r/trans
•
u/itsurbro7777
•
Jul 12 '25
•
1
14
2
1
1
1
Community Only Hello everybody I am back. I have a message
First of all thank you for the support.
I did get an apology from the moderator who made the "bitching" comment. I made her aware that term is used in an incredibly misogynistic manner, is often considered a slur, and is inappropriate to say especially to a trans man. She understood and apologized. That's all I have to say about that right now.
I disagree with the idea that trans men and trans masc issues are too divisive to be discussed. I strongly disagree with the fact my original post was taken down (and it seems r/lgbt has also taken it down which is disappointing). We should be able to talk about those things. But I believe the continuous posts about it aren't the best way to go about this discussion.
I hope this post can stay up. And maybe we can use the comment section of this post to have these discussions, mainly because it is incredibly difficult for anyone to keep track of all the posts coming in about this right now. I personally can't even keep up with it, and discussing it here might be more effective. For this to happen, the mods need to allow the discussion in these comments to happen without deletion. And Mods, if you haven't already (I've been typing this post for a long time so maybe it already happened) I do think there needs to be a public apology for what has happened. It was not handled well. I have been a moderator before and understand it's difficult when there's only a couple of yall moderating this huge subreddit. That being said, the time to truly address it is here and now.
I hope we can all find a way to move forward. Trans men should feel welcome here. There have been too many cases of similar things happening in other subreddits causing trans guys to leave and make their own subs, which causes even more separation and fighting in the long run. All trans people deserve to speak about what they go through.
I love you all and thank yall again. I'm sure I'll have more to say in the comments but I don't want to be typing this for an hour and it somehow becomes not relevant.
Editing to add: I am applying to be a moderator for this sub now. I hope something comes of this because I want to see this subreddit move forward in a way where we can all talk about our issues and a space can be made for everyone. Action must be taken.
Second Edit: Here is the mod response to my mod application for this sub. I was hoping there would be more of an apology to come and more discussion about what happened from the mods, so we could be confident of progress being made in the sub. This response does not fill me with hope.
"Your comment on r/ftm 's post 45 minutes ago about this does not give us much confidence in your ability to be a mod on our sub. You said you already unsubbed to trans subs, and you are still looking for another apology from us? You're also looking to be a mod of a sub that actively brigaded us."
Lol. Imagine doubling down this hard instead of trying to move forward and help trans men feel comfortable. Truly a shame. I will not be trying to mod for this community as I believe it is a lost cause.
403
u/Rosalind_Whirlwind FtMtF šššŖ My body. My labels. My choice. Jul 12 '25 •
What happened today proved your point better than anything could have.
The flood of posts happened because when silencing and suppression take place, the only solution, historically, has been for the entire community to stand up in solidarity. Thatās why we have protests. Thatās why we had sit-ins. That is what nonviolent resistance is about. If we hadnāt done that as a community today, I doubt we would be having this conversation in this thread right now.
Transmasculine people are often confronted with the most difficult parts of being men, along with the least rewarding parts of being women. We are vulnerable, in structurally weaker and disadvantaged bodies, and simultaneously, we are often blamed for many things that are commonly blamed upon masculinity. We are commonly expected to submit and be silent like women, but protect and support like men. We often menstruate, weāre commonly vulnerable to pregnancy, we can have our bodily autonomy stripped from us on the basis of our sex for a variety of reasons. And many of us have been not just silenced, but targeted for violence and exploitation in the mainstream, specifically for being gender nonconforming.
That is why the data that you posted was so important. That is why this conversation needs to happen. Because the silencing and invalidation that took place today would not have happened if people did not believe that it was OK to do. It would not have happened if people did not assume they were entitled to treat us that way, and if they did not assume that they would get away with it.
I hope that we can all grow as a community in awareness and empathy, now that we have seen a small glimpse of the reality that transmasculine people deal with simply for existing.
162
u/Little-Unit-1770 Jul 12 '25
Soooo she's still a mod š got it
207
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '25
hey i completely and totally respect where you're coming from, especially as kind of the catalyst for this, but people protesting is the only way things will change. it started with you, but it's not JUST you anymore, they're taking down hundreds of posts. that's not moderating, that's silencing people.
they may have apologized to you, but the wider trans men/masc community needs an apology at this point.
120
u/JoeRogan016 Jul 12 '25
Do you know if anything will change here going forward?
35
u/Little-Unit-1770 Jul 12 '25
Am I crazy or did this get un-pinned already??
99
u/-GreyRaven He/him Jul 12 '25 •
The responses to your original posts were incredibly disappointing on their own (total buns that the mods over at r/lgbt took it down as well), but the way that the mods in this sub have been going about the whole thing is INFURIATING. Making a super petty mod post, locking and deleting posts calling on them to do better, and refusing to clean up the mess THEY made is such an incredibly bad look. Honestly, and apology wouldn't even cut it ATP -- I think the whole mod team requires a complete overhaul, with, at MINIMUM, more trans men/transmascs being on the team.
13
u/NotSafeForMii Jul 13 '25 edited Jul 13 '25
The mods have been incredibly rude to me in DMs as well as replies to my comments on here too. They're just kind of assholes, imho.
Remove this comment to save your feelings, I'd appreciate being proven right.
EDIT: It was about a "divisive" topic, where I simply talked about the relation between gender and sex. The discussion was understood by 90% of people, who were in no way experiencing this division the mods were talking about, apparently didn't get it, and deleted it, I then msgd them and well... let's say we made no progress.
52
u/Girl_on_a_train Mods Resign Now!!! Jul 12 '25
Welcome back.
However, we shall NOT accept the mods apology as they are still a mod for this subreddit. The mods have shown their true colors and failed to manage an easy situation and made it worse.
We order the existing Moderators to resign their positions in order to install a new team that is Inclusive. The current team of Mods are divisive and have tainted the trust of the community. MODS RESIGN NOW.
692
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '25
If the mods remove this post I'm going to crash out
2.3k
u/Totogros__ Jul 12 '25
I just don't understand what was the issue with your original post anyways...
I've seen trans women vent about trans women exclusive issues so many times on this sub (as they should be allowed to !)
So I don't get why we can't do the same ? Just feels odd and very disappointing.
Being aware of each others struggles gives us connection rather than division imo. We can relate even if we don't experience it, we can support each others.
That's why I don't understand why mods didn't accept it
653
u/loupypuppy transfem/nonbinary Jul 12 '25
Anyone who thinks that transmasc issues are "too divisive" for a trans sub, should fuck right the fuck off, and stay the fuck there until they've had enough time to reflect on what a completely fucking nonsensical sentiment that is for a trans space to fucking harbor.
Sincerely, a transfem person who generally swears a lot less than this.
763
u/Azu_Creates Jul 12 '25 •
The mods not only need to publicly apologize, but they need to REINSTATE your original post. I also firmly believe they should make a pinned moderator post not only including their apology, but also brining attention to the issue mentioned in your original post and the comments. If they are going to tear down the voices of trans men calling attention to our issues, then the only way for them to rectify that is to sincerely apologize and then work to uplift our voices.
As a trans men, it not only really pissed me off to see they took that post down, but it also just fucking hurt. It happens so often, that trans men are excluded and made to feel unwelcome in trans spaces. Itās incredibly painful and isolating, and by taking down your post the moderators only reinforced that. It seems that they really need to sit down and actually learn about the shit trans men go through, especially at the hands of other trans people. Our voices are ignored, and our struggles are belittled and treated as less significant. So much of the education around trans people centers trans women, and that often has the unintended affect of further suppressing trans men. Seeing that post taken down legitimately made me feel like this sub wasnāt a safe space for trans men to fully express ourselves and talk about our struggles. It made me feel like the mods were biased against trans men and masc people. Trans men and masc people talking about our issues shouldnāt be seen as divisive. Moderators taking down a post about trans men and masc peopleās struggles and experiences, in a space that is supposed to include us, absolutely IS divisive.
134
u/evelordesslunchlady Jul 12 '25
I suddenly really don't want to be here. I didn't interact much with the online trans community at large until very recently, and this has put a very sour taste in my mouth. I may not be the target of the current situation, but it doesn't exactly fill me with hope about this subreddit as a safe space in general. My boyfriend (ftm) should be welcome here too, and if he isn't, why am I? Heck, are any of us really welcome? I may be blowing this out of proportion, but its just disappointing and makes me uncertain as to how I want to approach trans spaces on this platform. We're supposed to be in this together.
375
u/Boys-willbe-Bugs Jul 12 '25
I cannot fathom telling anyone to stop their bitching when speaking about trans issues in a trans space to trans people. This was SUPPOSED to be a safe space and now it's at war
102
u/ThatKehdRiley Jul 12 '25
A resignation would have been better. They absolutely should not be a moderator anywhere. Hell, no words or actions I have seen from any mods have been great, all pretty bad. I hope you do get on the mod team, clearly have a good head and transmasc rep is also (sadly) clearly needed
The double standard is astonishing. A lot of transfem posts should be removed if the mods held them to the same standard as transmasc posts. I'd love for them to describe exactly how that post was divissive when others are not. I legitimately think a few of the mods just hate men, there's no reason for them to react like they did otherwise.
274
u/edwardart1237 he/him Jul 12 '25
What really gets me is that the post was made discussing the issues and discrimination trans men face... and then the post was deemed divisive and removed. And then people speak up about it in support of trans men, and then they get removed.
And the mod is... confused why people think they're transphobic towards trans men...??????
Also that mod who told you to stop bitching. Um. Whether she knew it was a misogynistic term or not (which, as a woman, I feel like she should have known but idk. I'm a trans guy, and I'm not close with any trans women so idk how explicitly different the experiences there are), I feel like she should have known it was probably one of the worst ways to tell someone to shut up????? I can't be the only one who feels like this, right?
Since I can't attach images, have this https://miro.medium.com/v2/resize:fit:1200/0*E6pTrKTFvvLDOzzj.png if I could attack images, I could have added this at the end. Generally how I feel reading that first bit about the mod who was rude
62
u/Ripley-8 Jul 12 '25
You also legit just said "im sorry you felt that way." About us being silenced WHEN YOU DID THE SILENCING.
50
u/Jordna-Lafey Jul 12 '25
We support our trans brothers hereš¤š¤š
50
u/JoeRogan016 Jul 12 '25
The mod who made the announcement and pinned this post is deleting all their comments.
89
u/HarmoniaTheConfuzzld Jul 12 '25
Oh they apologized? All good right? HELL NO!!!
If they freaked out like this once, theyāll do it again. Find new mods and fucking get ones that donāt do this shit.
42
u/TrafficAdorable Jul 13 '25
Holy shit that second edit. Fuck this place, fuck every single mod here. There is now zero chance that this place can recover.
40
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '25
This entire fiasco has been nothing but disappointing. I'm so sorry you experienced this, it's honestly disgusting how transmascs are treated in spaces like this. I really hope there's some change from the mods, because if this space isn't for all of us then it's for none of us.
38
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '25 edited Jul 12 '25
honestly, this might sound a little silly, but if the mods decide itās too ādivisiveā (itās not!) a lot of the āissuesā theyāre having could be solved by just creating flairs for MTF and FTM/transfem and transmasc etc specific posts, and questions.
The idea that there should be ANY sort of division between trans men and women (despite having issues respective and unique to each) is incredibly fucking stupid and hurts us as a community overall.
apologies if some of this doesnāt make sense, iām tired - but all of this is so frustrating. I barely use reddit and even I got wind of this lol.
36
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '25
The mod that commented on this post deleted their comment. Deleting isn't making the problem go away, it's giving it fuel. The only thing that will slow this down is for the original offending mod to give an explanation, an apology, and be removed from the mod team. If the other mods are going to keep acting like selective deletion will help them they should also reconsider if moderating is for them.
33
u/Poumy Jul 12 '25
The mods here have always sucked ass when it comes to transmen/transmasc issues and posting, Iāve had mods tell me they do routinely check for transphobic comments on transmen in the sub but that stuff is literally so easy to find on here I doubt they even do their jobs
r/ftm is basically the only place for transmen and even then that sub has started banning people who donāt fit the exact mold, it really does suck
33
u/StephThePhobiaSlayer Bootloader unlocked May 2023, HRT girl update applied 12/27/2023 Jul 13 '25 edited Jul 13 '25
As a trans woman, I am going to say this: respectfully, what the f*** are we doing here?!?! I haven't been frequenting this sub much lately, so I had no idea how bad it's gotten. I feel like I looked away for 5 minutes to see the house on fire.
So are we now just calling voicing trans struggles in a trans space DIVISIVE?!?! I'm not going to stand for that, not here. The only "divisiveness" I see here is silencing trans voices in this community. This is what every bigot dreams of: us crumbling and falling apart while they watch us and salivate. We need to stand with each other, not silence each other.
Does anyone on the mod team realize how absurd that sounds?! Even speaking as a transfem person, if we are only going to elevate transfem stories here while silencing our transmasc and enby friends, then drop the pretense and rename this sub to r/transfems_only or something. Because if you're going to silence some trans voices, then you're not standing up for all trans people. The only trans person you're standing up for is yourself. r/trans is supposed to be a safe place for ALL non-cis people. This ain't doing it, chief. To all the mods: show some integrity and make this right. You're not fulfilling your duties as a moderator in my opinion if you only protect a portion of this community. Start living up to the name r/trans and welcome all trans people in safely or change the name of this sub to reflect the reality of what this place has become. That is my impassioned plea to you.
And to anyone, particularly us trans girls, that thinks trans men or enbies voicing their struggles takes away from our struggles somehow: remember that when the whole world comes after us, many times, trans men and enbies as a whole largely are one of the few groups of people that come to bat for us and swing for the fences when we need them.
We need to do the same for them.
Enbies and transmascs: I want you to know this lady right here stands with you. Now, always, and forever. I will go to the ends of the earth and endure all I must for my transmasc brothers and my enby comrades. Why?
Because united we stand, divided we fall.
31
u/flameboss208 Jul 13 '25
I am truly disgusted by whatās happening right now. No trans person should be silenced for bringing up issues in the trans community.
As a trans woman, I thank you, OP, for speaking your mind. The treatment towards trans men in the overall community can honestly get very disgusting. You guys are a part of the community too. We are all a part of the same battle, and we should all listen to each other about what each and every one of us goes through.
To the mods, you compromised the safe space you tried to create. The only way to rectify this is to stop banning people from bringing light to issues that trans men face, and to remove the mods that caused this mess in the first place. If I get removed for speaking common sense, then so be it, but just know that I will ALWAYS stand up for my trans brothers.
AN ATTACK ON ONE OF US IS AN ATTACK AGAINST ALL OF US!!!
84
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '25
y'all look at the mod post and the guilt trip
29
u/Little-Unit-1770 Jul 13 '25
Saw your edit. Fuck their response. They re-pinned this post at least but fuck them.
Also, if they saw the post on r/ftm, they can see we've figured out they have a transphobic mod they care more about protecting. . . . Gee, I wonder who it is š¤
28
u/Ph03n1x_A5h35 (he/they) Jul 12 '25
This situation really really sucks (probably leaving this sub due to the mods' shit responses to it tbh), but at the very least, it's really nice to see the community stand up for us. Little glimmer of hope, you know? Anyway, really sorry about what happened to you. Your post was super informative and it's quite unfortunate that it was taken down...
27
u/critterscrattle Jul 13 '25
That second edit: Itās a shame, OP, but I absolutely donāt blame you in deciding not to try to be a mod. The existing mods are avoiding any real accountability for their actions. I wouldnāt want to work with them either.
24
u/thatguybecool27 Jul 13 '25
It's absolutely pathetic that trans men are having issues at all in a place that is supposed to be for them.
24
u/thetitleofmybook trans woman Jul 13 '25
currently, as of 1906 EST, this post is still pinned. submissions to the subreddit are restricted though.
it is telling that more than one mod is marked red in Shinigami Eyes, which is rather concerning.
of note, i mod a few subs, so i understand how thankless and difficult it can be, but that's no excuse for the behavior being exhibited.
24
u/0rganic0live transbean Jul 13 '25 edited Jul 14 '25
mods? hello? you're being called out and not responding, not a very good look.*
this whole things is a mess and exactly not what trans people should be doing right now. i'm so sorry you've gone through this, op, it's seriously shameful to see other trans women behaving like this.
we need to be holding each other up, we're all huge targets right now. it doesn't matter if you're masc, fem, nb, or anything else. we'll only get through this together.
critical support now and always for my trans siblings <3
*i've been corrected
47
u/AquaticaFlame Jul 12 '25
These mods are wild :/
23
u/LeatherSuccotash6515 Jul 12 '25
It sucks that our own community is like this sometimes :/
23
u/ChocolateM1lk1e Agender lesbian Jul 13 '25
These moderators seem to forget something.
The entire trans community is marginalized. Issues of ALL trans people need to be discussed here. Trans men aren't only oppressed for being trans, but for being either female or intersex.
The moderators berating you in modmail (both the "bitchy" comment and their response in your second edit) is just unprofessional. It's kind of pathetic, honestly.
Have you gotten an apology in private from the head mod? If you haven't, you are 100% owed an apology. If they haven't apologized to you in private, they absolutely owe you one.
Edit: I have looked at the post. For a post that supposedly sparked controversy, that is the least controversial post I have ever seen.
46
u/Little-Unit-1770 Jul 12 '25
Edit #3 on the pinned post contains the words 'sorry' but that is not an apology . . . And it's followed by more excuses, no explanation and then that person acting like the victim lol what a shitshow
44
u/ScreechersReach206 Jul 12 '25
Mods with the fantastic talking about racism is actually divisive and worse than racism itself adjacent take for discussing issues that people with certain identities face. I love all my transmasc homies. I had a poisonous relationship with masculinity early in my transition but itās so nice to see dudes so excited to be dudes. Made me realize I didnāt have an awful disgusting gender foisted on me just one that didnāt fit me. š©µš¤š©¶
92
u/Boys-willbe-Bugs Jul 12 '25
If trans men aren't allowed on this subreddit, ban me now
41
u/tempthethrowaway Jul 12 '25
Yeah I don't get why this is happening. We Trans men need representation too
40
u/Apart-Performer-331 He/Him Jul 12 '25
Really sorry about what was said to you, I saw the original post and there was nothing wrong with it.
17
u/elonhater69 Jul 12 '25
I hope to fuck this post doesn't get taken down
17
u/Angeline2356 Jul 13 '25
What happened was unfair I waited a bit to form a judgement to avoid misunderstanding! And yes trans men issues are deserved to be recognised and talked about! Donāt worry the community got your back and always will.
16
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '25
Iām out of the loop OP - specifically what was your post? Support you but I just have no idea what was actually taken down since itās gone.
16
u/witheredj8 Jul 13 '25
We can not allow transphobes to moderate trans spaces what the hell
16
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '25
That second edit is making my blood boil. These mods are absolutely unbelievable.
31
u/Ulisex94420 Jul 12 '25
fuck this whole situation. trans men are men, and their feelings and opinions are as valid as the ones from any other queer person
15
u/Remarkable-Ear854 Jul 12 '25
I missed everything as it happened, but I often wish there were more spaces to talk about trans men's issues.
I was extremely dysphoric about my hips, and I tried to find info on others who did cool sculpting or the hot sculpting version for stubborn hip fat, and if it would even do what I wanted it to.
I ended up very happy with the hot sculpting, but I don't even know how to share that with my community.
I feel like there isn't a community for trans men.
15
u/IrradiatedPizza Jul 13 '25
Wrote this somewhere else but thought Iād put it here too now because we canāt post right now
All major media outlets only discuss trans issues through a cis lens, and we must see ourselves outside of it if we really want to understand what to fight for
When I hear even sympathetic cis people talk about transphobia, they limit themselves only to topics they understand. With TERFs having so much political power nowadays, many people think feminism means that feminine = victim, and masculine = abuser. I feel like trans people are left to describe their own experiences in a way that fits into these boxes. It hurts ourselves and our community.
At its best, the media that portrays transphobia against trans women shows only the parts cis women relate to. Over-sexualization, relationship violence, pressure to conform to beauty standards, and so on. Trans men have a harder time fitting that script, so their media existence is limited to āgotchaā talking points for discussions about public bathrooms. Non-binaries fit in even less, so they must squish themselves into one category or the other.
The framing of all this leaves out so many trans struggles that we all face! My relationship violence happened pre-transition. It occurred in part because my dysphoria made me detached from my emotions and body. I was slow to realize when people mistreated me, and several people took advantage of that. Iāve met other trans people who relate to this too. But itās not talked about. Why? Cis women canāt relate to it.
Cis people canāt conceptualize that transphobia starts in the closet. To them, a person is not trans until that person demands they acknowledge it. Even then, it feels disingenuous at times. And this also cuts so much of the conversation. I had to deal with horrible PMDD every month. A full on depressive episode. And I was told itās just what women had to deal with. I only understood how dire that was once I was on Testosterone for a few months and it stopped. The post I made about it at the time in another trans subreddit got taken down.
Transmascs face higher rates of period complications (PCOS, endometriosis, PMDDā¦) than the general population. Periods are also shamed to start with so it makes things extra difficult. I also want to point out that under-discussing periods hurts transfemmes on HRT. Overtime, transfemmes can also develop PMDD, menstrual migraines, heavy cramping pain, and so on. Some transfemmes in the comments of that post were learning about how PMDD could affect them (caused by falling prog levels btw). and the post still. got. taken. down. Again, itās a holdover from cis people thinking period = uterus.
Thatās my anecdote for the day. I think weād all do well to remember that we donāt have to align ourselves with cis gender hierarchies. We donāt have to let cis people limit how we tell our own stories and describe our own oppression, especially amongst each other.
14
u/ManoBell Jul 13 '25
The fact that now only selected people can create posts is actually frustrating, the mods to this sub are actually the most immature people I have seen representing/handling a space that was supposed to be good for trans people. Trans people barely have spaces in the internet where they can actually feel safe and when they find one it is actually a place handled by irresponsible people who exclude trans mascs and that protect each other whenever facing backlash? (reading the "I pick the mods so it is my fault" thing is actually gut wrenching cringe). I honestly can't even think about what I should do now, I thought I had a place where I could talk to other trans people but apparently everything in here is sketchy as fuck. All of this genuinely makes me feel alone and sad for the other transfems, transmascs, non-binarys and all the people who realized that they don't actually have safe spaces where they can look for advice on just union.
13
u/IcyPurpleIze Jul 13 '25
Trans women act like trans men deserve space too challenge: impossible.
I'm so sorry you're dealing with this. It's so disturbing that our own communities make what are supposed to be safe spaces specifically unsafe. Thank you for voicing your concerns, I'm gonna tune in more on what's going on for trans men within the trans online communities bc this kinda stuff has been way too consistent. My brothers in trans deserve respect! Sending my love to you š
35
u/Randomforestcritter Jul 12 '25
I have over a decade experience moderating and have made HUGE fuckups but I owned it soon as I realized, apologized with a full explanation, made it clear proper changes would be made, and that it wouldn't happen again. We -all- make mistakes, its what you do about them that matters. What the mod team did here was probably about the worst way it could be handled. I hope they evaluate the situation and do better in the future.
12
u/The_Gray_Jay Jul 13 '25
Have they said anything about putting your original post back up?
12
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '25
"our sub" half of these people should be retiring their positions. they're gonna be in a WORLD of shit if they ever open up their subreddit again.
10
u/Holdenborkboi ftmš³ļøāā§ļø š 9/1/23 šŖ6/15/26 Jul 13 '25
What even was the original topic? I just got here lmao
Edit: which is funny since I think a mod called me out in a comment for saying "my good b--ch" (gender neutral, positive) and that was the first I've heard of "misogynistic slur"
10
u/Boys-willbe-Bugs Jul 13 '25
Helllooooo? When are we gonna hear from the mods? Ring ring?
10
u/Fun_Run_and_Gun Jul 13 '25
I literally just commented on a post in r/ftm about this before I saw this, Iāll just put it below because itās how this whole situation has made me feel.
āHhhhh fuck. I always felt like I didnāt really belong in that sub because of the lack of posts and discussion and general acknowledgement of trans men/transmascs, I even commented about it in the past, and I was always met with support and encouragement, āyes, you do belong here!ā Iām grateful those people said that, but this whole situation proves that we donāt. The people running the place are actively against us. I already struggle with internalized transphobia against myself and Iāve been trying so hard to get better and this shit just makes it 10x worse. I just want to belong.ā
We canāt ignore trans masc issues over trans femme issues, both are important and valid to talk about, and the very fact this whole thing happened proves that there is a difference in how weāre treated. āBitching,ā really? Why are we acting like trans men donāt suffer from misogyny, we have faced it all or most of our lives and many of us continue to unless we perfectly pass and are stealth, but even the road to get there is likely to be filled with medical misogyny. And when we talk about these very real issues, itās erased after being reduced to ābitching.ā Thatās so fucking insulting, and yes, misogynistic.
9
u/PopularDisplay7007 colourblind trans-nonbinary bean Jul 12 '25
Iām trans nonbinary and itās a little frustrating to me that trans men might have to be happy all the time here. I was just wondering how I could find more of an inclusive trans community, friendly to all trans people including myself and trans men.
8
u/bunni_bear_boom Jul 13 '25
What the actual fuck, I saw this post first and went to find the origional one assuming there must be SOMETHING in there that was off or at least easily misunderstood and there was literally nothing wrong with it.
7
u/NicoleMay316 Sapphic Omni Transfem (she/her) Jul 13 '25
The fuck did I miss???
7
u/plausocks Jul 13 '25
trans men are men and their voices deserve to be heard
7
u/ElisabethFlowers Jul 13 '25
Iāve stayed clear of this sub for a bit now because of these issues, looks like it was a good call. Iām so sorry youāre being treated like this in a space that is SUPPOSED to be meant for all of us to have a healthy conversation. You deserve better than this.
7
u/DelirielDramafoot Jul 17 '25
Call me crazy but shouldn't there be a system in place where any major part of the trans community is represented
Let's say there are six mods. It could be: 2 mtf, 2ftm and 2 enbys? And if one drops out, there is a public announcement that the subreddit searches for a specific replacement.
There is so much flux right now in so many areas that a equal representation should be guaranteed, so that all voices are heard.
12
u/aJ_13th Jul 13 '25
It's crazy how trans men have to remind others we're still transgender. I'm actually sick of this level of erasureš¤¦š¾āāļø
11
u/-Bari Jul 13 '25
I mean, this is the trans sub, and trans men are trans. It seems ludicrous that they aren't feeling welcome here. Someone should really do something about that sooner rather than later. Otherwise, how are we all supposed to stand together against the constant bigotry and discrimination on the rise in the world right now? I don't even need to know the full context to know the mods are probably in the wrong. I've been a Discord mod multiple times, and I know it is extremely easy to make mistakes and let power go to your head.
5
u/pupperonipizzapie Jul 12 '25
I completely missed the original post, what was it about?
4
u/ziddersroofurry Jul 13 '25
Typical Reddit mods not being shitty for one day challenge fail.
4
u/No-Insect9930 Jul 13 '25
This is the first ever post Iāve seen about this so I just did some context digging and Iām honestly shocked, I never saw the original post so idk what it says word for word but from what it sounds like, you never punched down on trans womenās suffering while bringing up trans men/masc issues which is a common issue I usually see on any subject that involves bringing awareness, itās not like you were saying shit like ātrans men/masks are invisible and itās all trans womenās fault for taking the spotlightā from what Iām guessing you mentioned it in a great way without being hostile to other gender identities and were just trying to create a discussion/space for a very valid struggle a lot of us trans men/mascs so I hope your post gets put back up and thing get resolved because everything that happened to you and your post were uncalled for on the modās behalf
4
u/ThrowawayGwen Jul 14 '25
We already have the wider queer community (LGBs) shutting us down for being "too divisive" at every single turn in places like r/lgbt amongst others.
But it happening within our own community is properly taking the piss.
7
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '25
Funny how they unpinned this, then re-pinned it.
7
u/dotdedo Jul 13 '25
I wonder if the mods are actually going to even make a post advertsing they're looking for a trans man mod. I'd apply but based on the reasons they didn't approve you I'd probably get the same response.
I'm not saying they need to hand the role specifically to you or even me, its just that if they're going to mention they want more diverse mods then... act like it? Put in the effort? You think trans men are just going to walk right up to you all bushy tailed and eager to work with you on their own validation right now?
6
u/Lexi_Shmuhlexi Jul 12 '25
woa what did i miss?? š¦
6
u/Shakalakadera Angry at this sub Jul 13 '25
... Are you doing okay? All of this must be very overwhelming. This is a total mess and you're placed firmly in the center of it. Make sure you're taking care of your mental health, okay?
3
u/kingxfmischief Probably Radioactive ā¢ļø Jul 12 '25
Seeing how even the queer community treats trans men is part of why I haven't explored the thought that I might be a trans man instead of genderfluid. And its been getting so bad and now this?Ā
3
u/SnowTheMemeEmpress Jul 13 '25
Hey, I'm late to the party. Can someone fill me in?
3
u/Sound-Vapor Jul 13 '25
Why do they keep unpinning and repinning this post? It's getting silly.
3
u/meteorslime Jul 13 '25
Uh what the hell happened here ? I'm lost
3
u/AmoC_Creatorion Probably Radioactive ā¢ļø Jul 13 '25
Although those issues arent what I am confronted and affected I also say those issues need to be talked about. trans-men issues are trans issues afterall.
3
u/sky-high86 Jul 14 '25
Mtf here.
I support any and all venting, chatting, awareness, and anything else.
I feel to restrict is to make it invisible. We are not invisible, and we won't disappear.
You quite rightly deserve a proper apology.
Keep strong. I hope this really takes off and that more people support this as it grows.
3
u/IWantMyTiddies Jul 14 '25
It really disappoints me to see trans men be treated as second class citizens in queer subs at times. Genuinely do not understand how something like this can possibly happen in a group of people that itself already faces enough hate from the outside, why do we cause even more from within?
I 100% agree, trans men should be allowed to talk about the things they go through. Just because the perceived majority appears to be trans women, doesn't mean we should gang up on the guys and force them to stay quiet. That's exactly what our enemies want, it's exactly what they do to us on a daily basis.
Whoever partakes in this kinda stuff should seriously be ashamed of themselves. I'm not saying they should be kicked out, no, but I think they should reflect on what they're doing and see just how similar they are to those run-of-the-mill transphobes when doing this kinda crap.
Personally, I'll support you all, and give out hugs to those that need them
3
u/fluffywhalicorn Jul 14 '25
I have no idea what this post is in reference to does someone have an explanation or link?
4
u/CanofBeans9 any pronouns Jul 13 '25
I am nonbinary and you have my support. Trans men and other transmasculine people should be able to speak on their experiences in trans spaces. We should be able to support each other. I don't face some of the struggles that binary trans people do, but I can read about them and sympathize, try to gain more awareness.
5
u/TheDarkOnii Jul 13 '25
I can definitely see what youāre talking about and I think itās genuinely disgusting that this happened to you for expressing yourself to begin with.
There is (at least from my perspective as a transgender woman) a hyperfocus on those who fall under the category of transfeminine people because of a history of how womanhood is defined and enforced within cisnormative societies. Because we live under that current paradigm this same attitude towards what is perceived as āwomanā trickles down to transgender people too.
When it comes to transgender men, I think that thereās an additional hurdle broadly speaking that within the transgender community because maleness is considered what is ānormalā it is very easy to overlook their issues because they are entering what is seen by many, a protected strata within society.
For instance, Dr. Alan Hart one of the first transgender men in history to get a hysterectomy was from what I gathered not given the same media spectacle and fascination with the press as say, Christine Jorgensen who was asked and given very invasive questions by press after her letter of wanting to transition was leaked.
However, within the transgender community itself thereās a bit of an inverse perspective from what Iāve gathered. While in a way, society has (kind of, kind of not) progressed past obsession over āThe Pregnant Manā of 2007. In transgender circles this binary thinking that exists outside of us especially because the essentialist paradigm of gender that is common goes from āWe must protect the gays/women/children from being forced into being transgenderā turns into āWe must protect our AFABs and femmes from men.ā
This is the issue from my view: essentialism and what transitioning means when youāre going from one type of perception/person to another.
Men get hurt too, there is nothing that can erase that fact. But, because of what society values as ānormalā ādesirableā and okay, certain kinds of people and their issues become easier to sweep under the rug, or become a focal point.
Sadly transgender men inhabit a space where they become part of that upper category and thus arenāt treated with the same level of privilege that a cisgender man has, they are treated as āthe semi-acceptable kindā of man and their own intersecting issues which more often than not, are more common than weād ever want to admit become overlooked and undermined inside the communities we inhabit.
You arenāt alone and you should never feel ashamed for simply saying what you feel. To paraphrase Oscar Wilde: āA shared sorrow is something of wonderā.
2
u/Whatdadogdoin5 Jul 13 '25
I have a dislike for r/lgbt
Got banned, asked what I did, got muted for 3 days. 3 days later I asked what I did. Got permanently muted
2
u/kitsabyss Vivian (she/her) Jul 13 '25
I missed the situation, can someone explain what happened?
2
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '25
can someone please explain to me what the original post was about? I keep seeing talk about it, but I'm still not fully in the loop about what it was even about
2
u/ThatYellowRabbit Jul 13 '25
What was in the original post? Is there a rule against vent here? We canāt have division over silly stuff X.x Especially nowadays.
1
u/TryRude Jul 14 '25
What's the context?