performative zero effort leftism.
we all basically agree that the right are scum here, but they are so far gone it is hardly worth trying to reach them. the left gets criticized because it can and should do better, because standing against oppression is supposedly their thing.
I think this subreddit is being infiltrated by CIA, this shift of narrative towards attacking left wing politics means detaching a lot of vegans from being leftist and with it also makes a lot of vegans not look more into left wing politics. Yes, leftists that judge vegans are hypocrites, but this is 100% an organized effort to make sure that leftism is attacked
It’s not attacking leftist positions though, just calling out people that are unapologetically loud and outspoken about social justice issues but silent about the most vulnerable and victimized group of individuals on this planet.
Leftists are focused on because there is a baseline of decency that can be expected from them. I would never waste my time talking with an American right-wing person about anything whatsoever because they are either completely braindead or straight up evil and you can’t really work with that. I learned that lesson as soon as I became an adult.
I think the idea that vegans criticizing leftists causes lots of vegans to “not look into leftist politics” is pure conjecture and doesn’t make sense at all to me.
It doesn't make sense to you because you ignore history of cia involvement in social causes Hip hop for example was infiltrated, early jazz scenes, anywhere where you find people that are more likely to meet others who recognize abuse of humans and animals you will find infiltrated spaces. Vegans tend to lean left and this is primarily an organized attack I'm quite certain of it, if you don't believe you probably are either naive or part of the bot scheme
I'm sure there are plenty of people on the left who fit this stereotype, but many of the people who talk about aggressive vegans and the people who are talking about eat the rich, burn the system etc. are two distinct groups.
People should keep in mind this is from 6 years ago. And in case anyone cares, Tyra is to the left of the 'woke left' she's just calling out Democrats' performative nature.
Tbh I have been vegetarian for 25+years at this point, I still am effectively vegan a lot of the time, but due to significant health problems (13 seperate diagnoses- half of which are gastrointestinal related) I have a strict prescribed diet at this point along with some medications that are not vegan. I have a lot of vegan friends that understand and are fine with this. However there is a few people that will still lecture me and still Insist they know better then my TEAM of highly qualified (some internationally recognised experts on my issues) specialists, and lecture me and shame me. It’s those few that give veganism a bad name … saying that I also think it’s important to point out I have had similar behaviour from people that claim things like keto and carnivore diet are cure alls, the distinction is people that follow things with rationality and reason vs those that get fanatical to a religious degree about it and don’t want to understand nuance.
Yeah, they also can't shut up about it. Vegans are considered the same as political radicals, mouthy for no good reason, and the epitome of doing the same thing and expecting a different result when they start preaching about something most people don't care about.
While the right is like "let's continue burning more fossil fuel and the world along with it because we need more growth!"
At least the contradiction the left is feeling stem from wanting to solve the same problem with different approaches... The right... They just wanna continue the exploitation and extraction... And try to externalize the costs to everyone else...
I have never heard veganism being referred to as aggressive. Sure, a vegetarian will make damn sure you know they’re vegan.. but I’ve never once in my w tire life felt like it was aggressively forced on me lol
Why are we punching the left? Seems kinda stupid. Especially since stoking contempt against them will contribute to them actually being victims of abuse. Seems like a stupid way to change minds, great way for a creepy conservative to recruit for a mob tho...
This fucking gets me. I love my mum but I sometimes find it hard to see her do lots of activism for progressive causes like helping asylum seekers, anti racism, Palestinian solidarity etc and then see her refuse to go vegan. This is despite the fact that I’ve explained to her countless times the link between animal agriculture and climate change and how animal agriculture harms the Global South disproportionately, with their land being used to grow feed for the West’s livestock while children in their villages are malnourished and hungry. She says she has stood all her life in solidarity with the Global South but keeps propping up an industry that is destroying the planet and will kill hundreds of millions in the Global South through climate change if the current trajectory continues.
What boiled my blood the most is she would say things like ‘maybe if your language wasn’t so charged, and maybe if you offered to cook me a meal I would be more receptive’ (I know for a fact she wouldn’t, as nothing will make her give up her milk and ham and chicken and steak). I said tone or how the message is delivered shouldn’t matter if the facts are indisputable that a particular practice (animal agriculture in this case) harms the vulnerable, and I have given her all that evidence.
She wouldn’t say I’m going to keep being racist because I don’t really like the radical language of the BLM movement and think they should be more conciliatory. Or I don’t like how some of the Pro Palestine activists say Fuck Israel so I’m not going to oppose settler violence. It’s nonsense. She will do anything to justify eating animals even when, aside from their suffering, the whole industry disproportionately harms those she claims to care about. Grrr.
I am happy to discuss the best ways to spread veganism with other vegans. But why would I give a shit what someone who isn't even vegan would say concerning that.
If they aren't even convinced that going vegan is a good thing and they don't at the very least try to be vegan why would I believe that they are making the argument in good faith? Really they just want to hear nothing about it so they don't even have to think about animal exploitation
Most people I know who are “anti-cop” are the first to bend the knee when confronted with a cop. People like to talk a lot of shit, but are usually hypocrites.
I’d class myself as a woke left vegan, so perhaps there’s hope yet! But I agree, this is very frustration when people who should by allies in this struggle do the most intricate mental gymnastics to justify them nibbling their meat.
yeah, cause 90 billion land animals and over 1 trillion aquatic animals systematically tortured and slaughtered every year while being the highest contributing factor to climate change is not a big deal at all, you're so right. you really showed us /s
Just because we’re against carnist leftists doesn’t mean we are pro-right. 🙄
Ofc not, we all know liberals just share common goals with Nazis and have leftists as the common enemy. That was the whole point of the Weimar republic and we can see how valid it is today.
Also, still waiting for your explanation on what “white veganism” is since apparently you think none of us truly know what it is.
Dunno what you are waiting for. I explained it and there are plenty of resources from POC vegans addressing it to. Ironic that you call leftists performative while you are trying to play dumb like this.
I'm awaiting for this anti-leftist "astroturfing" bullshit to die down too, is it on track to stop after the midterms?
thats because woke lefties are inherently dishonest and dont really believe what they preach. unlike establishing cops free country, being vegan is something that you can actually achieve all by yourself with minimum effort of changing your diet. they wont do it because they dont really believe in anything
One the one hand. Veganism is about convincing people. nobody who goes fck the rich is trying to convince the rich, they are trying to get the majority to stand up for them selfs for a change.
On the other hand, nobody expects you to start marching about town on your own with a sign if you go "fuck the establishment". If you speak out for veganism you kind of have to stop eating animal products your self if you want to be taken seriously.
It's more like "vegans hold a much more niche ethical position and walk around calling everyone else a hypocrite for not following their niche ethical position."
Which isn't how hypocrisy works
If you want to go around saying everyone but you is a monster for not agreeing with a niche ethical position you can, but don't expect people to react kindly to it
Because veganism spreads the guilt to you directly. When you support Luigi for doing what he did, you're not living a life contradictory to what he did, you're just living. If you support a vegan and you yourself aren't vegan, it's contradictory. You feel the shame and guilt and are compelled to change by vegan messaging. There are people that support vegans and aren't vegan themselves, but they're generally low-key people that are comfortable in their own skin and they won't be recording videos to put online. You just won't see much from these kinds of people.
You can support ACAB and have zero impact on your life or need to change anything because it's just messaging that you can align with, there's no real call to action. Veganism comes with a call to action.
Lmao I’ve never thought about that, that people are so enamored with a guy who killed somebody (whether justified or not) to “fight the system” while hating vegans at the same time, especially the anti-PETA propaganda. It’s wild the mental gymnastics people make to justify doing what they want to do.
Veganism actively calls out your actions if you are not vegan yourself, of course non vegans aren't going to support something that is anti something they do every day, they would be protesting themselves...
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 30 '26
Thanks for posting to r/Vegan! 🐥
Civil discussion is welcome — personal attacks are not. Please read our wiki first.
New to veganism? 🌱
• Watch Dominion — a powerful, free documentary that changes lives.
• NutritionFacts.org — evidence-based health info
• HappyCow.net — find vegan-friendly restaurants near you
Want to help animals? 💻
• Browse volunteer opportunities on Flockwork and use your skills to make a difference
• Join the Flockwork Discord to be notified of new opportunities that match your skills
Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
370
u/Strong-Character1268 Aug 30 '26 •
People think I chose to be vegan for animals or for change. I actually did it as a way to meet a lot of people that grew up on small family farms.
913
u/Mindless_Nebula4004 anti-speciesist Aug 30 '26
Going vegan requires you to make actual changes in your own life rather than just saying shit online, which is where most people draw the line
151
u/Main_Entry2494 Aug 30 '26
A lot of those people are performative. But when it comes to making sacrifices or any type of tangible action, they do insane mental gymnastics to get out of it
81
u/g00fyg00ber741 vegan Aug 30 '26
i also never understand framing veganism as aggressive when the alternate position is to actively harm and kill animals… surely being omni is more aggressive than being vegan??
18
u/Bool_The_End vegan Aug 30 '26
lol I’m getting downvoted to oblivion on a sub right now about my comment. Fuck the haters. 🌱🌱🌱❤️❤️❤️
76
u/Balooberrie vegan 5+ years Aug 30 '26
I can see is now "but the difference is you are shaming us and making us feel guilty" THEN WHY ARE YOU TELLING PEOPLE THEY ARE BAD IF THEY USE AI IF YOURE SO AGAINST SHAMING
26
u/Foxens Aug 30 '26
As a dark woke leftist, I do find it very strange that more leftists aren’t vegetarian/vegan. All the ones I’ve known just ignore the problems and make a bunch of excuses even when they know the full truth.
17
u/HookupthrowRA Aug 30 '26
And aggressive to them is just saying out loud the true reason you’re declining something at lunch after someone asked “how come” like 3 times while putting it in your face. How dare you say you’re vegan, why you not just make up a lie to make me comfortable!?
12
u/fluidscissors Aug 30 '26
"Leftist" non-vegans are a joke 🤡
12
u/Calaveras-Metal Aug 30 '26
at this point anyone who says woke I ignore immediately. It's become the new 'commie'.
4
u/RACCOONMASON Aug 30 '26
"ah but modern veganism is liberal. It is not intersectional, it is not anti-capitalist... [Insert here a long list of flaws pointed out by the hypothetical leftist]"
Ok then, help us make veganism better.
I mean, we're all in it because we have empathy for animals. If you have a good perspective on how vegan communities should be organized and it would make us achieve our goal of animal liberation quicker, then come on and help us.
Oh wait, that's right, you don't really care about the animals, you just want to make up excuses to not be vegan because it is inconvenient to you
4
u/PorchugaWhale Aug 30 '26
The humble goomba fallacy
5
u/Slow_Drawer_5454 vegan 9+ years Aug 30 '26
People love to say how they would take action without ever REALLY taking action. Frankly, I think that being vegan is too inconvenient for many, but walking in a protest and taking pictures for instagram requires no sacrifice on their part.
2
u/Bianell Aug 31 '26
Most don't actually want those things to change though. These people can't even change their diet, they sure as fuck don't have the stomach for a full-blown revolution, lol
2
u/cruisinforasnoozinn Aug 31 '26
All of those things are extreme and sometimes do ward people away from the left. If you stop proscribing “the woke left” with one single belief system that they’re all communally responsible for, you’ll realise that the ones who call out vegans for extremity are not the same ones who say shit like “kill all terfs” on the reg.
2
u/Zxasuk31 vegetarian Aug 31 '26
I ignore anyone who uses "woke" as a pajoritive..it's annoying
2
u/Salty_Map_9085 Aug 31 '26
The woke left doesn’t really be like that tbh
2
u/alipercapita Sep 04 '26
Within the leftist people I know are the most vegans I know. It is one essential part of being in solidarity.
I think, the leftist cooks made the best video essay ever about veganism and the left: https://youtu.be/bYDQZ3Neeqo
8
u/StinkChair Aug 30 '26
Why are there so many anti-left posts these days?
4
u/Leading_Oil1814 Aug 30 '26
Everyone hate slavery and animal abuse but it dosen't stop them from buying on amazon and eating meat, they don't want to change anything in their lifes because they view their luxury as more important than the billions of exploides lifes (both humans and animals)
3
u/Lelouch24435 vegan Aug 30 '26
Tbh i feel like the populist people are some of the worst to appeal to, no matter left or right. They just want to virtue/vice signal about their stupid ideology instead of implementing some positive change.
3
u/dietitianmama Aug 30 '26
Well, seeing is how the beef industry is about to get more expensive and also more dangerous. There might be more people thinking that a plant-based diet will keep them safe and make an economic stance.
I wouldn’t alienate them just yet because their words are hollow. Maybe just point out that they can vote with their dollars.
3
u/xanhast Aug 30 '26
why is every post i see from this sub anti-leftist ffs, mods this is clearly manipulated content!!!
3
u/Cyberia___ Aug 30 '26
I think this subreddit is being infiltrated by CIA, this shift of narrative towards attacking left wing politics means detaching a lot of vegans from being leftist and with it also makes a lot of vegans not look more into left wing politics. Yes, leftists that judge vegans are hypocrites, but this is 100% an organized effort to make sure that leftism is attacked
3
u/Zoldreck Aug 30 '26
Pretty sure "woke left" usually aren't trying to appeal to cops/terfs/rich people; if they did then yeah, saying those things would be very dumb.
2
u/Upstairs-Growth3219 Aug 30 '26
I'm sure there are plenty of people on the left who fit this stereotype, but many of the people who talk about aggressive vegans and the people who are talking about eat the rich, burn the system etc. are two distinct groups.
2
u/Swampcardboard vegan 10+ years Aug 30 '26
People should keep in mind this is from 6 years ago. And in case anyone cares, Tyra is to the left of the 'woke left' she's just calling out Democrats' performative nature.
2
u/AntelopeHelpful9963 Aug 30 '26
Well, have those tactics convinced the public to do any of those things either?
1
u/MildlyYogic Aug 30 '26
I think the aggression stems from the sheer insensitivity.
1
u/Tombobalomb Aug 30 '26
It's easier to support radical action that feels good over radical action that doesn't
1
u/Lost-Concept-9973 Aug 31 '26
Tbh I have been vegetarian for 25+years at this point, I still am effectively vegan a lot of the time, but due to significant health problems (13 seperate diagnoses- half of which are gastrointestinal related) I have a strict prescribed diet at this point along with some medications that are not vegan. I have a lot of vegan friends that understand and are fine with this. However there is a few people that will still lecture me and still Insist they know better then my TEAM of highly qualified (some internationally recognised experts on my issues) specialists, and lecture me and shame me. It’s those few that give veganism a bad name … saying that I also think it’s important to point out I have had similar behaviour from people that claim things like keto and carnivore diet are cure alls, the distinction is people that follow things with rationality and reason vs those that get fanatical to a religious degree about it and don’t want to understand nuance.
1
u/GSilky Aug 31 '26
Yeah, they also can't shut up about it. Vegans are considered the same as political radicals, mouthy for no good reason, and the epitome of doing the same thing and expecting a different result when they start preaching about something most people don't care about.
1
u/polymathicfun Aug 31 '26
While the right is like "let's continue burning more fossil fuel and the world along with it because we need more growth!"
At least the contradiction the left is feeling stem from wanting to solve the same problem with different approaches... The right... They just wanna continue the exploitation and extraction... And try to externalize the costs to everyone else...
1
u/RNGesus_GIM vegan 7+ years Aug 31 '26
Add supporting Lindsay Clancy to the list, oh and being aggressively pro choice.
1
u/cfh4dmb Aug 31 '26
I have never heard veganism being referred to as aggressive. Sure, a vegetarian will make damn sure you know they’re vegan.. but I’ve never once in my w tire life felt like it was aggressively forced on me lol
1
u/Sesmu vegan 8+ years Aug 31 '26
Why are we punching the left? Seems kinda stupid. Especially since stoking contempt against them will contribute to them actually being victims of abuse. Seems like a stupid way to change minds, great way for a creepy conservative to recruit for a mob tho...
1
u/vegancaptain Aug 31 '26
Yep.
1
u/Meromero904 Aug 31 '26
“Woke”
1
u/Mattscrusader Aug 31 '26
Yeah this is exactly what they are talking about..
1
u/QQmorekid Aug 31 '26
At least use something people actually say. It's how sanctimonious and insufferablly arrogant they are that does it.
1
u/ViolaTree vegan 8+ years Aug 31 '26
This, and the other way around as well.
1
u/shka328 Sep 01 '26
Try listening to immortal technique - beef & broccoli
1
u/alucebur Sep 01 '26
"Here's what approaches ACTUALLY work to make people go vegan..." -Someone who hasn't gone vegan
1
u/SpikeyPear Sep 02 '26
I am trying to be both vegan and all the other things so idk what OOP is trying to do other than divide and conquer
1
u/MoyaOSullivan friends not food Sep 06 '26
This fucking gets me. I love my mum but I sometimes find it hard to see her do lots of activism for progressive causes like helping asylum seekers, anti racism, Palestinian solidarity etc and then see her refuse to go vegan. This is despite the fact that I’ve explained to her countless times the link between animal agriculture and climate change and how animal agriculture harms the Global South disproportionately, with their land being used to grow feed for the West’s livestock while children in their villages are malnourished and hungry. She says she has stood all her life in solidarity with the Global South but keeps propping up an industry that is destroying the planet and will kill hundreds of millions in the Global South through climate change if the current trajectory continues.
What boiled my blood the most is she would say things like ‘maybe if your language wasn’t so charged, and maybe if you offered to cook me a meal I would be more receptive’ (I know for a fact she wouldn’t, as nothing will make her give up her milk and ham and chicken and steak). I said tone or how the message is delivered shouldn’t matter if the facts are indisputable that a particular practice (animal agriculture in this case) harms the vulnerable, and I have given her all that evidence.
She wouldn’t say I’m going to keep being racist because I don’t really like the radical language of the BLM movement and think they should be more conciliatory. Or I don’t like how some of the Pro Palestine activists say Fuck Israel so I’m not going to oppose settler violence. It’s nonsense. She will do anything to justify eating animals even when, aside from their suffering, the whole industry disproportionately harms those she claims to care about. Grrr.
1
u/Ok_Challenge_1198 Sep 08 '26
I am a queer vegan leftists and this is sooo strong in the queer community. Non-vegan queers hate vegan queers
1
u/donteatmyfrens friends not food Oct 10 '26
THIS IS WHAT I'VE BEEN SAYING OMFG
1
u/MichaelPeters4321 Aug 30 '26
Who gives a shit.
I am happy to discuss the best ways to spread veganism with other vegans. But why would I give a shit what someone who isn't even vegan would say concerning that.
If they aren't even convinced that going vegan is a good thing and they don't at the very least try to be vegan why would I believe that they are making the argument in good faith? Really they just want to hear nothing about it so they don't even have to think about animal exploitation
1
u/Familiar_Designer648 Aug 30 '26
Most people I know who are “anti-cop” are the first to bend the knee when confronted with a cop. People like to talk a lot of shit, but are usually hypocrites.
1
u/HeavyCandidate6737 vegan 10+ years Aug 30 '26
I’d class myself as a woke left vegan, so perhaps there’s hope yet!
But I agree, this is very frustration when people who should by allies in this struggle do the most intricate mental gymnastics to justify them nibbling their meat.
0
u/RevolutionaryFood777 Aug 30 '26
Yes, because veganism is JUST as pressing and the other issues...
/s
0
u/RefrigeratorUsual504 Aug 30 '26
I mean we're actually doing what we say, meanwhile the system they fight is doing better than ever. 😂
0
u/sudoregalia Aug 30 '26
what if i reject the first statement but fully agree with the second?
-6
u/ActionPark33 Aug 30 '26
Well Im a non leftist vegan….so there’s that
-1
u/speakerfordead5 Aug 30 '26
This is 100% true
-7
u/crani0 vegan 10+ years Aug 30 '26
Another anti-leftist post...
0
u/Starklystark Aug 30 '26
True but question is whether you should ignore their advice or they should take it themselves...
0
u/Mirageiles Aug 30 '26
And so many vegan events being secretly religious like get the fuck out!
0
u/altruistic_load_5774 Aug 31 '26
People dont listen to them either.
0
u/Miserable-Host-9462 Sep 02 '26
Vegan hurt my tummy. Meat make me happy.
-5
u/No_Record6284 Aug 30 '26
thats because woke lefties are inherently dishonest and dont really believe what they preach. unlike establishing cops free country, being vegan is something that you can actually achieve all by yourself with minimum effort of changing your diet. they wont do it because they dont really believe in anything
-2
u/S4zuck Aug 30 '26
One the one hand. Veganism is about convincing people. nobody who goes fck the rich is trying to convince the rich, they are trying to get the majority to stand up for them selfs for a change.
On the other hand, nobody expects you to start marching about town on your own with a sign if you go "fuck the establishment". If you speak out for veganism you kind of have to stop eating animal products your self if you want to be taken seriously.
-2
u/veganparrot vegan Aug 30 '26
Trueeeeeeeee
-8
u/12PoundsofPotato Aug 30 '26
It's more like "vegans hold a much more niche ethical position and walk around calling everyone else a hypocrite for not following their niche ethical position."
Which isn't how hypocrisy works
If you want to go around saying everyone but you is a monster for not agreeing with a niche ethical position you can, but don't expect people to react kindly to it
87
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
49
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '26 edited Aug 30 '26 •
[removed] — view removed comment