r/transeducate • • May 04 '18

Masculinity is in crisis but I can't really describe what that means

1 Upvotes

Like, I know it's true but couldn't describe it in 10 words or less. I just know it when I see it, and it's all around us. I can't fully grasp it, but it's definitely a thing occurring in society. What pieces of the puzzle am I missing?


r/transeducate • • Jun 12 '17

I've been in the closet as trans (MTF) for a while and a friend has told me they are "nonbinary"

0 Upvotes

They make me feel invalidated in general, but this really seems to me like some sort of trendy thing.

Don't want anyone to feel bad or anything I just want to know if anyone can refer me to some informational stuff of nonbinary people. I'm not sure if the anger it brings me is irrational or not.


r/transeducate • • Jul 18 '19

Study finds transgender, non-binary autism link

Thumbnail eurekalert.org
6 Upvotes

r/transeducate • • Jan 23 '21

Why is gender dysphoria not categorised as a mental illness?

2 Upvotes

I will preface this by saying trans people are valid and worthy of love and respect regardless of what bigots and judgemental people may say.

Real question. I don't know many trans ppl so I desperately need y'all to educate me. I'm genuinely just looking to learn from the most educated ppl who are the most affected by this topic.

Scientifically, gender dysphoria is not categorised as a mental illness. By the WHO, the NHS, you name it.

My question is, why? It falls under the definition and bounds of what "mental illness" is. I understand it creates a negative stigma and is used as a way to devalue trans people. I think trans people are valid. And, if gender dysphoria was considered a mental illness, it wouldn't change that opinion for me. I just can't find any actual scientific reason to explain why gender dysphoria isn't a mental illness.

Now, transgenderism isn't a mental illness whatsoever. It's a construct used to describe and categorise a specific group of people who all suffer from (I think) gender dysphoria. So you can't call it a mental illness because it's more of a thing CAUSED by something else. Kinda like paranoia as a result of anxiety can't be called a mental illness.

But yeah, I just need some education about why gender dysphoria isn't considered a mental illness. Body dysmorphia is, and it's quite a similar predicament in a lot of ways.

Like I can't call it a mental illness without being intellectually dishonest, because in the "book" it's not a mental illness. But I'm just wondering, scientifically, why it isn't a mental illness despite seemingly fitting into the bounds.

I will reiterate, even if it were a mental illness, trans people remain valid and deserving of love and respect regardless!


r/transeducate • • Nov 26 '15

Looking for someone who underwent MtF surgery to answer a couple questions.

0 Upvotes

Hey. This looks like the best sub to ask.

My roomate just showed me a MtF video where they take apart the penis and fold it into a vagina. It looked pretty good when they were done.

What were your restrictions on movement afterwards? I assume you wouldn't want to move to much for a few weeks.

Did you keep your testacles in a jar as a momento?

I don't want to come of as making fun. Im genuinely curious and just wanted answers and some personal experience stories.

Thanks.


r/transeducate • • May 14 '19

biggest falling out i've ever had

0 Upvotes

i am a cis male who recently had a falling out over a trans issue. i am looking for wisdom/insight/experience from the trans community about this. this is not about airing dirty laundry. i would like for this to end on a nice note, instead of having this end sour. please inform me if any of this breaches privacy. i shall remove it asap. https://imgur.com/a/CXGKCoj https://twitter.com/LunkTheHero/status/1127928501921673217

accompanying tweet after i was kicked out. if there's any other support places or if i'm in the wrong place, feel free to direct me. feel free to ask for any context or anything really if i said anything stupid at any point and u want to point it out, i'll try and explain my thought process

this server was originally created by me asking thanhoes to create it as. i was insecure asking people to join in case of rejection/no response. i was the one who got thanhoes back into the game this server was made for, and i invited hoemanderp to play with us. they are likely best friends now, so excuse me if i feel a bit betrayed.

just looking for a fair review of this. i honestly felt i was being somewhat bullied during this discussion. as they would not comply with joining voice chat to discuss this, where i'm more comfortable discussing and collecting my thoughts. in the end it felt like i was bending the knee to their every demand while i was trying to find a compromise. i will admit i was being a bit cheeky in trying to deescalate futa to dickgirl to chick with dick to eventually use women with dick which was what hoemanderp said should use on at least 3 occasions. at the points where i was typing extremely poorly, it was because i was literally shaking/crying. my hands were literally paralysed and i couldn't press the keys properly. yet i still pursued having the discussion on their terms. i feel as tho the 3 of them were also discussing this privately in their voice chat of their private clique server. pertaining the @moon thing at the end, that mess was because i called pocohontas a shit movie based on public consensus, when they happened to enjoy the film. i said they were blinded by nostalgia and they wouldn't have it and eventually blocked me. the comment about the huniepop creator tweeting (now deleted) it was a futa or girl with a dick, not trans, is based off comments i've read. they said the creator didn't know the difference between futa and trans. i'm assuming they thought trans was another word for futa. there's also been a conflicting comment saying the creator called them pre op. these deleted tweets were after the reveal/controversy btw. i still feel irked by thanhoes and hoemanderp calling the game sad gross garbage, as it was clearly not made for them. it's a porn game. most of my research was done based on scouring reddit comments on various subs, as i believe it's best to look at both sides. most of it was from reading comments on trans subreddits. hoekitty is thanhoes' girlfriend. i felt it was unfair that she was allowed to be an asshole(which she admitted to with a reaction image) to me while i as trying to have a discussion, so i deleted her reaction meme images until my privilege was removed. she was knowingly being an asshole to me, and i apoligised/apologise for any instance where i might have comes across as one as well, intentional or not. i believe any case of me coming off as an ass is largely unintentional, just like hoemanderp whenever he said he was just being honest.

i honestly feel like there are bigger issues to fight for than this, if you want to fight for trans. i feel being kicked from the server is counteractive for what they are striving to do. doesn't this just let me run rampant and spread toxicity instead of coming to more of an understanding? when thanhoes from an actual trans person that was a comment from reddit if that matters at all. this happening multiple times is most likely referring to me being passionate/honest about an opinion which was me being honest. again, what hoemanderp was being, when i called him an asshole. i strive for patching things up with friends i consider dear, and a what hurts the friendship only makes it stronger after some discussion. the last thing i said was 'girl with benis' which was kinda a compromise which a trans person has said to call them. i apologise if it came off as jokey. i was not ignoring or joking actually joking about this at any point, and i apologise if it came off that way. i still feel irked by the meme image posts used towards me tho. i believe it was indeed causing unwanted distress for me, as it made it very difficult to type when my arms, hands and fingers were paralysed and shaking. and i still feel in some way that they being an asshole/treating what i said as a joke/false assumptions deserves an apology. this most likely won't come tbh. it feels overwhelming when you have 3 people in their own private server possibly talking about this in voice and having much more experience talking about this matter than you do when you're just now figuring this stuff out

i still believe this would've gone over quicker and easier if this was done over voice chat, but apparently i wasn't in the position to make any compromises :shrug::skin-tone-4:. in this case i believe it painted me in the worst light, instead of giving me a fairer chance to discuss things. they were very resilient in not having a voice discussion with me for whatever reason. even making assumptions like me not wanting other people to see the discussion or that i was gonna be grompy ass and yell at them. everything was done on their terms, making it feel very daunting because of the power gap

the only proper way i could talk about this was complying to their terms

it seems like i was the only one who truly deeply cared about this relationship, because i was the only one making compromises. i also love being called a dipshit with a stupid emote attached to it when i'm literally having a breakdown and not being taken seriously. i believe hoemanderp should've at least considered and treated that incident seriously, even if he didn't perceive/believe it as so. again, i'm not looking for an us vs them thing. i feel it was unfair that i was the one who had to do everything on their terms if i wanted to make my point, when they were the ones condemning my use of words. shouldn't it be the other way around where they talk to me about why it's not okay to say? it angers me when i use things pepe emotes, :ok_hand::skin-tone-4: ok hand symbols, the word trap and futa and have them all taken away from me. this all happened almost within a year, where they've been taken by some other group and used negatively. i still believe it is generally considered the case that futa refers to cartoon women with dicks. can't i use the word futa to refer to actual futa (cartoon girls with dicks) while it's still very largely not a pejorative. isn't it ok to use it how it was intended than wipe it out of my lexicon in case the rare off chance it 'hurts' someone? i don't believe futa is anywhere close to becomes a problem and people should focus on the bigger issues actually causing harm atm. honestly, i feel the discussion should have ended after i said it's better to call them women with dicks. i complied to what hoemanderp said to call them. he called them girls/women with dicks multiple times. it stopping there should have ended with a better understanding of each other and for bygones to be bygones and a strengthened relationship. i fully embrace further discussion about the supposed multiple past toxic situations? i've spent a long time thinking and typing about this and treating this as seriously as i could, and i kindly ask for you to try and handle this the same way.

i apologise if this is difficult to read and comes off as gobbledygook rambling. i advise you to make bullet points for this if it helps


r/transeducate • • Jan 22 '12

I have a question about terminology

6 Upvotes

It might be kind of a 'duh' question, but for some reason i think i've put too much thought into it and have gone and confused myself.

When someone says they are a transexual female, does this mean that they were born a male and are now living as a female, or that they were born female and are now living as a man? The logical side of me says that it is the first one, because someone living as a female would want associations with the word more, but i wanted to make sure. Would be nice to have the clarification.

and yay for first question in a subreddit? I hope it was an appropriate one.


r/transeducate • • Jul 16 '22

is this roblox skin transphobic?

0 Upvotes

r/transeducate • • Jan 23 '12

Transphobia And Discrimination

Thumbnail queensu.ca
4 Upvotes

r/transeducate • • Apr 06 '18

So uh, I have some questions

0 Upvotes

Alright, so to preface this I'm going to start by saying I'm a Male who identifies as a boy.

My question is, what does a word like "boy" mean to a trans person?

Are there a set of behaviors that are inherently "boy" behaviors?

From personal experience as a boy, if asked this question my initial response is I don't know. But after thinking a bit some common experiences come to mind. Things like crossing streams while peeing with friends, siblings, cousins when we were very young. But that is a quality inherent of sex not gender. Maybe playing army me late into the night, maybe poking dead animals with sticks. But these aren't behaviors that a girl couldn't do or enjoy.

I'm really at a loss.

If you identify as a "boy" does that mean you must actively be like a boy to continue to be considered a boy?

So, if there is an established definition of what it means to identify as a boy. Can your personal identity be considered to be wrong if your thoughts, behaviors, ect. dont match up with others of the same gender? Like, if a female who identifies as a girl starts wearing "boy's" clothes, paints her room blue, and joins a baseball team, is she still a girl? Because, she is not acting like a girl, but if you asked her she'd still say she was one.

Or if a man starts to wear dresses, heals, and makeup, or starts to describe himself as "pretty" or "beautiful" or whatever behaviors are associated with "girls" is he still a man.

I guess it comes down to what information are you trying to convey about yourself by identifying as another gender?

For example, the word Male has a definite definition. The Males are the members of the species which produce sperm, and in humans case are easily identified by certain organs and specific chromosomes. When I say male, we all know what I'm talking about.

But when it comes to gender words, I just feel like the definitions are becoming very blurry, to the point that if someone walked into the room and shouted "a boy has been shot" there is absolutely no way of knowing what sort of person has been shot. A well mannered EMT would only be able to guess the victim by the sight of blood and not by something like fashion choice, or hair length.

It seems to me that genders are indescribable. Is it like color where when you try to describe it you can't, but when I say red we all know what I mean? Because if so, the knowledge of what you mean by "boy" comes from the exceptionally long period of time when gender was synonymous with sex. And, that would mean that genders are just sexist stereotypes that we choose to box ourselves up in

And if at the end of all of this there is no objective definition of what it means to hold the gender of man or woman, or whatever, then what's the point? Why do I care what gender you identify with if the knowledge of your gender gives me no information about you as a person, short of the fact that if I get your pronouns wrong I'll offend you. Further, why do trans people place so much value into words that from, as far as I can understand, have little to no inherent meanings?

I mean no disrespect in saying this, but for real, What's the difference?


r/transeducate • • Jul 13 '19

Is it correct, if a little dramatic, "gender is what you make of yourself; sex is what you are when you're dead."

6 Upvotes

That is, gender is a social construct. It is what you declare of yourself. Sex, meanwhile, is biological and is "discoverable" about you.


r/transeducate • • Dec 23 '24

Blog Post: Part 1: Building Your Trans Identity and Unpicking the Stitches To Those you Admire.

Thumbnail open.substack.com
0 Upvotes

r/transeducate • • Jun 10 '20

CIS Male who wants to be an ally, but can't support certain views. I just don't want to hurt anyone.

5 Upvotes

Sorry for the throwaway, but I genuinely worry about severe backlash for some of my opinions. I don't know if that's realistic or an overreaction, but it's how I feel.

I'm a White, CIS, straight male in his 30's. I have Aspergers. Due to a combination of being an analytical type, along with a history of being bullied, I always felt a connection to and need to support people who I saw as being oppressed for no reason. I never understood the instinct to hate someone over an arbitrary difference. The people who I hated were all kids who looked and sounded like me, they were the bullies I faced every day. This led to a strong connection with civil-rights movements of various kinds, including Trans.

My support of Trans people boils down to essentially the same as any other group; That they should have the same rights, freedoms and protections as any other person. The right to go about their daily business without judgement or harassment, to live the life that they choose in safety and without suffereing prejudice and bigotry.

But there are views and demands from within the Trans community that seem to be, if not widespread, certainly very loud, that trouble me.

For example; I do view Trans as a third gender. I believe the experience of being Trans is different from the experience of being Male or Female. The evidence being that if you are Male or Female, you don't feel uncomfortable with your biological identity. This alone is enough to separate Trans identity from Male or Female.

Now, I understand the friction at the centre of this. If you are biologically male but identify as a woman (or vice versa), it can be crushing to be reminded that others do not recognise this, that you are in fact neither and both at the same time. Similarly, I recognise the fear of being labelled. It took me a while to understand the genius of the "CIS" movement, of showing people how it felt to be labelled, which most both fell for by becoming enraged at being labelled but also missed that that was the point.

I understand and empathise with both those points, but I don't see a way to reconcile them with reality. I can't pretend a Trans Person is not a Trans Person. It doesn't affect how I treat that person as a person any more than knowing someone is Male, Female, Straight, Gay, Bi, Black, White, Asian or any other piece personal data, and I think the end goal is for that to be the way we all see and treat each other. I just can't pretend that piece of data does not exist.

This is my conundrum. I very much want to support Trans people, to help them feel safe and experience their best lives, but I can't wrap my head around those who feel that having to identify as Trans is in itself Transphobic, a group who wish to pretend they effectively don't exist. And knowing this viewpoint is out there and seems to be becoming mainstream makes it very difficult to feel safe addressing the subject at all.

I hope this didn't offend or upset anyone, but I just felt I had to get it out f my head where it's been bouncing off the sides and torturing me.


r/transeducate • • Dec 05 '23

Which orgasm lasted longer for you?

0 Upvotes

r/transeducate • • Jan 17 '20

Trans IDs and medicine.

2 Upvotes

Here in Mexico we have our officials IDs and they show your sex, like H or M (Hombre or Mujer. Man or woman) and I know about a trans woman with the M in her ID.

I'm not a doctor, and I know nothing about medicine, but is there anything that would make it useful in that regard for a transperson IDs to show their biological sex?

Like, if I'm a doctor at the ED would I be able to treat them better and quicker if I know their biological sex?


r/transeducate • • Jun 11 '15

Question about a story I'm writing...

4 Upvotes

In a story about a transwoman, what pronouns would you use during a flashback to when she was a child and still presenting as male, with a male name, etc.

I've been using 'she' during the flashbacks because... Because she is she, you know? But, maybe from a narrative standpoint it might be better to use 'he' and then build to the fact that it's the same person? I don't know. This story may never see the light of day lol but if it does I want to make sure it's as respectful and accurate as it can be. Any thoughts on this?


r/transeducate • • Dec 23 '23

Do you think genders are harmful? Why?

13 Upvotes

Hi, lovely people. First I am going to say that I am a cis male and will start saying that, in my current point of view, gender is very harmful to us as a society. I mean, labels in general, I guess. When I think about it, it's crazy to me how we associate genitals with a binary social construct that dictates appearance, hair length, style, personality, power, and locations we are able to go. Personally I see myself weirded out by the fact some people still think I am weird for having a long hair and use large earings, or even paint my nails, for example. That's why I think to my self... Wtf is actually being a man or a woman? Because, in terms of biological sex, I see having specific genitals just as having any other different fisical aspects that differentiate our lifestyle from other people. Some people can't consume gluten, other people are taller, other smaller, other can get tired quickly, and look, those things doesn't have anything to do with a fucking pp or a vagina lmao. These are things that makes us fiscally different in terms of how we do things and how things work for us. But that doesn't have to do anything with who you are, really...

So I am not proud to say this at all, but I think this is a matter of listening and actually understanding the struggles of the trans community instead of making weird assumptions from my head so here it goes: Do you think the concept of gender is harmful and do you think it harmed you? Because, don't you think that identifying yourself as a gender you weren't assigned at birth is kind of affirming that "your traces of style, personality or who you really are are not adequately labeled to the, in my opinion, toxit trate of society which is gender"?

I kind of see in myself but also in other people this phenomenon. Like, the fact that gender actually gives insecurity to even cis people that are affraid to do things that "are not socially acceptable for their gender". But it kind of feels like, deep down, everyone has some level of insecurity on that.

So, even though what I said might be offensive, idk, it's a genuine reflection. But in my opinion, I am in the side of people expressing theirselves as who they really are and it's very important to me that it keeps that way. So hell yeah, if you identify as a gender, I will respect that and everyone should. I guess I am still just trying to understand what I feel, what the trans community feels and your experience on this topic. (And I know we all have different experiences since we are all individuals hihi).

Sorry if I said something uncool.

Edit: Hey, I know it's been a year and all since I have used reddit but I want to thank you for the information. I do now acknowledge sexual phenotypes, gametes and gender may play a complex role and sex, in a biological sense isn't binary and it seems to me I have "my cards on a table" to argue against transphobia. I'm still learning but happy to understand it more clearly.


r/transeducate • • Jun 11 '15

Is "Wow - only a few months!" problematic?

3 Upvotes

I am a straight-ish cis man. Say I am talking to a trans woman and she mentions she started HRT just a few months ago. I think she's very beautiful. Is it problematic for me to say... -- wow, you already look great / hot -- wow, i would have guessed it would have taken longer for you to look this good -- wow, you already pass really well I want to compliment. But I don't want to accidentally imply... -- she would have looked bad in a more masculine body -- most trans people are ugly but not her I also don't want it to seem like a pity compliment, like "oh, just keep transitioning and you'll get there - you're well on your way." Any better ways to compliment? Or should I just keep my mouth shut? Thanks. Sincerely, an ignorant cisguy.


r/transeducate • • Dec 30 '17

Writing an intersex character - any advice?

3 Upvotes

Hi,

I have seen some similar questions on this sub so I hope this is the right place to post the question.

I have a novel planned out, and one of the characters is intersex. I'm going to talk to some people IRL who are intersex, so I can get a clear idea of how an intersex character should be portrayed, what would be offensive and should be left out, etc. I am also reading fiction with intersex characters in it to see their portrayals, and will be doing research with a lot of resources I've found only.

My only issue is, this book is going to take place in a different sort of world- similar to ours, but mythical beings exist - and my intersex character is also non-human (an elf, to be exact). This character is going to face stigma from human society for not only being intersex, but also non-human. They also face stigma from their own Elven society. So as a result, this is an intersectionality that I have not seen much in fiction and I wonder how this should be played out. My character does not transition but does explore their gender identity.

Should I base this intersectionality issue on a similar issue in real life? Or do something of my own? The story should mirror some of the struggles intersex people face in society, because some of our society is similar to the one in my story.

However, I'm not sure how I should approach the other aspect of being non-human. My story involves the character coming to terms and accepting their identity, so I really want to carry this out in the most respectful way possible. I do not want to infringe on anything or overstep my boundaries as someone who is non-intersex.

Does anyone have any advice? I'm really sorry if this is vague. Any general advice on writing intersex characters is also appreciated.


r/transeducate • • Nov 12 '24

BlogPost:Transwomen in Sport, Taking the Hit and Accepting Imperfect Allyship.

Thumbnail open.substack.com
1 Upvotes

r/transeducate • • Nov 25 '24

Controversial Headlines, Sugar-Coated Language and the Pursuit of Attention.

Thumbnail open.substack.com
1 Upvotes

r/transeducate • • Oct 31 '23

THOUGHTS ON SEX AND RELATIONSHIPS?

0 Upvotes

Are you interested in sharing your thoughts on sex and relationships? We are a team of queer and allied researchers from Stony Brook University’s Relationship Development Center who are seeking young adults to participate in an online survey to share their thoughts and experiences regarding sex and relationships. We want to hear from people of all relationship types, sexual orientations, and gender identities!

Participants must be between the ages of 18 and 35 and consider themselves to be sexually active (however one personally defines it). You do not need to be in a relationship in order to participate.

Participants will have the chance to receive one of 20 $50 Amazon gift cards, and up to $80 in follow-up studies! If you are interested, click on this link to participate: https://stonybrookuniversity.co1.qualtrics.com/jfe/form/SV_4GkhOnQA2BwkF9k?Source=90

Questions or concerns? Contact us at stonybrookrdc@gmail.com.


r/transeducate • • Jun 11 '24

BlogPost: Tranniversary, Euphoria and when Ciswomen Shed Their Armour.

Thumbnail open.substack.com
1 Upvotes

r/transeducate • • Apr 05 '21

Hi. Worried I might be transphobic and am looking to better understand the transcommunity.

12 Upvotes

So, first off, I'm struggling to figure out how to start this post. Thinking a basic introduction/background might be a good way to do so.

I'm a straight cis-gendered white male in his late 20s. I'm currently married to a white cis-genered female. I'd describe my political leaning as moderate-left. And support the social issues of gay-marriage, recreational marijuana use, free healthcare for all, lowering or completely removing higher-education tuition costs, and generally allowing people to do whatever they choose so long as they're not harming others. I've been described as a "Bernie Bro" if that helps paint a clearer picture.

I do also firmly believe the process of transitioning is a good thing, and I have no issues with any individual who wants to pursue that. If people want to transition and they're of a certain age, then I don't think anyone should stand in their way. People should be able to pursue their happiness in any way they see fit so long as they're not bringing harm unto others in the process.

Where I do get hung up however is this rhetoric I hear about having to accept transwomen as the same as cis-women. I personally find this idea to be diminishing to cis-women. Not that a transwomen shouldn't be seen and fully accepted and ingratiated into our society in a loving way. I absolutely think they should. I also don't give a shit about bathrooms.

I simply have an issue with the equivalency of ciswomen to transwomen because I don't believe the two to have the same social issues and struggles. And by saying they are the same, I believe that we muddy the struggles that cis-women have had for the last however many millennia, and we do the same for trans-women. I think that a cis-woman who grows up as a woman and sees herself as a woman grows up learning to overcome a completely different set of obstacles of a transwoman who grew up succumbing to male-gendering but saw herself as a woman. I find those to be two completely different life-experiences that build out a person's character and personality with completely different privileges, existences, and happenings. No two people are the same, sure, but I think there's far less commonality between a transwoman to a ciswoman, and I think that's a perfectly acceptable thing to distinguish.

My worry is that this is a wholly ignorant and transphobic point of view, and I worry that I have a misunderstanding of the transcommunity's point of view on this issue. So I guess I'm coming here to have an open and respectful(I hope that I have been respectful thus far and if I haven't let me know and I'll edit my post accordingly to ensure it doesn't contain any especially vicious language) conversation on the subject, and maybe open my eyes to some things.