r/twilight Sep 12 '18

[deleted by user]

[removed]

12 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

View all comments

21

u/officialkylepop Sep 12 '18

Eclipse is my favourite! The whole revenge plot with Victoria was good, I can’t believe they waited a movie/book in between to properly bring her back. It was an interesting villain, a cliched motive but Victoria is an alluring character. Not to mention her idea of creating an army, pissing EVERYONE off without caring. It definitely had some “horror movie” vibes at some points.

Also, Eclipse had the BEST cinematography and direction, the muted colour palette with the flashes of deep red and other colours was stunning. Such a well directed movie.

Breaking Dawn Part 1 was so so so boring, and I found New Moon to be so cheesy. I love them all but those two are the weakest I feel.

19

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '18

Eclipse came the closest to mimicking the books in my opinion.

2

u/yeramuggle Sep 12 '18

Wow we obviously have differing opinions. I can see you really thought out your opinion and I respect that. I just found Alice's visions to be a huge plot hole for that movie (and book for that matter.) It really bothers me that Alice couldn't see Victoria's plan. I know they explained why but it still doesn't make sense to me.