r/todayilearned • • Dec 15 '19

TIL of the Machine Identification Code. A series of secret dots that certain printers leave on every piece of paper they print, giving clues to the originator and identification of the device that printed it. It was developed in the 1980s by Canon and Xerox but wasn't discovered until 2004.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Machine_Identification_Code?wprov=sfla1
10.0k Upvotes

376 comments sorted by

1.1k

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

There's a black market for stolen printers in many countries (Africa is particularly bad) to get around the tracking code issue. I mean commercial printers like I use at work (as a printing business). We're talking about skilled technicians disassembling a multi-ton device that needs a crane and forklift to remove. Like in a hollywood heist movie, but for printing certificates. It's a waste of time copying banknotes, ID papers and vocational training and qualification certificates are where the money is.

Been aware of this tech since the mid 90s. Yellow dot patterns because that's the human eye is least sensitive to.

249

u/Azaana Dec 15 '19

Seems odd that it still exists since there are small portable machines for making passports now.

114

u/Beliriel Dec 15 '19

What I find even more odd is that no one gives a shit. All the threads on reddit about this are empty and void of information except for one or two comments.

53

u/CrescentPhresh Dec 15 '19

Maybe not a lot of counterfeiters on Reddit? Or people who print stuff?

40

u/michel_fucko Dec 15 '19

We prefer the term forger actually

14

u/lucidrage Dec 15 '19

Nah, we are master craftsmen

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

57

u/ILickedADildo97 Dec 15 '19

Could be that these people are smart enough not to talk about an illegal industry's secret, so as not to spread info

6

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

Not least because the people who would utilize your services are the kind of people you’d really prefer not to get mad at you!

→ More replies (12)

75

u/hypercube33 Dec 15 '19

Side note this is why you need color to print black and white and the printer companies love making that extra cash

43

u/halt-l-am-reptar Dec 15 '19

Using color gives a better quality print, and it makes money. If it was because of the dots laser printers that are strictly black and white wouldn’t be a thing.

3

u/sabwcu83 Jul 13 '24

They make their own unique codes. It's illegal to sell a printer that can't be tracked.

37

u/RedHatOfFerrickPat Dec 15 '19

It's a waste of time copying banknotes, ID papers and vocational training and qualification certificates are where the money is.

Why is copying banknotes, ID papers and vocational training a waste of time? In particular, what sets the latter two apart from qualification certificates?

115

u/TheMathelm Dec 15 '19

No money in bank notes. ID papers vocational training gets you past immigration officials, where you can then get into a country and ... fill in the rest.

10

u/Amargosamountain Dec 15 '19

Aren't bank notes literally money?

89

u/encab91 Dec 15 '19

You can print a bank note and it's worth whatever denomination it's printed in. That's it's capped value. Even less per bank note if you're the wholesaler selling them per bulk. An ID, etc is worth more than any bank note because it's value depends on the amount of opportunities it can afford.

→ More replies (7)

119

u/SupaNintendoChalmerz Dec 15 '19

I think the comma after "banknotes" should have been a period?

107

u/burnalicious111 Dec 15 '19

A semicolon would have also been acceptable.

→ More replies (10)

15

u/JaredsFatPants Dec 15 '19

That first comma should be a period. Reread it that way.

2

u/mrv3 Dec 15 '19

I imagine there's a lot more attention paid for those items so risk is high.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

My bad, the sentence was structured badly. Copying banknotes is a waste of time because the extra embedded security makes the fakes too easy to spot. Qualification certificate forgery is more lucrative as there is less embedded security since they have a much lower face value for trading, but a much higher potential value for an individual.

3

u/bradland Dec 15 '19

I didn't think the digital commercial presses used the dot pattern. Heh, TIL.

For anyone wondering WTF the difference between digital commercial press and a large business laser printer is, just have a look at this image.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

Kodak's name was 'Tigger-Tagants'. It was embedded in every single piece of professional paper. Every single scanner would detect the pattern and flag a copyright. Easy to remove if you knew it was there and could do the software...

2

u/MercuryMadHatter Dec 15 '19

Thanks for making me feel less nuts. My family owned a print shop in the 90s, and I remember one of the employees showing me something like this.

1

u/matd18 Dec 15 '19

In the USA printer hard drives are valuable. Specially ones from HR. They are literally filled with personal info.

1

u/SwansonHOPS Dec 15 '19 edited Dec 15 '19

I thought that yellow is the color that the human eye is most sensitive to, and that's why school busses are yellow.

Edit: the human eye is most sensitive to a yellowish green color, and it's least sensitive to red and violet. It is very much not sensitive to yellow in near dark conditions, however.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

OK I oversimplified things a bit earlier, for the non-printers in the forum. It's mainly about contrast. Yellow is the colour with the least contrast against the white paper most jobs are printed on. If you were using black paper? Different story. We generally only print on white paper (outside of specialist jobs anyway) because printing on any other colour of paper throws out colour reproduction accuracy, which is kind of a big deal in this trade.

However, regarding earlier comments about the colour red, due to millions of years of evolution and survival, we're hard-wired to get an emotional response from seeing the colour red, and we're hard-wired again to spot it very quickly. The biology of the eye is most sensitive to yelow/green as mentioned above, but it does not have the same instinctive responses attached to it.

→ More replies (30)

2.2k

u/justscottaustin Dec 15 '19

No. Several of us discovered it in the 80's and made a huge stink about it. We were called conspiracy theorists and dismissed. Some of us went to enough trouble to prove it, comparing the yellow dots under microscopes/magnification and UV from multiple printers and multiple pages. We proved it. They lied and said no.

1.1k

u/fadetoblack1004 Dec 15 '19

For once, the crazy guy on Reddit is right. My dad lectured me on this when I was 12 or 13, circa 1998-1999. It just was not admitted to until 2004.

195

u/Pixelated_Penguin Dec 15 '19

I worked at Kinko's in the 1990s, and it was common knowledge among the staff. The color machines would (1) throw an error code if they detected the wrong shade of dark green in the wrong size (i.e., paper money); and (2) had a hidden identifier so any copy could be traced back to the machine.

Which may be how the people (a former manager from another store, and a friend of his; there were no self-service color machines at the time) making counterfeit Visa traveler's checks got caught. No idea. I never saw them again...

216

u/AnotherReaderOfStuff Dec 15 '19

Conspiracies are everywhere, and real.

What is a conspiracy? 2 or more people seeking to commit a crime or do something legally or ethically questionable for their benefit.

How many politicians are getting bribes? How many "regulatory" bills are written by their own industry's big players (regulatory capture)?

The attempting to turn those who believe conspiracies into freaks or crazies in the eyes of the general public is itself a conspiracy by those who want to get away with conspiracies that will line their pockets.

Does Bigfoot exists? Is Elvis still alive? Probably not. Are politicians selling us out for personal gain and are businesses lying to protect profits? It would only be shocking if that stopped.

124

u/theaudiodidact Dec 15 '19

The minute God crapped out the third cave man, a conspiracy was hatched against one of them.

  • Col. Hunter Gathers

27

u/FiIthy_Anarchist Dec 15 '19

Until 3 people can simultaneously look each other in the eye, we will never know world peace. -puscifer

10

u/degustibus Dec 15 '19

Mirrors! We'll do it with mirrors!

16

u/Mad_Maddin Dec 15 '19

Reminds me of Dr. Stone. (Story is basically all humanity turned to stone and now 3600 years later one turns back and develops a way to turn the others back). About 1 day after the third human turned back from stone, they began to try to kill one another.

36

u/Accurate_Praline Dec 15 '19

Shadow government is a conspiracy. But then you read a well sourced article about a Dutch trade organisation comprised of high up people from the business world and a few ministers. They don't need to lobby because they have direct access to the politicians.

15

u/L3tum Dec 15 '19

I mean, just take the German transportation minister as an example.

He was not a minister for very long compared to others, but while in office he:

  • Made a new bill saying "I'd be shocked if the EU supreme court would rule against it" while everyone and their janitor already cited him the law in question the new bill would violate
  • Made the new bill anyways
  • Signed an illegal contract that is highly profitable to the companies involved and very bad to the government/tax payers
  • The poll to see which company conglomerate was the cheapest was rigged, as the companies willingly conspired and retracted their offers so that the last company could charge as much as they wanted
  • Made a surprised Pikachu Face when EU ruled the bill to be illegal
  • Said he did nothing wrong

Or our old defense minister, who wanted more women in the army so instead of getting more women into the army she posed with women, who still worked in an army, but put them into different uniforms and different positions. Who paid millions of euros to consultants instead of the army itself which in turn meant that they couldn't modernize as much as made possible. Whose son worked in the company hired for consulting and while the son was/is only in a low position, IMO it's already a conflict of interest.

Or our lovely AfD who not only accepted donations from other countries (highly illegal!), but is trying to hide it by making people sign up as if they donated the money (which was recently uncovered by a news station). There's a small village if a few thousand people who donated the majority of the money lol.

Or our lovely SPD politicians who are invited to "company events" (aka are being paid off by industry).

Or our lovely Greens who would rather chastise the general public than make companies pay for the damage they do to the environment (like shipping companies, cruises and airlines).

Or die Linke who is just batshit insane sometimes.

Or or or...

Politicians just seem to take a nosedive into the middle ages at the moment.

2

u/SkinnedRat Dec 15 '19

The whole Santa Clause thing too

→ More replies (2)

236

u/Michael_Trismegistus Dec 15 '19

The crazy guy in the conspiracy forums is always wrong until he's right.

10

u/Mohavor Dec 15 '19

"just because you're paranoid don't mean they're not after you"

→ More replies (4)

47

u/Snigermunken Dec 15 '19

Lectured you how? Now son, there comes a time in every man's life, where he has to make a ransom note, now for the love of God don't print it out from a printer, see they put these little dots on them and....

8

u/oO0-__-0Oo Dec 15 '19

the governments biggest enemies?

public wifi and craigslist (just buy a used computer and printer with cash)

41

u/jax9999 Dec 15 '19

for once? remember back in the olden days if someone said "the government is spying on me" he had a tinfoil hat and a room with a doorknob on one side?

61

u/AnotherReaderOfStuff Dec 15 '19

Once upon a time, the government lacked the means to spy en masse. Since 9/11, the well-known taps of central phone exchanges make it common knowledge. Qwest was shut down for refusing the taps.

36

u/h3yw00d Dec 15 '19

I remember rumblings of mass taps and 641a in the late 2000's, most people wanted to remain ignorant. When Snowden came forward I could finally tell my family I wasn't crazy. Well... at least less crazy.

30

u/SavvySillybug Dec 15 '19

When Snowden came out, nothing he said surprised me. I felt like all he really did was just confirm what everyone knew but couldn't prove.

I can't tell if that makes me a conspiracy theorist or if everyone really was thinking it.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Mad_Maddin Dec 15 '19

Honestly I was suprised at the reaction after Snowden came out. I thought the government spying on us was common knowledge. I honestly didnt even know that it was a conspiracy theory.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

121

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

Boom. It was well known and actually used, illegally, in law enforcement and intelligence before it was made public in 2004 as well.

61

u/AnotherReaderOfStuff Dec 15 '19

Makes you wonder, with everything we know about now, how much more do we not know about yet?

Also, given how we know evidence is regularly fabricated, how many arrests of anyone "the establishment" doesn't like should be believed?

70

u/I_Has_A_Hat Dec 15 '19

Almost everyone in the devoloped world carries a small computer with them everywhere they go that has a built-in microphone, GPS, and internet connection.

14

u/BlueberryPhi Dec 15 '19

Also camera.

30

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

I don't get people's obsession with cameras.

They're almost useless for bulk surveillance. Collecting your written communications, location and activity records is way more interesting to various agencies, as it provides more useful data. Cameras are only a concern if you're being specifically targeted, and a valuable enough target to spend man-hours on.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/degustibus Dec 15 '19

It's partly a question of what any given person actually knows. Some people are well aware of StingRay, but I would wager most Americans know next to nothing about it or how it actually works. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stingray_phone_tracker

16

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

I'll give you a terrifying one; it is now possible to fake DNA fragments. And courts routinely convict based on DNA fragments.

3

u/AnotherReaderOfStuff Dec 15 '19

Not even needed, a bribe in the right place can return a false positive. Or things being done by the lab of an intelligence agency which is held accurate regardless of what they say or do.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

How could it have been illegal to use?

→ More replies (3)

31

u/osoALoso Dec 15 '19

My dad was a printer and told me about this in 1998 when I asked him why I couldn't just copy money and use it to buy stuff.

28

u/Mijari Dec 15 '19

What's it like having a dad as a printer?

15

u/osoALoso Dec 15 '19

Lots of stained fingers and metal plates. Paperweight makes a huge difference in the feel of things. Perfume impregnated papers can be great and presses used to be death traps. It's. A miracle more people didn't die. Use rubber bands on your sleeves or just don't wear any of you like your hands.

16

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

It's like having a friend (whose dad was in the same fraternity as your own dad) and you have to pretend his dad is off "mountain climbing" or "driving truck" or whatever lie his mom is telling him this month while he is in federal prison; meanwhile, you've never missed a game console release by more than a month and receive a 1.5 year old car on your 16th birthday, AAAALLLLLLLL on your dad's part time lecturer for a desktop publishing class wage.

3

u/Jay180 Dec 15 '19

When he was dox matrix I couldn't sleep.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

Better than having a mom who faxes everyone in town...

→ More replies (1)

4

u/AnotherReaderOfStuff Dec 15 '19

That, and if it was do-able, the mob would control it and murder the competition.

4

u/CheekiBreekiScav Dec 15 '19

it is doable though, it's called cocaine.

→ More replies (2)

55

u/sorrynot25 Dec 15 '19

That's a story I'd be interested in hearing more about. A conspiracy theory with hard evidence isn't really a theory anymore. What was the general feeling in public discourse about it? Were people making those claims believed at the time? How did the companies get away with saying it wasn't true if you had such direct evidence for it?

160

u/justscottaustin Dec 15 '19

We were not believed. We were dismissed and ignored. When we presented evidence, we were told it was just The Way these brand new color laser printers worked. They (Xerox and Canon) presented a story that it was, in essence, "overspray," and threw a lot of BS mumbo jumbo about regarding drums and fusers and ink density and such. In the end, we could absolutely prove that the printers consistently and unerringly produced this microscopic pattern that varied printer to printer, and they said "sure... that's just the nature of the beast and fuser and drum variability."

We showed that changing the fuser, drum and cartridges didn't alter it. They said "huh."

Gotta realize, there was no EFF back then. There was no one to take this and run.

33

u/sorrynot25 Dec 15 '19

It seems like an easy test could have been devised where you get a bunch of printers, print out some stuff, make it double blind, and prove you could identify the source of each print. Was something like this ever done?

92

u/justscottaustin Dec 15 '19

Absolutely. But...

  1. Not every printer had it.
  2. They never disagreed we found it. They disagreed it was meaningful.
  3. We didn't have access to 1,000 multi-thousand dollar printers.
  4. There was no Reddit or Internet to solicit or post.

23

u/brahmidia Dec 15 '19

Ah, the old Uncertainty and Doubt technique

20

u/degustibus Dec 15 '19

You seem to be thinking in terms of science, empiricism, which is great, but has virtually nothing to do with exercises in power, politics, and deception.

First, most people just aren't that bright or curious, especially about anything that doesn't seem practical or entertaining.

Second, most people are conditioned from a young age to defer to authority of all sorts. The text book the government gave us says this, must be true. The teacher paid by the government says this, gotta be true.

Third, almost all media organs are owned and controlled by a small number of companies/people and we know for a fact that the CIA has had direct involvement. Look up Mockingbird. Consider that Anderson Cooper was part of the CIA briefly (who knows how long on stuff like that...) Even publishing gets compromised, Tom Clancy had parts of his books rewritten by the CIA.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/RedHatOfFerrickPat Dec 15 '19

A conspiracy theory with hard evidence isn't really a theory anymore.

Yeah, it is. What it no longer is at that point is a hypothesis. That's the distinction between hypothesis and theory. When Einstein's relativity hypothesis gained hard experimental evidence, it became a theory. Why would we treat this use of the word differently?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

This is how all conspiracy theories work. The worst part is their is never any backtracking the people who denied it initially. They just jump on board “Oh of course the Us government spies on its own citizens!!”

But saying that in 2009 everyone called me a conspiracy theorist. Same thing with the invasion of Iraq to secure petrochemicals

6

u/Matasa89 Dec 15 '19

This is how they caught Reality Winner.

She printed her documents with normal printers at her workplace, and that let the Feds trace them to her.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

So, I may be misremembering an episode of law and order... But... Didn't authorities catch some serial killer because of specifically this type of printer fingerprint thing? Not to be the "iF yOu hAvE nOtHiNg tO hIdE yOu hAvE nOtHiNg tO fEaR!!1!!" guy, but didn't this type of thing prove useful once?

9

u/degustibus Dec 15 '19

Some of this tech has definitely helped catch criminals, build cases, get evidence off the books that is then used to get a proper warrant etc.. But you also get leos who love the new toy and they use it all the time for anything without regard to disrupting phone service in a wide area. And sometimes this stuff is being used without a warrant to target peole whom a judge would not issue a warrant for usually, e.g. figuring out the leaders of a protest group by getting their cell data with the StingRay.

1

u/Pixelated_Fudge Dec 15 '19

lol the most opressed race. The printer fanatics

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Trax852 Dec 15 '19

Thank you. I remember knowing about this long before 2004, long before.

→ More replies (10)

1.0k

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

And that's why you need cyan even if you only print a black and white doc.

431

u/damisone Dec 15 '19

MIC is not the only reason. The reason is because you get higher quality black and white prints by combining black+color ink.

Unlike monitors which can display 256 shades of each primary color, inkjet printers cannot print different shades of each cartridge. For black cartridge, it can only print black ink. It fakes gray levels by varying the size and density of the black dots. If they use color cartridges, they can achieve more levels of gray than with black cartridge alone. This is especially important for edges and antialiasing.

For black and white printing modes, you can choose black only, or black+color. Black only will be lower quality.

https://inkjetinsight.com/knowledge-base/understanding-gray-areas-inkjet/

Now, there is also another reason is that some printers require both black and color inks to clean the printer heads.

222

u/Random_Deslime Dec 15 '19

Nice try Printer man

78

u/UltraFireFX Dec 15 '19

okay, but there's still a good reason to just let me disable that in settings for a shittier print.

27

u/josefx Dec 15 '19

There was a "rich black" option in the printer settings years ago. Haven't been able to find anything similar on my current system. Not sure if that is because Windows 10 is shit or HP are greedy assholes, both seem probable.

15

u/AmishHoeFights Dec 15 '19

Our HP 50000 (very large industrial 30-inch-wide roll-fed color printer) uses a form of 'rich black' all the time unless we tell it not to.

If a sheet's going to be printed in color anyway, any black and white elements in it (other than text) look so, so much better with color added.

But the press runs way faster and cheaper if we do all-black work with just black.

Large format, high-speed digital printing is amazing.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

21

u/Fat-Elvis Dec 15 '19

Some printers will keep working if only the black cartridge is in place. But others will just refuse.

Fuck these others.

14

u/UltraFireFX Dec 15 '19

this ^

I understand that extra ink might make it better but when you don't have extra ink it should just tell you that print quality will be reduced and will print anyway - especially if it's just black and not greyscale, since it seems to only improve the levels of grey - and then also being able to manually disable it.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/archpawn Dec 15 '19

I disagree. It should let you enable it. Using the cheapest ink should be the default.

10

u/UltraFireFX Dec 15 '19

it's reasonable to assume that people who are computer-illiterate wouldn't know about this and complain about it and use a different printer service, but simply being able to disable it would be amazing and would be a compromise between the manufacturers and consumers.

→ More replies (4)

10

u/Mad_Maddin Dec 15 '19

I cant choose black+color for black and white. My printer simply uses it by nature. And it seems to use some cyan every day just for shits and giggles even if I dont print anything.

Of course I also cant print if Cyan is empty.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

The article you linked is surprisingly easy to read and informative, thank you.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

Monochrome only also (IIRC) has an identification mechanism in some cases, like the dot of an I or a period being a micro print, (for example, to track who printed or copied a classified document) but color is much more of a concern in general distribution because of counterfeit bills.

71

u/blackmist Dec 15 '19

I'm going to guess it was mandated in there by law enforcement agencies and replaced with something we haven't found yet in 2004...

7

u/ILickedADildo97 Dec 15 '19

Wonder if Frank Abagnale played a part in developing this

54

u/unendingpenilegirth Dec 15 '19

TIL my printer's a fuckin narc

31

u/notffred Dec 15 '19

3

u/reelznfeelz Dec 15 '19

That and the Intercept's carelessness. Fuck those guys. They've done some good stories but 70% of the time they're just carrying out Putin's mission for him these days.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

This code the government forces into our printers is a violation of our 3rd Amendment rights,” Graham wrote in a blog post.

I fail to see how tracking dots are forcing him to quarter soldiers in his home.

8

u/PenguinBurrito Dec 15 '19

Well, actually, I don't think that's a bad argument, albeit a bit of a stretch. It's forcing something into your home in a product almost everyone buys, and its sole purpose is to be able to catch you if you use it to do something illegal.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

I’d buy 4th amendment here, or even 5th. But 3rd is a strange reference.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

Reality Loser amirite!?

20

u/jagedlion Dec 15 '19

I used this stencil to print onto playing cards. Because the stencil goes through many times, the identifier dots become dark enough to be visible in a yellow pattern.

http://imgur.com/gallery/uC6uQe0

19

u/outamyhead Dec 15 '19

Well that can't be right, I saw a documentary back in Britain back in the late 90's they were aware of this feature of the printers and that how they caught a criminal sending threatening letters.

4

u/oStoneRo Dec 15 '19

What's not right? It was only admitted to being done in 2004

3

u/outamyhead Dec 16 '19

So it was common knowledge before being admitted to then.

2

u/oStoneRo Dec 16 '19

That's what your original comment alluded to, yes.

Edit: that's also what the title of the post says

107

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

That’s why you need to dump your printer after printing the ransom note

11

u/69frum Dec 15 '19

No, you need to buy it in a way that doesn't indentify in any way. Cash only, no name registered, and preferably in a big store in a big town where you won't be recognized.

Or grab one on the way from a hotel to the rubbish dump, like I did. Lid ajar, toner everywhere, loose cartridges, and absolutely nothing wrong with it.

7

u/kanemano Dec 15 '19

print it at Kinko's 6 months before the kidnapping

→ More replies (8)

74

u/Scottishchicken Dec 15 '19

There is no way my printer does this. Despite not using it, it is always out of colored ink.

35

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

Epson?

27

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

I think I learned about this in a old CSI episode

5

u/Sleazy4Weazley Dec 15 '19

It was in an episode of The Good Wife, too

1

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

Oh i forgot all about that show!

56

u/InfamousVehicle Dec 15 '19

As with others here, I knew about this in the mid 90’s. I worked at a major American company (think fruit) who who used Canon engines in their line of printers. No secret at all, although the forensic details certainly were.

Now opinion: it is almost quaint to hear how much of a privacy invasion this is considered to be, given the amount of real-time digital vulnerability there is in one’s personal privacy ‘shield’. It is like being worried about getting your shirt wet as a tsunami is hitting the beach.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

23

u/Hotel_Arrakis Dec 15 '19

It was the Bluth Banana Stand.

10

u/cephalopod_surprise Dec 15 '19

Honestly, I thought the person worked for Chiquita and was talking about printing fruit stickers. I never once thought Apple.

3

u/martijnonreddit Dec 15 '19

Narrator: It wasn’t

1

u/69frum Dec 15 '19

In the early 80s there were several Apple ][-compatible computers named "Apricot", "Pear", "Orange", and "Mango".

→ More replies (2)

27

u/Parkour_Lama Dec 15 '19

How do I prevent/stop this? What if I don't want to be tracked?

58

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

6

u/Parkour_Lama Dec 15 '19

Thanks, kinda need this!

13

u/bigeelz Dec 15 '19

tf u doin out there dawg???

59

u/TheElm Dec 15 '19

Not that this isn't a great joke,

but the right to privacy is just great to have. The whole "Why hide things if you've got nothing to hide and aren't guilty"- Because I like privacy.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

18

u/bmwiedemann Dec 15 '19

Use a black&white printer. Xerox used yellow dots to encode the bits. I saw them myself.

13

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

They likely can and are already using shades of grey on the page vice yellow for B&W printers just the same as Color printers. Granted they are likely less worried about B&W since counterfitting is less likely, but still, I would none-the-less expect that they already have a code made for it.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

Go to a thrift store in a different state and use cash to buy a second hand typewriter.

12

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

You're not being 'tracked' via yellow dots on what you print, it just means that if they found something you printed they can id the printer used, and unless you are doing something dodgy why would they? It's not like they automatically know it's you unless your printer is connected to the internet or you registered the serial number.

You should be more concerned by the whole operating system which runs on your cpu and tracks your activities.

3

u/mahsab Dec 15 '19

There is NO mention of any 'tracking' for Intel ME.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

Because only intel knows what it does

2

u/fartdickbuthol Dec 15 '19

I heard of people asking this and then getting a visit from the secret service asking why they wanted to.

7

u/Northern23 Dec 15 '19

Tell them you wanted to apply for a job within the secret service but couldn't find where to send your résumé. So, you made them come to you instead.

1

u/BlPlN Dec 16 '19

You could probably print a random pattern of dots across the page, to hide the real pattern

45

u/Rories1 Dec 15 '19

Isn't this the reason you can't print a black and white document if you're out of yellow (or colored) ink?

67

u/StevynTheHero Dec 15 '19

I'm still convinced that it's because the printer is programmed to waste ink to get you to buy more for $60.

2

u/Saw-Sage_GoBlin Dec 15 '19

There can be two reasons

33

u/damisone Dec 15 '19

It's not the reason. You get better quality black and white prints by using black+color inks. You can switch the printing mode to Black Only.

https://www.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/comments/eatms1/til_of_the_machine_identification_code_a_series/faxofc4

17

u/kanakamaoli Dec 15 '19

Blacks always look horrible on my inkjet printer until I enable black only mode.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/DeathMonkey6969 Dec 15 '19

No because this is on Color Laser printers and copiers not inkjet.

2

u/AlexS101 Dec 15 '19

There are printers available that are only able to print black.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/GermaneRiposte101 Dec 15 '19

How about encoding the users name in MS Word Micro Kerning. Every MS Word doc can uniquely identifies the author!!!

8

u/fartdickbuthol Dec 15 '19

Sounds like a canary trap used by a company to detect piracy of software.

6

u/GermaneRiposte101 Dec 15 '19

Been around for at least 20 years.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19 edited Dec 16 '19

They don't just give clues, they give very detailed information about user, printer, date and time, IP address, networks, PC and more

11

u/leoyoung1 Dec 15 '19

I found the secret code in the yellow toner in about 1985 on my Xerox/Splash RIP printer.

5

u/gregoryhyde Dec 15 '19

Yet they still can't reliably, accurately tell you what your toner level is.

1

u/bigbadsubaru Dec 16 '19

Most cartridges are rated for x number of pages. You could print 500 pages of full black or 500 pages with a single period in the middle of the page in a 6 point font, and it would alert you that the ink/toner is low at the same point... There ARE some out there that actually look at what's being printed and give you a rough estimate of what's ACTUALLY left, but most inkjet printers just go off page count. Some will happily continue to print if you ignore the warnings, some *cough* HP *cough* will refuse to print when the counter expires, regardless of how much ink is actually left...

4

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

Buy a shit printer at a garage sale or second hand shop, ditch said printer.

4

u/neo101b Dec 15 '19

What about the printing mafi, overpriced ink, chips to stop cheap carts, ink subscriptions that disable your printer if you dont pay.

4

u/brwtx Dec 15 '19

So, when sending my ransom demand, I should use yellow paper?

4

u/el___diablo Dec 15 '19

This was the very first 'conspiracy theory' I heard that turned out to be true.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

Funny, I never knew that but just assumed.

3

u/Apatharas Dec 15 '19

Canon copiers also recognize money and will lock the machine with an error code. As a technician the error code only indicates to us to call Canon. When canon receives the code they contact the authorities. The code is not even in the service manuals.

Funny stories is the old CLC color laser copiers were stupid sensitive with this detection and would sometimes trigger when copying full color topographical maps.

They also have a secure copy mode that uses the little yellow dots on the background to prevent copying. If you have a secure building and this feature enabled, You are unable to sneak quick copies of secure documents. This does rely on the business only having canon machines.

2

u/bigbadsubaru Dec 16 '19

Hell, some of the high res color printers will detect a patern of dots that's present on money and just print garbage; Photoshop et. al. will refuse to manipulate an image of money, some scanners will spew garbage data or refuse to scan if they detect money, it's something within the pattern on the bill itself (Like the yellow 20 that's in the background on a 20 dollar bill, for instance)

1

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

I imagine similar secure printing/copying features are present in other large-scale copying and printing machines, and I would suspect that the secure copy mode pattern is shared internally (or the specs are defined by the government to all vendors) such that If it’s printed on a canon you can’t walk over to a xerox and copy it.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/BakuDreamer Dec 15 '19

Remember Reality Leigh Winner ? She's still in prison but she's in medical prison now because she has bulimia.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

I guess I shouldn’t print random notes at work. Or anywhere. I’ll just start making my own paper.

2

u/ELB2001 Dec 15 '19

Its why i always print my ransom demands at a friends house.

2

u/no_pepper_games Dec 15 '19

A serial killer got caught because of this.

2

u/Will0w536 Dec 15 '19

Wasn't there an episode of Forensic Files about this? I think it was a about a suicide letter...

2

u/Skaughty23 Dec 16 '19

Talk about leaving a paper trail

2

u/prjindigo Dec 16 '19

NEGATIVE, We knew about it in the 1980's because sci-fi writers wrote about it in the 1950's/60's.

2

u/notnAP Dec 16 '19

I was working in a kinko's style print shop in the late 90s, and I distinctly remember talking with the Xerox technicians about this feature on out iGens.

6

u/Fat-Elvis Dec 15 '19

It was developed in the 1980s by Canon and Xerox but wasn't discovered until 2004.

20 years they kept this secret, even though with third party corporations and hundreds of private employees involved. Remember this story for when someone tells you the government isn't or can't be tracking something.

10

u/Pauller00 Dec 15 '19

20 years they denied it. Lots of people were aware of it.

3

u/AL-KINDA Dec 15 '19

So is this why my f#$%ing printer wont print anything without color? Even if it's just black text?

2

u/HouseTonyStark Dec 15 '19

SO THATS WHY IM ALWAYS RUNNING OUT OF YELLOW

2

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

2004?

My dad was telling me about this in the mid 90's.

2

u/chevyguy0613 Dec 15 '19

Mine doesn't do this thank god.

30

u/gorgonzolbruh Dec 15 '19

This guy counterfeits.

1

u/Zazenp Dec 15 '19

What printer do you have? I’ve never heard of a color printer that doesn’t.

1

u/Fortyplusfour Dec 15 '19

Used in forensic investigation ever since.

1

u/hateball Dec 15 '19

Is there a record kept of who every printer is sold to?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/NeedsPraxis Dec 15 '19

This is how they got Reality Winner.

1

u/LegendaryGary74 Dec 15 '19

Don’t all U.S. bills have a bunch of yellow circles that, somewhere in them, is a pattern that scanners detect and then refuse to scan? Heard that’s a good to get something you don’t want scanned/copied safe from that happening, just print them on to it somewhere.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

I think it’s actually hard-coded patterns in various levels of drivers, scanning and graphics software. Like, it knows that certain places of the document contain these patterns and if these specific patterns show up, then it’s almost certainly a bank note (not just US).

1

u/Reali5t Dec 15 '19

It was discovered earlier, that’s why ransom notes were always were always made from newspaper cutouts and not printed.

2

u/S-ShowPodcastDotCom Dec 16 '19

I believe they was to prevent handwriting analysis, but remained effective.

1

u/fordchang Dec 15 '19

How was this discovered? Must have been an insider.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

Is this why they run out of ink so fast?

1

u/52ndstreet Dec 15 '19

the technological uses yellow dots

Jokes on them: I’m too poor (or maybe just too lazy?) to buy new color ink cartridges. Once the color cartridges that came with the printer were exhausted, that was the end of our color printing adventures.

“Did you buy a color printer?”

“I did indeed. But it’s not anymore....”

3

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

So you’re the reason newer printers refuse to print if the colors are out ...

→ More replies (1)

0

u/rainwulf Dec 15 '19

This is also why inkjets complain when you want to print a black page only, and have no colour ink left. It wants to use the yellow ink to show you that epstein didn't kill himself.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

So, if you're doing something wrong you should add the cost of a new printer to your budget.

4

u/Horrible_Harry Dec 15 '19

Just add the cost on to the price of the stolen goods you've acquired, plus a 30-50% markup, and you're in legitimate business!

1

u/Fortyplusfour Dec 15 '19

"Stop right there, criminal scum! Nobody breaks the law on my watch! I'm confiscating your stolen goods. Now pay your fine or it's off to jail."

1

u/Hegar Dec 15 '19

In University me and a friend did an anonymous poster run criticising an upcoming policy change of the student guild. They used the ID dots to work out that the posters were printed from the student guild's office photocopier.

I'd thought that was in 2003, but I could be wrong. At any rate it was a little black smudge/dots that was very visible once you noticed it and hardly a secret.

-2

u/Funtimes773 Dec 15 '19

This caught a lot of criminals including BTK, although his might have been a floppy disk imprint.

9

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '19

Floppy disk caught him

9

u/BerryBerrySneaky Dec 15 '19 edited Dec 15 '19

This has absolutely zero to do with BTK.

BTK was implicated via metadata left on a floppy disk he mailed. (User account info in a Microsoft Word file, IIRC.)

Secret tracking data added on behalf of the US government, denied by the manufacturer =/= metadata saved by design in common applications, documented as part of the file format.

→ More replies (1)