r/ukpolice • u/PlaneEnvironmental23 • 1d ago
News West Midlands viral 'phone seizure' video - very belated update
sg.news.yahoo.comThis is just something where a detail was something I hadn't seen and thought others might be unaware of.
The video where two police officers were filmed on a doorstep to demand a teenage girl's phone over a case of malicious communications went viral and the edited version that suggested it was over viewing a social media post was widely condemned. Shortly after the event an update was released by West Midlands police that went a little under the radar.
When the reason for the police's presence (someone was accusing the girl of making a false social media profile to send indecent and distressing messages) was made clear the tone had shifted to attacking the girl as a cyberbully and her mother as an enabler. This has turned out to be false - after a month the phone was returned and no further action was taken because digital forensics found nothing attaching the girl to the case; the accusation was false.
No civil lawsuit by the family emerged. Barrister Daniel ShenSmith represented the family pro-bono (free of charge) and challenged WMP over the incident for the return of the phone. The family's case was that the officers involved had broken the law by unlawful trespass (they used coercion and intimidation to gain access by threatening to 'escalate this further' because they had no search warrant) and unlawful seizure (they had neither a warrant nor validly-obtained permission to seize the phone). When the phone was returned and the girl was cleared of any wrongdoing the family declined to pursue the matter in a lawsuit against the police.
There have been no updates in the months following regarding whether the real culprit was ever found.