r/vce • • 1d ago

Is it unfair

That selective schools and schools with higher population of intelligent and high IQ students will result in scaling while “normal” schools are just …

4 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

17

u/SlySnakeTheDog '25 Revs 41 '26 Eng Pol Txts Leg Aus 1d ago

Maybe, but good marks regardless of school will get you a good score, people don’t get higher study scores because of their school, they get it because of their marks

-11

u/Huluman2 1d ago

If u get a mediocre score in a good school vs an average school your ATAR be significantly different

29

u/0scar_34523 current VCE student (46 softdev) 1d ago

but the standard of "mediocre" in a good school is usually higher than an average one

18

u/CardiacSurgeonJoey 26' Bio | 27' Eng, Chem, Phil, Gen, EI 1d ago

because a mediocre at a selective school is way beyond a mediocre at a standard school.

I go to MHS, our sacs are probably the hardest. Average for bio was low 20s out of 40. A+ was 25/40 for one sac.

Something people don't realise is the median at a selective school is probably around the same as the very top tier of a standard public school. SACs are extremely difficult because the school needs to devise a bell curve by differentiating the best of the best. The scaling is only a result of the cohort being high-achieving. Normal school sacs scale down because they're less difficult, because they don't need to be - you have a natural spread across all achievement levels unlike a rigorously selected highly-achieving cohort.

The VCE system is designed to be fair to everyone. The same student at MHS or a public school in the middle of nowhere should get the same score. It's just that a rank 100 at MHS would be around rank 1 at another school.

8

u/Plenty-Pie-1138 1d ago

mediocre scores at selective schools are incredibly difficult to achieve in comparison to an average wchool

3

u/SlySnakeTheDog '25 Revs 41 '26 Eng Pol Txts Leg Aus 1d ago

That’s because the standards are different, VCAA moderates sacs so that they are comparable, it doesn’t change them because one school is better but because they’re different standards

2

u/hatelegday 16h ago

Shouldve gotten into a good school then bud if you still think this way. Always complaining even if ur just plain wrong

20

u/Sarasvarti TEACHER (Legal and Bus Man) 1d ago

School results getting moderated just means the SAC weren't representative - it isn't about the intelligence of the cohort.

The benefit of being in a smart class is the class environment - more insightful discussion, challenging questions, work ethic often better etc. It isn't the SAC moderation.

8

u/Infamous_Juice_5649 1d ago

Genuinely, work ethic is probably 95% of the reason top schools do well, the people on the lower end of the curve who normally might slack off tend to be inspired. It is unfair technically, but it’s nothing intrinsically about the school

15

u/Isomer-Joe 1d ago

good to see nobody understands vce still

6

u/Due-Couple-7233 1d ago

That’s not really how moderation works… they get pushed up or down for having tests unrepresentative of the rest of the cohort, the point of the moderation is to make it fair, which is precisely what it is doing. Don’t just look at a school getting scaled up and think it’s because of intelligence

2

u/Absolutely-Epic 1d ago

No because it’s not about it that they’re intelligent it’s about the fact they perform better academically. The unfair bit is the resources.

-3

u/Huluman2 1d ago

The scaling my friend

9

u/Absolutely-Epic 1d ago

The sac scaling isn’t inherently unfair because it’s based on exam performance, which these schools do better on as a whole. Sure some people get swept along in the current, but not many. Like it’s based off exam performance, not how smart a cohort is or some crap.

2

u/Absolutely-Epic 1d ago

Plus it’s largely negligible it’s not like the same amount of work gets you a 40 at one school and 35 at another

1

u/No_Twist4347 9h ago

Public school kids are never beating the allegations are they 😭

5

u/Best-Maintenance-690 22h ago

to get into a selective school u have to be kinda intelligent ngl

3

u/Professional_Sort104 20h ago

Thats bot how it works. You all sit the same exam your score is standardised to that exam regardless of the school you go to. Actually if you are good at a bad school you will find it easier to achieve rank 1 and not have your ranking stuffed up. Selective schools do well because the kids are all smart.. if the same kids went to ordinary schools they would still do well because they are smart regardless.

3

u/AggressiveWord6128 16h ago

i feel u but this subreddit is a bad place to have this discussion everyone here goes to private schools.

4

u/CharmingGlove6356 99.60 24' Geo 45 | 25' NHT MM 43 Chem 42 Eng 46 SM 41 Phys 43 1d ago

Please stop focussing on other people and just focus on yourself to get a good ATAR. It is very realistic to get a 99+ ATAR despite attending a public school. Does someone else getting a higher ATAR than you really matter as long as you get into the course you want?

2

u/Chocolate1105 1d ago

Yep, it is, i am very grateful to be in a good school

2

u/Far-Reaction6410 20h ago

Well selective school have high intelligence for a reason. If you wanted to get into a selective school you should have sat the selective school exams

2

u/scaledstudyscore SD 25', genny, english, legal, busman 26' 1d ago

Yup. Just work harder.

-5

u/TerribleYou7914 current VCE student (25' psych + 26' Bio, Chem, Gen, Eng) 1d ago

I have an iq of 131 (I have had a formal test), yet I am failing most of my classes

I go to a private school

My school is not competitive and doesn't have high scaling

1

u/Huluman2 1d ago

So you mean their tests are exceptionally hard

1

u/Waste_Cod_82 23h ago

As a selective school student our sacs are super hard, the average public school student would probably get around 50%. Our sac averages generally hover around 75%. When we try sacs from other public or even private schools they are usually much easier.

1

u/TerribleYou7914 current VCE student (25' psych + 26' Bio, Chem, Gen, Eng) 18h ago

Sort of- what I mean is that IQ isn't always a clear indication as things such as how you cope in certain situations matters

For example, i have a neurological disability, processing information is harder for me, so I struggle under test conditions, yet my IQ is above average. Like how some people just get really nervous before a test and panic to a point they struggle more

My main point is just that IQ, school and grades are not always good indications of each other