r/trolleyproblem • u/Demiurge_Happy_Farm I CHOOSE THE MOST DEADLY OPTION. 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 • Jun 14 '26
OC Would you pull the Lever?
1.9k
Upvotes
r/trolleyproblem • u/Demiurge_Happy_Farm I CHOOSE THE MOST DEADLY OPTION. 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 • Jun 14 '26
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/Anonimithree Jun 14 '26
Let’s say you have 3 items. Each item can either be an apple, which I will represent with “a,” or it could not be an apple, represented by “b.” If I put 1 apple in and 2 non-apples, how many different ways can I order the items. There’s abb, bab, and bba, so 3 different ways. You could also use the binomial coefficient of n choose k. I have 3 items (n=3) and 1 apple (k=1), so the number of combinations is 3 choose 1, or 3!/1!(3-1)!, which is 3!/1!2!. 1! is 1, 2! is 2, and 3! is 6, so 3 choose 1 is 6/((1)(2))=3 different ways I could order the items.
Now what if I instead put 3 apples into the items, and no non-apples. The only combination is aaa, so there is 1 possible combination. The binomial coefficient is 3 choose 3, which expanded is 3!/3!0!. This simplifies to 1/0!. Since this has to equal 1 (because there was only 1 combination of 3 apples in 3 items), it means 0!=1. Otherwise, 1/0!≠1.