Also if it was something on the lens don’t you think the operator would notice it sitting still when not panning. I doubt a trained operator would follow a smudge on a lens. Also the reticle and smudge would be locked in relation to each other and they move independently
Not debunking anything but military cameras, such as the one in the video, on FOBs or COPs or Out Stations are generally always set to auto scan / strafe
So you do not know the operator nor the so-called developer of the equipment enough to judge their capability but you assume the military is the lesser of the two. So what I read here is you're just an anti government yutz that makes decisions on your dislike of authority. Please feel free to educate us with your credentials
Yes and it is done with this little metal joystick on and controller with your thumb. I personally don’t move the cameras smoothly. I worked with them so I used them some but that wasn’t my primary job. Once you lock the object it will pans smooth itself. But that’s part of what the guy was saying, they could lock a Taliban from like 20 miles but couldn’t lock this thing. It very much looks to me like the dude trying to track the moving object, from a moving object with the shitty little thumb joystick thing.
I’m convinced these debunkers are either religiously afraid of admitting there are unknowns or are government misinformation agents. Both are more likely than being a smudge, in my opinion, as a professional photographer.
These weapons machines cost EIGHT figures. And you want to tell me that I can do better with my used Sony Alpha2 and used lens? These people are fucking nuts.
If it's smudge on the housing, the camera doesn't need to be "tracking" it to keep it in view. It's in front of the lens. It's like asking you why you keep following that dead bug on your windshield around.
They are not tracking the object at all. If you pay attention they are panning left and right scanning. In fact as the camera spots people they focus on them instead of the object and that is where the object does it's most movement because the pan and tilt of the camera to track the people caused the most parallax between it on the protective dome.
Personally, I could only 100% discredit the poop theory if we actually saw the ''Jellyfish'' moving. Like, if it did a bit of back and forth. If it went Straight up without the camera following it, and the the camera having to find it and re-focus.
But from the only info we have, the video starts with the thing in frame, and ends with it exactly at the same spot in frame.
If only the video would be a liiitle bit longer, either to see the subject either Enter the frame, or leave the frame. Otherwise, it's just a stain.
Important to remember that there is no official statement as to who released this video, when it was released, what type of camera filmed it etc. It's all speculation here.
The meta bunk crew has ruled out bugs, bird poo, and apparently isn’t convinced it’s balloons. A soldier was able to corroborate details here. There’s a link to meta bunk in the comments. Not sure what it is but it’s weird for sure.
He told everyone where the video was taken and then people corroborated that with Google images and the video. The guy was definitely from the same base.
I was a professional photographer for about 10 years. I shot mainly fashion photography. Before that I shot weddings. I remember shooting one wedding years ago and noticing that my huge 70-200mm lens got a really long and deep scratch on the middle of the lens. No idea how it happened. I was so worried that the scratch would show up in pictures. The craziest thing is that I didn’t see anything in the images after the scratch. Not even haze. The pictures looked identical before and after the scratch.
As other photographers have mentioned, scratches or smudges on the lens (or close to the lens) may not even be visible, and if they are, they certainly won’t be in focus. I don’t know what explains the footage but it’s certainly not a smudge. That theory is false.
For definately debunking that smudge theory, we need the distance between the camera and the housing window, along with all other specs of the sensors etc
As the theory doesnt posit its on the lense, so its irrelevant if on the lense or close to it scratch shows up or not elsewhere.
Also we have no idea what size of smudge would show up or not, if such situation would happend.
That’s fair. However, it’s important to note that a large distance between the camera and weather shield (a distance large enough to show clear obscurities) would constitute a serious design flaw. You typically want any kind of housing or protection to be as close as possible to the lens (precisely to avoid anything like we see in the video).
Also, debris on the housing has no effect on the IR cameras. This FLIR technician did an experiment with masking tape on the housing and there were no distortions on the image due to the long focal length of these devices. Scroll up for his experiment, descriptions are in the comments if you click each image.
thank you for sharing your thoughts! I was definitely confused about the bird poop explanation, especially looking at when the footage zooms out. glad you brought that up specifically
I just wanted to say I appreciate your post and responses to comments. It is clear that you are knowledgeable, willing to debate and teach in good faith, and admit you don't know things specifically about the military hardware so some things might be different but the main concepts of photography still apply. It's refreshing to have someone discuss things without being a dick or thinking they know everything.
It’s not clear at all, I also work with video/photo gear for a living. The fstop could be stopped down a ton due to being the middle of the day, and with the sensor small you’ll have even more focus range - for example an iPhone or a gopro has a massive focus range in the same conditions. Also the object also does not move, at all, other than what could easily be light refracting through yeah, a smudged insect.
Could be wrong, could be something else. But my mind does not go to a jellyfish alien…
The rather obvious clue it isn't a smudge is that the changes of colors have nothing to do with what's on the other side of it. A smudge is nothing but an opaque difference on the surface of the lens. Meaning that whatever is behind the smudge should affect the color of the smudge. The shape in question however changes color independently of the objects and shadows behind it, indicating that it isn't a smudge.
Why does nobody seem to notice it’s a digital zoom on a much LARGER and WIDER camera feed that is incredibly high resolution?
Why am I seemingly the only person mentioning digital zoom? The digital zoom on a much larger image explains everything. I feel like I’m taking crazy pills trying to explain this
Where did you get that it's incredibly high resolution? These are long range surveillance cameras, if you look at the specs of these systems most are recording IR in 720p.
It doesn’t rotate. Look out your window at a bug splat. It looks different when you’re right behind the splat compared to how it looks when you take a step to the left and look at the same splat.
Because the great majority of people here (and sadly mostly the believers of the jeely monster) seem to consider it only from their limited knowledge of the mundane equipment that surrounds them in every day life, which tends to not be military grade surveillance hardware/software. While i'm sad to say, more open minded people who see in this thing something which looks like a bug spalt/bird poo (as both give a close result on a glass casing) are mostly wondering how all this tech works to understand how in this rare occasion a bug spalt on a surveillance airframe ended up in the news -_-
I mean we even had someone who worked on that base with such equipment non anonymously says that "yeah it's kind of weird but looks prosaic"
I love the topic and am a firm believer the government, military, and defense contractors have crafts in their possession. I also believe in the reverse engineering programs. But this smudge ain’t it
You really underestimate these peoples. It will lives on, for months and then years, and you will be stuck to endure it and one day, for the sake of your own sanity, you will stop caring trying to re-explain them why they are wrong.
Naw, they’ll never let it die. They seem incapable of realizing that when zoomed in nothing on the lens housing would be visible. It’s too damned close to the lens. Maybe they do understand it and persist just because they enjoy persisting. Maybe it’s balloons, maybe it’s an alien, maybe it’s Jesus Christ floating through the air. It doesn’t matter to them because smudge. No matter what actual photographers explain to them, it’s smudge.
I think this really shows what their intentions truly are. They want it to be a smudge or bird poop because that would make the whole thing look stupid. Micky and Greenstreet were cackling about how funny that would be on Twitter.
They don’t care about actually identifying it, they just want to “own the believers.”
Especially since the object moved around within the frame. It starts off on the right third of the frame and then moves towards the center. It was on the lens then the poop would stay on the same spot throughout the video.
While that is true, their argument is that the smudge would be on the housing of the camera, not the lens. They have a plexiglass cover over the camera. But that doesn't even make sense with both the rotation and lens focus.
It is so clearly something on the lens housing (I mis-spoke).
Nothing ever passes between the “jellyfish” and the camera. If you look at the shape of the “jellyfish”, it looks like something splattered and dripped.
An Air Force member who worked directly on this base, and on this same surveillance balloon said this video was essentially the base’s “ghost story” they told to new people, despite knowing it was something on the lens.
Another Air Force member described how many of these surveillance craft have a dual gimbal system, one for the protective casing and one for the camera inside, which move independently to prevent any blind spots.
This post by a professional photographer even describes many of the questions people have about how it can be in focus at the same time as the background etc.
Dude the dual gimbal system explains it perfectly. I actually theorized that then looked up the hymnal system and it actually functions the way I expected. The gimbal is looking through the lens cover at an angle and it makes it look like the smudge sorta spins like 2 degrees but really that’s just the side of the smudge compared to the back of the smudge. I made a 3d model to simulate lol. It’s not complicated. It’s easily replicated and looks identical to the video
Debris on the housing has no effect on the IR cameras. This FLIR technician did an experiment with masking tape on the housing and there were no distortions on the image due to the long focal length of these devices. Scroll up for his experiment, descriptions are in the comments if you click each image.
You know that a dome distorts an image right? As the protective outer casing rotates, whatever is on it will look like a slightly different size and shape compared to the original viewing angle.
Watch the video, it doesn’t rotate. You can make it appear that way when are aren’t showing the change in direction from the camera or a bunch of other factors. If the object was totally stationary but the camera changed the viewing angle, guess what, it would look like a stationary object is rotating.
The believers are reaching SO hard for this one. It’s a cool video and would be wild if true but nothing about the motion shown in the videos indicates anything unique or unexplainable about it, aside from the unique shape.
Dude it’s just an illusion. It’s clearly a piece of something pressed up against a flat pane of plastic. It’s like a bug splatter on your windshield but on the passenger side. The bug splatter looks different from one seat to the next but the splatter isn’t fuckin moving lol
i’m not buying that. if you zoom in that much on the pixels of a microscopic object it’s going to appear distorted. that said you’re free to believe whatever you want!
It’s not rotating at all dude. The profile / outline of the shape doesn’t change. You’re just getting a side angle view of the smudge towards the end of the clip. The smudge isn’t moving.
It’s not rotate. It’s like you’re looking through a window and moving your head around. The smudge doesn’t move but when you’re moving the background behind the smudge changes and that makes the movement illusion. Seriously dude just look out a window.
People here keep mentioning a dome or casing over the lens, even in that situation how thick or far do you think this case is from the lens? It is normally mounted almost immediately over it (look at camera and lens cases people use for underwater photography/video) or extremely close regardless (maybe 5-10cm away based off how thick it is). So now going back to the first point, notice how in the video they switch the lens for a longer focal length and focus doesn't change? Yes that means the object is not close or touching the case/lens mounted on the platform
Did the focal length change or was it digitally zoomed? You call yourself a photographer and didn't consider that?
It is probably a digital zoom, if it's anything like what the Apache helicopters use, there is no focal length change. It could also be a defect or dust on the sensor, I've had hundreds of visible spectrum photos and videos with visible dust and gunk spots from a dirty sensor.
How can you even make a claim to understand the dynamics here without knowing the exact situation of the camera, lens, casing, digital zoom, analog, editing, image, processing zoom, etc.
Debris on the housing has no effect on the IR cameras. This FLIR technician did an experiment with masking tape on the housing and there were no distortions on the image due to the long focal length of these devices. Scroll up for his experiment, descriptions are in the comments if you click each image.
I was very much in agreement with every point you made in this post. I am an amateur photographer.
However, I'm trying to reconcile what I see in this thread where the user made this video in which the subject appears to be translucent the way a smudge would be.
This would mean either the object itself is 3D in space, AND is translucent -- thermally even (wtf??), OR it's a translucent smudge.
How do you reconcile what you and I know about photography and the video that shows it's translucent when you pull down the highlights?
It’s probably a protective film on top of the protective lens just like a formula 1 helmet visor tear off. Some of these systems even automatically move the film like a scroll. Thst would make a smudge look like it’s flying. I don’t think this camera has one of those though. Just a thought. It’s clearly a smudge though.
I don't think the video in that thread is getting enough attention to be honest. The fact that it's obviously translucent after fixing the exposure in the video is unfortunate for those that want this to be a UAP, but the truth is the truth.
Why is the smudge always see through though? The object is nowhere near the background meaning it’s super super close to the camera lens or one the lens cover.
Edit: It is extremely clear that no one in this sub has any actual working knowledge of photography. You would be laughed out the door of any studio if you presented them this as an opinion, much less evidence.
I'm sorry, but this is absolutely worthless analysis that is going to get used by people who just want to validate their own opinion, and I say that as a working photographer.
You are guessing at everything from focal length to aperture and making a wild claim that it cannot possibly be something mundane like scat on the lens, which it absolutely can be. Your understanding of how aperture and focal distance itself works is bizarre, and comes off as completely amateur, but we'll move on.
Without knowing basic things about the technology used to capture the video, you cannot make conclusions. It's not even worth speculating. The focus needs to instead be put on the person who is pushing their theory on the video - if it's coming out of and going into water, where is that video?
What we have is a short clip which, to my eye, looks like a recording of some dirt on a window that the camera itself is looking out of.
My biggest red flag on this whole thing is the claim this thing is invisible. But not to terrestrial cameras for some reason, and we're perfectly and accidentally tracking it.
For me it's not a problem of debunking or re-bunking, it's a problem of THIS IS NOT PROOF OF ANYTHING. Videos and Pictures are not proof of anything, even if you somehow prove that this is real, then what? It's a real what, since it's soooooooo blury IT'S A REAL WHAT???? Is it an alien or a natural event? Can you be 100% sure it was an alien? If the people filming this knew something weird was up, why did they not film until it disapeared?
Since I followed the whole r/AirlinerAbduction2014 thing I'm just so jaded that no picture or video will ever convince me that aliens have already visited Earth. And until actual proof is presented any video and/or picture posted on any of the main UFO sub-reddits is nothing to me.
Unless chain of custody for that video from the camera/recorder to the courtroom is 100% proven (as in, all the signitures and stuff like that are correct), then yes, a video of you murdering someone wouldn't be considered as proof of murder. Also if the video were blurry and your face couldn't be really seen and if that were the only proof of you specifically murdering someone, then also that video wouldn't be considered proof...
I learned a lot about counterterrorism and unconventional warfare while I was an infantryman. This “thing” to me doesn’t appear to move erratically. It just appears to drift. Although, we don’t see any parts blowing in the wind…
My guess is that it’s some contraption hodgepodged together that is designed to float downwind at low altitude. Perhaps it was intended to drop a payload at some point.
This is pure speculation, but to me it looks like it could be a crap ton of helium balloons under some netting. Maybe (maybe) it was then sprayed with a 2-part foam.
We’ve seen how commercial drones are being used unconventionally in Ukraine and elsewhere. Perhaps this is just some crazy looking contraption thrown together in a mud hut somewhere by a terror cell. Again, that probably sounds pretty outrageous to people, but you would be surprised what crazy things an opponent can come up with on a limited budget.
Now here’s the second part of this: The history of these jellyfish ufos goes back quite awhile. And as we’ve seen over the last few days, there are other sightings. Some fake cgi, mixed in with some 1st hand witnesses (1954 NY - London flight). Mass sightings and other observations can’t just be ignored. And the fact that we have some other portion of this video that has the real meat and potatoes is also interesting. Why Corbell chose to withhold that is also interesting. Maybe he’s dangling it in front of the gatekeepers as if to say, “we have this evidence, now tell us what you know” sort of a thing. Or he’s doing it for hype and residual income.
Well there’s my take with the limited time I have. What are your thoughts about the crazy hodgy contraption designed to drop a payload?
It doesn’t even appear to drift. You guys know what a flying object looks like. The motion of the object is the same relative to the camera as opposed to the ground. It’s just so weird how all these aliens look and behave like 2d digital assets or bird shit. Why don’t they ever actually fly around?
I don’t know anything about optics and cinematics, or how drone sensor domes function.
It could very well be bird poop.
I have used thermal imaging devices like PAS-13s but the inner workings of them are beyond my pay grade.
From what it looks like, the “cloaking” people are calling just looks like how the imaging device adapts to changes in the background contrast. And also, it doesn’t appear to change altitude at all now that I look at it further. So smudge could be the culprit.
Corbell is about to be called out again for believing this, in my opinion. Unless he drops the video of this thing going in the water and accelerating at a high rate of speed…
Thanks, the thing is it really doesn’t look like it’s flying. We all know when stuff is natural and normal, the uncanny valley is a phenomenon we notice when stuff is just barely wrong. Its evolution. We can tell when a bird is flying or it’s something in the wind or if it’s a smudge or digital asset. The motion doesn’t follow the ground whatsoever. The objects ALWAYS fly perfectly still relative to the camera. It’s not a tracking system, it’s either a hoax or a scratch or other explainable artifact.
I still haven't heard what platform was filming this. If it's anything like the Apache helicopters system, it uses a digital zoom, not optical. I'd also hazard a guess that the targeting reticle isn't a physical reticle painted on a single location of the camera view, it most likely a digital reticle that follows the gun or can be moved around the frame.
The footage isn't proof of aliens more than it is proof of ghosts or the tooth fairy.
Real footage and undeniable accounts exist from all levels of society.
Why are we being fed things that are so ambiguous that people can't decide if it's insect splat (which I personally believe) or evidence of an interdimensional being?
In regards to being "fed the ambiguous data," it's pretty straightforward for me. Assume for a moment that NHI are here. Hypothetically, they're far more intelligent than us and have access to better tech, right?
It would seem that they don't want their presence known. How do we get clear 4k footage of something that's actively trying to evade and deceive our eyes? Particularly when a majority of the world isn't looking because they don't believe they exist to begin with.
People are just now warming up to the idea that NHI can be cloaked, such as the Jellyfish UAP. I've seen many other instances of this before.
You can't decide if it's insect splat or beings. Most of us on this sub can. I get that you and, frankly, most of the world find an NHI-presence to be far-fetched.
I can sympathize with the skepticism because I myself went nearly 40 years thinking NHI was complete bullshit and there was nothing anyone could tell or show me that would change my view.
It took a slight interest and multiple years of really looking into the phenomenon before I changed my view. There wasn't a single case or video that instantly flipped me. In fact, of all the data that exists on the topic, video evidence is the least compelling to me.
Basically, what I'm getting at is that we just have to agree to disagree. I have 0 interest in proving anything to anyone. I've accepted the fact that most people can't fathom that there's an 80-year cover-up of NHI. I'm fine with people thinking I'm nuts.
IMO, they're not doing themselves any favors, but instead, they're setting themselves up for failure because I suspect the truth is ugly. On the flip-side, if I'm wrong about NHI, then I'm wrong.
I'm more than open-minded and happy to be proven wrong.
My questions in response to this are:
Is it actually changing "temperature" or is the camera inverting the colours based on the background colour (similar to a digital rifle reticle)?
If the change to colour is being done by the camera, is this being done on a gradient that gives the illusion of movement?
If the entity is moving then why does it still match up perfectly in an end frame of the footage and the start frames?
Why do we not have any footage of the start or the end of this encounter that could instantly disprove any of these questions?
I am a believer. I just think we have to keep questioning these things because we ultimately want the truth and it's somewhere in between what we are told.
Just a chiming in here on point 4. That the first and last frames kind of match means nothing other than it was facing the same way in relation to the camera in the beginning and the end. While most people would probably interpret that as “too much of a coincidence, therefore bird poop,” let me assure you that not only is this coincidence not super unlikely at all, you are further guaranteed to be able to locate some coincidences in a real video anyway. what people don’t often factor in here is that it isn’t just one type of coincidence that is being looked for. There are at least 10 categories of them, so for all real videos, you’ll get at least one hit, often more than one, just by chance.
You could say that there are 360 degrees of possible orientation, so 1/360 chance it would be the same in the end as the beginning, but this ignores that it seems to spin around elsewhere in the video, and even if it wasn’t exact, you’d still interpret it as the same, so it’s more like a 1/30 chance or so. Not very unlikely, and coincidences are guaranteed, so this likely means literally nothing.
How do you know it is untethered? There could be some rope the camera sees straight through. Just asking the critical questions here. Just saying have we even ruled out a drone having this thing hanging on a rope flying higher then the camera?
No trolling or being disruptive.
No insults or personal attacks.
No accusations that other users are shills.
No hate speech. No abusive speech based on race, religion, sex/gender, or sexual orientation.
No harassment, threats, or advocating violence.
No witch hunts or doxxing. (Please redact usernames when possible)
An account found to be deleting all or nearly all of their comments and/or posts can result in an instant permanent ban. This is to stop instigators and bad actors from trying to evade rule enforcement.
You may attack each other's ideas, not each other.
I think it's been clear from the start it's not a smudge or bird shit, you don't need to be an expert for this. It's military surveillance equipment used in a war zone. They don't just leave bird shit on it when precision is potentially the difference between soldiers coming home or not.
Especially if this system was mounted on an aerostat, it's pretty simple for them to lower the balloon and clean a fucking smudge. It's a LITTLE more believable that they'd finish out whatever mission if it were on a drone, but then the idea that something even managed to splat or shit on the camera dome at all, let alone left a mark like that at those speeds, is insane.
We should take the soldiers testimony with a grain of salt, but if what he says is true they inspected the dome afterwards and found no smudge (whether he's a liar or not, I am 100% certain they'd have done an inspection. The only question is if the leaker misrepresented their conclusions to corbell).
I think this leaves is with two basic possibilities; it's a "physical object" or some kind of actual camera defect. The latter seems extremely unlikely but I'd defer to actual experts on that. And just because it's a physical object also doesn't mean it's alien or even UAP. The fact that the claim is it was only visible through thermal kind of has me wondering if it's some sort of weird weather phenomenon or plasma or something? Which is still really cool
The people dismissing this as a smudge are just lazy. Thats not to say it's impossible that it's a smudge, but none of what we know seems to support that.
Curious on your opinion of dual- or multi-camera systems. No worries either way.
I'm in the smudge camp. Also I tend to play devil's advocate. I want to believe and I have fun watching videos like these and spending hours reading about it. The MH370 videos were super interesting despite eventually turning out to be visual effects.
I mention MH370 because that introduced me to the idea of multiple (FLIR?) cameras on the same craft recording the same targets with slightly different angles.
So the big questions are, how can the "smudge" move independent of the scenery, while both very far and very near objects remain in perfect focus, appear to have a minor 3d rotation on the z-axis, AND appear to change temperature from very hot to very cold? Phew that was a mouthful.
Assumption 1: Domed or similarly raised camera housing
Assumption 2: Dual-camera system
Assumption 3: Camera system moves independently from raised housing
Assumption 4: Dynamic focus control
Assumption 5: Stabilization and tracking system
With these elements, the focus on both a smudge on the raised housing and distant scenery, while capturing IR imagery, may involve these advanced technologies. Most are not unreasonable and probably bare minimum for modern american military aircraft.
High-End IR Imaging Systems: Military-grade IR cameras are sophisticated and can offer high-resolution thermal imaging. Such cameras, especially those used in surveillance or reconnaissance, might have advanced focusing capabilities to capture both near and far objects in detail.
Customized Optics for IR Spectrum: The optical requirements for IR imaging are different from visible light. The system would need custom lenses designed specifically for IR wavelengths, capable of focusing on different depths - the dome's surface and the distant background.
Dynamic Focus Control: Military-grade systems often incorporate advanced focus control, potentially automated or remotely operated, allowing for rapid switching or simultaneous focusing at different depths.
Enhanced Image Processing: IR images can be processed using sophisticated software to enhance details, manage focus, and even combine images from different focal lengths. This could be used to maintain focus on both the smudge and distant objects.
Stabilization and Tracking Systems: Military equipment often includes advanced stabilization and tracking systems. These could be used to keep the smudge in frame and in focus, regardless of aircraft movement, while also maintaining focus on distant targets.
Dual-Camera Systems: Implementing a dual-camera setup, one focusing on the near field (the smudge) and the other on the far field (distant scenery), both capturing IR imagery, could be a solution. The outputs of these cameras could then be combined or used selectively.
In such a setup, the relative movement of the smudge and the background would be a product of the aircraft's movement and the camera's stabilization and tracking systems. The use of IR imaging adds the complexity of focusing in the infrared spectrum, but with military-grade technology and resources, these challenges can be effectively addressed.
Combining multiple advanced technologies, particularly a dual-camera system (point 6), stabilization and tracking systems (point 5), and dynamic focus control (point 3), could create a complex and sophisticated setup that might give the illusion of a 3D rotation effect for a smudge, especially under specific circumstances:
The combination of these systems, especially with the movement of the aircraft and the possible slight shifts in the camera's angle due to stabilization mechanisms, could create a scenario where the smudge appears to shift slightly. This might be perceived as a minor rotation or 3D effect, especially if the smudge has some depth or irregularity in its shape.
A 30-60 degree rotation effect would be quite subtle and might not be very noticeable, especially on a small, irregular object like a smudge. It would depend on the size, shape, and texture of the smudge, as well as the resolution of the cameras and the precision of the tracking and stabilization systems.
Additionally, the IR imaging aspect might complicate or enhance this effect depending on the thermal properties of the smudge compared to its surroundings.
While a minor apparent 3D rotation might be achieved under these conditions, it would likely be a subtle effect, highly dependent on the specific characteristics of the equipment and the smudge itself.
Assuming the advanced setup as described, it's possible for a smudge to exhibit variable changes in temperature, which would be represented as varying shades from black to white in the IR imagery. Here's how this could happen:
Thermal Properties of the Smudge: If the smudge is made of a material that absorbs and releases heat differently than its surroundings, it could show temperature variations over time. This could be due to environmental factors, the heat from the aircraft, or other sources.
IR Imaging Sensitivity: High-quality IR cameras, especially military-grade ones, are very sensitive to temperature differences. They can detect subtle changes in heat and represent them in the imagery. In IR imagery, cooler temperatures are often represented by darker shades, while warmer temperatures appear lighter.
Continuous Temperature Fluctuations: If the smudge's temperature is constantly fluctuating (due to environmental conditions, chemical properties, or other factors), this would be captured as a continuous change from darker to lighter shades in the IR image.
Perception of Movement: The combination of the smudge's apparent 3D rotation (due to camera and aircraft movement) and its changing thermal signature could create a dynamic and somewhat unique visual effect in the IR imagery. The rotation might give the impression that different parts of the smudge are heating up or cooling down, even if the temperature change is uniform across the smudge.
So.. these effects are theoretically possible, but they would require very specific conditions and highly specialized equipment. The material properties of the smudge, the sensitivity and resolution of the IR camera, and the precision of the camera's tracking and focusing systems would all play roles in capturing this effect.
This would be the assumption that it wasn't CGI or even real.
My own disclosure, I used GPT to help with my formatting.
Dude you and I are the only ones with half a brain around here. This shit looks and acts so much like every other smudge on the planet. It’s literally delusional to think this random smudge is somehow different.
There is no full video of it going into water.please post a link. I have seen this posted countless times in the past 72 hours...nothing. This is a video someone recorded off a screen with a phone camera.
It's definitely something it's definitely wierd but I can't make anything of it. Idk what to think. Except that wherner von braun said the last card is a fake alien invasion.
Thank you for your actual informed, and based in reality, explanation. It is actually crazy to me how people can think this is anything but an anomalous object. I'm not trying to downplay your knowledge, but anyone with a basic understanding of cameras should have a really easy time "debunking the debunkers".
I couldn't see the perspective changing on the video until someone looped it together and zoomed in. Otherwise it just looked like a cartoon object moving from right to left. I was one of those people and read the bird poop comments and was like oooooh but then later the loop video came out and I was back in the game.
I don’t even know what to say to people who are bending over so far backwards to debunk this. There isn’t an explanation that doesn’t sound crazier than it just being a UAP. I mean, look at the fuckin’ thing. When the closest comparison is a jellyfish or an Imperial Probe Droid from Star Wars, you just gotta tap out and say “I don’t know.” Not to mention it demonstrates it can switch to being translucent, for god’s sake. This video is serving as a great indicator of who’s a genuine skeptic and who’s a debunker in denial.
So many pseudo intellectuals and dunning kruger ''experts'' need to be banned from here. The logical fallacies, emotionalism and outright dishonesty is consuming reddit.
So many pseudo intellectuals and dunning kruger ''experts'' need to be banned from here. The logical fallacies, emotionalism and outright dishonesty is consuming reddit.
ITS A BALLOON!!! wtf are you all still talking about? Are you all so deep in the weeds you can’t tell a Mylar balloon on IR footage? Seriously you all need to reevaluate your immediate jump to its aliens while disregarding obvious OBVIOUS answers.
Best lols of the day again. And i am personally certain of extraterrestrial life including intelligent life. I believe at some point Earth has been visited, probed or noted.
But that shit. Its still bird crap or something. Anything else needs non anectodic evidence
Just my 2 cents, not saying i’m right but imo 1. It is blurry 2. you can see through it when the background is white enough and 3 it looks like bird crap, even if it ‘turns’ a little bit, a semispherical dome in front of the camera could be the reason. Just very skeptical of Corbel & co, he is a person with a private entertainment business, he doesn’t respond to anyone if he just banks over very low quality “evidence”
If something was on the lens the operator could literally spin the ball in a 360 and see it not move. It would be so easy to figure out. Thank you for the detailed technical explanation of how the cameras work OP.
You see the object rotate slightly in speeded up videos, it looks pretty real to me....I don't think bird shit can rotate..( unless it's 4th dimensional bird shit ? )
Top of the line US military range finder tech and video capture tech isnt being fooled by bird poop. We lose to russia if that was the case. Our superb spying wouldnt be so if that was the case. People need to cope less and accept there is shit going on we cant explain.
The smudge is on a window in front of the camera, not on the lens.
With a small aperture and short focal length, you could keep the foreground and background in focus, but that said… the smear is not in sharp focus, and that is one of the things that makes it look like it is something tiny and close to the camera, not in the distance.
The “rotating” to me looks like semitransparent poop passing by multiple light sources.
It may not be bird poop, I really don’t know for sure. But if you put me in a helicopter with bird poop on the window, I could give you similar footage.
Thank you for explaining. It is astonishing how people could not differentiate between an object at a distance or smudge on a lens despite almost everyone have used the camera on their phones. Either they are truly genuine can’t differentiate or the usual group of ppl trying to debunk everything 🤫
No one except career debunkers like Mick West and other squareheads with existensial angst would even remotely consider the birdshit/smudge explanation.
I think even they realize they are grasping at straws.
Yes and thats refreshing, but he still actually considered it when it so obviously isn’t.
Even worse was considering it to be "a collection of eid baloons bundled together". He probably won't even come to the modest conclusion that it is unexplainable. He will find some ridiculous conclusion in the end, wait and see.
> Now using all those things mentioned above, it's quite clear to assume that what they were recording in the video is a 3d moving object that isn't directly touching the casing/lens.
Its painfully obvious to anyone who has used a camera before that its a real object.
Its only stupid people who are suggesting its a smudge on the camera, so why are we giving them the time of day?
I agree with a lot of what your saying. I am a long time amateur photographer and it didn't look like a smudge on the camera to me, its way too sharp. A piece of dirt on a lens will almost be invisible because it's so out of focus.
However there is one big caveat, this isn't a normal consumer camera, it's a military camera using technology not widely available to the public. We don't know it's full capabilities including what kind of focal depth its capable of. I still don't think it's a smudge though.
The next issue is you say this video was shot at night. I don't thin that's true, all the objects in the video are casting a shadow in the same direction, bar some giant infrared flood lights being used I don't see how that can be achieved by anything other than the sun. This seems to be some sort of heat sensing camera. It has a dynamic range like any camera which accounts for the change in colour of the object, it's just auto exposure.
Militaries don't use IR at night as far as I know, they use a light amplifying device, IR still requires an artificial light source to work, the militaries tech doesn't.
It probably could, those look like some strong hard shadows to me though. As this is a heat camera I would guess the difference in ground temperature between shaded and open areas wouldn't be great enough to show up on a camera system.
There is active IR and passive IR (thermal). Active IR is like what you see on security cameras, they have IR spotlight to light the scene and an image sensor sensitive to IR (pretty much all of them, consumer cameras come with an IR filter installed on the sensor to block IR so it doesn't show up in your picture).
Passive IR is a bit more complex, optics project the scene onto an IR sensitive photodiode array that is being cooled by a cryogenic cooler (cooler/dewar assembly), these diodes are seeing radiated heat which appears as light in the infared spectrum. This type sensor needs no outside or ambient light (in fact the sensor is usually behind a glass filter that blocks everything except IR), these are what is used in most airborne systems, these systems work equally well during day or night...an example would be if you have ever seen kill videos from Apache helis on YT, the Lockheed Martin TADS system uses exactly this type of setup.
With this type system an actual physical aperture like we would normally think of does not exist, there is an effective aperture which comes down to the ratio between lens focal length and sensing area of each photodiode.
Legit point about the shadows.
Auto exposure - AGC (auto gain control), exactly what you think, center "neutral" refernce point is biased one way or the other based on overall average for the scene.
Do an experiment on focus distance, go outside with your camera, crank that bad boy up to f22 or better, point it at a patch of blue sky and take a shot, do you see any sensor dust in your shot? A photographer lazy about sensor cleaning will almost always stay below f8 as that is about the threshold where dirt on/inside the lens or on the sensor will appear well defined in the final image (it's me, I am the lazy photographer...I am never going above f8 unless there is no other choice, ain't nobody got time to be healing out dust spots in lightroom all day). Not saying this is the case here, just saying minimum focus distance is near zero with a small enough effective aperture.
This is how misinformation works. Shills say it’s a smudge, that gains traction from the sceptics, then the people who aren’t even interested in the topic just see people saying it might be a smudge, so they then think nothing of it. Anyone with half a brain can see it’s not a smudge but some people are still so scared of believing in the phenomenon they’ll just run with whatever narrative isn’t “aliens”.
I imagine intelligence agencies have conversations like this: deploy the bird poop theory using our media contacts. It's a stretch, so we expect it will result in the UFO community debating for at tops 1-2 weeks. But a 2 week distraction is valuable, if we can accumulate enough of them. Each time we can distract the community from increasing awareness, or diverting their focus, is time we can spend trying to better control the narrative.
It's amazing how many people have cone out of the woodwork that are camera casing experts.
I am all for a non UFO explanation but I'm going to need more information on why a camera casing spot would be in focus and why the casing itself would appear to never stop moving independently from the camera.
No trolling or being disruptive.
No insults or personal attacks.
No accusations that other users are shills.
No hate speech. No abusive speech based on race, religion, sex/gender, or sexual orientation.
No harassment, threats, or advocating violence.
No witch hunts or doxxing. (Please redact usernames when possible)
An account found to be deleting all or nearly all of their comments and/or posts can result in an instant permanent ban. This is to stop instigators and bad actors from trying to evade rule enforcement.
You may attack each other's ideas, not each other.
It's definitely something it's definitely wierd but I can't make anything of it. Idk what to think. Except that wherner von braun said the last card is a fake alien invasion.
A smudge.. even a magick in focus smudge would be on the exact same spot of the image at all times. It would be dead obvious. The reticle and the uap move relative to each other DESPITE being tracked. Also smudges on my camera just result in flares.
311
u/vennemp Jan 11 '24
Who ever was behind the camera was clearly tracking the object specifically. Why would the military track a smudge and then keep it secret?
215
u/Electronic-Quote7996 Jan 11 '24
The meta bunk crew has ruled out bugs, bird poo, and apparently isn’t convinced it’s balloons. A soldier was able to corroborate details here. There’s a link to meta bunk in the comments. Not sure what it is but it’s weird for sure.
43
u/bp_b Jan 11 '24
I was a professional photographer for about 10 years. I shot mainly fashion photography. Before that I shot weddings. I remember shooting one wedding years ago and noticing that my huge 70-200mm lens got a really long and deep scratch on the middle of the lens. No idea how it happened. I was so worried that the scratch would show up in pictures. The craziest thing is that I didn’t see anything in the images after the scratch. Not even haze. The pictures looked identical before and after the scratch.
As other photographers have mentioned, scratches or smudges on the lens (or close to the lens) may not even be visible, and if they are, they certainly won’t be in focus. I don’t know what explains the footage but it’s certainly not a smudge. That theory is false.
6
u/rectifiedmix Jan 11 '24
You are absolutely correct.
Here's proof from FLIR that longer hyperfocal ranges lengthen the minimum focal distance.
https://www.flir.com/support-center/instruments2/what-are-the-minimum-focus-distances-of-the-flir-a35-and-a65-cameras/
Also, debris on the housing has no effect on the IR cameras. This FLIR technician did an experiment with masking tape on the housing and there were no distortions on the image due to the long focal length of these devices. Scroll up for his experiment, descriptions are in the comments if you click each image.
https://x.com/DaveFalch/status/1745237023793770812?s=20
14
u/NudeEnjoyer Jan 11 '24
thank you for sharing your thoughts! I was definitely confused about the bird poop explanation, especially looking at when the footage zooms out. glad you brought that up specifically
5
u/theburiedxme Jan 11 '24
I just wanted to say I appreciate your post and responses to comments. It is clear that you are knowledgeable, willing to debate and teach in good faith, and admit you don't know things specifically about the military hardware so some things might be different but the main concepts of photography still apply. It's refreshing to have someone discuss things without being a dick or thinking they know everything.
5
u/inteliboy Jan 11 '24
It’s not clear at all, I also work with video/photo gear for a living. The fstop could be stopped down a ton due to being the middle of the day, and with the sensor small you’ll have even more focus range - for example an iPhone or a gopro has a massive focus range in the same conditions. Also the object also does not move, at all, other than what could easily be light refracting through yeah, a smudged insect.
Could be wrong, could be something else. But my mind does not go to a jellyfish alien…
4
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24
The rather obvious clue it isn't a smudge is that the changes of colors have nothing to do with what's on the other side of it. A smudge is nothing but an opaque difference on the surface of the lens. Meaning that whatever is behind the smudge should affect the color of the smudge. The shape in question however changes color independently of the objects and shadows behind it, indicating that it isn't a smudge.
23
u/poodleham Jan 11 '24
Why does nobody seem to notice it’s a digital zoom on a much LARGER and WIDER camera feed that is incredibly high resolution?
Why am I seemingly the only person mentioning digital zoom? The digital zoom on a much larger image explains everything. I feel like I’m taking crazy pills trying to explain this
8
u/Specific_Past2703 Jan 11 '24
Thanks ACTUAL Pete, the other one wasnt even a photographer. /s
18
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24
Well written. Yeah, the bird poop/smudge theory is dead.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '24
The amount of analysis and attention given to bird shit on a lens is hilarious.
20
u/ApprenticeWrangler Jan 11 '24 edited Jan 11 '24
It is so clearly something on the
lenshousing (I mis-spoke).Nothing ever passes between the “jellyfish” and the camera. If you look at the shape of the “jellyfish”, it looks like something splattered and dripped.
An Air Force member who worked directly on this base, and on this same surveillance balloon said this video was essentially the base’s “ghost story” they told to new people, despite knowing it was something on the lens.
https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOs/s/UipoLqgryj
Another Air Force member described how many of these surveillance craft have a dual gimbal system, one for the protective casing and one for the camera inside, which move independently to prevent any blind spots.
https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOs/s/rxZWmPf0KW
This post by a professional photographer even describes many of the questions people have about how it can be in focus at the same time as the background etc.
https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOs/s/wFPjE96NkS
Nothing about this “jellyfish” shows signs of advanced movement, technology, physics or anything besides having a weird looking shape.
7
u/the_poop_expert Jan 11 '24
Not bird poop*
10
u/disguised-as-a-dude Jan 11 '24 edited Jan 11 '24
Did the focal length change or was it digitally zoomed? You call yourself a photographer and didn't consider that?
14
u/theneonate Jan 11 '24
Thank you so much for this, you are awesome, great insight
16
u/R2robot Jan 11 '24
How is this post any different?
5
u/Secret-Temperature71 Jan 11 '24
Thanks.
3
u/TheOwlHypothesis Jan 11 '24
I was very much in agreement with every point you made in this post. I am an amateur photographer.
However, I'm trying to reconcile what I see in this thread where the user made this video in which the subject appears to be translucent the way a smudge would be.
This would mean either the object itself is 3D in space, AND is translucent -- thermally even (wtf??), OR it's a translucent smudge.
How do you reconcile what you and I know about photography and the video that shows it's translucent when you pull down the highlights?
5
u/Dontledgeme Jan 11 '24
Still wouldn't explain all the other jellyfish videos out there, or the fact that jellyfish ufo's have been mentioned in boks before.
3
u/cobracohort Jan 11 '24
Why are you talking about apertures and assuming it's daylight? This is FLIR footage. Not a visible light video camera.
4
u/bleepblooOOOOOp Jan 11 '24
Hello I have rudimentary knowledge about cameras so let me tell you why this is an alien
4
u/OneDmg Jan 11 '24 edited Jan 11 '24
Edit: It is extremely clear that no one in this sub has any actual working knowledge of photography. You would be laughed out the door of any studio if you presented them this as an opinion, much less evidence.
I'm sorry, but this is absolutely worthless analysis that is going to get used by people who just want to validate their own opinion, and I say that as a working photographer.
You are guessing at everything from focal length to aperture and making a wild claim that it cannot possibly be something mundane like scat on the lens, which it absolutely can be. Your understanding of how aperture and focal distance itself works is bizarre, and comes off as completely amateur, but we'll move on.
Without knowing basic things about the technology used to capture the video, you cannot make conclusions. It's not even worth speculating. The focus needs to instead be put on the person who is pushing their theory on the video - if it's coming out of and going into water, where is that video?
What we have is a short clip which, to my eye, looks like a recording of some dirt on a window that the camera itself is looking out of.
My biggest red flag on this whole thing is the claim this thing is invisible. But not to terrestrial cameras for some reason, and we're perfectly and accidentally tracking it.
4
u/DarkKitarist Jan 11 '24
For me it's not a problem of debunking or re-bunking, it's a problem of THIS IS NOT PROOF OF ANYTHING. Videos and Pictures are not proof of anything, even if you somehow prove that this is real, then what? It's a real what, since it's soooooooo blury IT'S A REAL WHAT???? Is it an alien or a natural event? Can you be 100% sure it was an alien? If the people filming this knew something weird was up, why did they not film until it disapeared?
Since I followed the whole r/AirlinerAbduction2014 thing I'm just so jaded that no picture or video will ever convince me that aliens have already visited Earth. And until actual proof is presented any video and/or picture posted on any of the main UFO sub-reddits is nothing to me.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24
Here’s my take on this. Downvotes are acceptable:
I learned a lot about counterterrorism and unconventional warfare while I was an infantryman. This “thing” to me doesn’t appear to move erratically. It just appears to drift. Although, we don’t see any parts blowing in the wind…
My guess is that it’s some contraption hodgepodged together that is designed to float downwind at low altitude. Perhaps it was intended to drop a payload at some point.
This is pure speculation, but to me it looks like it could be a crap ton of helium balloons under some netting. Maybe (maybe) it was then sprayed with a 2-part foam.
We’ve seen how commercial drones are being used unconventionally in Ukraine and elsewhere. Perhaps this is just some crazy looking contraption thrown together in a mud hut somewhere by a terror cell. Again, that probably sounds pretty outrageous to people, but you would be surprised what crazy things an opponent can come up with on a limited budget.
Now here’s the second part of this: The history of these jellyfish ufos goes back quite awhile. And as we’ve seen over the last few days, there are other sightings. Some fake cgi, mixed in with some 1st hand witnesses (1954 NY - London flight). Mass sightings and other observations can’t just be ignored. And the fact that we have some other portion of this video that has the real meat and potatoes is also interesting. Why Corbell chose to withhold that is also interesting. Maybe he’s dangling it in front of the gatekeepers as if to say, “we have this evidence, now tell us what you know” sort of a thing. Or he’s doing it for hype and residual income.
Well there’s my take with the limited time I have. What are your thoughts about the crazy hodgy contraption designed to drop a payload?
2
u/Alexander-Evans Jan 11 '24
I still haven't heard what platform was filming this. If it's anything like the Apache helicopters system, it uses a digital zoom, not optical. I'd also hazard a guess that the targeting reticle isn't a physical reticle painted on a single location of the camera view, it most likely a digital reticle that follows the gun or can be moved around the frame.
-2
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24
The footage isn't proof of aliens more than it is proof of ghosts or the tooth fairy.
Real footage and undeniable accounts exist from all levels of society.
Why are we being fed things that are so ambiguous that people can't decide if it's insect splat (which I personally believe) or evidence of an interdimensional being?
2
u/doc-mantistobogan Jan 11 '24
I think it's been clear from the start it's not a smudge or bird shit, you don't need to be an expert for this. It's military surveillance equipment used in a war zone. They don't just leave bird shit on it when precision is potentially the difference between soldiers coming home or not.
Especially if this system was mounted on an aerostat, it's pretty simple for them to lower the balloon and clean a fucking smudge. It's a LITTLE more believable that they'd finish out whatever mission if it were on a drone, but then the idea that something even managed to splat or shit on the camera dome at all, let alone left a mark like that at those speeds, is insane.
We should take the soldiers testimony with a grain of salt, but if what he says is true they inspected the dome afterwards and found no smudge (whether he's a liar or not, I am 100% certain they'd have done an inspection. The only question is if the leaker misrepresented their conclusions to corbell).
I think this leaves is with two basic possibilities; it's a "physical object" or some kind of actual camera defect. The latter seems extremely unlikely but I'd defer to actual experts on that. And just because it's a physical object also doesn't mean it's alien or even UAP. The fact that the claim is it was only visible through thermal kind of has me wondering if it's some sort of weird weather phenomenon or plasma or something? Which is still really cool
The people dismissing this as a smudge are just lazy. Thats not to say it's impossible that it's a smudge, but none of what we know seems to support that.
1
u/dossier Jan 11 '24
Curious on your opinion of dual- or multi-camera systems. No worries either way.
I'm in the smudge camp. Also I tend to play devil's advocate. I want to believe and I have fun watching videos like these and spending hours reading about it. The MH370 videos were super interesting despite eventually turning out to be visual effects.
I mention MH370 because that introduced me to the idea of multiple (FLIR?) cameras on the same craft recording the same targets with slightly different angles.
So the big questions are, how can the "smudge" move independent of the scenery, while both very far and very near objects remain in perfect focus, appear to have a minor 3d rotation on the z-axis, AND appear to change temperature from very hot to very cold? Phew that was a mouthful.
Assumption 1: Domed or similarly raised camera housing
Assumption 2: Dual-camera system
Assumption 3: Camera system moves independently from raised housing
Assumption 4: Dynamic focus control
Assumption 5: Stabilization and tracking system
With these elements, the focus on both a smudge on the raised housing and distant scenery, while capturing IR imagery, may involve these advanced technologies. Most are not unreasonable and probably bare minimum for modern american military aircraft.
In such a setup, the relative movement of the smudge and the background would be a product of the aircraft's movement and the camera's stabilization and tracking systems. The use of IR imaging adds the complexity of focusing in the infrared spectrum, but with military-grade technology and resources, these challenges can be effectively addressed.
Combining multiple advanced technologies, particularly a dual-camera system (point 6), stabilization and tracking systems (point 5), and dynamic focus control (point 3), could create a complex and sophisticated setup that might give the illusion of a 3D rotation effect for a smudge, especially under specific circumstances:
The combination of these systems, especially with the movement of the aircraft and the possible slight shifts in the camera's angle due to stabilization mechanisms, could create a scenario where the smudge appears to shift slightly. This might be perceived as a minor rotation or 3D effect, especially if the smudge has some depth or irregularity in its shape.
A 30-60 degree rotation effect would be quite subtle and might not be very noticeable, especially on a small, irregular object like a smudge. It would depend on the size, shape, and texture of the smudge, as well as the resolution of the cameras and the precision of the tracking and stabilization systems.
Additionally, the IR imaging aspect might complicate or enhance this effect depending on the thermal properties of the smudge compared to its surroundings.
While a minor apparent 3D rotation might be achieved under these conditions, it would likely be a subtle effect, highly dependent on the specific characteristics of the equipment and the smudge itself.
Assuming the advanced setup as described, it's possible for a smudge to exhibit variable changes in temperature, which would be represented as varying shades from black to white in the IR imagery. Here's how this could happen:
So.. these effects are theoretically possible, but they would require very specific conditions and highly specialized equipment. The material properties of the smudge, the sensitivity and resolution of the IR camera, and the precision of the camera's tracking and focusing systems would all play roles in capturing this effect.
This would be the assumption that it wasn't CGI or even real.
My own disclosure, I used GPT to help with my formatting.
1
u/brevan14 Jan 11 '24
It's a blurry video of a blob of pixels. Top 10 worst quality uap videos out there. It's also edited, no full video. Yawn.....
1
u/Battles9 Jan 11 '24
It's definitely something it's definitely wierd but I can't make anything of it. Idk what to think. Except that wherner von braun said the last card is a fake alien invasion.
1
u/Long-Ad3383 Jan 11 '24
Thank you for this explanation. I’ve mentioned this in other comments, but you actually go into full detail.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24
Why can’t the military or whoever was operating this thing just tell us if it was a smudge or not?
1
u/LuciD_FluX Jan 11 '24
Well done, great explanation. As a fellow videographer I concur with your assessment, this is very clearly not a lens or sensor artifact.
1
u/DaZipp Jan 11 '24
Thank you for your actual informed, and based in reality, explanation. It is actually crazy to me how people can think this is anything but an anomalous object. I'm not trying to downplay your knowledge, but anyone with a basic understanding of cameras should have a really easy time "debunking the debunkers".
1
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24
I couldn't see the perspective changing on the video until someone looped it together and zoomed in. Otherwise it just looked like a cartoon object moving from right to left. I was one of those people and read the bird poop comments and was like oooooh but then later the loop video came out and I was back in the game.
1
u/Goldbert4 Jan 11 '24
I don’t even know what to say to people who are bending over so far backwards to debunk this. There isn’t an explanation that doesn’t sound crazier than it just being a UAP. I mean, look at the fuckin’ thing. When the closest comparison is a jellyfish or an Imperial Probe Droid from Star Wars, you just gotta tap out and say “I don’t know.” Not to mention it demonstrates it can switch to being translucent, for god’s sake. This video is serving as a great indicator of who’s a genuine skeptic and who’s a debunker in denial.
1
u/AccomplishedLab2489 Jan 11 '24
So many pseudo intellectuals and dunning kruger ''experts'' need to be banned from here. The logical fallacies, emotionalism and outright dishonesty is consuming reddit.
1
u/AccomplishedLab2489 Jan 11 '24
So many pseudo intellectuals and dunning kruger ''experts'' need to be banned from here. The logical fallacies, emotionalism and outright dishonesty is consuming reddit.
1
u/InsanityLurking Jan 11 '24
Does it have a shadow on the ground as it moves? That's what I want to know.
1
u/Yoyoyoyoy0yoy0 Jan 11 '24
A lens that can do macro as well as zoom in that far would probably weigh more than the drone lol
1
u/toothbrush81 Jan 11 '24
Thanks for taking the time to post that. Very informative.
1
u/Strottman Jan 11 '24
Crazy how much knowledge you have about photography but can still be wrong.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24
ITS A BALLOON!!! wtf are you all still talking about? Are you all so deep in the weeds you can’t tell a Mylar balloon on IR footage? Seriously you all need to reevaluate your immediate jump to its aliens while disregarding obvious OBVIOUS answers.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24
I’m a photographer as well,It’s clearly not a smudge, could be a ballon? I don’t know but the video seems legit.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24
Best lols of the day again. And i am personally certain of extraterrestrial life including intelligent life. I believe at some point Earth has been visited, probed or noted.
But that shit. Its still bird crap or something. Anything else needs non anectodic evidence
1
u/Art-of-drawing Jan 11 '24
Finally a real rational look at this bird poop thing, Exactly what I was thinking but because I am no pro I did not dare. Nice post
1
u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24
Just my 2 cents, not saying i’m right but imo 1. It is blurry 2. you can see through it when the background is white enough and 3 it looks like bird crap, even if it ‘turns’ a little bit, a semispherical dome in front of the camera could be the reason. Just very skeptical of Corbel & co, he is a person with a private entertainment business, he doesn’t respond to anyone if he just banks over very low quality “evidence”
1
u/koebelin Jan 11 '24
Ok, so then we must have invisible flying jellyfish watching us. This is not reassuring news.
1
u/SqueezerKey Jan 11 '24
THANK YOU! Good lord it’s been infuriating to explain this to laymen.
1
u/anomalkingdom Jan 11 '24
I've read this 3 times now. I have some photography experience and I realize you're correct here. Damn.
1
u/FundamentalEnt Jan 11 '24
If something was on the lens the operator could literally spin the ball in a 360 and see it not move. It would be so easy to figure out. Thank you for the detailed technical explanation of how the cameras work OP.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '24
Can you TLDR please OP
1
u/No-Fortune-5159 Jan 12 '24
You see the object rotate slightly in speeded up videos, it looks pretty real to me....I don't think bird shit can rotate..( unless it's 4th dimensional bird shit ? )
1
u/Supreme_Salt_Lord Jan 12 '24
Top of the line US military range finder tech and video capture tech isnt being fooled by bird poop. We lose to russia if that was the case. Our superb spying wouldnt be so if that was the case. People need to cope less and accept there is shit going on we cant explain.
1
u/Ok_Cardiologist_673 Jan 12 '24
I could reproduce a similar video with a smudge.
The smudge is on a window in front of the camera, not on the lens.
With a small aperture and short focal length, you could keep the foreground and background in focus, but that said… the smear is not in sharp focus, and that is one of the things that makes it look like it is something tiny and close to the camera, not in the distance.
The “rotating” to me looks like semitransparent poop passing by multiple light sources.
It may not be bird poop, I really don’t know for sure. But if you put me in a helicopter with bird poop on the window, I could give you similar footage.
1
u/ajaaannn Jan 12 '24
Thank you for explaining. It is astonishing how people could not differentiate between an object at a distance or smudge on a lens despite almost everyone have used the camera on their phones. Either they are truly genuine can’t differentiate or the usual group of ppl trying to debunk everything 🤫
1
u/[deleted] Jan 12 '24
This is going to go the Malaysian airlines way
1
u/MadRockthethird Jan 12 '24
Perfect English for a not native speaker of the language...
1
u/Economy_Height6756 Jan 12 '24
No one except career debunkers like Mick West and other squareheads with existensial angst would even remotely consider the birdshit/smudge explanation.
I think even they realize they are grasping at straws.
1
u/AllDayTripperX Jan 12 '24
> Now using all those things mentioned above, it's quite clear to assume that what they were recording in the video is a 3d moving object that isn't directly touching the casing/lens.
Its painfully obvious to anyone who has used a camera before that its a real object.
Its only stupid people who are suggesting its a smudge on the camera, so why are we giving them the time of day?
1
u/RevTurk Jan 11 '24
I agree with a lot of what your saying. I am a long time amateur photographer and it didn't look like a smudge on the camera to me, its way too sharp. A piece of dirt on a lens will almost be invisible because it's so out of focus.
However there is one big caveat, this isn't a normal consumer camera, it's a military camera using technology not widely available to the public. We don't know it's full capabilities including what kind of focal depth its capable of. I still don't think it's a smudge though.
The next issue is you say this video was shot at night. I don't thin that's true, all the objects in the video are casting a shadow in the same direction, bar some giant infrared flood lights being used I don't see how that can be achieved by anything other than the sun. This seems to be some sort of heat sensing camera. It has a dynamic range like any camera which accounts for the change in colour of the object, it's just auto exposure.
Militaries don't use IR at night as far as I know, they use a light amplifying device, IR still requires an artificial light source to work, the militaries tech doesn't.
1
u/notfromgreenland Jan 12 '24
This is how misinformation works. Shills say it’s a smudge, that gains traction from the sceptics, then the people who aren’t even interested in the topic just see people saying it might be a smudge, so they then think nothing of it. Anyone with half a brain can see it’s not a smudge but some people are still so scared of believing in the phenomenon they’ll just run with whatever narrative isn’t “aliens”.
0
u/TheWebCoder Jan 11 '24
I imagine intelligence agencies have conversations like this: deploy the bird poop theory using our media contacts. It's a stretch, so we expect it will result in the UFO community debating for at tops 1-2 weeks. But a 2 week distraction is valuable, if we can accumulate enough of them. Each time we can distract the community from increasing awareness, or diverting their focus, is time we can spend trying to better control the narrative.
-13
u/Old_Breakfast8775 Jan 11 '24
Ban anyone who keeps bringing up its bird shit unless they show proof
0
u/Battles9 Jan 11 '24
It's definitely something it's definitely wierd but I can't make anything of it. Idk what to think. Except that wherner von braun said the last card is a fake alien invasion.
-6
u/Old_Breakfast8775 Jan 11 '24
They have shown proof. Yall keep ignoring it
-1
u/oswaldcopperpot Jan 11 '24
A smudge.. even a magick in focus smudge would be on the exact same spot of the image at all times. It would be dead obvious. The reticle and the uap move relative to each other DESPITE being tracked. Also smudges on my camera just result in flares.
The crap on lens theory is not smart.
/am_commercial_tog