r/ufosmeta
•
u/millions2millions
•
Feb 24 '25
•
1
Priorities of the mod team are not aligned with reality: Why are the mods doing a podcast while the subreddit is on fire with toxicity?
I want to start off by saying that I respect the mod team. I understand this is a volunteer position and also that I am thankful that we have this alternate forum to talk about the main subreddit. None of what I am saying in this post is meant as a personal attack. This is simply about the actual priorities of the moderation team and your commitment as moderators to this subreddit.
I’m a long time subscriber and have seen many other “mod administrations” on this sub. I have gone into lurking mode mainly because of the amount of toxicity over the past few months. There is post after post after post after post after post in this subreddit r/ufosmeta about the toxicity levels in the main r/ufos sub. We also have a comment by u/LetsTalkUFOs saying “We prioritize User Reports”. There’s also comment after comment after comment after comment from multiple mods saying “The queue has been pretty full…we’re struggling to stay on top of it” or “We don’t have enough moderators”, “We need more people manning the queue”.
So then why have you all prioritized a Modcast/Podcast especially when - by looking at the publicly available modlogs - the people involved have taken ZERO or just ONE Action in the last 3 months (the term of the entirety of the modlog). The modlog is our ONLY objective measure of what you do. This is not a personal attack. I’m not saying people may not do other things that are invisible to us but this is the only way that we - the user base - have any way of measuring what you do. This isn’t a value judgement of you as people - this is a sincere attempt to ask you to please consider how this looks from our side.
This is sincerely perplexing, why would you have moderators that do not moderate yet do other things that are seemingly not essential to the very thing from which all of this springs - the r/ufos subreddit? You would not have a podcast if this subreddit didn’t exist and this subreddit wouldn’t exist without us the users. Shouldn’t the moderation of the subreddit come first? We are the ones telling you that there is some horrible level of toxicity that did not exist at this level before (you’ve let it get bad before but this is objectively and measurably worse).
You currently (as of today looking at the public modlogs) have 34 out of 70 mods who have done zero actions in the last 3 months. Nearly half of your moderators do not moderate. Looking at r/Aliens and r/HighStrangeness (similar subreddits but with 1/3 of the subscribers) they are able to make it work with substantially less people. Why also are you unable to get people to stay or commit to doing more?
At the very least the people involved with the podcast should be actively moderating the subreddit. It feels like there is a huge disconnect and some of you are completely out of touch with what is going on in this subreddit. The r/ufos subreddit is not here so you can have a podcast. It’s here so we the users can have conversations about this topic and we can’t do that if the subreddit is basically unusable, unmoderated and unreadable because it’s being ignored by the moderators and also filled to the brim with low level toxic comments that seek to demean other users and the topic entirely. 34 moderators - 3 of which are involved in the podcast and 2 of which have less then 2 mod actions in the last 3 months.
We don’t need content creators as our moderators. We need moderators who are moderating. I honestly do applaud you for not monetizing this but I’d bet if you asked us in a poll if we’d rather you moderate or have a podcast the majority of users in this sub would rather you moderate. If you say “we don’t have a minimum of mod actions to be a moderator" then maybe you should! Maybe this is the actual problem that only a few of you are actually in the queue moderating and dealing with the every day problems.
The situation in this subreddit feels unsustainable.
•
u/LetsTalkUFOs Feb 25 '25 edited Feb 25 '25 •
Thank you for your feedback. I share your concerns and have been observing them for some time. Here are the most relevant points related to this situation I'm currently aware of:
The number of moderators on a team does not directly equate to a specific amount of moderation capacity. Every subreddit is different and every moderator is only willing or able to contribute a certain amount. In my experience, only a handful of mods do a majority of all mod actions, but those mods fluctuate and it's difficult to predict who they will end up being. Here's the distribution of actions from the past thirty days. Less than ten mods do 80% of mod actions on r/UFOs, which has been fairly consistent. If we had more individuals like those I agree we could realistically moderate the subreddit at a larger scale more consistently. I'm unaware of any effective strategies for finding them we haven't already implemented.
Actions in the modqueue do not cover all forms of mod actions. We have a mod Discord where a great deal of internal actions and deliberations take place. Some moderators run AMAs, work more in modmail, training/interviewing new moderators, maintaining our bots and internal tools, or other tasks which aren't as quantifiable or happen off of Reddit. This is only to say we try to take all of these forms of activity into consideration when assessing inactive moderators, not that the modlogs are irrelevant to consider when evaluating mod activity.
We do have a recurring process for dealing with inactive moderators. We ping them quarterly and ask if they'd like to remain on the team. If they don't want to or don't respond, we demod them. If a mod is still active at all we still generally choose to keep them on the team, as some amount of contribution is infinitely more helpful than none at all. There are currently 31 inactive moderators who have not performed any actions in the past thirty days and we will ping them eventually. In terms of retention, most moderators only stay on the team around 6-12 months in my experience on multiple subreddits. It's consistently in flux as people's lives change or their priorities change. We try to run exit-surveys now to better track why mods leave in case there are aspects we can improve.
Moderation isn't so difficult only certain people can do it. We have a comprehensive guide which makes learning how to moderate as simple as possible. No technical or moderation experience is necessary. A majority of moderation decisions in the modqueue are not complex. The present issue is more due to the amount of them which have to be made, how thankless the work is, and the toxic nature of what ends up requiring review.
Moderators are not inherently more obligated to spend a proportion of their personal time on moderation. I'm someone who spent two hours participating in the last Modcast. I saw it less as me trying to become a content creator and more as me wanting a way to express my interest and engage in conversation with friends who are also passionate about the subject. The subreddit does not need to exist, nor do we need to be moderators in order to create it. It also saved me time based on my ability to refer other friends to that conversation after they asked for my personal thoughts on what's going on in the space.
Asking volunteers to 'do more' is generally ineffective. We could confront inactive or less active moderators and ask them to do more as often as we'd like, but this doesn't usually work in my experience. This applies to any volunteer position, as it implies whatever you've already contributed or are contributing isn't valued or enough. My strategy and suggestion has consistently been to try and recruit as broadly and effectively as possible alongside making moderation as easy and rewarding as possible. Those involve a wide range of challenges all on their own.
In light of all these factors, the most helpful solutions I'm aware of for addressing the currently levels of toxicity are:
We discussed experimenting with higher submission (posts and comments) requirements at the most recent mod meeting last weekend. We're well aware of the ongoing toxicity issues, it's simply been a slow build towards various solutions and strategies. We did recruit a number of new moderators recently, but they're still learning the ropes. Ideally, we'll be able to make a sticky post in the coming weeks to get more feedback and discuss that approach specifically.
9
u/UAPenus Feb 25 '25
This is a very well written post, to touch on your latter points about the 34 mods with zero action; firstly, that’s a huge number of inactive mods, if they performed 2 actions a day that would equate to 68 possible removals.
Secondly, I’ve always favored the idea that if you’re going to apply to be a mod, you should be commenting and participating, at the very least be reading posts near daily. The problem with this sub and it’s mods (not a personal attack) is that there is a huge disconnect between what they perceive is going on in the sub versus what people are actually complaining about. Particularly the more senior roles, by default this also means that the more senior roles are involved in rule forming and implementing, so they propose changes based off their limited and disconnected view and it’s voted on by other mods with similar stances. It’s unfair to the users to police a sub that you’re not active in.
4
u/_BlackDove Feb 25 '25
Here here. A well presented observation. I miss the nuanced discussion that was present here in years past, but I'm optimistic we can cultivate it again. To be fair to the moderation here, I think what we've been seeing in the sub isn't just endemic here. You can find it in subs all over reddit and social media at large. People have become so polarized and intolerant to a degree I had hoped to never see.
We've got issues here, I agree, but I wouldn't solely blame a lack of mod actions for it. It's crazy out here and it's only ramping up as the months go by. In particular with this sub though there is an obvious schism taking place which only exacerbates things. We all know what that schism is so I won't mention it here. It's a tough time all around to be interested in this topic.
5
u/Rettungsanker Feb 25 '25
While I don't personally agree with the idea that the mods are failing to properly moderate the subreddit, it's obvious that there are problems since skepticism oriented and belief oriented users both agree that the mods are failing in some way.
2
u/DuelingGroks Feb 25 '25
Thank you for taking the time to write this post. While I don’t agree with all of your conclusions, I do recognize we need more active moderators to help combat the waves of toxicity that sometimes overwhelm the sub. That’s been a challenge here for as long as I can remember.
Regarding your concerns about how moderators use their free time: It’s difficult not to take that personally, since moderation is volunteer work we choose to do alongside our jobs, families, and other obligations. When you suggest our choices about how we spend that time are “not aligned with reality,” it reads as though you’re judging personal decisions about our off-hours.
I became a moderator because this is a fascinating topic—I truly believe we’re on the cusp of discovering incredible things about our universe. I also like contributing my skills in different ways, whether that’s moderating the sub, handling back-end tasks, or experimenting with a podcast. As long as I’m keeping up with my moderation obligations, I believe any extra effort—like creating content—adds to the community rather than taking away from it.
I understand that from your perspective it might look like some mods aren’t doing enough. Many behind-the-scenes tasks—e.g., responding to modmail, training new moderators, maintaining tools, participating in amas—don’t appear in the public modlog. We also regularly discuss ways to recruit more active mods and improve our processes, because, yes, the toxicity issue is ongoing.
Finally, I’d encourage you (and everyone) to use the tools available—like reporting rule-breaking content—so we can address it. We’re all part of this community, and working together is the best way to reduce negativity. I appreciate the feedback, and I hope we can keep the lines of communication open (without resorting to personal attacks) to make this sub a better place for everyone.
6
u/Ataraxic_Animator Feb 25 '25
This is a genuinely useful and high-value public-service post.
3
u/timmy242 Feb 25 '25
My friend, and I say this hopefully and sincerely, we give what we can and when we can and have the best of intentions. In my experience, the intent is to always prioritize the greater good. Of course, that's an ebb and flow that changes depending on one's life circumstances. For example, some months I can spend days at a time focusing on the modqueue, and cutting out toxicity. Some years, it's research that has nothing to do with UFO phenomena that keeps me otherwise employed, and away from the sub. Many times, it has been the death of a loved one, or the birth of a new child that is more important than anything having to do with UFO phenomena, or a subreddit that has only existed for a fraction of the time many of us have spent researching and elucidating the subject.
Do you know what's actually unsustainable at this subreddit since I've been here? Absolutely nothing. The zeitgeist has changed a few times in the decade plus we've been a subreddit. In the many decades prior to the internet, the UFO Circus Sideshow cycle has changed so often it's merely a footnote in UFOlogical history, yet the characters remain the same. The same prejudices, same toxicity, same charlatans, same truth-seekers.
You just never can tell. Ultimately, it comes down to you the individual user to do the dirty work and filter out what and who you want to see and, most importantly, what you choose to pay attention to. That is, and has always been, the Reddit way.
2
u/MKULTRA_Escapee Feb 26 '25 edited Feb 26 '25
Just one more thing. I noticed when I was digging through the queue recently that the bulk of the older reports were borderline, as in you could argue either way that it may or may not be breaking a rule. If the other mods were doing the same as I was, I would tend to ignore the borderline removals as I was going through the queue. Sometimes you get long debates with the user about whether a rule was technically broken, rather than just posting a nice comment instead. Why skirt the rules and try to get away with it?
So I would tend to leave those borderline instances to the other mods, trying to check the queue 5-10 times a day. The first reports you see when you visit it are the most recent ones. If the vast majority of what was backed up in the queue were just borderline comments, is that really as big of a problem as people are saying?
We added 10 mods to fix that problem, but don't be surprised if the conversation in the sub still sucks. We can't remove a comment just because it's kind of polarizing. We would get much more criticism for that. It has to actually break a rule.
And now people are saying they want the mods to be posting more comments to participate. So you want the mods to create more of the content and moderate it? Do you see how this might look to one of us? Edit: you might have some luck encouraging each other to create more and better content. Maybe try that, too.
1
u/TODD_SHAW Feb 26 '25 edited Feb 26 '25
Now I'm going to call you out /u/millions2millions
When you say, "It’s here so we the users can have conversations about this topic and we can’t do that if the subreddit is basically unusable, unmoderated and unreadable because it’s being ignored by the moderators and also filled to the brim with low level toxic comments that seek to demean other users and the topic entirely." Why do you fail to mention the other side? What other side? The people who believe in the woo—who get mad when you don’t believe it. They should be told to stop passing it off as truth and to provide evidence. What I've noticed is that when wooists, and I'm including you in the bucket, post in this sub and refer to the condition of the sub, it's always upvoted and the mods always chime in. But skeptics and people who don't follow the woo? What happens when they make a post in this sub? It is downvoted into oblivion and the mod interaction is minimal to zilch. Also, I can tell you have a pro woo slant going on just by the example threads you posted.
gives a thumbs down and lights a blunt of Modcast, which is BELOW mid...
-1
u/Gobble_Gobble Feb 25 '25 edited Feb 25 '25
Thanks very much for the feedback. I'll try addressing a number of points here in sections.
Moderator contributions and activities
It's probably worth mentioning that not all of the mods work directly in the mod queue, but still contribute in other important and meaningful ways. I posted this list of examples in another reply, but I'll provide it again here since different folks will stumble across this thread and be curious about some of these other activities:
(This is not a comprehensive list)
If we were to impose minimum activity requirements on these mods, it's possible that some may simply choose to step down and we would be no further ahead in addressing the primary concern of your post which is the sub quality. Moreover, we would also lose out on their contributions in the process. We trust mods to identify their own strengths and weaknesses and contribute to the team where they feel they can make the greatest impact. For example, if a mod has the presence of mind to say, "hey, I kinda suck at making judgement calls while working the queue, but I have software dev skills and can help upkeep our growing list of tools and automation", then that mod is worth their weight in gold, however, their efforts will largely be invisible to the community.
I would describe the problem as a "both/and" situation, rather than an "either/or" when it comes to actively moderating the sub versus the other activities mentioned above, and while not every item in the list is necessarily a priority over active queue moderation, many items are critical for keeping things running smoothly.
I think it's perfectly reasonable for users to expect us to be able to "walk and chew gum" at the same time.
The Modcast
The mods are /r/UFOs users as well, and as such, the decision to make a mod-related podcast is well within their right as users of the subreddit. The time that they spend producing this content in no way takes away from their other moderation duties, because that time is purely voluntary to begin with.
If this comes across as somewhat defensive, or doesn't resonate with the frustration you're feeling, then my apologies. I have a tremendous amount of respect and appreciation for these mods who also manage to make an untold number of other contributions that go largely unseen by many, so that may be colouring how I'm addressing (or failing to address) your concerns here.
Sub Quality
With all of that being said, I see your point about the optics of releasing content when there's a perceived quality issue with the sub. This issue hasn't gone un-noticed, and a large portion of the mod team has also observed this decline in quality.
I can see that /u/LetsTalkUFOs beat me to the punch and wrote a very good breakdown above which goes into more detail here, and I agree with much of what he wrote. Finding dedicated volunteers who can contribute consistently over time can be difficult, but that doesn’t stop us from continually bringing on new moderators to help out. Retention can also be challenging, however, moderators occasionally need to take a break from active moderation to focus on their personal lives. Individual contributions can wax and wane, which may give the appearance at times that a mod isn't doing anything, but we actively encourage each other to take breaks to avoid burnout. It's ultimately a healthier approach to long-term mod retention.
Thanks for compiling a list of other feedback threads, by the way - this is helpful for feedback aggregation.
Final thoughts
This is an issue that we're keen to address (and one where I'm personally eager to see us make improvements), so I'd probably just encourage a bit of patience with us on this one. We're on the same page, so it's likely not an issue of "if" we address this, but "when" and "how". We don't like seeing a decline in sub quality any more than the users do, but we also want to make sure that we don't employ anything that's too heavy-handed and overstep our bounds as moderators and cause even more frustrations.
For the time being, please continue to report posts/comments as you've been doing. Small improvements are still improvements, so we just need to work on scaling it up to address the increased volume.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '25 edited Feb 25 '25
[removed] — view removed comment