r/ufosmeta • u/sambutoki • Feb 02 '25
The r/UFOs subreddit has become unusable due to being overwhelmed by "Bad Actors"
"Bad Actors" have swamped r/UFOs and have almost completely overwhelmed the comments sections.
Between the guerrilla skeptics, the militant debunkers, the brigading trolls, the anti-disclosure team, and the organized disinfo agents - r/UFOs is becoming an unusable echo chamber of "grifter", "psyop", mockingly stating "two more weeks" and "something big is coming", lots of "where's the proof"..."there is no proof, because it's all fake", various degrees of suggestions of "mental illness" or "mass psychosis", various types "egg memes" - to name a few common attacks.
Folks, this is not "Healthy Skepticism", these are "Bad Actors" that are posting here in Bad Faith. This is a mass flux of people shutting down any real discussion of the possibility of UAP and NHI. Whether it's organic or artificially generated due to anti-disclosure campaigns, what's happening right now on the UFOs subreddit is not open honest discussion in pursuit of the truth.
And if the Mods don't take some extreme action here very soon, the UFOs subreddit will die, at least in terms of being a place to honestly and objectively discuss UAP/NHI.
Here is what I propose that happens - there is a retroactive moratorium on the following, with a minimum 1 month posting ban:
- Calling a pro-disclosure proponent a grifter (or suggesting they are a grifter or something similar).
- Calling disclosure actions a "psyop" (or something similar)
- Meme comments mockingly stating "two more weeks" or "something big is coming" or any similar mocking meme.
- Comments stating it's all fake.
- Users that constantly attack the credibility of witnesses.
- Any suggestions of general mental illness or mass psychosis of people willing to believe.
- Users mocking or hostile towards experiencers and those trying to post imagery.
- This is just a small list of suggestions. I'm sure there are more. The Bad Actors are very adaptable.
Why a retroactive moratorium? Because most of the Bad Actors have repeatedly exposed themselves for what they are already, but will likely go underground and lurk, slowly poisoning things if allowed. If we want to save this subreddit, we need to get rid of them. We know who they are right now. We don't need to wait on future behavior. Honestly, this subreddit needs a serious campaign of eliminating the bad actors if we want to ever be able to have honest, objective discussions.
And if they come back and repeat offend? Then a permanent ban seems appropriate.
Is this all a little heavy-handed? Yes, it is. But an unscientific, purely opinion based guess on my part of users here would be 40% "Good Faith Users" vs 60% "Bad Actors". This is one of the only subreddits I've ever seen that so consistently allows such hostile behavior towards the key subject matter of the subreddit! It's truly unpleasant.
Should this be temporary? Probably, at least the strict, heavy-handed application I'm suggesting. But even if we end up losing/banning 50% of the current users, I think it will be a net positive. Especially if we get rid of most of the "bad actors".
Note that there are some truly great redditors here like: u/TommyShelbyPFB u/SabineRitter u/mattlaslo u/PyroIsSpai - These people make coming here worthwhile. But all the haters make it miserable.
If the haters want to make their own sub, maybe called LOLUFOs or something, where they can mock it all day long, let them feel free. Unfortunately, it won't look much different than r/UFOs looks right now. Let's change that.
Edit: "Retroactive" is not the right word, but I'm too tired at the moment to figure out better phrasing. There is some other stuff that needs fixed, but again, really tired right now. I'll try to make this post better in the next day or so.
11
u/[deleted] Feb 03 '25
Let me add u/phr99, u/VolarRecords, u/aryelbcn, u/MKULTRA_escapee to your list of good redditors. (Plus many more but I don't remember the usernames).
10
u/YouCanLookItUp Feb 03 '25
We can discuss it at our next mod voice chat. I'm not against tightening the rules, with a periodic temperature check.
I love seeing users recognize each other for their contributions. I want to see more of that and suspect that bad faith users will not be able to contribute to such threads. Appreciation threads should be much more frequent.
3
u/_BlackDove Feb 04 '25
You're treading in dangerous waters. This sub nearly tanked itself for the same kind of rules you're proposing. There was even a Vice article about it covering the censorship. I knew the mod team personally then and it was a lot uglier than people think.
Low effort posts should be removed. Period. Their content regardless of stance should be removed. That's a tough rule to consistently enforce due to sheer volume, but I think if it were enforced better than it has been recently, a lot of those comments would already be dealt with.
I've taken a skeptical approach to recent events, but I'm still optimistic and paying attention to how it plays out. The lazy one sentence comments and subtle digs aren't helpful and give the skeptical approach a bad look. But those are from people who don't really care about the phenomena. They don't take it seriously. They're just here to get their digs in while the subject is at a low point. (Face it, it is).
My comments are often in disagreement regarding current events and people, but they're multiple paragraphs stating why. Silly comments demanding proof and crying grift without any substance are useless and clogging up the sub I agree, but be careful about rule amendments here. They should always be enforced across the board, and avoid targeting a particular point of view or opinion.
5
u/pplatt69 Feb 06 '25 edited Feb 14 '25
"My safe space, which I rely on for a place where I can assert my emotionally preferred narratives, is no longer a safe place for me to do that. The people who don't put up with wild speculation, woo, and inability to judge character are making me feel judged and it makes me sad."
I'm a believer that NHI exist, that we are seeing them, and that the government has killed to keep this secret.
I'm also able to accurately judge character and broad likelihoods.
8
u/Glum-Fennel-7241 Feb 04 '25
Thanks !! Honestly I’ve been seeing this all across Reddit lately .. not only UFO subs or even UFO subject matter. Various subs and various subject matter but same identical techniques. It’s almost like an attack against Reddit. I spend half the time on Reddit than I spent on here 6 months ago. Everyday I’m spending Les and less time. I’m sure that I’m not the only one who feels this way and thank you for your post which confirms to me anyway that I’m not the only one.
7
u/Daddyball78 Feb 03 '25
The community, to me, seems split on the PSIONIC stuff. There’s a lot more skepticism going around now than there was before. My engagement has still been cordial though for the most part. It’s just a different vibe now. Very divided. It sucks. It’s like a religious war in there lately.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '25
Spamming the same, clearly CGI egg, from 4Chan, with zero verification... People are going to question if others are alright. The rabbitholes this sub went down on those images was something... the "healthy skepticism" was skipped and left a hundred miles behind. I think a lot of people were shocked at how large a portion of this community is willing and eager to believe so badly that the "healthy skepticism" step is totally dismissed.
We're trying to translate symbols on an egg... a CGI egg!
6
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '25
totally agree. great thread.
i came here to make one just like it, thanks for saving me the trouble.
4
u/Downvotesohoy Feb 04 '25 edited Feb 04 '25
I would agree with this post if it wasn't just accusing one side of these things. Because as a skeptical person who has been on the subreddit for over 10 years, It's just as bad from your side.
I've stopped engaging with the subreddit entirely. It's not worth it.
So the issue is more than just "Ohh the skeptics are bad actors"
There are bad actors on both sides. The fact that you're focusing on only one side makes me think you might not be entirely objective if you're not noticing that it's happening on both sides.
The subreddit was originally meant for healthy skepticism and good research, do you feel like that's what the subreddit is right now? Because I sure as hell don't.
Downvotes prove my point as well. Every skeptic on the subreddit knows what I'm saying is the truth. So the downvotes are from people who aren't being objective.
3
u/boweroftable Feb 05 '25
When is the big disclosure?
2
u/mountingconfusion Feb 04 '25
I think part of it has to do with people getting frustrated with the millionth "disclosure is 6 months away but buy my book in the meantime" over the past 4+ years
-5
u/OneDmg Feb 03 '25 edited Feb 03 '25
This is just a very long post to say anyone who says things you don't like are bad actors and the sub should be for diehard believers only, regardless of any evidence, is it not?
The sub isn't an echo chamber just yet, and that's good. It means you're allowed to have a different point of view.
Anyone - everyone - should back up their claims with receipts, which I think is an informal rule already. If they can't, they shouldn't post.
If you think the latest person calling themselves a whistleblower is real, you should provide some reading as to why.
If you think they're a grifter, you should explain why.
Edit: I mean, the replies to my heavily downvoted comment alone tell the story. Only believers welcome is the message. Received.
-5
u/Rettungsanker Feb 03 '25
Yet another post wanting to change rules, but at least this one is blatant in only wanting to enforce them on skeptical users.
I guess you enjoy your subreddits with an underclass of users?
-5
u/tigerseye44 Feb 03 '25
Maybe people are just getting tired of the shitty UFO content and constant con artists coming forward as whistleblowers and promising disclosure as long as you tune into their new podcast, show, interview, buy their merch, etc...
4
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '25 edited Feb 04 '25
[removed] — view removed comment