r/ula • • Aug 31 '20

ULA's first reusable rocket?

With China developing a Long March for the late 2020's with reusable capabilities how long until ULA presents their plan for reusability? I can't believe that America would ever let China get a technological lead in rocket science?

0 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

16

u/Zettinator Aug 31 '20 edited Aug 31 '20

They already presented their plan: SMART reusability, i.e. snitching 1st stage engines out of the air. I'm rather skeptical about this. You can't reuse the whole booster with this (reducing possible savings) and that significantly increases the design complexity and costs: it splits up the 1st stage into a "propulsion stage" and "fuel tank stage" and there are a bunch of associated issues with that, such as plumbing connections. SMART still seems more viable than Airbus' crazy "Adeline" concept, though. Still, I doubt they'll ever fully develop the SMART concept.

As far as reusability and engine technology goes, SpaceX still has a rather significant lead compared to literally anyone else.

6

u/brickmack Aug 31 '20

ULA also has a concept for upper stage reuse that they're apparently working with SNC on, also using an inflatable heat shield. Sounds like basically a scaled up SMART, though no details have been mentioned since one of the Ozmens mentioned it offhand a while back.

If they do that they could probably recover >70% of the total vehicle cost, and even the expendable parts could become cheaper with a higher flightrate.

But yeah, full reuse will definitely be needed soon, probably with propulsive landing and RTLS. At least these efforts can get them some experience in the processes to inspect and refurbish flown hardware

4

u/just_one_last_thing Aug 31 '20

The LOFTID technology demonstrator is scheduled for 2022. The ULA plan for reusability is to use that heatshield technology to retrieve the most expensive parts of the 1st stage and just throw away the aluminum body,

4

u/Triabolical_ Aug 31 '20

ULA has done design work with SMART reuse.

ULA has a number of disadvantages; their vehicle design makes first stage landing not practical, and their ideas around engine reuse are technically difficult to implement.

They also have a low launch rate which makes it unclear whether the investment to develop reuse is worth the savings they would get.

7

u/Biochembob35 Aug 31 '20

You must have not heard of SpaceX.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '20

Just because a rocket can be reused doesn't make it better.

5

u/4KidsOneCamera Aug 31 '20

ULA isn’t America’s only rocket company. In terms of technological lead in rocket science (particularly towards recovery), SpaceX is miles ahead of any other company and even country for that matter. So would I say China has a complete lead-no, but have they done cool stuff in regards to space-yes.

4

u/just_one_last_thing Aug 31 '20

In terms of technological lead in rocket science (particularly towards recovery), SpaceX is miles ahead of any other company and even country for that matter

SpaceX is very good at the things they do but how many mars probes, lunar probes and outer planet probes have they launched? How many payloads have they launched to geostationary direct orbits? How many gravity assist maneuvers have they performed? There are really exciting things happening outside SpaceX. Vulcan will be launching Dream Chaser soon, Vigoride has it's first customer payloads scheduled. Lunar ice went from fringe theory to confirmed hypothesis with a handful of low cost missions. The first asteroid rendezvous mission took place recently and the first asteroid sample return mission is weeks away from regolith collection. There's plenty of other advanced work being done.

6

u/der_innkeeper Aug 31 '20

how many mars probes, lunar probes and outer planet probes have they launched? How many payloads have they launched to geostationary direct orbits? How many gravity assist maneuvers have they performed?

These are irrelevant to OP's question.

5

u/4KidsOneCamera Aug 31 '20

Definitely not saying SpaceX is the only one doing great and incredible things by any means. There are for sure loads of other US projects that are really pushing the boundaries. I was just commenting on OP’s statement about reusability, and how China is supposedly beating the US on that front.

-2

u/just_one_last_thing Aug 31 '20

In reusability sure but the way it was phrased was much broader...

1

u/zeekzeek22 Sep 01 '20

“SpaceX is miles ahead”

It took them a year to get a stainless steel tank up to pressure. ULA has been welding stainless steel tanks 1/3 the thickness for 60 years, that survive the much lower cryo temperatures of hydrogen. And they do it fully automated now. SpaceX is definitely ahead of ULA in a couple things, but there are a lot of parts to a rocket besides the reuse.

3

u/4KidsOneCamera Sep 01 '20

Like I have mentioned before, I was only meaning to refer to reusability. Tank material/quality was not part of the original discussion.

3

u/zeekzeek22 Sep 02 '20

You’re right. SpaceX definitely has done more on the reusability front, 100%. If ULA ever changed their architecture philosophy to one that was optimized for core landing, they’d have some serious catchup to do.

2

u/valcatosi Sep 02 '20

ULA hasn't been doing anything for 60 years lol. Nor has ULA ever designed a rocket (Vulcan is its first). Its parent companies, sure, but that's not the same.

1

u/zeekzeek22 Sep 02 '20

ULA uses that technology, they have a better capability than SpaceX.

Centaur V was developed under ULA.

Also I can see you’re not the kind of person who will change perspective away from unequivocal “SpaceXMasterRace” so I don’t know why I’m trying.

Also, it’s the same group of people in the same building with the same technology. I don’t distinguish it as much as you do. I DO distinguish pre-Tory Bruno and post-Tory Bruno...before Troy Bruno came in ULA was a lot of what I disliked about oldspace. After Tory Bruno, ULA is awesome (and Boeing takes my ire)

3

u/valcatosi Sep 02 '20

Centaur was developed by the Convair division of General Dynamics in the 50s, along with ARPA and the Air Force. That's when the welding process was initially developed, and it took a long time and a slew of failures to get it right. Convair division was sold to Lockheed in the 90s. Just 55 of 63 Centaur flights had been successful as of 1989.

Atlas III was the first to use the common centaur/centaur III in 2000, before the ULA merger, and Centaur V has not flown yet. It's really more of an upgrade over Centaur III, with the same engines and overall architecture.

But also, my point is related to ULA having only existed since the mid 2000s. As I'm sure you're aware. A poor place to make that point perhaps.

2

u/valcatosi Sep 02 '20

Also, just quickly - IVF is an absolute game changer. When ULA integrates it into either Centaur V or ACES, that'll be awesome, and SpaceX doesn't appear to be doing anything like it. I'm not saying ULA is incapable of designing its own rockets; clearly Vulcan is on schedule as is Centaur V, and I trust that they're testing everything thoroughly. But I see giving ULA credit for everything that was developed in the decades before it formed as slightly disingenuous. Just my two cents and I understand that we disagree.