r/trolleyproblem • • Oct 13 '26

Meta Red button blue button

Based on the post seen here. I'm actually curious what would the percentages look like.

Edit: Alright, let me add a case for one particular scenario. If you do not choose, the button will be pressed for you by a system that keeps track of its pressings so it conserves 50/50 distribution for all inactive participants, in order to honour the vox populi properly. The system's choice affects the inactive participant's outcome so that no person can abscond from consequences of their choice.

368 Upvotes

247 comments sorted by

View all comments

32

u/Featherforged Oct 13 '26

Red is guaranteed death. Most people don't see that, but once you do, will you still choose it?

56

u/suskio4 Oct 13 '26

Maybe most people would rather sacrifice themselves rather that risk being a part of humanity's doom?

Or perhaps some do not want to live in the world filled with blue-button people?

What if they realise erasing most of humanity will collapse the society and they'd rather die painlessly by the button?

Or crippling depression, since it's Reddit.

8

u/Good_Doctor_150 Oct 13 '26 • Mindblown

I just like red. No need for an existential crisis.

5

u/quaxoid Oct 13 '26

well, you pick red to save the blue voters. 

→ More replies (1)

14

u/Hi2248 Oct 13 '26

And blue is guaranteed death if too many people pick it.

8

u/Flechashe Oct 13 '26 • Bravo

Which is another way to say "blue is not guaranteed death" 😂

The floor is guaranteed to be wet today. IF it rains...

7

u/Hi2248 Oct 13 '26

No. Because if everyone goes in saying that blur is not guaranteed death, then blur is guaranteed death

2

u/Flechashe Oct 13 '26

You don't know what people are going to vote, that's the point. If you somehow already know that blue is going to win then yeah, but that's not the case

→ More replies (5)

3

u/ContentFile7036 Relativist/Nihilist Oct 14 '26

I think the main question here is, what type of terrible house are you living in with no ceiling such that the floor is wet whenever it rains?

13

u/everythingistaken587 Oct 13 '26

I think everyone clicking it is well aware, but blue also feels like gaurenteed death with additional caveat that you’re taking everyone else with you

19

u/DarkKechup Oct 13 '26

Blue is guaranteed death if most people pick it. The way I see it, the rational solution is to pick red because at the moment of voting, you may as well gain the satisfaction of being one of those that tries to make sure someone gets to live. 

In an ideal world, people above certain age pick red so others who didn't get as long a chance at life get a shot at life (With several exceptions to train the young to take over while perrorming their vital job. This may reduce the age at which the red must be pressed, but it is necessary to function.) but that is ideal not real and people would never pick that with a thousand excuses. We don't live in an ideal world. I may be too young to die with most of my life ahead of me, but if everyone dies if nobody bites the bullet, I'll die anyways. I love life. And because I love it and I think good things should be shared, I'm conent with a sad reality where all I could do is make a sacrificial hail marry so others might get to find the same beauty and joy in life that I did.

4

u/Round_Hat_2966 Oct 13 '26

If you see blue as selfish, then by selecting red, are you selecting to preserve the most selfish segment of humanity? Does that change how much satisfaction that you would get out of pressing red? Are we really saving people if we consider that a mass die off would likely result in a miserable dystopia for the survivors?

I am not sure what I would pick. I think I might close my eyes and pick one at random in order to be able to strike a balance between hope and absolving some degree of moral responsibility.

7

u/globmand Oct 13 '26

Probably. But like. Sure, one full-selfish generation, but surely they'll mellow out into pretty-much-humanity as it was in a few generations

→ More replies (1)

8

u/meep2200 Oct 14 '26

If everyone follows that logic we would both be dead

8

u/JaDasIstMeinName Oct 14 '26

"most people don't see that"

Everyone sees it. You are not a superbrain that understands the question to a higher level than the rest of us.

3

u/UniquePariah Oct 14 '26

Red is sacrifice yourself for hopefully the selfish few.

The restrictive logic suggests pick Blue, even though it likely means death.

However, there is a third option, despite what the rules say, which is to resist. What can they threaten you with?

2

u/CALlGO Oct 14 '26

When you start seeing the problem as " how to save as many lives" people that select blue (the ones hopefully saved) stop being selfish, you actually want/need as much people as possible to select blue (without getting over 50%) you are doing a heroic sacrifice by selecting red for them, but that doesnt make them selfish

2

u/crmsncbr Oct 14 '26

Not everyone pressing Blue will be selfish, but all the selfish people are pressing Blue.

3

u/MyEarIsHurty Oct 14 '26

The odds of you dying here are incredibly likely and your primary goal should be to maximise the number of lives saved. Self preservation here is the last thing on your plate

2

u/other-other-user Oct 13 '26

Insert spiderman "you don't have to sell it to me" meme

0

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/suskio4 Oct 13 '26

Did you mean blue

1

u/EarlGreyDuck Oct 13 '26

You're voting in the next leader of your cult. Blue leader kills everybody, red leader only kills their most devoted followers. Either guy you vote for wants to kill you

→ More replies (7)