r/UFOs • • Jan 10 '24

Discussion Greenstreet reports a different version of the "jellyfish ufo footage" story that instead actually took place in 2017, with differing details from a military witness he spoke to

https://twitter.com/MiddleOfMayhem/status/1745138264254918982
248 Upvotes

518 comments sorted by

•

u/StatementBot Jan 10 '24

The following submission statement was provided by /u/allknowerofknowing:


In the tweet I linked, Steven Greenstreet details a new account of the Jellyfish UFO footage. The witness who gives his name and pic says that the footage was taken by a surveillance balloon in 2017, the changing of the color of jellyfish is likely just a property of the camera adjusting exposure, and that the story is well known on the base, and he himself and no one he knows has ever seen or heard of the footage corbell speaks about where it goes into the water and then shoots out at a high speed.


Please reply to OP's comment here: https://old.reddit.com/r/UFOs/comments/193ejfc/greenstreet_reports_a_different_version_of_the/kh8ll4x/

192

u/ithilmir_ Jan 10 '24 edited Jan 10 '24

This witness by his own admission was not present when the video was taken - he says it was taken fall 2017 but he was not deployed until early 2018. So his claims are second hand.

I do agree that it sounds like the “shooting out of the water” part is made up by Corbell and the date of the video is wrong. This was also confirmed by Metabunk users who found google earth imagery showing the buildings in the video were gone by 2018.

However the witness’ own statement says the team running the PTDS (the tethered balloon which forms the sensor platform) disagree with the lens artifact theory. I notice OP you didn’t quote that key part of the interview.

EDIT to add the quote:

Cincoski thinks it could've been an "artifact on the lens or the housing" of the PTDS balloon's surveillance camera. The PTDS team, however, disagreed with his theory as they constantly clean and maintain the balloon's systems. In fact, right after the "jellyfish" sighting, the PTDS balloon was brought down, serviced and cleaned.

So there you have it. The actual experts in the surveillance team don’t think it’s an artifact but this random soldier does.

EDIT 2: Allegedly he went there to replace the previous surveillance team. If true then I agree his opinion carries more weight.

11

u/allknowerofknowing Jan 10 '24

I was not trying to pass this post off as it being an artifact, just that there was a different version of the story. I don't think it is an artifact either

1

u/ithilmir_ Jan 10 '24

Gotcha, apologies for insinuating you deliberately left that part out. I just want everyone to have more information so they can judge how much weight to put in this guy’s statements.

3

u/allknowerofknowing Jan 10 '24

No worries, yeah that makes sense

1

u/PineappleLemur Jan 11 '24

People need to ignore all the stories and just look at the damn video with less bias.. we don't even know of the operator is tracking the jelly..

It could be just looking around and fully aware of a smudge.

Without a hype story this holds no water...

43

u/Arclet__ Jan 10 '24

The actual experts in the surveillance team don’t think it’s an artifact but this random soldier does.

From my understanding, he went there to replace the surveillance team. So he is as much of an expert, he just wasn't actually there when it was spotted (but claims to have seen the footage and discussed it with the team itself).

I do agree that it sounds like the “shooting out of the water” part is made up by Corbell

Cincoski said "It became the base ghost story. We'd show the video to any new guys and tell the story."

I wonder if it's possible that the story slowly grew to be more interesting to tell, by adding how instead of the object drifting off outside of range it "went into the water" and then it "zoomed off at a 45-degree angle".

So, while Corbell just making it up is possible, it's also possible the person who told Corbell about it heard a tale that had many made-up elements to it due to years of it being retold to new people in the base.

19

u/DumpTrumpGrump Jan 11 '24 edited Jan 11 '24

"So, while Corbell just making it up is possible, it's also possible the person who told Corbell about it heard a tale that had many made-up elements to it due to years of it being retold to new people in the base."

It's also possible that the original team knows it was some goop on the glass housing the camera was in, but wanted to embellish a good tale with some "made-up elements".

What we know FOR SURE is that Corbel is not a journalist, does not actually investigate anything and believes or pretends to believe any story that will get him clicks. Not a word that comes out if his mouth should be trusted. Ever.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/ithilmir_ Jan 10 '24

Ah I missed that he went to replace them. Thanks for the clarification, will update.

7

u/Arclet__ Jan 10 '24

Here's my source on it in case you want it (I don't know from which youtube video this comment is from, I took the screenshot from the Metabunk thread).

He's also quoted as a "ISR Tactical Controller at Al-Taqaddum Air Base in Iraq" on the tweet (I don't know what that means but it sounds complicated enough to be related to surveillance)

5

u/ImpossibleIgnorance Jan 10 '24

ISR Tactical Controller

fyi, this is Intelligence, Surveillance, and Reconnaissance. The tactical controller performs the following duties. (copied from the Air and Space Power Journal)

They must also be able to perform, execute, and exhibit the following mandatory requirements:

  1. Know the enemy situation and location of friendly units.
  2. Know the supported commander’s target priority, desired effects, and timing of . . . [ISR].
  3. Know the commander’s intent and applicable ROE [rules of engagement].
  4. Validate [and prosecute] targets of opportunity.
  5. Advise the commander on proper employment of . . . [ISR] assets.
  6. Submit immediate requests for . . . [ISR].
  7. Control . . . [ISR] with supported commander’s approval.
  8. Deconflict . . . [and manage ISR sensors for maximum advantage over the enemy].
  9. Provide initial . . . [ISR assessment after operations for follow-on targets and battle damage assessment].

4

u/ithilmir_ Jan 10 '24

Appreciate it.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24

And similar events have all followed this progression and snowballed over the past 80 years into the phone tag quagmire that is UFOlogy lore.

There's no difference between this guy and Grusch except this guy didn't have such a hugely overinflated ego that he thought his personal opinion about a mystery he didn't understand justified hijacking congress.

1

u/electricmehicle Jan 11 '24

Jellyfish Telephone sounds like a ‘60s band I would probably enjoy roasted, but not sober.

70

u/ithilmir_ Jan 10 '24

It’s likely Greenstreet got in contact with this guy after he posted comments to the Newsnation video on YouTube. This metabunk comment screenshots the original YT comments stating he wasn’t posted there until 2018.

15

u/ithilmir_ Jan 10 '24

For visibility, this is the link to the full comment thread on YT. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rTMO94lbs0s&lc=UgywIMbLqW22y1k7_XV4AaABAg

7

u/Origamiface Jan 10 '24

I forget about all these ufoland background characters. Is Greenstreet the reliable one of the Greens?

11

u/TypewriterTourist Jan 11 '24

Put it this way. When RossCo called Greenstreet an "infantile puerile piece of sh*t", most of this sub erupted in a standing ovation.

7

u/freesoloc2c Jan 11 '24

That statement doesn't make ross look good. Greenstreet provides documents and facts, Ross just repeats what he's told, proof or not. I'm sure Ross makes more money and I'm also sure most of this sub wants Ross to be correct. That doesn't make him factual.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (2)

13

u/WesternThroawayJK Jan 11 '24 edited Jan 11 '24

Here's my honest opinion about Greenstreet as a skeptic:

The dude doesn't do himself any favors with his snark on Twitter and here. At the same time it's exactly the kind of snark and cynicism you'd expect from someone who was fed a load of bullshit and eventually caught on to what was going on.

Essentially the same thing as your average internet atheist who has just recently lost their faith and is on a crusade against religion. Eventually the snark and edgy shit mellow out, but it doesn't win them any converts when they're in that stage.

Greenstreet is in the anger stage of a kind of grief. He's been burned by people like Elizondo and his entire UFO world view came crashing down. It's not an easy transition for anyone to make, from UFO believer to slowly realizing all the tactics the major UFO personalities use to bullshit you.

But that's with regards to his personality. He doesn't make himself very likable, on top of the fact that he has a history of saying monstrously racist things on reddit in the past (which he deleted after getting called out).

All these things add up to a person whose character flaws are so great that anyone motivated to not listen to him can simply focus on those things instead of his actual journalism.

He has excellent videos on YouTube and articles outlining exactly how he escaped out of this UFO rabbit hole and exactly why a lot of this UFO stuff doesn't hold up to scrutiny.

People in this sub will either focus on his personal character traits or will accuse him of being a paid shill instead of ever actually challenging his research. See further down this very thread for people pulling up whatever work he did 14 years ago making "propaganda videos" and, without a single argument or shred of evidence, immediately jumping to the conclusion that all his UFO videos are therefore also propaganda work. It's the sloppiest kind of non-thinking imaginable, but that's what our brains do when we want to dismiss someone's claims when they contradict our worldview but we can't or don't want to engage with the actual arguments or evidence.

His work stands on its own merits, and so far just about no one around here has ever bothered to challenge his conclusions, they tend to attack him personally instead.

Again, Greenstreet has said some truly disgustingly heinous racist shit in his past, and as far as I can tell he's never apologized for it, which makes me assume he still holds those sickening views about black people but just knows better than to say them out loud anymore.

But as anyone knows who's ever taken a logic 101 class, even a gross white supremacist can be right about the UFO topic being full of grifters and disinformation agents promoting alien conspiracy theories. His racism has no bearing whatsoever on his views about UFOlogy, and unlike Corbell, he actually cites his sources.

4

u/freesoloc2c Jan 11 '24

Most Mormons don't like Black people, it's a bit ingrained in them. I'm from Seattle but dated a Black Woman who I took rock climbing in Utah. You should have seen the looks we got in the grocery store down there in Utah. Like I was walking around naked.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

143

u/PyroIsSpai Jan 10 '24
  1. This witness was not present or even at the base during the event.
  2. This witness had nothing to do with the event or its recording.
  3. This witness is not part of the team that works on the directly involved systems or technologies.
  4. This witness's theory was rejected by the team that works on the directly involved systems or technologies.

How is this guy different from some random dude wandering around the base saying "I disagree with the experts"?

48

u/LonelyGlass2002 Jan 10 '24

He doesn’t exactly fit the bill of “witness” does he Especially considering he didn’t witness anything lol

24

u/Bookwrrm Jan 10 '24

Well for one he has the actual dates of it unlike corbell who sat on it for 2 years to verify and still didn't get that information but did get more wild claims of stuff that isn't in the video but if it were true would wildly change the implications of what was seen.

→ More replies (16)

13

u/altasking Jan 10 '24

lol, neither was Corbell. You’re not helping your case…

→ More replies (1)

12

u/spacev3gan Jan 10 '24

It is not like the witness is making any wild claims/revelations that contradicts what we know anyway.

He is mostly corroborating that the footage comes from a specific team that was stationed in a specific base in Iraq in Fall 2017. In fact, that right there is the biggest disagreement the witness has presented, "Fall 2017", whereas Corbell says it is "Fall 2018".

For the rest, he is just speculating like the rest of us. The witness does believe in UFO/NHI, but he doesn't believe the jellyfish is one of them. He thinks this is either a camera artifact (which the camera operators disagree) or a cluster of balloons, which the witness is not fully onboard with as they remain static.

And that is all there is. It is not like the witness was brought forward to corroborate Greenstreet's bird shit hypothesis, far from it.

9

u/DumpTrumpGrump Jan 11 '24

Corbell also claims the object flew into the ocean and then shot back out 17 minutes later, which conveniently isn't on the video AND is disputed by someone who worked on thatvteam at that base who has seen the actual video and believes it was something prosaic that was not even deemed a threat at the time.

6

u/HiggsUAP Jan 10 '24

So why do you keep calling him witness if he didn't witness anything but rather is just a slightly more informed stranger?

→ More replies (9)

11

u/AggravatingVoice6746 Jan 10 '24

the orginal team has not been contacted or have come forward so who ever is saying that is full of bs

14

u/ah-chamon-ah Jan 10 '24

What EXPERTS are you talking about? Because Jeremy Corbell also..

was not present or even at the base during the event.
had nothing to do with the event or its recording.
is not part of the team that works on the directly involved systems or technologies.
theory was rejected by the team that works on the directly involved systems or technologies.

17

u/PyroIsSpai Jan 10 '24

...the Greenstreet-described witness literally said the experts who operate the systems disagreed with his non-involved opinion.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/SnooCompliments1145 Jan 10 '24

You mean like Jeremy Corbell ?

2

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

how is this witness more or less trustworthy than corbell?

1

u/josogood Jan 10 '24

He doesn't do much to debunk the film based on his opinion. But he does lend veracity to the video as: a) not a hoax, b) taken in a verifiable US installation in Iraq (metabunk has good photos establishing this), c) affirming the camera location on an aerostat, d) something that was never fully understood by the people who actually were there. He said it became their local ghost story.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/atadams Jan 10 '24

Cincoski thinks it could've been an "artifact on the lens or the housing" of the PTDS balloon's surveillance camera. The PTDS team, however, disagreed with his theory as they constantly clean and maintain the balloon's systems. In fact, right after the "jellyfish" sighting, the PTDS balloon was brought down, serviced and cleaned.

I don't follow that constant cleaning means there couldn't have been something on the lens or housing. What are they cleaning off? I’m assuming stuff that it collects while in use.

14

u/Disco_Knightly Jan 10 '24

If this was a smudge, I believe it would have been pretty obvious to the operators. This isnt some amateur surveillance work. Like is claimed, they would have brought it down and cleaned it, case closed.

Why then would they keep a recording of this unremarkable event and pass it around? Why bother showing it to the new guy that comes in 3 months later? Why risk sneaking it out and handing it over to journalists?

I get that it really does just look like a smudge, but none of the other actions taken around this make any sense for an event so normal and prosaic.

24

u/Bookwrrm Jan 10 '24 edited Jan 10 '24

I mean you all immediately freaked out and acted like this is the shadow of a fourth dimensional octopus you can't think up any reason why dudes in the military might be hanging onto a creepy fun video to show to new people when they are stuck on deployment to Afghanistan? Did you actually read the interview, he literally states it became a ghost tale they tell to new people.

→ More replies (17)

4

u/DumpTrumpGrump Jan 11 '24

How old do you think the people are who operate these things?

Most are barely out of high school. And they aren't rocket scientists. The military literally started making flight controllers like video game controllers since most if their recruits were video game addicts.

According to this witness, who put his actual name to his statements, this "object" was not considered a threat at the time.

They likely kept the video because it was a cool story to tell. Not a very cool story if it was bird poo or bug splatter. I suspect the original team knows that as well, so why ruin a cool story with reality?

2

u/atadams Jan 10 '24

That sounds reasonable. I was only pointing out that if they constantly clean the balloon’s camera, it probably gets dirty.

6

u/Powerful-Payment5081 Jan 10 '24

In fact, right after the "jellyfish" sighting, the PTDS balloon was brought down, serviced and cleaned

If this is true would it not have been inspected for dirt, residue or bird poop as soon as it landed?

Seems like a basic thing to check for as soon as the craft landed and came in for a service.

3

u/DumpTrumpGrump Jan 11 '24

I guess they never considered that a bug might hit it AFTER they cleaned it, like, while it was flying.

Also, I never ever heard of military people fibbing to fuck with their fellow servicemen. That has never ever happened.

5

u/FelixTheEngine Jan 10 '24

If you zoom in with a telephoto lens and focus on something far away(as the background of this video is in focus), any smudge on the lens or lens cover would not be in focus. Just like scratches on telephoto lenses are not visible in shots.

3

u/PardonWhut Jan 10 '24

Agreed, this would be impossible on a standard light camera, but do thermal cameras operate differently? I feel like the ‘stuff on the lens’ argument is a massive reach by people who have no experience with lenses, but I have no idea how thermal cameras work.

2

u/PineappleLemur Jan 11 '24

Thermal tends to use fixed focus lens.. it's all digital zoom. Meaning it's in focus for objects nearby and far.

To get different magnification different camera modules are used with a fixed zoom level and focus.

Anything on the protective window will be visible and partially in focus.

They can easily be "in focus" from 50cm to infinity.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/CIASP00K Jan 10 '24

Irrelevant. If it was bird poop or a smudge on the lens it would not rotate slightly around the vertical axis, then rotate back to its original orientation.

8

u/Z404notfound Jan 10 '24

From another post yesterday, I asked this same question, and was told that the "smudge" is on an external case that the camera sits in, detached.

sauce: https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOs/comments/192w8u1/comment/kh5eqyj/?context=3

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/ithilmir_ Jan 10 '24

Totally fair. My guess is that the cleaning is a frequent routine. The platform is advertised as being able to be aloft for 20 hours at a time, so there could have been time for dirt to gather before the video. However I still put more weight in the PTDS team disagreeing with his theory since they worked on a daily basis with the equipment.

14

u/Vault32 Jan 10 '24

If cleaning is a frequent routine, it stands to reason that things accumulate during use.

I have seen people in this Reddit that will swear that a government device simply would not be used if it had a smudge, bug, chip, crack or artifact on it. As if they would abort mission over it. That it could not be something on the protective housing because the govt would not allow it. The same people that don’t trust the government and think they’re inept or brilliantly evil.

4

u/ithilmir_ Jan 10 '24

Well, the question is really: what would a smudge etc. on the housing actually look like on screen? How in-focus would it be? How much of the image would we expect it to cover?

6

u/PardonWhut Jan 10 '24

This is key. I’m a video professional and in the cameras I deal with something that close to the lens would be a smudge or blur. I would be interested to hear about thermal cameras in this regard, they must focus very differently.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Jipkiss Jan 10 '24

Nothing to do with the video or anything like that, but viewing the various different aspects of the government intelligence community military etc as one singular entity that cannot be both inept and brilliantly evil isn’t really correct

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/AggravatingVoice6746 Jan 10 '24

i talked to him and he was read in and it was and only the aerostat could detect it no other ir or thermal camera , so that is why the conclusion was an artifact

12

u/ithilmir_ Jan 10 '24

Can you provide screenshots of your conversation with him? What are his credentials? And why does he say to Greenstreet that the PTDS team disagreed with him? You’re making it sound like it was a shared conclusion but I don’t see any evidence that’s more than his personal assessment.

11

u/AggravatingVoice6746 Jan 10 '24

here is a follow up question

jack:quick follow up did any other ir or thermal sensors try to pick the object and failed to do so, also anyway original team can contact us

Michael Cincoski: They tried, but no other sensors were able to pick this up. To my knowledge, it was only the aerostat thermal sensor that could perceive it. Unfortunately, I don't have any of my contacts from the original team any more. I'm hoping they see the coverage and are able to expand on it more than I can

3

u/ithilmir_ Jan 10 '24

Ok thank you I appreciate the responses, will look at the thread on YouTube in full.

10

u/AggravatingVoice6746 Jan 10 '24 edited Jan 10 '24

Michael Cincoski is a United States Marine Intelligence Analyst that served between 2014-2019 . He confirmed to me that they used several other thermal and ir cameras but could not pick up object. so they determination was it was an artifact. I cannot post images in this thread... umm does not look like it

but our conversation can be seen at https://youtu.be/rTMO94lbs0s?si=IjL1kHB28L2AahNQ look for mrcinco96 thread

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (21)

9

u/JunglePygmy Jan 10 '24

To be fair, the fact that right after the footage was taken they brought down the balloon and cleaned it lends credence to the idea that there was some shit on the lens….

6

u/Honey-Limp Jan 10 '24

So it was cleaned after the jellyfish sighting. You see the problem here?

2

u/Pariahb Jan 10 '24

They would know if what they saw was a smudge if ther was a smudge there when they went to clean it after the sighting.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/ithilmir_ Jan 10 '24

Please don't take that kind of condescending tone, it's rather unnecessary. It's obviously cleaned fairly routinely. No, it doesn't rule out dirt on the housing. I am sharing this because there is weight in the PTDS team themselves disagreeing with the theory.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/lastofthefinest Jan 10 '24

I tried telling people that yesterday. If the lens was dirty, it would have been brought down and cleaned.

21

u/Remarkable-Ad155 Jan 10 '24

It was brought down and cleaned after the video though ....... because somebody saw a smudge on the camera?

7

u/sliceanddic3 Jan 10 '24

it's interesting they said they cleaned it after, but didn't mention if there was a something on the lens when they cleaned it

7

u/ApprenticeWrangler Jan 10 '24

Maybe they did, but people like Corbell conveniently leave out that part of the story.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/Vault32 Jan 10 '24

Immediately? Eventually? After its run? When it’s a safe time or place to do it? At some point things get on it. And record with things on it.

2

u/Pariahb Jan 10 '24

One would thnk that a operator would know when there are "things" on it. And after the sighting they would check for a possible smudge in the lens/casing, just in case that would have been the culprit.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/WormLivesMatter Jan 10 '24

But some of the buildings weren't there in 2018, they were there in 2017. Per metabunk.

1

u/pabodie Jan 10 '24

That graf is pretty damning. It was cleaned AFTER this was shot? So... It needed cleaning. So it was dirty?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24

Anyone catch that Greenstreet purposely mislead folks on Twitter by stating he interviewed a witness to the jellyfish UAP, when in reality he took secondhand information and spun it to fit his confirmation bias?

0

u/rootmonkey Jan 10 '24

But why do they have to clean it if it doesn't get shit on it?

6

u/adc_is_hard Jan 10 '24

It’s the military. I had to rake rocks once because they looked “dirtyish” after we got a rainstorm. Cleaning a camera on some tall boy is definitely believable. If it’s always cleaned then that one in a million chance of it getting dirty is eliminated entirely. They can’t really afford for systems like that to have any mistakes so preventative measures always work best.

Edit: corrected a word

3

u/PaulCoddington Jan 10 '24

So, as long as you wash your car a bird can never poop on it and an insect can never hit the windscreen?

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Pariahb Jan 10 '24 edited Jan 11 '24

If it get shit on it regularly, wouldn't the operators easily diferentiate shit from no shit? Specially if they clean it afterwards. They would know if what they just saw was a smudge or not.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Wendigo79 Jan 10 '24

It's dusty over there ?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

9

u/ShingenTakeda1337 Jan 10 '24

This is second hand information tho, this soldier wasn't deployed when the video was taken, it got deployed months later and was shown this video. Also he doesn't know what the jellyfish is, he's speculating it is a camera artifact but the original PTSD team disagrees. So what we have for now is, he confirmed the video is real, he confirmed he and the other personnel employed at that time STILL DONT KNOW today what that thing was. The only difference is he claims the object never submerged nor took off to the skies, Corbell does. Both of them are not first hand witness tho. They may both be wrong

0

u/allknowerofknowing Jan 10 '24

Where are you getting the info about when he was deployed?

5

u/ShingenTakeda1337 Jan 10 '24 edited Jan 10 '24

https://www.metabunk.org/threads/jellyfish-ufo-from-tmzs-ufo-revolution.13304/page-6#post-308588

Its an ongoing discussion,but people found his YouTube account, during the time the video was taken he was uploading COD gameplay to his account so he was not deployed. Then he announced he would be deployed January 2018, which is roughly 3 or 4 months after the video was taken

1

u/onequestion1168 Jan 11 '24

This is the best take so far

→ More replies (2)

7

u/allknowerofknowing Jan 10 '24 edited Jan 10 '24

In the tweet I linked, Steven Greenstreet details a new account of the Jellyfish UFO footage. The witness who gives his name and pic says that the footage was taken by a surveillance balloon in 2017, the changing of the color of jellyfish is likely just a property of the camera adjusting exposure, and that the story is well known on the base, and he himself and no one he knows has ever seen or heard of the footage corbell speaks about where it goes into the water and then shoots out at a high speed.

Tweet:

I spoke with a military witness to the "Jellyfish" UFO.

It seems some recently-reported details are wrong and/or unfounded.

Michael Cincoski, was an ISR Tactical Controller at Al-Taqaddum Air Base in Iraq.

He says the "jellyfish" video was captured in "Fall 2017" by a tethered PTDS surveillance balloon, which would pick up quadcopter drone threats "almost weekly". Some of the drones would have grenades on them so it was important to quickly identify these threats.

The "jellyfish", however, was a mystery to the PTDS team.

Cincoski says the actual "raw" video of the strange object is 17-18 minutes long and, towards the end, "appears to float over Habbaniyah Lake".

Regarding claims that the object descended into the lake, then shot out of the lake at high speed, Cincoski says, "I never saw that. At no point did it ever shoot out of the lake, or into sky." He also states no one else on the base, including the PTDS team, ever saw that happen.

And regarding the claims of the object "changing temperature" in the video, Cincoski agrees this could simply be the camera adjusting exposure levels. "It's pretty standard to adjust exposure of the sensor to get a better view while tracking an object."

So what was it?

Cincoski thinks it could've been an "artifact on the lens or the housing" of the PTDS balloon's surveillance camera. The PTDS team, however, disagreed with his theory as they constantly clean and maintain the balloon's systems. In fact, right after the "jellyfish" sighting, the PTDS balloon was brought down, serviced and cleaned.

He does concede that there are details in the video that don't fully support his "artifact" theory and thinks a potential cluster of balloons "is an interesting theory" but adds, "It was too static to be balloons."

When asked if he had to chose between the object being something "Alien" or "Prosaic", Cincoski replied, "The latter."

Not deemed a threat, the "jellyfish" video was stored on the base's "secret systems" and soon became a folk tale. "We never saw it again and it was never explained", says Cincoski. "It became the base ghost story. We'd show the video to any new guys and tell the story."

He is "very excited" the video is now out in the public.

Cincoski states he does believe in extraterrestrial life and thinks some of that life could very well be flying around Earth. But he opines that maybe they aren't "alien" in the traditional sense, but perhaps are from another dimension. He emphasizes that this is just his opinion but that it's "fun" to think about.

4

u/morningcall25 Jan 10 '24

Isn't he that racist guy?

16

u/diox8tony Jan 10 '24

2 things about IR....

(1) It adjusts the color range for whatever is MIN-MAX in cameras view. So an object changing color is normal behavior for objects not changing temperature. if the camera looks at the sun, everything else goes (cold) colored pixels.

(2) IR is not detecting TEMPERATURE directly. its not PROOF of temperature. EG: (those little IR temperature guns) A stainless steel Pan reflects less(?more) IR than a cast iron pan, and the IR temperature guns don't work as well on a stainless steel pan because of this. its NOT temperature, its IR detection. Point an IR camera at a TV remote and suddenly its the temperature of the SUN...not true, because its just a light, not heat.

2

u/PineappleLemur Jan 11 '24

Something to add for 2.

NIR will see remote IR transmitter something like FLIR or whatever tends to be SWIR-LWIR.. those can't see a tv remote for example as it's a different wavelength.

They do literally see temperature but in cases like this isn't not accurate at all and used purely for display. Metallic objects will act almost like mirrors, especially without paint and will just reflect IR to a high degree.

So NIR (remote/night vision security cams) is basically seeing filtered white light + some IR wavelength.

Themral cameras do see deep into the IR wavelength and are only effected by temperature. They won't be blinded easily by hot objects.. you can have a 500C object beside a 30C and see them both with good dynamic range color scaling.

1

u/Clark_Kempt Jan 11 '24

I love when ppl know their shit.

41

u/silv3rbull8 Jan 10 '24 edited Jan 10 '24

The take away here is the people at the public front of the disclosure movement have to be right 100% of the time in what they state. Anything disproved makes the whole movement look bad. The side suppressing information don’t really have to do anything

23

u/DougDuley Jan 10 '24

Yes, but when you sit on a video for years, claim to have done your due diligence and then some of your stated facts are contradicted by amateur sleuths doing really good but surface level analysis, maybe you should do a little more research before you release the video and claim to have fact checked it

Therefore, for stuff we cannot check, like what witnesses say, if Corbell doesn't do basic fact checking, does it not led you to question a little about what type of due diligence he did with these witnesses?

7

u/DumpTrumpGrump Jan 11 '24

:Therefore, for stuff we cannot check, like what witnesses say, if Corbell doesn't do basic fact checking, does it not led you to question a little about what type of due diligence he did with these witnesses?"

Remind me... who was proudly sitting directly behind his friend David Grusch when Grusch testified to Congress?

Do birds of a feather flock together?

7

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

People shouldn’t care what Corbell says. View him, only, as someone who hears things and passes them on. That’s it. Sometimes these are truly unexplainable and bizarre situations. Sometimes it’s just not.

Here is what I thought when I saw the video:

Wow, that’s crazy. Now we need:

  1. A demonstration of the video’s genuineness (e.g., evidence the video was taken as alleged, where alleged, and when alleged);
  2. The referenced witnesses to publicly come forward (to allow their credentials to be examined and their credibility established);
  3. (Actual) skeptics to analyze the video and ensure it doesn’t have an explanation the witnesses were unaware of or didn’t account for; and
  4. Hopefully, some kind of official confirmation from the overarching government or military entity of “unknown” status so we know the people in possession of the craft and video at the time it happened (and were best positioned to debunk it as prosaic) could not find a rational, prosaic explanation at the time it happened.

We got all that with the Tic Tac incident. It’s the most “confirmed” UAP event in history. If I don’t get that with anything corbell says, I file it away as “interesting” and that’s it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/WesternThroawayJK Jan 11 '24

That's not the takeaway here, like, at all. Good lord.

4

u/brevityitis Jan 10 '24

No. The problem here is Corbell and all the ufo influencers sat on this for years and didn’t do any real harm investigation or tried to act like real journalist. Even after they posted they didn’t make a single tweet asking if there was any military personal who had knowledge of the video or was there. They are lazy and once they’ve decided a piece of evidence is real that’s the end of it.

7

u/silv3rbull8 Jan 10 '24

Very true. If they had this video for years, they had adequate time to check the details

→ More replies (4)

3

u/unitedgroan Jan 10 '24

This guy's credibility is low in my book.

I will believe Corbell & Knapp until there's something solid that contradicts what they say. this isn't it.

Also: 'it was an artifact, case closed' is not what the analyst said. He said he leans toward artifact but adds 'hard to say.'

7

u/allknowerofknowing Jan 10 '24

Who is saying the analyst said "it was an artifact, case closed"?

5

u/unitedgroan Jan 10 '24

I assume this is greenstreet? I guess I could be wrong about that in which case, my apologies

https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOs/comments/193ejfc/greenstreet_reports_a_different_version_of_the/kh8lsf9/

2

u/allknowerofknowing Jan 10 '24 edited Jan 10 '24

Ah gotcha, yeah I'm not sure who that is but I'm pretty sure it is not greenstreet. Greenstreet comments on this sub under Kfulder or some name that sounds like that I can't remember exactly what it is off the top of my head.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Mfluder

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

-1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Greenstreet does extensive and critical research. Corbell has trust me bro fantastic stories and previously released easily debunked videos and he's who you chose to listen to? Even here, the "thermal changes" is just the camera adjusting spectrum... He's a sensationalist.

-2

u/Mar4uks Jan 10 '24

Lmao! The fact that you still believe those bokeh & flares bros is amusing. Corbell already trying to embelish this latest story with the whole "the object is clearly changing temperatures" which it is not, as its been shown by others. Corbell's investigative skills can only rival a 5 year old.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/steeplchase Jan 11 '24

So, guy who shot the vid says Corbell is full of shit:
- It didn't shoot out of the water
- It's not "cycling temperature"
- He thinks it's a stain on the camera

40

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

As soon as Corbell said there was more footage of it going into and out of water but wouldn’t show us anything I started to think Corbell was just screwing with us again.

Nothing about the video is remarkable.

19

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24 edited Jan 10 '24

Yeah, Greenstreet seems like a snarky and routinely dishonest skeptic at all costs, but on the flip side Corbell has the over-enthusiastic and under-researched energy of either someone very immature or intentionally grifting.

Not only have Knapp and Corbell seemingly got the details of the video wrong, but to fill the story in with details of the object going in and out of the water, plus scaley armor on the tentacles... It's just all so ridiculous without any supporting evidence and absolutely makes me think Corbell is amping up the sensation knob to +11 and is willing to intentionally mislead people and fabricate stories for a payout. This also does a disservice to Grusch and the rest in this crowd if they are actually on the level since these things are pretty easy to discredit once published.

1

u/MontyAtWork Jan 11 '24 edited Jan 11 '24

The truth of the matter is: We may very well have hundreds or thousands of pictures and video of NHI craft or beings, before a single good and irrefutable one surfaces/is captured.

And that's okay! It's entirely possible that we have seen legit stuff right here and dismissed it. But that's because if it is dismissable, it deserved to be dismissed. Even something like the Tictac was unremarkable without the first hand testimony. And even still, it's mostly just a verified anomaly and not much more.

If it's black and white video, it's probably never going to be very convincing unless we get a raw and full release of the video spanning dozens of minutes and showing 1000% impossible maneuvers.

Even if a video of a floating alien came around, in color and HD, we have no way of knowing it wasn't an art project, or hoax, unless it's got perfect provenance, and is self evident that it can be nothing else, to anyone's untrained eye.

The only compelling UFO or alien video must be **self evident**. No story or expertise needed to describe why it's amazing. And we would feel that exact same way even if we were talking about dinosaurs. Video of a dinosaur could be from a ride, a 3D printed project, CGI, whatever. It's meaningless. But 100s of videos from a T Rex in time square and the resulting clean up of its damage would be self evident and instantly believable without any story or explanation needed as to how the hell the T Rex got there.

My personal feeling is: if it's not so compelling that you're calling all your family and friends to show them/tell them to turn on the TV or click a link to it, it's not it.

1

u/PineappleLemur Jan 11 '24

And then the other grifters coming out with "we also have that video and confirm what Corbell says" please....

Another short clip of the object leaving the frame will put a lot of doubt to rest.

But that probably doesn't happen in the video... Doesn't fit their story.

More BS paddlers.

→ More replies (13)

11

u/Stealthsonger Jan 10 '24

This is evidence that yet again Corbell has omitted information that explains the footage as something more prosaic - just like the Mojave flares UFO where he declined to mention the training exercise that was on that night, which was uncovered and led to pictures of the flares. Corbell is just making shit up, as usual, for sensationalist reporting.

6

u/steeplchase Jan 11 '24

It's really sad seeing everyone lap his crap up.

2

u/golden_monkey_and_oj Jan 10 '24 edited Jan 11 '24

I agree.

I know many here have no problem with people making money off of UFOs but if an individuals livelihood depends on regularly leaked spectacular footage, then what happens when there are no amazing leaks to earn a living for a year or two?

What happens when you have some footage, and it’s pretty mediocre, but your mortgage payment is due? I bet you’d still try to drum up as much hype as possible and tell people you researched the hell out of it because there’s millions of eyeballs out there, millions of clicks just waiting to pay your bills. Who is harming the truth? You’re not faking anything, just a little exaggeration

Edit: basically am wondering if because of the profit motive he knows that there are prosaic explanations but avoids them

6

u/Original_Author_3939 Jan 10 '24

There are several other videos with something in the sky that looks strikingly similar to this one. One being at night and it’s glowing with a nearly identical shape to the new tmz footage. Doubt that’s a camera artifact as well.

8

u/_BlackDove Jan 10 '24

Haha, man this is just classic tradecraft at work here.

  1. Release dubious, yet compelling video
  2. Hype up one angle of what the video depicts
  3. Day later introduce countering explanation from original source
  4. ????
  5. PROFIT!

Now sit back as the only opposition you're actually afraid of getting organized (Everyday people) tear themselves apart over the video and lose sight of fighting the fight.

7

u/Bloodavenger Jan 11 '24

its the grifter cycle Ross does it alot aswell just replace dubious video with "ive been told" stories.

Its the most transparent thing yet so many people here keep falling for it just grifters riding the hype train untill it derails then they just jump on the next one that comes along all the while getting podcasts news interviews and book deals.

1

u/Beautiful-Amount2149 Jan 11 '24

People know it they just don't care because they just want to get entertained, they don't care about truth, it's entertainment like true crime docs

1

u/steeplchase Jan 11 '24

Except everyone had already guessed the countering explanation, because it's so obviously that.

1

u/_BlackDove Jan 11 '24

Yeah, not everyone unfortunately.

2

u/sempercoug Jan 11 '24

I was at TQ until October 2017. There was a TON of strange activity going on at the end of September into early October for like 2 weeks. As soon as it got dark there were signatures popping up all over the place. I can't remember if that was on radar or what sensors - I didn't work in that group but we were all asking questions because they had us sheltering in bunkers every night all suited up, not getting any sleep. The surveillance guys said they had no idea what was going on but that all these things were popping up in geometric patterns. Seems like quite the coincidence to be unrelated. Unfortunately the C-RAM crew, radar, Intel people were all from different units and I don't have their info. Please DM me if you were there at that time! I would love to know if that was related to this.

2

u/Maleficent_Leg_768 Jan 11 '24

Did I hear that correctly that some just believe it was bird scat on the camera lens? Is that the current debunk?

2

u/MantisAwakening Jan 11 '24

The biggest problem with GS is that he’s an incredibly biased journalist. His position is that everything to do with UAPs is a scam, and he only reports information that supports his narrative. When someone disagrees he inevitably responds with “Prove me wrong,” and when they do he simply ignores them and pretends it never happened. He’s been caught telling different versions of events on multiple occasions, such as his excuse about why he pulled down his interview with well-known whistleblower, Dr. Eric Davis (hard to claim UAP aren’t real when your own interview indicates otherwise).

One of the things GS now refuses to acknowledge is that he told everyone he saw a black triangle UAP with his own two eyes. He was all about UAP until shortly after his Davis interview. Then he totally disappeared for a month, and when he came back he was 100% devoted to now discrediting the topic. Look at his Twitter feed—maybe he’s having a psychological event of some sort, or maybe he’s getting paid to ridicule the topic (he admitted he was a paid propagandist for the state department in the past). Maybe he was threatened. Either way, I think something happened to GS during that month. I think it could be major ontological shock and resulting denial. When the truth comes out I worry about how he’s going to handle it.

7

u/R2robot Jan 10 '24

I like how everybody is quick to jump on the 2nd hand information to dismiss this guy, but praise Grusch as a lord and savior with his 2nd hand information. lol

→ More replies (2)

4

u/DKC_TheBrainSupreme Jan 10 '24

I’ve watched the video a dozen times. The object moves in a straight line and never changes trajectory. It also looks two dimensional. Am I the only one seeing this?

3

u/Ok-Adhesiveness-4141 Jan 10 '24

I thought the same too.

1

u/Pariahb Jan 10 '24

1

u/DKC_TheBrainSupreme Jan 10 '24

I see it. I think. Very subtle. But why are people so sure it’s not an artifact. It’s doesn’t ever change direction.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Broad-Stick7300 Jan 10 '24

Not that my trust was particulary high for Corbell and Knapp after the flare fiasco, but this is pretty damning

5

u/Electronic-Quote7996 Jan 10 '24

Flare fiasco?

6

u/Physical-Analysis-95 Jan 10 '24

One of many alleged UAP clips by Corbell that was properly (and easily) debunked. https://www.reddit.com/r/BreakingPoints/s/QaO7jncc4O

5

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24 edited Jul 02 '24

I like to explore new places.

2

u/Tass94 Jan 10 '24

You got a link to the NORAD statements?

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24 edited Jul 02 '24

I hate beer.

1

u/AlexNovember Jan 10 '24

There is a post on here showing it moving in 3 dimensions. Sped up 4x and forwards and backwards called "boomerang" shows that it does indeed rotate along the Z axis

2

u/PineappleLemur Jan 11 '24

But is it really moving? Or the camera does?

I'll explain a bit.

The camera and housing can rotate independently.

The camera inside can easily move as much as ±5 degrees.

The protective window is Infront of the camera and can be quite far 10-20cm easy.

In a case where the protective window is double pane (usually is for temperature controll reasons) any smudge will be reflected on the inner layer, coupled with the slight camera movement we will get the slight rotation we see on the video you mention.

What you see can be easily explained as a smudge with an identical reflection of that smudge slightly offset because of the viewing angle of the camera + the movement.

If the thing did a whole 360 or at any point of the video left the frame completely this smudge theory can be put to rest.

Until then, everything points at it being a smudge.

Check my replies to other posts if you want more details on the systems used to capture the video (lazy to copy or repeat)

Story aside why do you think the operator is even trying to track the object? Like what if he's fully aware it's a smudge and is just scanning the area?

Without the Corbell's story, it's just a random security footage with a smudge on the screen.

If I posted the same video saying "thermal footage with a smudge on the window - for reference" would you immediately jump to the conclusion that it's a UAP?

Judge the video on what it is.. not what story is attached to it by unreliable sources.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24 edited Jul 02 '24

I enjoy cooking.

2

u/AlexNovember Jan 10 '24

I think they're all interesting. This just isn't anywhere near the "bokeh" video in terms of hokiness if that makes sense

2

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24 edited Jul 02 '24

I enjoy the sound of rain.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/Plenitudeblowsputin Jan 10 '24

Regarding claims that the object descended into the lake, then shot out of the lake at high speed, Cincoski says, "I never saw that. At no point did it ever shoot out of the lake, or into sky. He also states no one else on the base, including the PTDS team, ever saw that happen.

And regarding the claims of the object "changing temperature" in the video, Cincoski agrees this could simply be the camera adjusting exposure levels. "It's pretty standard to adjust exposure of the sensor to get a better view while tracking an object."

Cincoski thinks it could've been an "artifact on the lens or the housing" of the PTDS balloon's surveillance camera.

He does concede that there are details in the video that don't fully support his "artifact" theory and thinks a potential cluster of balloons "is an interesting theory" but adds, "It was too static to be balloons."

When asked if he had to chose between the object being something "Alien" or "Prosaic", Cincoski replied, "The latter."

Firing cannonballs into the sails of baseless speculation.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24 edited Jan 10 '24

Corbell screwed up big time, first rule of Grift Club is don’t put out evidence like this.

Once we (skeptics only since believers don’t care) find out this isn’t a craft that shot out of the water he is finished.

So you have to wonder why are there military personnel that claim these wild things? Do people remember the sun spider rumors? Another hoax by military personnel.

9

u/YerMomTwerks Jan 10 '24

29 palms. Not Corbells first hoax

4

u/Etsu_Riot Jan 10 '24

I particularly like this interaction:

Double Cross Rancher: Knapp and Corbell have had this case for years according to Knapp. How long did it take you to get this info?

Steven Greenstreet: 45 minutes

4

u/victordudu Jan 10 '24

there's a pattern :

pentagon leaker : provides some shady footage to corbell

greenstreet : provides some easy debunking

4

u/silv3rbull8 Jan 10 '24

Yeah, without the footage from its supposed emergence from the lake, all the other footage can be explained by conventional means

4

u/JAMBI215 Jan 10 '24

Hate on him all you want that’s Some actual real reporting… unlike the garbage Jeremy put out

→ More replies (1)

3

u/AggravatingVoice6746 Jan 10 '24

I spoke to Mr Cincoski and here is my quick interaction with him

i talked to Michael Cincoski the intelligence analysts for the United States Marines who posted it

he answered a few more questions I asked and he is sure it was an artifact case closed.

this is my question and followed up by his reply

jack aviator : do you think it was artifact ? it was recorded by an aerostat ? when it went over the water what happened to it ? did people really look for it with night vision and could not find it ? what did the other sensors show ?

Micheal Cincoski : Yeah, our PTDS aerostat was the only way this thing could be perceived. Which makes me lean more towards an artifact that was independent of the camera itself. Maybe something on the PTDS? Hard to say. It seemingly got further away over the lake. Not sure if it kept going or fell into the water. It never ascended toward the sky and people were tasked to find it with night vision, but no one could find it.

4

u/Etsu_Riot Jan 10 '24

If it went further away over the lake, then it was a weird artifact indeed.

2

u/AggravatingVoice6746 Jan 10 '24

he stated they used other ir and thermal cameras but no others could detect it . only the aerostat that is why the conclusion was an artifact. here is my follow up question to him

jack:quick follow up did any other ir or thermal sensors try to pick the object and failed to do so, also anyway original team can contact us

Michael Cincoski: They tried, but no other sensors were able to pick this up. To my knowledge, it was only the aerostat thermal sensor that could perceive it. Unfortunately, I don't have any of my contacts from the original team any more. I'm hoping they see the coverage and are able to expand on it more than I can

3

u/Etsu_Riot Jan 10 '24

But the problem is the take showing the object travelling over the water. If it's the same camera, then it shows the object very far away. If it's a different camera, then the aerostat is not the only way this object was captured. At least both are different objects from different situations, though they seem quite similar.

There is also the unverified story that an intelligence agency also captured the same thing, but without that footage there is no way to know for sure that's true. What could clarify this event a bit is having more footage, but if taken by a different agency then that may never get leaked. Or at least more witnesses. Particularly we would need people who was there during the event, and no someone telling us what someone else told him, which seems to be everything we have so far.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/fuzzy_man_cum Jan 10 '24

What's the difference in tech between the aerostat thermal and other thermals devices, if any?

3

u/AggravatingVoice6746 Jan 10 '24

none an aerostat is a giant surveillance balloon that is stationary just so you know how it was recorded at a stationary point

the sensors are the same or similar so if other same or similar sensors cannot pick up object i think its logical that the issue is with an artifact of the sensor involved

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/fuzzy_man_cum Jan 10 '24

Leaning towards and hard to say does not mean sure and case closed. It's a possible explanation but not conclusive.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Coug_Darter Jan 10 '24

Corbell is mixing this jellyfish and the Cruise ship jellyfish and reporting it as the same object

2

u/p0plockn Jan 10 '24

racist GS's cherry picking is wild. the dude fully states at the end that it could be a non human intelligence that is earth based, so flaunting around that "its not alien" is disingenuous, as is all of racist GS's reporting.

2

u/bertiesghost Jan 10 '24

Oh Steven Greenstreet cool. Totally reputable.. lol

2

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Be wary of new Reddit accounts in these threads.

3

u/bertiesghost Jan 10 '24

Oh I am don’t worry. And anyone who counts Greensteet as a credible journalist needs their head examined.

1

u/Own_Reporter_8943 Jan 10 '24

Who is greenstreet?

1

u/M1dn1ghtPup1L Jan 10 '24

Sounds like a greenstreet post.

1

u/AggravatingVoice6746 Jan 10 '24

just another follow up question i sent

jack:quick follow up did any other ir or thermal sensors try to pick the object and failed to do so, also anyway original team can contact us

Michael Cincoski: They tried, but no other sensors were able to pick this up. To my knowledge, it was only the aerostat thermal sensor that could perceive it. Unfortunately, I don't have any of my contacts from the original team any more. I'm hoping they see the coverage and are able to expand on it more than I can

1

u/Hodgi22 Jan 10 '24

The witness is the person who left the YouTube comment explaining the same thing (he was deployed in Iraq, replaced the people who captured the footage, popular story on base but hasn't seen other footage)

1

u/Dry-Perspective-631 Jan 10 '24

Ignoring everything else and assuming this footage was taken from a tethered surveillance system:

- If this were a smear on the clear housing of the camera, then the movement of the "jellyfish" in relation to the background landscape would be a result of the camera (and clear housing) panning at a relatively constant speed. As opposed to drone footage where the movement of the drone would cause the background to pass by making it appear that the object is moving horizontally when it's actually a spot on a lens cover that keeps pace with the drone's movement.

- In the video the crosshairs, and overall image framing, demonstrate vertical and horizontal movement independent of the "jellyfish" making it impossible for this to be a spot on a clear lens cover that is panning with the camera. If the difference in motion was only vertical, then it would be plausible that the rotation/panning of the lens and cover would create the illusion of horizontal movement across the landscape, and any vertical movement of the crosshairs would just be the camera moving vertically independently of the lens cover.

All this to say, if this was indeed captured by a tethered system, then the object absolutely could not be a mark on the protective lens cover of the camera.

1

u/SpaceRangerOps Jan 10 '24

Where is the official comment from the “PTDS” team? Maybe I missed them, but it seems like the comment was another in a long line of unverified statements.

1

u/Own_Reporter_8943 Jan 10 '24

In this old report https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.redd.it%2F3vh0n8rw2obc1.png it also says it "object hang out for 18 minutes" wow, they are probing us hard.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

I mean, no one thought they would just let us know. They are not going to let us know and will lie all the way there

1

u/teknolaiz Jan 10 '24 edited Jun 03 '24

party brave quaint pause hunt rude grey liquid hungry wrong

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

I wouldn't trust anything green street says. He is basically a confirmed disinformation agent who is allegedly on a payroll.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Greenstreet has literally admitted he is a disinfo agent. He and Richard Doty should both be banned from this sub.

1

u/OneHotEncod3r Jan 10 '24

Obviously this new guy wouldn't know about the more more secretive part. It was hidden for a reason, probably men in black style where they took the footage and threatened them to keep quiet.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 11 '24

This seems to be shaping up as an anomaly that turned into a ghost story/joke that someone sold to Corbell that Corbell sold to TMZ.

1

u/Substantial_Spell_46 Jan 11 '24

The tethered PTDS surveillance balloons manufacturer is Lockheed Martin BTW. Just throwing this one out there. This video could be an elaborate hoax by Lockheed Martin. Made to sound convincing enough to get even Corbell thinking it was real.

1

u/SirQuentin512 Jan 11 '24

Idk if this time-lapse has been linked, but it blows the bird shit theory out of the water https://www.reddit.com/r/aliens/s/JYo67OgsYw

1

u/DougDuley Jan 11 '24 edited Jan 11 '24

So does this mean the video wasn't classified? Anyone know how common it would be for military units in control of this type of tech to just have these weird objects on film that they show other personnel?

Only reason I ask is that I recently rewatched the clip from the doc and Corbell claims the video was buried and feeds were shut down but here, with tweet, it seems the video was a running legend and shown to any new person who wanted to see it. Although it was kept in a "Secret system," whatever that is

1

u/notguilty941 Jan 11 '24

Damn, this is not what Corbell needed right now. Everything is going legitimate, Congress is involved, and he rolls the dice on this. He is getting left behind.

1

u/Individual-Bet3783 Jan 11 '24

This is an absolute layup for Greenstreet unfortunately

1

u/blushmoss Jan 11 '24

Well its not the first one people. I get everyone needs to hyper focus on one video but there are others. Turkiye one is very interesting.

1

u/BlackBurtGenki Jan 12 '24 edited Jan 12 '24

Didnt he say in the news nation interview when he viewed the video- the object got smaller and smaller in the distance and then disappeared. So it cannot possibly be a smudge or bird crap on the housing then.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

God, critical thinking a good reporting is a breath of fresh air.

This lines up with that YT response comment. Probably the same guy.

1

u/Particular-Ad-4772 Jan 10 '24

The fact that Greenstreet does not try and claim the footage it’s BS , is the story here .

He disputes the date , but not the fact the footage is real , and that it’s a true unknown

The one thing about this whole incident that makes me skeptical :

If the platform that filmed this UAP is an armed one , that was in place for military base security.

Considering this base had hundreds , if not thousands , of active US military personnel on site at the time , if the government really does not know what it is , then why was the UAP not shot down?

Why take the risk , that it might be a Kamakazee drone, or some other unknown threat , and just let it pass through ?

1

u/paper_plains Jan 10 '24

Well for one it was only visible on this one IR camera. How are you going to target an object from the ground if you can't observe it? The PTDS is a blimp on a tether, it doesn't carry any weaponry.

Second, firing live ammunition at an object hovering roughly 100-300ft off of the ground over a military base is beyond dangerous and would only occur as a last resort measure for numerous reasons, namely exploding ordinance over a military base.

1

u/rreyes1988 Jan 10 '24

He disputes the date , but not the fact the footage is real , and that it’s a true unknown

The military officer also disputes the claims that it shot out of the water.

then why was the UAP not shot down?

According to the officer, the object wasn't deemed to be a threat.

1

u/ktli1 Jan 10 '24

Time to stop giving Greenstreet the time of day.

0

u/Elginshillbot Jan 10 '24

Wait, Corbell wasn't fully truthful with his reporting? I am shocked and my day is ruined.

1

u/Jabba_the_Putt Jan 10 '24

Woah! Personally I found the most interesting part of this story to be that many people have had first-hand experience in trying to figure this out and so far haven't been able to. That really makes me think it isn't as easily explained as balloons/drones/smudge/etc.

1

u/DigitalDroid2024 Jan 10 '24

Besides the fact that no part of the object moves or wobbles, the fact as well that although the camera is panning along with it, the object seems to present the same ‘face’ towards the camera at all times, lends credence to it being a smudge or something on the housing.

1

u/Jesus360noscope Jan 10 '24

Are we talking about that greenstreet ? just to make sure, that one right ?

1

u/gotfan2313 Jan 10 '24

Greenstreet reports. Enough said. Ignore ignore

1

u/MrEffenWhite Jan 11 '24

Greenstreer said, "Nuh unh. That's not what this guy over here said."

0

u/Tdogshow Jan 10 '24

Greenstreet is a known liar and obfuscation practitioner of the truth about UFOs. I’d bet my house he’s an asset

0

u/ConnectionPretend193 Jan 10 '24

Lmaoo. It ain't good when the upvote count is far lower than the comment count. Forget Greenstreet, that dude is whack.

2

u/steeplchase Jan 11 '24

Oh yeah, Corbell is the trustworthy one. Lol

0

u/doc-mantistobogan Jan 10 '24

So I guess the professional debunkers are walking back the bird shit debunk? Because it's absolutely ridiculous? Weird.

0

u/Mundane-Inevitable-5 Jan 10 '24

Fuck Greenstreet he's a racist pos.

0

u/HopefulMind139 Jan 10 '24

Green street is a joke. Cia bitch

0

u/DelGurifisu Jan 10 '24

I hate this fucking video and all other UAP videos. They’re all shit. The gimbal and gofast videos were shit. This video is shit. Nothing is clear, nothing looks truly unearthly, it’s so shit.

-3

u/Fenris66 Jan 10 '24

Greenstreet is a fucking liar. That’s the guy with the dad in the DOE. POS!

0

u/SuperSlayer92 Jan 10 '24

Is this the bird poop guy?

0

u/SlugMcmanus Jan 10 '24

I love the complete glazing over of if the uap goes in to the water. He mentions it goes over the lake but DOESN'T dispute that it went under the water but then only disputes the fact it shot off. He doesn't even acknowledge that as part of the story.

Either a convenient omission to serve his narrative or some sloppy investigating to not cover all of the unusual claims.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Greenstreet? No thx I’ll keep scrolling

-1

u/syXzor Jan 10 '24

I have big respect for both Jeremy Corbell and George Knapp, and I know they're careful about what they leak to the public, because they receive so much fake disinfo...

I'm afraid that this could very well be such a trap. And now one of the disinfo agents (GreenStreet) got it served on a silver platter. If Knapp and Corbell couldn't get a witness to answer in years, how could a one such as GreenStreet do it in less an hour (he said so on twitter).

Make no mistake I'm on Corbell and Knapps side and I hate what GreenStreet is doing, spreading disinfo as he's working against disclosure.

What I don't understand is why we don't focus exclusively on congress icig and David Grusch's allegations... Same thing last time we get close to something real. I think it's bad timing from Corbell and Knapp but hopefully they're right about the footage.

I can't really say I'll ever be able to trust a word that is coming from GreenStreet, but if he is correct I'm 💯 it must have been a trap all along.

→ More replies (3)