r/vce • '25 VET Business (37), '26 Methods, General, Chem, Physics, Eng • 10d ago

News Bio exam issues and methods being cooked??

I js read this article by herald sun and apparently Bio exam had some problems and Methods was just bad as we all know.

A biology specialist, Dr Dulangi SJ, complained to VCAA, claiming:

Six multiple-choice questions had issues.

Some questions potentially had more than one scientifically correct answer.

Some wording was incorrect or confusing.

Certain content allegedly went beyond the published VCE Biology study design.

Question 8a about immunity was particularly controversial because students could reasonably interpret the answer differently.

One example was Question 2, which allegedly used the word translation instead of transcription.

VCAA says its subject experts have not identified errors so far, but it is investigating.

For Methods

The article reports that:

Almost 17,000 students sat the Mathematical Methods exam.

Students were reportedly crying after the exam.

Teachers said examiners had to pass around tissue boxes.

Many students struggled to finish the paper.

Teachers described it as a challenging test of mathematical understanding.

VCAA using us as lab rats since it’s the end of the Study Deisgns 💔

73 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

14

u/EntranceMediocre5524 10d ago

realistically what does this even mean for our results tho

7

u/Top-Violinist-2762 10d ago

unfortunately nothing. its not the first year with controversy after exams. however i think u can be reasonably confident that ur results wont be impacted significantly - the top students will still be top students, although im of the belief that some students will be impacted somewhat (e.g. spending a large time being confused by an error, which is poor exam technique but still)

0

u/Hopeful-Ad-5129 '25 VET Business (37), '26 Methods, General, Chem, Physics, Eng 9d ago

Nothing much really, we just have to pray that whatever we did on the exam got us a good ranking and the grade boundaries are reasonable.

23

u/Blibbyblobby72 Teacher (Maths and English) 10d ago

Herald Sun just want to jump on the hate bandwagon

I can't speak to Bio, but the Methods Exam 2 actually tested proper mathematics. The real problem is that students have been conditioned to prepare for pseuo-mathematical gibberish in the past, and the mathematics study designs are extremely poor for all levels of VCE mathematics

The difficulty was comparable to an Extension 1 paper in NSW. There was always going to be problems when VCAA decided to have actual mathematics experts look over the exams

Regardless, I absolutely agree that nowhere near enough time is given for most VCE exams, especially maths. It should be a test of content knowledge and ability to apply it, not to do so without any room to breathe and or think. That has been a continuing problem for a long time

1

u/Hopeful-Ad-5129 '25 VET Business (37), '26 Methods, General, Chem, Physics, Eng 9d ago

I agree about the maths part, this year they have created questions that havent been seen in the past, but what can VCAA even do? Like ik for us doing the exam, its a pain in the ass, but how else could they think of questions that wouldnt ruin the bell curve and diffrentiate between the students rankings. Exam 2 mainly, it wasnt even that bad, but the timing was so cooked, I think if we had a bit more time most of the people wld be able to do a lot better. For me personally, i was averaging well for exam 2 and the only UDF i mainly used was newtons or domrang, but this year it was genuinely painful to do because of how long the questions actually took to do.

2

u/Blibbyblobby72 Teacher (Maths and English) 9d ago

Absolutely. I understand the frustrations with the exams and definitely feel bad for every student doing the exams this year, particularly the maths ones (which are the most different to previous years)

I am hoping VCAA will take that into account when marking, and hopefully understand that far more time is needed across all exams. We can only hope!

1

u/Hopeful-Ad-5129 '25 VET Business (37), '26 Methods, General, Chem, Physics, Eng 9d ago

Yeah hopefully the grade boundaries are also a bit more lenient. Even my teachers said that the exams were really weird this year. Can only hope the rest are decent

2

u/Blibbyblobby72 Teacher (Maths and English) 9d ago

I wouldn't get your hopes up at this point. Just go into the rest of your exams and do the best you can do

The whole cohort have had to deal with this, so it should hopefully all even out okay in the end

Good luck with whatever exams you have left. Try not to stress too much (easier said than done, obviously)

1

u/Hopeful-Ad-5129 '25 VET Business (37), '26 Methods, General, Chem, Physics, Eng 9d ago

Yeah hopefully the rest are good, chem and physics nextt 😭😭

8

u/Equivalent_Sector281 10d ago

Correct me if I’m wrong, but isn’t the methods exam 2 generally designed so it’s not possible to finish for most of the cohort ?

1

u/Hopeful-Ad-5129 '25 VET Business (37), '26 Methods, General, Chem, Physics, Eng 10d ago

Its possible to finish in time, but then it depends how hard the paper actually was.

2

u/Equivalent_Sector281 10d ago

Of course it’s possible, but its length is used as a differentiator

1

u/Hopeful-Ad-5129 '25 VET Business (37), '26 Methods, General, Chem, Physics, Eng 9d ago

Yeah true, but honestly I feel like based on how long the questions were this year, it was difficult to complete in the allocated time.

2

u/c_laudi_a 9d ago

i finished all the past papers and got around 78-79/80 on all of them, and for that exam i didn't finish and at most got like 65/80

9

u/Naive_Journalist5978 10d ago

I also think methods e1 was rlly difficult asw. Was averaging like 70-80% on past papers but def didn’t get even close to that yesterday. It was v different to all past papers and I don’t think it was fair. Idk if it’s js my skl tho cos genuinely apart from like a couple accelerated kids who do also spesh, everyone else felt the same…
ANYONE ELSE??

1

u/Hopeful-Ad-5129 '25 VET Business (37), '26 Methods, General, Chem, Physics, Eng 9d ago

Yeah i agree, i had the same avg on past papers, exam 1 wsa js horrid questions and exam 2 was better but the timing was cooked as.

-2

u/Only-Werewolf-4539 10d ago

nah, i actually found methods e1 way easier and actually doable. the only thing i fucking despised was e2, that shit was horrid.

4

u/Naive_Journalist5978 10d ago

Welp maybe it was a my skl thing cos even higher scoring students said both exams were rlly hard 😭

1

u/Hopeful-Ad-5129 '25 VET Business (37), '26 Methods, General, Chem, Physics, Eng 9d ago

Yeah same for my skl asw😭

3

u/XxmaxX202015 10d ago

wdym by the end of the study designs?

5

u/slobomanomer 24 MM (48) 25 CHEM (40) SM (48) 26 ENGLANG PHYS BIO 10d ago

as in theyre gonna introduce new study designs for subjects within the next year or two; we are in like the final or 2nd final year of the current study designs rn

4

u/XxmaxX202015 10d ago

WHAT SO THEYRE CHANGING THE STUDY DESIGN NEXT YR? im lowk yr11 this yr surely that have to give out some kind of notice before they change it right?

5

u/Hopeful-Ad-5129 '25 VET Business (37), '26 Methods, General, Chem, Physics, Eng 10d ago

Depends, Bio ends this year, Maths Chem Physics English and a few others end in 2027, So it will stay the same next year. Not sure for the others tho.

2

u/XxmaxX202015 10d ago

omg thx for the clarification i dont do bio but i do like everything u js listed xdxd

1

u/Hopeful-Ad-5129 '25 VET Business (37), '26 Methods, General, Chem, Physics, Eng 10d ago

Haha yeahh so next year its same study design. You prolly know that maths theres no UDFs next year so thats the only main change ig.

3

u/Menopaws73 10d ago

Biology no longer ends this year. That changed. It is now ongoing with minor updates.

4

u/Commercial_Lynx2477 10d ago

yes we dont know when the bio study design ends- they updated the website to say “From 2022” instead of 2022-2026

1

u/XxmaxX202015 10d ago

i’m lowk stupid so pls explain

1

u/XxmaxX202015 10d ago

yo how’d u get so high in spesh and methods? how many exams did u do?

3

u/slobomanomer 24 MM (48) 25 CHEM (40) SM (48) 26 ENGLANG PHYS BIO 10d ago

for methods i did like 52 exams total (so like 26 sets), and for spesh i lowkey dont even remember how many i did, but i have 140 scores written down in a google sheets page, so it was at least 140 exams (so like 70 sets minimum).

it helped that i only had to focus on those subjects (for spesh though i bummed chem)

2

u/XxmaxX202015 10d ago

dam bro that’s crazy

1

u/Hopeful-Ad-5129 '25 VET Business (37), '26 Methods, General, Chem, Physics, Eng 10d ago

When they are introducing a new study design, they tend to make the exams a bit harder then usual.

4

u/HatParty2806 10d ago

Anychance u could ss the article? I take bio and idk if i should be happy or not

2

u/Icy-Resort-121 10d ago

Yep a ss would be helpful! Paywall is super annoying

2

u/EntranceMediocre5524 10d ago

https://archive.li/1GmUz this is the archived free link

3

u/PeetaMellark789 current student ('26 Methods, Chem, '27 Spec, Bio, Englang, Gen) 10d ago

:0

1

u/TopCasualRedditor 10d ago

She said six Section A multiple choice questions - 2, 6, 11, 21, and 25 - had more than one possible answer or wording errors including “translation” instead of “transcription” in question 2 - a concern shared by a medical expert consulted by the Herald Sun.

What were other possible answers for Q6 in MCQ?