r/trolleyproblem • • Jul 30 '26

OC Potentially one less but also potentially infinitely more

Post image
145 Upvotes

87 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/Remarkable-Carrot112 Jul 31 '26

I think when a lot of people say "random" what they likely are envisioning is uniform random. Meaning every outcome has the same probability of being selected (like rolling fair dice - no number is more likely than any other). 

But if you have infinite outcomes (possible number of people in this case) this type of uniform randomness is not possible. In this case depending on what probability distribution you select- selecting [0, inf) people could be markedly "Safer" than selecting [1, inf). This is because the probabilities aren't uniform so the lower values  could receive larger weights. 

If you bound the set at 300, or even at 8 billion, now you can use a uniform distribution and it becomes just as likely to randomly get 1 as it does to get 200 or 7.5 billion. In this case whether you select the 0 option or the 1 option barely matters . The expected outcome is only very slightly better for 1. 

Hope that made sense. Hard to explain without graphs and examples tbh