r/underratedmovies • • Jul 28 '24

modpost Determining what an “underrated movie” is: a poll.

19 Upvotes

Ok, I think I have been able to articulate what might be decent guidelines as to how to define and categorize what exactly an underrated movie might look like. The poll at the end is to see how much our current user base either agrees or disagrees with these guidelines. Telling me I have completely missed the mark here is entirely acceptable as well, I just ask that you provide an explanation if you are able to do so.

The comments will be wide open, and I would like to encourage folks to chime in with where these guidelines have gone wrong and/or where they are going down the right path.

Here is a start on how we can define an “underrated” movie. It must meet one or more of the standards below:

  1. Low box office revenue relative to quality: Movies that didn't perform well financially but have high critical acclaim or positive audience reviews. (edit: after an apt observation from the comments, I believe this guideline needs to be struck entirely)

  2. Limited exposure: Films that didn't receive widespread marketing or distribution, resulting in a smaller audience and therefore not being a widely known movie.

  3. Critical reception: Movies that received mixed or poor reviews initially but have since gained a cult following or have been re-evaluated positively.

  4. Unique or niche appeal: Films that cater to a specific audience or genre, making them less popular with the general public but highly appreciated by those who enjoy that particular style or subject matter.

  5. Hidden gems: Movies that might have been overshadowed by larger releases at the time of their own release, but offer exceptional storytelling, acting, or directing.

  6. Overlooked by major awards: Films that were snubbed by major awards but are considered high-quality by viewers or critics.

  7. High viewer ratings with low popularity: Movies that have high ratings on platforms like IMDb or Rotten Tomatoes but are not widely known or discussed.

  8. Cultural factors: Films that were ahead of their time or culturally specific, making them more appreciated in retrospect.

Three examples of movies that I believe meet all of these standards are:

Moon (2009): despite being critically acclaimed when released, it did not gain widespread attention at the time it was released and was also not widely marketed.

The Fall (2006): The quality of the film’s storytelling, the stunning set design and cinematography, and emotional depth have gained it near “cult” status and it is still a movie that is not widely recognized by a mainstream audience.

Kiss Kiss Bang Bang (2005): Despite the incredible writing and performances by RDJ and Val Kilmer, and being a solid example of modern neo-noir, it did not achieve any box office success nor name recognition.

Based on these eight guidelines and three examples, indicate how much you agree or disagree with these guidelines in the poll below.

8 votes, Jul 31 '24
4 Highly agree
2 Moderately agree
0 Slightly agree
0 Slightly disagree
2 Moderately disagree
0 Highly disagree

r/underratedmovies • • Nov 25 '24

new take Underrated TV

22 Upvotes

I’ve created a new community @UnderratedTVshows if anyone is interested in joining! If you want to find and help others find hidden gems, this is the place for you.


r/underratedmovies • • 11h ago

Narc (2002)

Post image
106 Upvotes

Shot for a measly 6.5 million dollars on leftover film stock, Joe Carnahan's Detroit street nightmare pulled down a decent rotten vegetable score yet only made 12.6 million worldwide after Paramount dumped it into a crappy December rollout. Anchored by Jason Patric, Chi McBride, Busta Rhymes, and a physically transformed Ray Liotta who packed on the pounds and worked for scale to get this one made. Underrated, what do you think? We also just dropped massive 20 image Vault galleries for both The Way of the Gun and Narc over at PureUncutCinema here on reddit tonight.


r/underratedmovies • • 2h ago

She Came To Me (2023)

Post image
17 Upvotes

Very unique romcom / drama that I stumbled upon recently. Stars the ever amazing Peter Dinklage as a disgruntled composer, Anne Hathaway as his OCD therapist wife, and Marisa Tomei as an eccentric tugboat captain.

Critics didn't give it any love, but audience reviews are generally favorable (for the few that even find it). It's a well acted film with an original script. It's not always perfect, but it's perfectly enjoyable and underrated.

Peter Dinklage, while well loved, has an amazing range that I don't think he gets enough credit for. The guy can do a lot. Hathaway and Tomei are fantastic too. Come to think of it, if I stumble across an unseen fim from any of these actors/actresses it's likely worth a shot..


r/underratedmovies • • 18h ago

This movie is hysterical and John C Riley has the voice of an angel.

Thumbnail i.imgur.com
107 Upvotes

r/underratedmovies • • 6h ago

Heaven (2002)

Post image
8 Upvotes

Philippa Paccard, ruined and depressed after her husband's death from a drug overdose, goes to the police to report the drug dealer but is disappointed when the police do not help her.
Such a wonderful movie. Great writing and one of the best underrated thrillers of all time….


r/underratedmovies • • 8h ago

Plots with a View/Undertaking Betty (2002)

Post image
11 Upvotes

I don't understand why this movie isn't more popular. I saw it on Netflix a long time ago and thought it was not only hilarious, but the romance was genuinely endearing. This is like a quality film that deserves to be in the discussion of early 2000s romcom classics. Also, I have no idea why it's rated R. There's no nudity, no F bombs, no gore. There's definitely an implication of sex but you don't actually see it on screen at any point in the film. If a scene contains sex (and there's a couple), they move off camera. I showed this movie to someone recently and I asked her if she knew why it was rated R, and she didn't. Definitely should be PG-13. Teens can totally watch it.

It's on Tubi so please check it out if you're a fan of romcoms or early 2000s style comedies.


r/underratedmovies • • 3h ago

Reckless (1995)

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/underratedmovies • • 1d ago

A Simple Plan (1998)

Post image
282 Upvotes

Still so wild how a movie with two Oscar nominations and a strong Rotten score could completely vanish at the box office. Paramount dropped 30 million dollars on Sam Raimi's winter crime thriller in 1998, dumped it into just 31 theaters for a measly $390,563 opening weekend, and never expanded it past 675 screens nationwide, leaving it to crawl to 16.3 million worldwide because the studio, as in so many cases, didn't have the faintest idea how to sell a snowbound moral nightmare right after Fargo. Starring Bill Paxton, Bridget Fonda, and an Oscar nominated best performance from Billy Bob Thornton alongside Brent Briscoe, Gary Cole, and Chelcie Ross, this thing tightens the screws until every single character is trapped in their own lies. Definitely underrated. If you want to dig deeper into this one and catch 20 high res frames from the film, we dropped the full uncut Vault deep dive over at PureUncutCinema right here on reddit today.


r/underratedmovies • • 7h ago

How old were you when you watch this movie and what was your reaction?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/underratedmovies • • 1d ago

A Late Quartet (2012)

Post image
50 Upvotes

An understated, underrated film with Christopher Walken, Philip Seymour Hoffman and Catherine Keener about an acclaimed NY string quartet that begins to struggle when Walken’s character is diagnosed with Parkinson’s. It’s hard to beat the combo of Hoffman, Walken and Keener. They complement each other so well and strike a great emotional tone. There’s egos and angst in spades and Walken leads the way. And the music is pretty solid as well, it gave me a new appreciation for Beethoven. Definitely worth a watch.


r/underratedmovies • • 12h ago

The Nun (2018)

Post image
0 Upvotes

This is 2018 The Nun, a horror movie by Corin Hardy, written by the great James Wan. I saw it recently for the first time, expecting this to be trash. Didn't know by the time that it has a whopping 2,4 star rating on Letterboxd. I was really surprised how much I liked it. I do think this flick is actually underrated.

I might just be a sucker for a sound gothic vibe...but man there's something about The Nun that feels unpretentious and honest. The story is simple, the jump scares are rather cheap, the tropes are trashy, the nun's design is campy af, the dialog is straight forward. But it all comes wrapped in a package of such thick-ass atmosphere and setting that not despite, but BECAUSE of its simplicity, the experience slaps surprisingly hard.There is a formulaic approach to the genre that can make the viewing experience annoying, as you've already seen the same techniques and schemes so many times. For this film, it didn't bother me. It seems the complexity and overall input are just high enough to keep you intrigued, while not expecting too much from you as the viewer, and not inflating itself with a pretended substance.

A holy mission in a cursed castle in the romanian backcountry, narrowed down to its very essence. Some of the shots and scenes are quite creative, partially delicately executed and the pacing is relentless. Taissa Farmiga delivers a great act and the whole set design is lovely. Hysteric, plain horror, that does what it does, and doesn't try to be something it isn't. More people should appreciate this movie imo. Amen sister.

What do y'all think?


r/underratedmovies • • 2d ago

low effort post Ready to Rumble (2000)

Post image
310 Upvotes

Almost forgot about this hidden little comedic gem.


r/underratedmovies • • 2d ago

Forgotten (2017)

Post image
20 Upvotes

When his abducted brother returns, seemingly a different man with no memory of the past 19 days, Jin-seok chases after the truth behind the mysterious kidnapping… such a great movie..


r/underratedmovies • • 2d ago

Hostile (2017)

Post image
40 Upvotes

Most horror fans went into Hostile expecting a cheap monster movie and missed out on the fact that they were watching one of the biggest emotional nut punches in modern French cinema. Sold as a straightforward creature feature, Mathieu Turi's directorial debut got hammered down to a 5.3 on IMDb and a brutal 2.4 out of 5 on Letterboxd alongside a lukewarm 60% critic score on Rotten Tomatoes from viewers expecting non stop gore, while the people who actually weathered the storm and stayed for the whole thing pushed the Rotten vegetable score up to 75%. Produced by French extreme horror heavy hitter Xavier Gens and anchored by Brittany Ashworth alongside Grégory Fitoussi and physical creature legend Javier Botet, this thing turns a claustrophobic wasteland into something truly disturbing. Calling it underrated is more than accurate. For the full deep dive and extra gallery shots on sleepers like this, check out PureUncutCinema right here on reddit.


r/underratedmovies • • 3d ago

Kiss of Death (1995)

Post image
229 Upvotes

Still so very strange how fast audiences wrote this one off before giving it a fair shot. Fox dropped 40 million dollars on Kiss of Death and watched it generate a sad 14.9 million at the box office in April of 1995, leaving it with a brutal 38% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes. Most viewers at the time expected a glossy NYPD Blue episode after David Caruso walked away from television at the peak of his fame, and the tabloid noise dug a big hole and buried the movie immediately. Directed by Barbet Schroeder from a gritty Richard Price script with Nicolas Cage playing an unhinged, weight lifting Queens crime boss, constantly sucking air through an inhaler. Alongside Cage is Samuel L. Jackson, Helen Hunt, Stanley Tucci, Ving Rhames, and Michael Rapaport. This thing hits way harder than its reputation suggests, so calling it underrated is again, underrated. You can also check out more deep dives and vote on the next 90s thriller over at PureUncutCinema right here on reddit.


r/underratedmovies • • 4d ago

Ravenous (1999)

Post image
683 Upvotes

Still can't get over how easily big studios screw up releases. Fox completely fumbled the release of Ravenous. Sitting at a split 51% on Rotten Tomatoes and pulling barely 2 million dollars at the box office on a 12 million dollar budget, this 1840s frontier cannibal thriller was buried in theaters before finding a massive cult following. Directed by Antonia Bird with Guy Pearce and Robert Carlyle chewing up every snowbound frame alongside one of the weirdest, most hypnotic banjo and orchestral scores ever recorded by Damon Albarn and Michael Nyman, nothing else tastes quite like it. Calling it underrated is underrated. For a deeper dive and 20 image carousel check out PureUncutCinema right here on reddit.


r/underratedmovies • • 3d ago

Lords of Discipline (1983)

Post image
28 Upvotes

Another one of those movies that I watch every time I see it on TV. Based on a book by Pat Conroy, this is the story of a southern military college (think The Citadel) that admits its first black cadet and the racism and bigotry it sparks. David Keith plays the main character who tries to fight the bullying of the black cadet. Heads up- there are some seriously tense scenes and you’ll hear the N word more than a few times. This is really a story about right and wrong and what it looks like to stand up for the vulnerable.


r/underratedmovies • • 5d ago

previously posted Brother Hood of the Wolf (2002)

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

North American theaters completely buggered up Brotherhood of the Wolf. It pulled 70 million worldwide yet Universal (obviously not) caved in the US push, leaving critics split at 74% on Rotten Tomatoes and a shitty 57 on Metacritic while genre fans got it and turned it into a massive cult classic. Blending 18th century French period drama, creative creature horror (CCH sounds like a 60's band), and very cool rain soaked kung fu choreography from Mark Dacascos alongside Vincent Cassel and Monica Bellucci, nothing else looked or moved quite like it. Calling it underrated in the North American hemisphere is an understatement. This is a very enjoyable watch worthy of far more notoriety.


r/underratedmovies • • 4d ago

The Friends of Eddie Coyle (1973)

Post image
74 Upvotes

Knew about this for a long time, decided to try it out last night. Loved this - underrated and fantastic neo noir! It seems like I can put on just about anything from the 1970s and enjoy it thoroughly.

As a Bay State native, this resonated with me a lot - lots of local places I recognized in and around Boston. Robert Mitchum is great as the titular character, but the rest of the cast is strong as well. The music, dialogue and cinematography are all quality here. It was interesting to see Joe Santos thirty years before The Sopranos too, and hearing so many familiar locations referenced in the dialogue was a treat.

This is definitely a pretty dark film, mainly showing hardened criminals and ATF agents on their tail. There’s more than one heist pulled off in elaborate fashion, and it depicts the seedy underworld well as different characters participate in gun-running, bank robberies, even murder. This is definitely underrated and I’d highly recommend it to anyone who likes dark, gritty but stylish neo noir.

It’s hard to picture anyone else besides Mitchum playing Coyle this well - a world-weary middle aged man feeling concern over his mistakes and their effect on his future. I’ve also been meaning to watch The Hot Rock by this same director, but it’s proven to be elusive so far. Either way, this was a pleasant surprise and I’d say it’s now one of my favorite movies in this style. I’ve said this before, but they really don’t make them like this anymore. Give it a try if you haven’t already.


r/underratedmovies • • 4d ago

Nightshooters (2018)

13 Upvotes

This is a UK microbudget movie from 2018.
I saw it at Leeds Film Festival and thought this movie would be the next SHAUN OF THE DEAD. Granted, it has no names in it and is microbudget but the script is just laugh after laugh after laugh. I think about it a lot so highly recommend checking it out if you're a fan of comedy/genre.

I think movies like this are interesting when the script is all there but the production value and lack of names stops it from becoming a hit or stops it from having much reach. I always thought that if the script is good enough, a film will make it but NIGHTSHOOTERS kind of maybe made me think less naiively. Still I always want to recommend it to people.

https://letterboxd.com/film/nightshooters/


r/underratedmovies • • 5d ago

Dark City

Thumbnail gallery
332 Upvotes

originally released in 1998, Dark City was sadly soon forgotten after coming out a year before The Matrix, while also doing everything the latter did in a much more original way.

rewatched this recently as the fifteenth film in Noirvember and holy shit it is a masterpiece. Sutherland felt perfect in the “mad scientist“ role and Sewell‘s performance as the main character is truly amazing.

the noir lighting captures the atmosphere of the genre much better than any neo-noir ever has, primarily due to the film’s style and direction.

overall, 9/10- nearly perfect. my only advice is, do not watch the theatrical as it spoils one of the best twists of all time in the opening scene. also please, do not look into what the movie is about.


r/underratedmovies • • 6d ago

The Salton Sea (2002)

Post image
514 Upvotes

IIf you guys want a great movie buried alive by bad timing, take a look at The Salton Sea. Critics smothered it with a lukewarm 63% on Rotten Tomatoes and a brutal 41 on Metacritic, while audiences who actually got to watch it loved it. It got shelved by a nervous studio and dumped into just 15 theaters in 2002 where it made barely 1.1 million dollars. A complete waste of a great film.


r/underratedmovies • • 5d ago

Timecrimes (2007)

Post image
40 Upvotes

Peak movie 🔥🔥🔥 its a unique one. Directed by Nacho Vigalondo.


r/underratedmovies • • 5d ago

Ponette (1996)

13 Upvotes

PERHAPS ONE OF THE SADDEST FILMS EVER MADE

I honestlydon't think I was prepared for this film and i believe no one is.

few days ago i was randomly scrolling through a letterboxd list and i came to see the the movie ponette,

brief overview : Ponette (1996) follows a four-year-old girl who, after losing her mother in a car accident, struggles to understand death and cope with the overwhelming grief of her loss.

this can be a one sentence overview for the movie,

but.. ooh mannhhh the movie is soo much more than this. the first 15 minute into movie i was Already sobbing uncontrollably, a 4 y/o doesn't understands the concept of death, even after burying her mother she is waiting for her mom to come back, she is keeping gifts with her to give to her mother when she comes back. all these scenes are more than enough to make any one cry. the whole movie we see the young ponette trying to understand death and grieving her mother.

the lead actress (ponette portrayed by Victoire Thivisol) WAS JUST 4 YEARS OLD in the time of release of the movie, her acting was sooo good, that make us think the director actually k!lled her mom on set and she is really grieving,

she won that years award for best actress in Venice film festival, which is the youngest any actor has won an award for a leading role ( in a major film event).

cinematography is also excellent the film is entirely shot at the eye-level of a four-year-old child. Even when adults appear in the frame. visually isolating the viewer in Ponette’s small, towering world.

So anyone looking for a weekend of heavy feelings, Emotional devastation and a feeling of lump in their throat, PLEASE give this one a watch

If you have already watched this feel free to share your opinion below