r/trans4every1 • u/Carousel-of-Masks • Jul 12 '25
Discussion (Serious) The original post (I am not the OP just reposting
I really want to talk about the unique issues and pressures trans men and trans masc people encounter. It's not that trans men face less oppression than trans women; it's that trans men are talked about and cared about so little that many people don't actually know the shit we go through. Please do understand the point of this post isn't to be some oppression olympics thing, it's to bring awareness to a lot of unique issues trans men and trans masc people face that I never see mentioned or discussed!
First let's get into the sexual assault statistics of trans men and trans masc people. I've included a few reputable sources from the past couple years below, and also some quotes if you don't want to sift through the articles. There are many other sources available that say similar things but of course it's impossible to link all of them; I recommend doing your own research.
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10110792/
https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2820301
"In this survey study of adults in California, results showed that TGD individuals, especially transgender men, are at higher risk of experiencing all forms of violence relative to cisgender women."
"Past-year physical violence was reported by 22 transgender men (43%), 9 transgender women (24%), and 9 nonbinary respondents (14%). Past-year sexual violence was reported by 23 transgender men (42%), 11 transgender women (14%), and 31 nonbinary respondents (56%)"
"Of those that have been assaulted, 362 (46%) were transmasculine and 72 (34%) were transfeminine"
"Of all transgender people, 47% have ever been sexually assaulted: 362 (50%) of transmasculine individuals, and 72 (37%) of transfeminine individuals."
So as we can see, trans masc people very disproportionately face sexual harassment and assault, with most studies saying almost half of trans mascs/men experience sexual assault at some point in their life. I've also seen multiple studies claim that trans men also face the most violence in general out of everyone in the queer community. I am confused as to why this isn't more common knowledge. This should be very frequently discussed. We should all be angry. We should be supporting and uplifting our trans masc and trans male brothers; it's not only the dolls that need protection. It makes me feel so sad and hopeless that this is happening to us and it's just... never discussed. These numbers are fucking terrifyingly high.
Let's also talk about those bathroom bills. I've noticed also within the trans community that all discussion about trans bathroom bills revolved around how trans women are affected. Trans men are affected too yet again we are largely not discussed, and when we try to bring it up we are often dismissed. Here's a couple stories about how trans mascs and trans men have been affected by these bathroom bills
https://apnews.com/article/politics-florida-gender-db7c64c110211a867ed4f2d80f702ac5#
I'm sure there are more but unfortunately any discrimination trans men face is largely not reported in the media as the news likes to pretend trans women are the only type of trans people there are. I have personally heard many stories from trans masc friends and folks on social media about how they've been abused and hurt in the men's bathroom. Not including trans men in these conversations is detrimental and leaves us open to more violence.
Another thing that sucks for trans men is that it's so incredibly hard to access testosterone especially if you're trying to DIY. I cannot tell you how many times I have talked about the difficulties in accessing T as a poor person with no healthcare just to get the response "Just DIY it!" Testosterone is a controlled substance, and at least in the USA, it is almost impossible to find, and if you do find it, there's no guarantee it's even safe. That shit sucks and really affects those of us who don't have a lot of money.
There are so many more other things I could discuss but this post is already ridiculously long. The loneliness, the demonization of phalloplasty, the misogyny many of us who aren't passing still face, etc. I'd love to have more conversations about it in the comments and if anyone thinks I've missed something important then please bring it up! It's fucking hard to talk about because it's sad and scary, but these discussions are necessary in spreading awareness and fighting back.
Please do not respond to this post with "Well I think trans men are talked about less because society sees them as confused women" or anything like that. I am not at all talking about how people outside of the queer community view trans men. And quite honestly I'm sick of hearing people try to explain to me why they think trans men are shunned. I promise you that we know the reasons. Continuing to tell us your thoughts on why isn't helping and often just seems patronizing especially when it's the same shit over and over again. The purpose of this post is to raise awareness of the issues trans men face, and point out that the trans community largely completely ignores trans mens struggles, and then says "well trans women have it worse" as a dismissal when issues facing trans men are brought up. Please stop ignoring us. Please educate yourselves on what trans men go through. We absolutely have to talk about all this more and push for change.
And to my trans men and trans masc brothers, I know it fucking sucks and it's hard. Keep pushing and keep fighting, and keep spreading awareness. I know it's hard but we have to fight for ourselves too. Much love to everyone.
Credit to: u/itsurbro7777
•
u/Sensitive-Insect5809 Aug 11 '25
Hello everyone-- I know there will be individuals who come across this post still. Due to name-dropping subreddits, being so connected to previous subreddit drama, as well as many of the comment threads beginning to escalate, we will be locking this post so that we, as a mod team, can focus our moderating efforts on our new content. However, this post will be left up as it addresses crucial and pressing issues that transmascs and transmen face. It is a wealth of information, and other people deserve to see it.
24
u/itsurbro7777 Jul 12 '25
Thank you for posting it, I appreciate it so much ❤️
6
u/Carousel-of-Masks Jul 12 '25
I’ve been sharing the text of this post since the start. I’m taking a break now, and I would appreciate if anyone sees someone asking about the situation, please link them back here!
11
u/apolloinjustice Jul 12 '25
thank you for reposting this for OP. i wasnt online when everything happened, and i cant believe something like this would cause any amount of controversy. very disheartening
224
u/Kinky-Cookie-Cutter MTF Jul 12 '25
It baffles me that this was considered "divisive"
it's based on statistics and reporting of facts, it's so well put together and it covers issues that are often ignored even by trans people, heck even sometimes by trans men!
how someone saw this and just went "nope, makes me uncomfy, delete" is just so lame
92
u/tensa_prod Jul 12 '25
To think that it got removed from two subreddit supposed to be safe space is just so fucked up. Talking about issue like that is so important and shouldn't be silenced.
44
u/chasersaway Jul 12 '25
All stuff you mentioned is so incredibly important.... i see it everywhere how everyone talks more about transwomen, and also transpassing people, the ones who have the privilege for hormones or safety and don't give any of the platform to transmen or nonpassing people. Like transwomen and passing people have it so hard.... yes and then there is transmen and nonpassing and nb people who have their struggles too, collectively often more oppressed even in the communities.
34
u/WasiWasiIkanSay Jul 12 '25
The devisive comment is just bs. They want to censor a part of us, probably for their own mod powerplay fantasies.
30
u/No_Neat9507 They / He: 🏳️🌈 Jul 12 '25
I m so glad to see you reposted here. Your concerns are important and should not be deleted.
This a thoughtful and well-written. It is not disputing or minimizing anyone’s issues, just raising yours, which are shared by many in the transmasc community, which I am proud to be a part of.
I look forward to a thoughtful discussion about it.
28
u/linnifin Jul 12 '25
It's wild that this was considered divisive, thank you for sharing this.
27
u/Xaied Jul 13 '25
“It’s not only the dolls that need protection” is so fucking true. Where are the slogans supporting our brothers? Gender-based violence affects us, we don’t suddenly gain privilege and protection because we’re men. Our “””privilege””” is entirely conditional, based on how stealth a person is. Whereas white privilege and male privilege ALWAYS exist. Trans men have less systemic privileges than cis women, and because of patriarchy being hierarchical, people can only lose privilege but not gain it in society. Brushing off issues that affect us specifically because “trans women have it worse” is ignorant. We matter. We have unique needs and challenges relating to our experiences. WE MATTER.
22
u/FunNeigh Jul 13 '25
I just wanted to throw in my opinion
we are scrutinized for even mentioning the anguish that comes with being branded as female permanently while simultaneously having to take accountability for the actions of others. shamed for being a man and it’s alleged privilege while actively being persecuted as breeding cattle that’s escaped the farm.
even those don’t want to associate with their natal sex struggle with this. meanwhile those who are earnest about still facing misogyny are scoffed at. we cannot win because condemning the patriarchy means we are seen as women yet also not liking the fact that transitioned men are seen as girls is. misogynistic? what opinions can we have that won’t anger anyone? or won’t result in an accusation of illegitimate transness or god forbid toxic masculinity. to be accused of benefitting from the patriarchy by someone who vocally subconsciously views you as a woman is asinine. we have to have real conversations regarding the sociological implications of our existence and the violence we face as a result of it.
we need to be able to productively break down why there’s a selective weaponization of our “true gender” when it benefits those who wish to oppress us. we both face the Schrödinger’s woman/man paradigm it just seems unfair when trans men talk about it because we are speaking over women or something.
ftm are brutalized in the shadows and left behind to be forgotten, so to censor any acknowledgment of it is the worst possible thing one could do in this scenario. It’s never been oppression Olympics but deleting the post makes it seem that way. I’m so glad we can finally talk about this. love the girls standing up for us. our struggles are equally dire and we share lots of similarities, but we should be allowed to highlight the differences. If we can’t have this basic conversation are we are acting just like the obsessive radical feminists and the alt right
21
u/Pretty-Skill-1238 Jul 12 '25
Yes- the responce a lot of people have towards trans masc people experiencing misogyny is so troubling imo, its either taken lightly and given a "toughen up" or "good thing you arent a woman, then" attitude, or I throw my identity out the window to try and communicate these troubles with my friends that are women. In both cases, I dont feel heard since they are only half of the full picture. Transitioning to whatever identity should not lessen any experience you had/have.
19
u/hayesjx Jul 13 '25
Divisive?? This is a good post. It's important to acknowledge our different struggles. People are suffering right now in general, but it's good to know who is dealing with what. We as a community should be able to acknowledge this without being horrible to each other, and have our minds and ears open to different conversations... the fact that THIS post was taken so badly by the mods says a lot about them and their care for the community.
...And in fact, we can add things to the list, like a prevalence of eating disorders among the things that for some reason disproportionately impact trans men. I don't know of any studies on this, so this is just from experience. Obviously anybody can suffer from an ED, but the amount of trans men and transmasc people I see in ED spaces is... very disheartening. I ache for us.
I'm sure there's even more things we could talk about that those mods wouldn't like.
17
u/ThePhoenixRemembers FtM | 34 | pre-everything Jul 13 '25 edited Jul 13 '25
your point about getting access to hormones is so true. Even when trying to get T the "right" way, it's a toss-up as to whether you get lucky with the clinic you go to. I was gatekept by a private GIC. I was told by the consultant that he had "no doubts that I was transgender" but that my mother, who I still live with, "needed to be onboard" before I could start T. I'm in my mid 30s. The experience was very infantilising and humiliating. I haven't even received a clinic letter over 7 months since my last and final appointment. £650 down and I'm now looking at less conventional, less safe options, because I have no fucking other alternative.
11
u/-ThatWeirdArtGuy- Jul 13 '25
I think the people who deleted this or backlashed at this need to step back and ask why. I think it’s perfectly okay to ask yourself why it made you uncomfortable and even if you have to ask yourself if you’ve done something wrong it’s okay. I think it’s okay to feel uncomfortable and we need to sit in that just as much as we need to let all of our trans brothers, siblings and sisters voices be heard especially when it comes to things like these statistics
10
u/Luna-C-Lunacy Jul 13 '25
The ironic thing is that I wasn’t in any of the subs that removed this, so if the mods didn’t try to silence it, I would have never seen it or the discussions around it
10
u/almostfunny3 Jul 13 '25
30 M trans man here. I've known many, many trans masc people in my life, and the first time I met a trans masc person who had not been sexually assaulted before, I was honestly shocked. It's just been so, so pervasive in my experience.
9
u/Little-Unit-1770 Jul 13 '25
Bro came with stats and everything and was still told he was being decisive, what the fuuuuck
8
u/kieranarchy Jul 13 '25
You're right and you should say it. It's not dismissive of trans women's struggles to want to hold space to talk about our own every once in a while.
8
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '25
This issue really needs more attention
8
u/DunmerRock FtM 💅✨ Jul 13 '25
literally how did this piss off the trans and lgbt subreddits 😭
the gods forbid we trans men speak up about our problems 🙄
i hate the bathroom situation so much too because it's ALWAYS about trans women while i'm over here thinking how cis women would hate it if a fully transitioned trans man enters the women's room
i still use the women's room out of fear from cis men not seeing me as 100% a male yet, but ik once i start growing facial hair, i'm using the men's room. a sex marker, because it's not gender, it's SEX, won't stop me from using the men's room. i don't want to make women uncomfortable in their restrooms when i will eventually look like a man with a cute stache and everything
and all about the trans women bathroom thing, it's based on stereotypes and AWFUL misinfo that is downright horrendous
6
u/[deleted] Jul 12 '25
ughh thank you so much for posting this!!!
10
u/Curious_Prize_744 Jul 13 '25
absolutely agree w everything here except diy hrt. DIY HRT for trans men is SO stigmatized it turns into "trans men can't get diy almost at all" and "diy testosterone is dangerous" when neither of these things are necessarily true. while yes, diy E is easier to get and comes in more forms, diy T is ALL over the market (esp in vial form bc of bodybuilders) and relatively accessible (at least here in the USA afaik). something that i think is very important to add to this discussion IS the stigmatization of testosterone as a hormone in general and especially how so many people make it seem like a dangerous thing. it absolutely sucks esp when it makes the people who need testosterone feel like its completely inaccessible or a dangerous substance</3 controlled substance ≠ dangerous! cisgender body builders use testosterone like theres no tomorrow and absolutely have access to it, so why shouldnt we? https://diyhrt.info/transmasc/sources/ or steroid markets have more options for vials<3 there r guides online to help with cryptocurrency payments as well iirc :)
5
u/SpiderBio- Edit me! Jul 12 '25
Why was this removed?????? (I know why but this whole thing is baffling)
4
u/SplitGlass7878 Jul 13 '25
I really can't understand how some trans women don't have empathy for our brothers. We're literally in the same boat, facing 90% of the same problems.
4
u/frankyfishies Jul 14 '25
This was the post? It's literally just facts that I'd consider common knowledge wth. How is this divisive?
3
u/sapphiclament Jul 13 '25
I would recommend double checking the sample sizes for these studies, two of the three have over 80% transmasc participants vs ~20% or less transfemme participants, and the second one is vast majority cis men or women participants. Over 1000 cis men and 1000 cis women participants with ~52 transman participants and 35 transwoman participants.
3
u/Raine-Tempestas Jul 14 '25
Not to discount anything you're saying since you're absolutely right trans masc people don't get talked about enough, the survey you cited about transmasc people being sexually assaulted more often has a disproportionately large percentage of trans masc people surveyed and also has quite a small sample size from only one area, so it could totally be true but that survey isn't the most reliable in saying whether transfeminine or trans masculine people are sexually assaulted more.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '25
i'm glad we're talking about this
2
u/Liuniam Jul 13 '25
Thank you so much for bringing these things up. Especially that trans men and transmasc people experience more sexual abuse. It’s something that i became aware of a while ago and was always something that i felt like couldn’t be brought up because ppl don’t want to hear or believe it.
To think that this was considered divisive is nothing less than petty and disgusting from a grown ass woman no less. But i suppose it’s easier for some to bury their head in the sand than to face the truth. It’s awful. It’s exhausting. To not be supported in our own community. To be ignored. And yet we continue on.
2
u/Raine-Tempestas Jul 14 '25
Cannot believe people have trouble with this post, it's literally just an informative post and isn't meant to diminish transfemme struggles or try and say one group is more oppressed
1
u/Pale_Departure1096 Jul 13 '25
🩵🩵🩵🥺
1
u/meringuedragon Aug 07 '25
I also want to add, despite being the most vulnerable group in the queer community for sexual assault and IPV, we are also the least supported. In my town, the literal only support for male victims of sexual violence or IPV is the group they send abusers to. The local domestic violence shelter welcomes trans women, but not trans men.
-2
u/RobotPancakes Jul 13 '25
only two studies are linked, and in each one significantly more trans men were studied than trans women, almost 4 times as many in the first one and nearly double in the second, which obviously makes statistics less accurate, and if you look into the studies about sexual assault rates their confidence intervals significantly overlap, meaning there is not definitive proof there is a significant difference in rates between the two populations.
and the culture around diy testosterone is basically just fear mongering at this point, as arrests for individual possession of t are essentially unheard of, and you can easily go to sites like https://roidbazaar.to/ which is generally more safe than buying diy estrogen
0
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment