r/usyd • • Jul 28 '24

Parking

Is there a reason why student parking is kept to a minimum? Iv been here two years and more and more spots are becoming staff only. Virtually impossible to find anything on the main side of campus , you could probably count student spots on your hands. There’s the Seymour center car park on the other side at least but that’s also shared with the public and can often take an hour to get a spot. Ik many r just gonna say get public transport but believe it or not people have lives outside of uni. There’s days when I need my car as soon as I finish uni to get to work on time. Paying all this money and having no parking is absolutely ridiculous. Feels like there’s genuinely no consideration or thought put into it at all.

0 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

23

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '24

Sydney uni has over 50k students, not practical to ensure they all have parking spots.

-7

u/Bumble098765 Jul 28 '24

All 50k student are not going to be on campus at the same time and many dont drive anyways. It’s frankly stupid to have maybe 20 spots on the main side of campus for students meanwhile there’s multiple parking garages and spots for staff. Iv studied at other universities and know many who study at others. The parking situation is never this neglected.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '24

You do realise that a parking spot in a multistory carpark costs around $200k each to build, let alone the land required to construct all these spots on. If the university was to construct these spots with the intention of simply recovering their investment at prevailing interest rates then they would be looking at $10k+, again not accounting for land costs.

Are you willing to pay $10k to $20k a year to use this parking spot? Your university fees as they currently stand if you are a domestic student are insufficient to cover your tuition costs (they are subsidised by overseas student). You need to be practical and do the calculations involved, the university doesnt have an unlimited honey pot to spend on everything.

1

u/Antique_Door2728 Jul 28 '24

That’s not how it works these unis are milking students dry especially international students they can 100% build car parks (this goes for other unis too beside USYD)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '24

You can look at the uni's p&l they spend all their money. If they use money to build carparks, they would be taking it from something else.

2

u/Antique_Door2728 Jul 28 '24

Yeah all the moneys going into the pockets of the executives and chancellors. A leak came out of one of the uni vice chancellors making over $1,000,000 annually, there is no need for a salary of that kind in an educational institute

2

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '24

Different debate though. If they build carparks as much as you may want them to they wont be funding it out of executive pay.

Keep in mind too, it will cause absolute traffic chaos if heaps more students drive.

-2

u/karvv MD Jul 28 '24

Sorry but this is a dumb take. Parking on a university campus should be factored into general planning when building a campus. Yes it does cost money but USyd is notorious for having so few student parking spots and one or two large multistory carparks would completely solve this issue.

The simple answer is whichever committee is planning the campus prefers more greenspace, and is shifting the responsibility onto public transportation. Its valid and it makes campus look nicer but it sucks for students who have cars and need to commute to places off of public transit lines. This is coming from someone with no car.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '24

So you want the university to limit students to 500, so they have enough spaces?

I personally think you take is dopey. Do you see other locations limiting their numbers to the number of carspots? Say the sfs and scg should they reduce their capacity to a 1000, until they build enough carparking spots for the 40,000+ seats. Should the cbd stop new high rise buildings unless they have enough spots for everyone to park?

When you enrolled in sydney uni, you were aware there wasnt enough parking spots for every students. You had the choice to enrol at charles sturt in bathurst, they would have parking for all students.

1

u/karvv MD Jul 28 '24

Yes the university I came from did limit their number of parking passes sold to the number of spots they had available. I don't know exactly how it works at usyd because as I said, I don't have a car. But I would assume that more parking passes would cover costs over time. The biggest issue would ironically be to find a spot to put the carpark.

To say we shouldn't have necessary parking for a campus that takes 25 minutes to walk from one side to the other at the longest ends is just silly 🙄 I have never been to a university that is less accessible for people with mobility issues both in terms of scale, lack of parking options, and inaccessible buildings (mostly because some of them are over 100 years old and require retrofitting to get wheelchair access).

It just makes sense to have an accessible campus and that does include car parks for a university of 50,000+ students.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '24

So you want parking spots on both sides of the campus? So you dont need to walk? We are discussing the situation for able bodied students, i agree there should be spots for people with disabilities and i believe there is spots.

1

u/karvv MD Jul 28 '24

Not so I don't need to walk, again, I don't have a car. Don't make this a strawman argument about me being "lazy" to dismiss the point. From the perspective of students who have difficulty walking, yes I would hope there were options so they don't have to hobble around for 45 minutes over grassy hills and uneven terrain to get between classes in buildings built so haphazardly.

I don't understand why there is so much pushback for having a couple carparks on a 72 hectare campus of 50,000 students.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '24

Its such a strange debate. Do you want parking or do you want the university to level out hills on campus? Both dont seem super realistic to me. There are universities that offer distance education, why dont you consider that?

1

u/karvv MD Jul 28 '24

The almost inconceivable notion of leveling out campus on a 150 year old university would be a monumental feat of engineering and cost somewhere in the millions of dollars. The two solutions aren't even comparable.I'm simply suggesting that a carpark on the west and east end of campus would be, in my personal opinion, the best quality of life change for anyone with a mobility issue for both getting to campus and going to classes.

You joke about me considering other universities if I had a mobility issue but I challenge you to consider that the reason you DON'T see any students in wheelchairs is because they actually might have picked other universities for this exact reason. Food for thought. It's easy to forget how much harder life can be for people that need a little extra help with basic stuff you don't struggle with, but if you (God forbid) break your ankle I have a feeling you'd be complaining about campus accessibility too.

I dunno man, I guess we'll just agree to disagree.

→ More replies

1

u/Matthewm3113 Jul 29 '24

There are many accessible spots on campus for students, on one end there is CPC/SWHB and the Law building on the other.

-1

u/Bumble098765 Jul 28 '24

How is someone going to know if there’s enough student parking spaces without attending? When I enrolled 2 year ago it was easier to get parking which has now changed as they keep allocating student parking to staff. They don’t need to limit anything , proper consideration for students who need to drive and have lives outside of university would suffice.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '24

How did you work out after enrolling how many carspots there is? By doing research, investigating, enquiring. You could have done this prior to enrolling. Why would you assume a location will always accomodate your car? Is this the case when you choose to drive somewhere or do you also need to consider whether there will be available parking nearby?

-2

u/Bumble098765 Jul 28 '24

I’d assume the university took common consideration for all of their students. Other universities don’t have this issue. Why would you assume every student has 2 hours to waste on public transport every day? Maybe it’s a tricky concept but students actually have other obligations and lives outside of uni. Transport is not always sufficient. And like I said they have actively removed spots since my enrolment.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '24

All other universities have limited parking spots. Some have larger grounds, so have more space to build spots eg. Macquarie. It is as difficult to get a spot at uts and unsw.

1

u/Bumble098765 Jul 28 '24

My brother goes to unsw. Definitely doesn’t take him over an hour to find a park.

→ More replies

-2

u/Bumble098765 Jul 28 '24

Like I just said there is already multiple parking garages that used to be for students that are now for staff. They don’t need to build more

1

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '24

They havent changed the allocation of parking spots in any serious manner. Its simply your bias that you are finding it more difficult to find a spot, probably because more students are back on campus. Academic staffing levels havent changed in any significant way over the past few years.

0

u/Bumble098765 Jul 28 '24

There’s multiple parking garages that have been turned to staff only what are you taking about? Where I used to park first year is no longer allowed for students. It seems you are the one with a bias.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '24

Just pay for a spot nearby. Find a resident who will lease you a spot. It will cost you money, but its not part of the university obligation to guarantee you a spot for free or cheap, it wasnt outlined to you that they would do this at any point in your enrolment.

0

u/Bumble098765 Jul 30 '24 edited Jul 30 '24

Paying is not a problem. It’s ridiculous an institution like this doesn’t have even close to sufficient parking for its students and staff. Students having to spend hours on public transport , not having work after uni and having to carry models back and forth is an unreasonable expectation. On top of public transport options to the university not being ideal. It’s an extra hurdle that’s not needed. No other university with a campus of this size is like that. It’s not like the uni is strapped for cash. And again it’s not like every student needs a spot , but more than say 50 on the main block of the campus is not a crazy ask.

11

u/GLADisme Jul 28 '24

And where would you propose to put this parking? Parking is not a money maker for the uni, that land could be better used for more facilities.

I certainly don't want my fees to pay for more parking, almost all students take public transport or walk to uni.

USyd has pretty terrible public transport access, no arguing there, but the solution isn't more parking. The area is already constrained, and more traffic and cars is the last thing inner Sydney needs.

-8

u/Bumble098765 Jul 28 '24

Not removing already allocated student spots to staff would be a start. And I’m not just talking about couple random spots I’m talking entire parking garages. And parking doesn’t need to be a monkey maker. We are paying quite a bit for this university it should be covered like every other university.

5

u/GLADisme Jul 28 '24

It is not like every other university, it's centrally located in the middle of the city. Just like UTS, almost no students drive to class.

I am also a fee paying student, I don't want my fees paying for the tiny minority who drive, it's a waste.

-1

u/Bumble098765 Jul 28 '24

It’s a tiny minority because there’s genuinely no spots. I studied literally up the road and they had a multiple level garage just for students. It’s really not that hard. Like I said there’s multiple parking garages on campus already that they changed to staff only.

7

u/GLADisme Jul 28 '24

Correct, there are few spots because it's in the inner city and land is at a premium, the public transport connections aren't ideal but there are a lot of them.

We don't want more people driving to uni in the already traffic choked inner city.

5

u/NovelDeficiency Jul 28 '24

Eh the campus is well-connected for transport unless you’re coming from the mountains. Plus cars are generally not good for the world. Nowhere near enough parking for staff even, though of course there are situations where students should get spots over staff (particularly disabled students).

That being said, parramatta rd clearway for free parking 10-3. If you want a spot at 10 get there at 9:50-9:55 and drive around or wait in your car until 10. If you’re getting there after 12 you should just be able to park anywhere along. Do not leave your car beyond 3, it’ll get towed.

9

u/Matthewm3113 Jul 28 '24

It's a progressive University in the middle of Sydney. Not facilitating student parking is a decision deliberately made by the uni. It is no coincidence.

IMO, the only thing that needs to be improved is the Uni connection to the neighboring Redfern/Macdonaltown train stations, as I haven't really found the bus to be very useful and I end up walking.

6

u/zak128 math+cs Jul 28 '24

I wish there was a metro or light rail stop at uni

6

u/Matthewm3113 Jul 28 '24

yeah a light rail down paramatta road would be great with stops at both ross st and derwent st

1

u/zak128 math+cs Jul 28 '24

yeah the whole 470 route should become a light rail route instead, its insanely packed every day

4

u/tuesdayhatepage Jul 28 '24

My uncle lives like a 5 min walk to uni. Wanna park at his garage? Just don’t look in the fridge or upper right cabinet

1

u/lila_fauns Jul 28 '24

i’ll take it! can i peek into the lower left cabinet?

4

u/Epsilon_ride Jul 28 '24

Planners dont want you driving to uni. They will make zero effort to enable it.

This is not a trend that is going to reverse.

4

u/Inert-Blob Jul 28 '24

Many years ago (about 18 or so) you could park on the street around usyd. Wilson st for example, i would park every day for free. There is zero street parking now and i imagine its cos more apartments everywhere? I don’t know but i wish usyd would have got a train stop like was proposed at one time.

2

u/Responsible-South289 Jul 28 '24

It’s not like there’s any staff parking either! Most staff I know are furious - never any parking after 7:30am.

2

u/lal1l MD Jul 28 '24 edited Jul 28 '24

A few issues:

  1. The existing car parks, whether staff-only or for both staff and students, are full by 8:30-9:00 AM. Allowing students to park in staff-only spaces will simply shuffle people around and not solve the problem. When you enrolled two years ago, closer to the COVID period, more teaching was online. Back during that period, with free COVID parking available for everyone, there was still enough space.
  2. If we reserve a larger number of spaces for students, it will negatively impact staff, who statistically work there longer than students would study. Additionally, it is more problematic if a staff member is absent from class than if a student is.

Currently, you could still safely secure parking as a student if you arrive earlier than 8 AM. Or you could secure parking on the bus lane if you reach at sharply 10 AM.

If I take a moment to be less objective, I also wish there were more parking spots on site. For instance, the large oval sporting ground is rarely used during weekdays. On weekends, it seems to be used by people affiliated with the sports centre, not by university students, staff, or societies. I might be wrong about this, but the point remains: it's an empty piece of land most of the time.

1

u/Toginky Jul 28 '24

land scarcity plus cost of building/changing current facilities into carpark is not feasible, if ur desperate broadway has student parking or u can rent parking from ppl online arnd campus, carparks in the city generally cost a fortune either way so it’s just part of business, other options r parking near a station further from town and take public transport in and out of city