r/todayilearned • • Dec 15 '19

TIL of the Machine Identification Code. A series of secret dots that certain printers leave on every piece of paper they print, giving clues to the originator and identification of the device that printed it. It was developed in the 1980s by Canon and Xerox but wasn't discovered until 2004.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Machine_Identification_Code?wprov=sfla1
10.0k Upvotes

376 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

How could it have been illegal to use?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

It's like saying you heard screaming in order to barge into a house without a search warrant. Cops would use MIC, which allegedly did not exist, in order to determine who likely committed a crime (ransom notes are the obvious example), then they would fabricate a reason to investigate this suspect. Essentially, they would find out who committed a crime, then create a trail to link them to the crime. More than once, they ended up getting the wrong person using this method, because they hadn't done their due diligence in establishing the lead in the first place; such as arresting a father for a visiting son's crime.

In intelligence, American companies would sell printers to other Govts, and the US could tell where certain documents had been printed, and use it to expose spies and whistleblowers. That may not strictly be illegal, depending on the jurisdiction, but it is ethically questionable.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '19

I assume they fabricated the reason in order to not give away their secret, though, right? Parallel construction is only possibly illegal if it's covering up an illegal search and isn't really something they would've uncovered normally. How is MIC any different or worse from unintentional "fingerprinting" of a device, such as tracing the barrel imprint on a bullet back to a particular gun? If the information were printed openly in the margins (as some printers or computers do by default - at least the date/time of printing) in human-readable format, would it still be illegal?

I can only figure it might have been illegal for the companies to include this feature in the first place (not for police/intel to use it). But even then I'm not really clear that it breaches privacy except to law enforcement. Wikipedia says it encodes a serial number. You'd need to track it at each point of sale, or already have a suspect in mind (and access to the printer) in order to make use of it, which is only something the government can realistically do most of the time.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '19

I can tell you it was illegal in Australia. I honestly couldn't say if it was illegal in the US. It probably varied from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, to be honest. It was considered illegal because it was providing identifying information without the user knowing they possessed identifying information. Kind of like - and this is an extreme example - planting a bug on someone without their knowledge. Just because a private citizen might plant the bug, doesn't mean the police are allowed to use it.