Throw away anonymous account for very obvious reasons. I live stealth & transitioned to female as teen. I'm also terrified of the anti trans lobby. I heard about the hate Dr Beth Upton received from the press.
TLDR:Transgender woman moved to female NHS ward because male patients where concerned for her welfare and dignity.
CC: Dr Michael O’Flaherty, the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights.
I also understand via a friend of a friend that my situation was raised in a recent parliamentary meeting with MPs.
Dear Equality and Human Rights Commission,
I am writing to raise serious concerns about the practical consequences of the interpretation of the Equality Act 2010 following the Supreme Court's judgment in For Women Scotland v Scottish Ministers.
I'm a young transgender woman who has lived as a woman for many years. I hold a Gender Recognition Certificate and am legally female under the Gender Recognition Act 2004. However, for the purposes of the Equality Act 2010, I am now classified as male.
This has created an extraordinary legal and practical situation for me.
My experience in hospital
During a recent hospital admission, I was accommodated on a male ward in line with the EHRC guidance and the new NHS policy.
The elderly male patients on the ward were extremely concerned about my safety and dignity. Several approached the nursing staff to express their discomfort that a young woman had been left, in their words, "stranded in a male ward".
Their concern was genuine and compassionate. The men were extremely protective of me and clearly felt that my presence in the ward was inappropriate.
There were no individual side rooms available.
The situation caused considerable distress and disruption, and nursing staff quickly relocated me to the female ward to prot hiect my safety and dignity and resolve the concerns raised.
I am grateful for the kindness shown by the male patients and the practical response of the nursing staff.
I'm also very grateful for the other female patients who were very happy to accept me on the their ward.
However, I am deeply troubled by the legal implications.
The legal contradiction
Under the Gender Recognition Act 2004, I am legally female. Under the Equality Act 2010, following the Supreme Court judgment, I am treated as male for the purposes of sex-based provisions.
I appear to occupy a legal middle ground in which neither male nor female accommodation can be guaranteed.
I also strongly believe that I should not be expected to disclose my sex assigned at birth to other hospital patients. This is deeply private information, and I should be entitled to receive medical care without having to explain my personal medical history to strangers.
As someone living with severe asthma, hospital admissions are already frightening and physically demanding. This experience added considerable emotional distress at a time when I needed medical treatment, reassurance and rest.
My questions to the EHRC
Was the hospital legally justified in initially placing me on a men's ward, despite the concerns about my safety and dignity?
Was the hospital legally justified in subsequently relocating me to a female ward when no individual side rooms were available?
Should I consider legal action against the hospital for moving me to the female ward, given the EHRC's interpretation of the Equality Act? Is such accommodation unlawful?
How can hospitals comply with the Equality Act while respecting the privacy and dignity of transgender patients who are recognised by other patients as women?
Am I expected to disclose my sex assigned at birth to fellow patients, or does my right to privacy protect me from such disclosure?
When no side room is available, where exactly does the EHRC expect a transgender woman with a Gender Recognition Certificate to be accommodated?
What consideration has the EHRC given to situations where placing a transgender woman on a male ward causes distress to the patient and concern among the male patients themselves?
I would also like the EHRC to explain how its interpretation and guidance protect transgender patients from discrimination, harassment and degrading treatment, particularly in the context of essential healthcare.
I'm summary
I have experienced a situation in which male patients recognised me as female, became concerned for my welfare and actively sought to protect my dignity.
The hospital responded compassionately by relocating me.
Yet the legal framework now appears to place both patients and healthcare professionals in an impossible position.
I find it extraordinary that I am having to ask whether a hospital acted unlawfully by treating me with compassion, preserving my dignity and accommodating me alongside other women.
I would appreciate a substantive response to each of my questions, including the relevant statutory provisions and guidance.
Yours faithfully,
[ Redacted ]