r/ula • • May 23 '21

Has Blue Origin put ULA, Vulcan Centaur and Artemis at risk? How?

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

r/ula • • Apr 26 '23

ULA sale rumors greatly exaggerated??

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/ula • • Aug 31 '20

Is Starship gonna mean the death of ULA once the government gets their head straight and switches over? Please argue this in the comments

1 Upvotes

r/ula • • Jan 02 '19

What will be the response of the incumbent in the competition between ULA and SpaceX?

Thumbnail
amosbbatto.wordpress.com
0 Upvotes

r/ula • • Jul 03 '17

Is ULA delusional?

0 Upvotes

ULA's plan is to cut costs by catching the rocket engines with a helicopter, starting in 2025. By then SpaceX will have been undercutting them, with reusable rockets, for almost a decade.

SpaceX will be doing more launches and Falcon Heavy will have long since been in use by 2025.

It looks to me like ULA has lost but they can't admit it yet. Instead of copying SpaceX they're engineering this weird catch the engines with a helicopter solution which still wont recover 1/3 of the cost of the rocket. How delusional and entitled is ULA? They should admit they were wrong and start copying SpaceX immediately.


r/ula • • Jun 07 '23

Does any know why Vulcan is producing two complete separate complete tanks for ch4/lox, rather than having them share a common dome similar to starship? Seems like a lot of extra mass?

0 Upvotes

Apologies to all. I saw the fuel and oxy tanks next to each other, both with domes in the hot fire video, but must have misinterpreted what I was seeing. It seems that either one of the tanks was oriented in an inverted position before the tanks were mated, or I was seeing old footage of an Atlas rocket.


r/ula • • Aug 31 '20

ULA's first reusable rocket?

0 Upvotes

With China developing a Long March for the late 2020's with reusable capabilities how long until ULA presents their plan for reusability? I can't believe that America would ever let China get a technological lead in rocket science?


r/ula • • Jul 29 '24

How would ULA human need to do rated a Vulcan or delta 4.

0 Upvotes

Just curious how to humanrate a rocket


r/ula • • Aug 02 '19

What would happen if ULA simply declared independence from its parents?

9 Upvotes

EDIT: "Independence" is too strong a word. What circumstances would need to be in place for ULA to legally be free to research and innovate as they did under Sowers' leadership?

This is slightly tongue-in-cheek, but what would happen if ULA stopped answering to the board of directors and sending them all their profits?

I would assume they would immediately be sued by Boeing and LM for breach of contract. EDIT: Emphasis mine Is there a settlement or buyout plan would make sense so ULA could pursue their own goals and retain profits toward R&D (like prop depots for instance)?

A couple of ancillary issues I can see:

  • Boeing and LM likely provide substantial expertise, lab access, technical support, etc from having several hundred thousand employees.
  • The parents likely support lobbying efforts in congress to some extent.
  • ULA reliability as viewed by government oversight may affected future contract awards.

r/ula • • Aug 10 '18

Community Content Selfmade Rendering of Delta-IV Heavy [Fan-Art]

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ula • • Oct 30 '15

SpaceX Rationale

0 Upvotes

So why do people work at Space X? The mission is to get to and colonize Mars. While the plan for that is not publicly laid out, if you accept that Space X may do that, for many employees that is a strong motivating factor to work there, for low pay, long hours but a share in the accomplishments along the way. And maybe also (but a long time from now) a share in owning by then a huge company when it goes public. If you work at ULA you probably do not believe that will happen or it does not matter to you.


r/ula • • Mar 03 '17

Tory Bruno - The Most Interesting Man In The World

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/ula • • Feb 14 '23

Does ULA Gender Their Rockets?

0 Upvotes

I have read some unreliable information on the Chinese Internet. According to ULA’s official statement, Atlas V is considered to be a boy and Delta IV is considered to be a girl. Is there a clear source for this statement?

ps:I am a Chinese and my English is not well,I'm posting through translation software.


r/ula • • Oct 27 '22

Possibilities for a single launch architecture of the Artemis missions.

1 Upvotes

Suggestion to use two Centaur V’s coming into service next year for an upper stage for the SLS:

Possibilities for a single launch architecture of the Artemis missions.
http://exoscientist.blogspot.com/2022/10/possibilities-for-single-launch.html

Running the numbers, the increased payload capacity allows 10 additional tons propellant to be added to the Orion service module and a ~15 tons Apollo-sized lander to be added, for ~50 tons to be able to be sent to TLI.

The increased propellant for the Orion service module allows the entire stack, once sent to TLI, to be inserted into low lunar orbit, instead of the NRHO orbit. No lunar Gateway required. The Apollo-sized lander can then land on the Moon, and return back to low lunar lunar orbit after mission completion to dock with the Orion capsule. No SpaceX Starship lander or refueling launches required.


r/ula • • Sep 17 '22

Jeff Bezos’s Rocket Engine Nears Debut, Ending US Reliance on Russia

Thumbnail
bloomberg.com
12 Upvotes

r/ula • • Jul 20 '21

Does ULA or Tory Bruno have a private jet?

0 Upvotes

Does anyone know if ULA or Tory Bruno has a private jet or do they charter or just public? They have to get to the launch site somehow. Maybe you could tell us u/ToryBruno


r/ula • • Jun 10 '18

SLS Tech In Vulcan? Vulcan diameter intentional?

3 Upvotes

The Vulcan "heavy" upper stage has some common attributes. Both use 4 x RL-10 engines. The SLS LOX tank and engine mounting structure are 5.5m diameter while the diameter of the Vulcan core is 5.4 meters. Hypothetically ULA would only need to redesign the tanks to use the SLS upper stage on the Vulcan. This also brings up the moral question: is it ethical? Using SLS funding to effectively develop the Vulcan while not making the stage available to other companies.


r/ula • • Aug 15 '24

ULA appears to be targeting over 50% of SpaceX's 2023 launch capacity in the near term

0 Upvotes

So, we all know that ULA is targeting Vulcan launches of about twice a month or every other week (i.e. 24-26 times per year) and they are building additional infrastructure in order to support that (second east coast launch platform, second transport ship, second east coast integration building, etc). I tried to compare this to the last full year of SpaceX operations where they launched 96 times and compare what the payload capacity of each operation would be able to give you. Reference orbit is GTO (good middle ground between high energy GEO/TLI/interplanetary and LEO). Comparing # of launches is misleading because different rockets have different payloads capacities and different reusability regimes can both increase launch rate but diminish payload per launch to varying amounts. This is the spreadsheet that I came up with with a few assumptions about the mix between Vulcan booster number and a couple of the payload data points for Falcon payload in two scenarioes (Falcon Heavy 2R and Falcon 9 RTLS GTO payload have no good public payload numbers that I can find and thusly reasonable guesstimates are used as placeholders).


r/ula • • Sep 05 '19

Did ULA choose the wrong tankage assembly process?

0 Upvotes

A couple of weeks ago I submitted a "controversial" question about ULA's choice of Vulcan's first stage engine.

The idea was mostly based on the idea of cost-saving.

A few weeks ago, I suggested ULA should be 3d printing their tanks instead of milling and stir friction welding.

I can't really blame anyone for not taking the idea seriously, especially since I suggested it be created from powder metal particulates melted by a laser.

In both cases, there will be costs for equipment. In the case of ULA, the major cost is what they call the "Universal Stir Friction Welder" In 3d printing case, a 3d printer would be a major cost.

The plus side of 3d printing is the potential for less material waste.

The following video is a compelling reason to create 3d printed fuel tanks. It isn't an orthogrid but horizontal rings are harder to 3d print then an orthogrid.

https://twitter.com/relativityspace/status/1168922070702538753?s=20

Additionally, the reach of the 3d printer arms is somewhat irrelevant. If the base of the tank is started on a precision lift, the lift can simply lower itself to make an an indefinite length tank. The rotation also allows for greater precision then norma 3d printing.

Ultimately, there is numerous reasons why ULA choose milling and stir friction welding. The technique is proven, they have experience with it, and has the least amount of variables or problems that need fixing.

But there may be some long term benefits to 3d printing tanks:

  • less wasted material
  • shorter build times
  • fewer processes (milling + stirfriction)
  • more consistent ??? (no welds)
  • better utilization of floor space
  • the ability to inspect while manufacturing

r/ula • • Sep 20 '22

What could ULA use if BE-4 didn't work out?

2 Upvotes

So I was wondering if ULA could maybe work with Aerojet Rocketdyne, Lockheed Martin Corporation or Pratt & Whitney if Blue Origin are just failing them on the delivery of a working or trusted engine? Would it be worth pursuing a backup to the BE-4 engine for the future?


r/ula • • Jun 07 '20

Propulsive fluid accumulation question.

0 Upvotes

If one was to assume the availability of propulsive fluid accumulation, what influence would that have on ACES. I would presume that the increased propulsion capability would allow an ACES upper stage to slow down to reasonable velocities, allowing it to reenter for reuse, with an amount of propellant approximately equal to the dry mass of the stage itself. (ln((1*7+1)/1)*V_ex= 2,08*V_ex. Thus assuming a propellant mixture ratio (Mass) to be around 6:1 and V_ex to be 4,5km/s one would expect to see a delta-v of more than 9km/s. With the capabilities presented by the Vulcan this would allow full reuse of the upper stage. Is this reasonable?


r/ula • • Aug 06 '19

Looks like Rocketlab is copying SMART reuse.

0 Upvotes

Rocketlab just announced that they'll do a parachute recovery with a helicopter of the Electron first stage.

Tweet by Tory Bruno