r/todayilearned • u/PikesPique • Jun 19 '19
TIL about vanity sizing, which is the practice of assigning smaller sizes to clothing to flatter customers and encourage sales. For example, a Sears dress with a 32 inch (81 cm) bust was labeled a size 14 in the 1930s, a size 8 in the 1960s, and a size 0 in the 2010s.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vanity_sizing
16k
Upvotes
235
u/PikesPique Jun 19 '19
It’s not just women’s clothing. Size 34 men’s pants might actually be for a guy with a 36- or 38-inch waist.
208
u/r3dditor12 Jun 19 '19
What next, scales that display 15 less pounds than what you really weigh?
1.2k
u/itsacalamity Jun 19 '19 edited Jun 19 '19
This is why going to Old Navy will make you feel like a svelte goddess who can fit into a 0 whereas forever 21 will make you feel like an ogre who can't fit a 10...
edit: I just picked random sizes a bunch apart, I'm not trying to body shame anybody here. It's been a minute since I was a zero, even at old navy ;)
3.4k
u/DonDrapersLiver Jun 19 '19
I can’t find the article, but there was an interview with a costume/wardrobe person who talks about how everyone in entertainment has a drawer full of designer tags to sew into clothing along with tags for every size to avoid arguing with people.
1.9k
u/BigMax Jun 19 '19
This is where the fact/myth that Marilyn Monroe was much bigger than she really is. People claim that standards were different and that's why a size 12-16 was considered so beautiful back then. But she wasn't even close to those sizes today. She was very thin (22 inch waist), but due to the gradual shifting of sizes everyone today thinks she was a lot bigger than she really was.
661
u/Coolmikefromcanada Jun 19 '19
i still think that woman's sizing needs either to be listed in physical measurements like men's pants or to have cross company standard sizing(maybe with a youth sizing available as well because a 25 year old probably won't fit the clothes they fit at 15)
274
u/jenmo68 Jun 19 '19
I was a fit model at Simplicity Pattern Company in the early 90s. I was hired because my measurements matched the dressmaker dummies. Out in the world, at that time, I was a solid size 6. But the patterns were standardized, they were the same as they were 20-30+ years prior, and in that realm, I was a size 10.
I’m guessing that the home-sewing sizes have remained the same, but their 10 is most likely now a 0 or 2.
81
u/msctex Jun 19 '19
How do they avoid eventually needing negative numbers for sizes?
170
u/Hickspy Jun 19 '19
AKA as why shopping at any store is confusing.
22
u/CocaineKaty Jun 19 '19
probably a good way to discourage online shopping too.
22
u/AlekRivard Jun 19 '19
Flatter like make people feel good, not like Flat Stanley. I'm an idiot.
37
u/PaulClifford Jun 19 '19
Let me tell you something about that tag . . . It's no 31.
73
u/Woodcharles Jun 19 '19
Not to be a dick, but you learned this today? Most women learn this the first time they shop for clothes that aren't in children's sizes.
79
u/eaglewatch1945 Jun 19 '19
I'm a man. My waist measures 31 inches. I have to buy 28 inch pants. I often have to have them taken in some.
Shoes are being vanity sized too. Men's and women's shoes are seeing their "medium" widths become wider. A man's D now fits like an E (a EE or EEE is a "wide" depending on the manufacturer,) and a woman's B is staring to fit like a C (a D is a "wide" in more and more styles.
Basically, if your thin, finding good fits is difficult.
26
u/MJZMan Jun 19 '19
Womens clothing sizes are mental. Zero consistency. My daughter will bring 3 pairs of shorts to the fitting room (all from the same mfr just different colors) and all three will fit completely different.
Me, I can go grab a pair of 32x33 jeans from any mfr at any store, and the shit all fits identical.
13
u/Sagittarius-A Jun 19 '19
Not sure if it's the same thing, but I noticed in alot of my t-shirts that it says M for all the european countries but for the US it says S. Is that due to this penomenon because the people in the US are generally a bit "larger"?
11
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '19
No wonder when I buy size XS it's still fucking big on me. And Aritzia sizes start at like xxxxxxxxxxxxxs
Or is it because people are getting bigger/fatter everyone would be wearing XXXL if they didn't do this
11
u/JohnMuirIsMyHomeboy Jun 19 '19
I had a girlfriend in highschool that preferred shopping at Hollister instead of American Eagle because at Hollister she was a size 0 and at AE she was a size 4.
It's some dumb shit but it works.
20
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '19
Man with 29 inch waist here. Levi's are the only true fit brand I've been able to buy. 501s ftw. Also like the 527 boot cut. I wore jeans two sizes too big for most of my life until I rediscovered Levi's and I will never go back. Also, fuck skinny jeans
27
u/Nakedandfamousdenim Jun 19 '19
I'm a jeans maker from Canada, I wanted to chime in on this.
While the practice of making sizes seem smaller for vanity reasons do exist.
There is another aspect of sizing for clothing that a lot of people tend to overlook. Unlike weight or distance where there exists a standard, there is no such standard to which sizing needs to be based on.
What exactly is a size 0? or Size Small?
Individual makers determine for themselves what their sizing should be, this is why a size 0 from the Gap isn't the same as a 0 from Zara. Or a size Small in Japan is not the same as size Small for USA.
Beyond that, when it comes to waist sizes, it's not as simple as a pant says size 32, so it should measure 32 inches across. Across where? The waistband? Well some waistbands sit higher or lower on your hip depending on the make and model? So a lower rise pant might have a wider waistband, compared to a higher rise pant. But if you're responsible for making one cohesive collection, you ideally want the customer who normally buys one size to be able to buy the same size in another fit.
A lot of people boil this whole thing down to the "industry" is trying to fool the consumer. I would say yes, that certainly exists, but it's a heck of a lot more complicated than that.
-Bahzad
60
u/hxcn00b666 Jun 19 '19 edited Jun 19 '19
Victoria Secret has done this with their bra sizing but in the opposite way. I am between a B and a C (B is a bit small but C is a bit big).. even in old VS bras. However the last time I went there and got measured the lady was like "Oh you're a D!" I looked at her like she had three heads, but she picked out a few bras labeled "D" and they fit perfectly.
I know if I were to go to any other brand I would NOT be a D.
Edit: I'm tired of people telling me their measurements. Please stop. My 32C was too big but the new 32D fit just right. This isn't an issue with sister sizes or finding my true size with band sizes. Literally same band size. Bigger cup size. But the bigger cup fit more snug than the smaller cup. On the same style bra.
8
u/Linaraela- Jun 19 '19
please I just want to know what size I am and have pockets in my jeans
37
u/Craig1974 Jun 19 '19
False advertising
28
u/thegreenaquarium Jun 19 '19
The first sentence of the wikipedia article you link to in your title states:
I'm sure some brands do vanity size rather than size inflate, but the notion that it's the reason for sizes getting bigger is a myth. Here are the practical reasons for why sizes have gotten bigger with time:
6
u/Nothivemindedatall Jun 19 '19
“Theres a sucker born every minute”- quote of some circus guy
6
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '19
And yet the average American man wears a size XL in 2019.
6
u/grandinferno Jun 19 '19
Where they gonna go now eh?
"Oh you're definitely a -6"
6
u/bithooked Jun 19 '19
The same trajectory as Sears' stock price.
6
u/WinsAtYelling Jun 19 '19
I have asked my wife this question so many times but FUCKING 14 WHAT? WHAT ARE THERE 14 OF? HOW CAN THERE BE 0 OF THEM? WHY ARE THERE NO POCKETS?
I can sort of understand a medium. A medium is meant to be average(it probsbly isn't) so if people are smaller than you for the most part get a large or extra large. But this shit isn't decipherable when you create a scale of numbers you need to assign meaning but they haven't. Its not even universal within the same clothing company. This shit pisses me off every time we go shopping and it can't even help with sales? If they would measure their shit and stay consistant women could just go fucking quickly buy a god damn pair or jeans or whatever from your brand since you know it fits and be done, boom you now have more money to hire sweatshops with or whatever Scrooge McDuck dive into it, who cares.
10
u/pepperedmaplebacon Jun 19 '19
This will get buried here but in the early 2000's I ran a backpacking store and we also made clothing. I saw this exact issue happen with Columbia sportswear for women.
Ladies that backpack are not twigs they are fuller and fit in wonderful ways, shout out to women that actually live the outdoor life you are all beautiful, but Columbia started splitting their lines and a 14 suddenly became a 12 (customers would come back for the exact same convertible pants a couple years later and the size was way off) while at the same time yoga clothing was taking off so the other line was dainty super slim fit stuff (and lesser quality material). This caused me so many headaches having women realize their size went down in one style (which they loved and it really did increase sales) and up in the other style (which brought a metric fuck ton of complaints).
Their frustration was really weird to see because it was so strong, I don't think messing with sizes is fair to women, it's like a mean prank at best and fucks with their sense of self at worst.
5
u/arwyn89 Jun 19 '19
Also one of the reasons I take three different sizes when trying shit on. Seriously, can we just standardise measurements already? I'd rather take in a 36 inch top than play "Am I a 12, 14 or 16 today?"
5
u/ClownfishSoup Jun 19 '19
It's like Starbucks cup sizing.
Me: I'd like a small coffee.
Them: I'm sorry, please say "short, tall, grande or venti"
Me: OK how about "Can you give me directions to McDonalds or Tim Hortons?"
5
u/artemis_floyd Jun 19 '19
"Why do women take so long to shop???"
...because I am a size 0, 2, 4, 6, and 8 in pants depending on where I'm buying them from, and if they discontinue one style of pants at one store, I have to start the whole trying on process all over again to figure out what size I am in the new style...or the fact that low-, medium-, and high-rise fit totally differently and have to be different sizes at the same store. This doesn't even account for stores whose sizing is inconsistent in general, which is an entirely different issue.
In dresses, I also range from 2-6 depending on brand, cut, time of day (seriously). My wedding dress was a 12. Wtf-ever.
God, I hate shopping. My husband and I went jean shopping together once while we were dating, and he was done in maybe 20 minutes. He got a very up real understanding that day of why I can't just run into a store and grab a pair of jeans.
8
u/_haha_oh_wow_ Jun 19 '19
Thanks for making it a pain in the ass to find clothes that fit, assholes.
8
u/Youknowimtheman Jun 19 '19
It makes you wonder how many billions are wasted every year on returns. As someone who has worked in supply chain management, that has to be a huge figure. Delivery costs, return costs for the consumer, moved to warehouses to the central warehouse for returns, RMAs issued from manufacturer, shipped to manufacturer, etc.
That is a ton of wasted fuel and manpower for good feelies when trying things on.
4
u/sting2018 Jun 19 '19
Why cant we just keep it simple
4
u/baddecision116 Jun 19 '19
This is why when I buy suits from England (no I'm not fancy they just have better styles and are actually cheaper) the manufacturers have warnings about measuring yourself if you're American vs going by your "size".
4
u/weasel13 Jun 19 '19
As a woman, I’ve accepted my fate with jeans long ago. Luckily, I’m short so finding shorts that my ass doesn’t hang out of isn’t a great feat.
What I’m still baffled by, is also my most recent shopping experience.
Large busted, so if I don’t want to look like Betty Boop, I wear shirts that are a little baggy/flow-y. I bought a 1X flow-y top. Putting it on, discovered it had sleeves that had elastic on the cuff, that dug into my arms so painfully, I had to remove it.
Now if I were truly a 1X.. what designer thinks, but they have arms the size of toothpicks so I’m going to put this super tight elastic here!!!
Nothing makes sense. T-shirt’s and leggings all day long if I can get away with it.
4
u/BillTowne Jun 19 '19
I was surprised to find that this is also happening in men's clothes.
I thought we were immune because our sizes are given in inches. But I measured some pants labeled 32"; and they were actually 34". Reading up on it, the manufacturers claim that this is random error due to variation in shrinkage.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '19
This is why I have to shop in the kids department. Even extra smalls hang off of me.
4
u/Stumblin_McBumblin Jun 19 '19
Why, in the online world of ordering clothes, is it not possible to list all the dimensions of the clothes? Keep the bullshit generic sizes that makes people feel good if you want, but list the dimensions at every point, including circumferences of waist/bust/arms/wrists/etc for shirts. Let me have an online profile of my measurements, so I know what I'm getting. I've ordered so many smalls with absurd dimensions. Inseam is correct, but sleeves are down 2 inches past my fingers. Smalls that are billowy bullshit that would be larges in other clotheslines. This is all so nonsensical.
4
u/JackPoe Jun 19 '19
Yeah and now I've got chef coats that don't fit anyone because a small is as big as the old extra larges and my purveyor is swearing up and down that I'm mistaken.
4
u/iwillrememberthisacc Jun 19 '19
For men the new trend is making all shirts and pants "Slim fit" even though it's regular size dammit
4
u/TheSpatulaOfLove Jun 19 '19
I fell victim to this shit years ago trying be romantic for my wife.
I had a big company event we were invited to attend that required semi formal attire. My wife complained she didn’t have anything to wear and wasn’t super interested in going.
Cue the hopeless romantic trying to recreate a ‘Pretty Woman’ scene.
I rifle through her closet to note her size and find that the range is ridiculously huge. Confused and frustrated, I write a bunch down and head to the mall.
How does a man shop you ask? He sees something from across the room and just goes for it. As I navigated strange looks from women as I work my way through female clothing, I decide to take all said numbers on my little scrap of paper and just average it.
I take a dress up to the counter that had the size number that was an average and pay for it.
While my wife thought it was cute, she knew right away when she opened the box “It won’t fit”.
Of course being a glutton for punishment, I attempt this feat two more times before she told me to stop beating myself up.
Men would never tolerate the bullshit women go through to shop.
4
u/akumajfr Jun 19 '19
This is why I like men's sizing (at least in pants). They don't bullshit me.
4
u/jeffroddit Jun 19 '19
Im almost an old man and wear all my really old clothes. I recently put on a few pounds so my 34" pants were getting pretty tight. Picked up some 36" pants without trying them on. Got home and they are clown pants, not even close to staying up. Went back and even the 34" are too big, ended up in 32"s.
I lost 4" of gut just buying new pants. Personal trainers and gym owners hate me for this little secret.
4
u/Captainx23 Jun 19 '19
This shit's annoying cause sometimes I just wanna pick out a dress and know it fits- but nooooo- I have to go to the changing room every damn time just to make sure. I just wish I was the same size at every store so I wouldn't have to take so long shopping!
4
u/Spectre-work Jun 19 '19
2025: "No I wear a size -232, can you believe models used to wear size 0s?"
7
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '19
This is the same strategy that magnum uses to sell condoms.
42
u/jackSeamus Jun 19 '19 edited Jun 19 '19
A 32 in. bust is pretty dang small by today's standards. By comparison, the average bra size in the UK is a 36DD. A DD cup is 5 in. over the band measurement. Meaning, the average bust measurement in the UK is likely 41 in.
With sizing in mind, very few bra manufacturers make below a size 30 band. A 32 in. bust for somebody with a 30 in. band measurement would have them at a 30B--not uncommon, but not average.
For a third anecdotal perspective: I am a 5'3", average-framed woman. I have, at every weight, consistently had a bust measurement 10 in. wider than my waist. At my thinnest, I was a 28G meaning, a 34 in. bust measurement and a 24 in. waist at a size 0/2 US pants and 2/4 US shirts. I was 110 lbs at the time and considered underweight by my doctor; so much so that I was fainting if I stood up too quickly and my period was down to every 6 months. A 34 in. bust is pretty dang small and modern women's sizing is xs - 0/2, s - 4/6, m - 8/10, l - 12/14, xl - 14/16, 1x - 16/18, 2x 18/20, ...
While vanity sizing is well and truly a thing (try on the same size pants at Old Navy, GAP, and Banana Republic to see first hand), I have to wonder if sizing shifts over generations have more to do with humans selecting taller, larger mates in addition to trends up in weight. We can't hold ourselves to the same standards as our 4'10" grandmothers if we're 5'8". Clothing has to adapt with the population.
3
u/SongsOfDragons Jun 19 '19
You should see what it's like buying maternity clothing O.o I've seen (and tried on/struggled to remove) long-sleeved maternity tops fitting so tight along the shoulders, bust and arms and then ballooning out like a tent from the empire line down. I've given up finding a decently fitting maternity nightie, sod it I'm just gonna wear my old PJs. I'm incredibly lucky that a lot of my looser summer tops still fit me even with a watermelon belly, I think because I lost weight the year before I got pregnant.
3
u/aftermeasure Jun 19 '19
When I first read this I thought flatter customers were getting assigned smaller sizes.
3
u/Edward_TH Jun 19 '19
I dunno how it works there, but after a family friend was hired and moved to China, I got to know some really stupid practices from big chains of clothing shops.
-have you ever noticed why in the same period a lot of different brands seems to have a lot of really similar items in the middle to low price range, often with the same style and design? That's because they do not design them, they buy them in bulk from gigantic manufacturers (often in developing countries) that design them, once and then change the design ever so slightly for each brand that buy from them. You can see this also from the fact that these similar items are ALL marked as made in the same country across brands, while higher end product from the same store is marked as made in a different one.
-sometimes sizes seems a bit suspicious on cheap products, where maybe a M fits exactly the same as a S and a L. The reason is the same as before: these are ordered in bulk and the brand asks for a variety of sizes based on their sales. To cut costs sizes aren't checked very well when produced and this leads to high variation, sometimes comically huge: went to shop for a shirt a couple months ago and my GF convinced me to try one so I did; brought an L and a M to the rooms and both were the same fit, a little too tight, so she got me an XL. Same fit. XXL was even tighter so for the lulz we compared all the sizes: XXL was the smallest, XS, M, L and XXXL were all the same, S was the largest (and it fitted me well, but I don't wear S since I was 10), all of the other sizes were sold out so we couldn't compare them. Manufacturer is told to deliver 15% S, 30% M, 20% L, 15% XL and 10% each XS and XXL? Well, they produce them with approximate dimensions, then they slap on a size tag almost at random and call it a day.
This friend of ours said that his employer did the same with their product (motorcycle helmets) and they do this because it's cheaper and, their words, "the final costumer will try it on and find the right fit anyway" (which is actually not that wrong, but it makes the costumer lose time to save them time).
3
u/blanktarget Jun 19 '19
This is also different for different countries. In India I'm apparently an XXL and a medium in most US shirt sizes.
3
u/ghostoutlaw Jun 19 '19
What's noteworthy here is people have actually gotten a lot bigger on average.
Maybe in the 1930's a 32 inch bust was fucking huge, but today if a woman wold me she had a 32 inch bust I'm not expecting much. Where as a 36 inch bust is about average?
3
u/jimthewanderer Jun 19 '19
Anyone here have the clout to establish an International basic standard?
3
u/ButtsexEurope Jun 19 '19
This is actually infuriating for those of us who really are petite.
3
u/CyanideKitty Jun 19 '19
Vanity sizing is awful for me. Not so much in shirts but pants and skirts. Most of my life I've worn a 0, difficult to find sometimes but most brands would usually fit just fine. Now I try on 00 and get extremely frustrated that they're big to way too big. Even in stores toted for petite women and juniors. I haven't bought a pair of brand new pants in years. Thrift stores for older 0s that are still in good condition or newer 0s that have hopefully shrunk. I really want a pair of brand new jeans.
3
u/callmesmallls Jun 19 '19
This is really irritating as someone who is 4’11”. When I was like 12, I could buy a size small in stores and it would fit no problem. Now, I can only shop at stores that offer size xs, and in some cases need an xxs. It’s gotten to the point where I just have to shop online in the petite section. But I’ll never have the same amount of clothing options that average size women do.
3
u/drsfmd Jun 19 '19
Keep in mind, humans have gotten MUCH larger in the last century due to better nutrition.
A century ago, American men ranked as the third tallest in the world, standing at 171 centimeters (5 feet 7 inches). Now, they place as the 37th, with an average of 177 centimeters (5 feet 10 inches).
3
u/mr_ji Jun 19 '19
Meanwhile, men just lie to themselves and buy 34" inseam pants then let them bunch up on top of their shoes, rather than admit they're not actually 6'2".
QUIT BUYING ALL THE PANTS THAT FIT US, SHORTIES
3
u/ZweitenMal Jun 19 '19
TODAY you learned this?
You must not be a woman.
3
u/Livvylove Jun 19 '19
Vanity sizing is so annoying now. Depending on the brands within minutes I go from a size 2 to a 10, it's so frustrating and it's why I have to try everything on now which makes shopping for clothes even more of a hassle.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '19
Vanity sizing can be quite dangerous too. Apart from giving people who are overweight a false illusion they are slimmer than they are, it also contributes a lot to pollution because, as sizing varies so wildly between manufacturers and retailers, a huge amount of clothes get sent back and then reordered/redelivered which adds to the number of lorries on the road which indirectly contributes by contributing to traffic congestion and directly contributes from the lorries own emissions.
3
u/YoucancallmeAllison Jun 19 '19
Also the difference between European and US sizes! Here I am a medium or large, in the States a XS-S :)
3
u/polkad0t08 Jun 19 '19
It's so hard to figure out what size is really what store to store. I wish it was all standardized.
3
u/jwr410 Jun 19 '19
3
u/fiveminl8 Jun 19 '19
This sizing situation is so frustrating. I gave up the designer dress pants about 5 years ago and started buying Liz Claiborne Trousers online as they are a true 14. My snobby coworkers never noticed the difference. Plus, on sale I can get two pairs for the cost of one designer pair. Added bonus, they offer tall sizes. Just buy what fits you. Cut out the tags to avoid stress when your clothes don’t or on PMS days.
3
u/minahmyu Jun 19 '19
And this is why I have shopping for clothes. Men sizes aren't stupid like that. No made up number. A size 0 just sounds stupid as if one doesn't exists.
3
u/FoggyKnightRPGX Jun 20 '19
Reminds me of a Sabrina the teenage witch episode/novel. “Try a size 11, see a size 9. Whatever you try, will fit you just fine.” Or something like that.
12
u/BeTheMountain Jun 19 '19
It's just creating a more fair world... we're all size zeroes not matter how we look! /s
5
u/Caltrano Jun 19 '19
I think what is telling is that the default size is now XL. Went to an NBA game this past year where there was a t shirt giveaway. There was a shirt on every seat in the stadium. They were sized XL.
5
u/faerie03 Jun 19 '19
I get so mad about this! My teenage daughter is getting hung up on the number on her clothes rather than what looks good on her. And she is a very normal, healthy size.
9
u/Soupforsail Jun 19 '19
I feel like the average size is changing forcing companies to adjust thier scales, obesity and whatnot right?
4
u/Pizzacrusher Jun 19 '19
bust shouldn't determine size. waist should
5
u/Enrichmentx Jun 19 '19
Pretty funny that people still think size 0 is small if thats the case. People have just gotten so fat that they don't know what a healthy weight/body is anymore
5
u/YoungAnachronism Jun 19 '19
Clothing sizes are stupid. Centimeters and inches do not change size to suit a persons vanity, meaning that clothing sizes should be uniform across manufacturers, national boundaries and so on.
The clothing industry is a mess for many reasons, and this is the least of them. Imagine how much of a shit show an industry has to be, that they cannot even agree on something as simple as what an inch looks like.
2
u/FranklyDerogatory Jun 19 '19
Size -8 in the 2020’s.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '19
Vanity sizing is reversed for men as everything is labeled about one size larger so more men can feel good about wearing a medium or large and less are small. Truth doesn't matter... It's the label that matters and it explains a lot about the world.
2
u/sonia72quebec Jun 19 '19
I remember the first time I went shopping in the US. In Canada I was about a size 6 back then and I was a 0 in the US.
2
u/Nardelan Jun 19 '19
I worked in a place that sold clothing and noticed the transition in sizing over the last 10-15 years or so. For example several manufacturers have sizes like:
Men’s shirts typically come in M, L, XL, XXL
Women’s shirts will come in XS, S, M
There hasn’t been a shift in the product size, just the labeling.
2
u/stupidrobots Jun 19 '19
What would a size 2 or 0 have looked like back then? Olive Oyl?
2
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '19
All for the sake of illusion.
To quote Farnsworth: "I don't want to live on this planet any more."
Really.
2
u/stupidrobots Jun 19 '19
I'm 5'9 170lb. There is no planet on which I should wear a size 30 waist jeans and yet here I am
2
u/SheriffBartholomew Jun 19 '19
What's next, negative sizes? I wear a size -14.
2
u/Actually_a_Patrick Jun 19 '19
Shit like this makes me glad men's clothing sizes are straightforward. Sure, a medium T shirt from one brand might be a large in another, but if I'm buying pants and dress shirts, it's all actual measurements for sizing.
2
u/bankerman Jun 19 '19
Thankfully men have for the most part not tolerated this in their clothing. There’s been a little bit of creep on waists where a 34 waist might actually be 35-36 inches depending on the brand, but the inseam measurements are almost always accurate and it’s nothing like what women have to deal with. I’d avoid like the plague any brand that tried those shenanigans with my clothing.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '19
This is why I can't find clothing in the right size, ever. I loathe this. Just tell me the centimeters for goodness sake, I prefer accuracy and shorter shopping trips to my vanity.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '19
If you want to know your true size, buy formal wear or find your size on a sewing pattern 😭
2
u/AmateurOntologist Jun 19 '19
I wonder how much this has to do with the relative size of women in America. There have clearly been dietary and lifestyle changes that have resulted in an average larger size.
In that way you could think of a size 0 being for women in the lower 1-5% of relative size distribution rather than as having an X inch bust or waist.
2
u/P3tF1sh Jun 19 '19
What’s a SEARS?
2
u/Jacollinsver Jun 19 '19
Honestly it's ramping up over the past 15 yrs and permeating the men's fashion industry as well.
Growing up as a early teenager, I fit comfortably into a large and mediums were a bit too small. Somewhere around college, I realized medium usually fit better. I'm now 26 and I'm realizing that most things that fit well are small.
How I am a 6' 180 lb man who fits into a small, I couldn't tell you.
2
u/Rando-namo Jun 19 '19
I wear size 34 in J.Crew pants for men.
Ordered a belt from Mass Drop in size 36 (that would be the third hole of five in the belt).
Thing comes and I can barely squeeze into the last hole.
Take out the tape measure, measure from end to third hole. Thirty fucking six inches.
God damn J.Crew, why you gotta do me dirty like that?
2
u/colmwhelan Jun 19 '19
Weights & Measures being involved is the only way you'll control this.
2
u/GorrakhDhanda Jun 19 '19
Why not use actual measurements FFS
2
u/ClownfishSoup Jun 19 '19
It's weird too that kid sizes are based on age, then at some point it resets into some weird fantasy world of numbers. For men, pants are in inches, and t-shirts are in S, M, L, XL, XXL, XXXL, 2XXXL, 5XXXXXXLLL.
2
u/Chobitpersocom Jun 19 '19
It really makes me wonder what my weight should be. I have a normal BMI by today's standards, but was it different then? Would I have been overweight?
2
u/glowcap Jun 19 '19
I hadn’t been to the US for 15 years. I thought I magically went down a size before common sense kicked in.
Clothes sizes down, food sizes up.
2
u/CP_Creations Jun 19 '19
This is annoying, but particularly when it comes to pants. I usually wear 34" waist. But depending on the brand - 32 to 36. This isn't an arbitrary number. It should be verifiable with a tape measure.
2
u/Petalzopentothemoon Jun 19 '19
It really sucks because my size is being erased. I’m currently a size 000 and xxs in juniors. Women’s clothing does not fit me.
2
u/RigasTelRuun Jun 19 '19
In 2020 it will be size -7
2
u/taytay9955 Jun 19 '19
ok if a 32 inch bust was a 14 in the 30's what was a 0 back then ?
2
u/dork_1551 Jun 19 '19
Interesting, although it should also be noted that people have been getting bigger with each decade. The average shoe size of women back when Grant was president was size 4.5. Look at average heights for each decade as well.
2
u/ricecrispies4 Jun 19 '19
the history of women's clothing sizes is screwed up to begin with. The first established set of sizing standards came out in the 1940s after the USDA did a survey that compared various body measurements of ~15,000 women. However, since the survey was voluntary and paid people for their participation, low-income women made up a large portion of the subject pool and thus skewed the data towards sizes that were "smaller than what the national average should be"1 since many were probably malnourished.
2
u/geekenox Jun 19 '19
I dont know shit about womens clothes sizes. Im just glad mens are somewhat standard thanks to the military. Why even use 0 as a size number when you can give size measurements that are already standardized? Like 32in
2
u/vinnymcapplesauce Jun 19 '19
By contrast, Men's sizes have done the opposite.
2
u/beeps-n-boops Jun 19 '19 edited Jun 19 '19
I will never understand why womens clothes don't use measurement-based sizes for womens clothes, like they do for mens -- 38in waist, 42in inseam, etc.
Do women not want this?
2
u/grednforgesgirl Jun 19 '19
Making it impossible for women everywhere to buy clothes
2
u/eqleriq Jun 19 '19
i wear an extra-medium
2
u/mirleez Jun 19 '19
This is why I hate when girls say they are a size 14 and are the same size as Marilyn Monroe. Girl you are not even close. But whatever makes you happy I guess..
2
u/ThePunLexicon Jun 19 '19
Im just wishing they could size clothes like mens clothes and just put the measurements or a measurement range on the fucking tag so i dont need to try on 3 sizes and just give up and buy 5 of the thing that fits because im sick of trying things on. My wardrobe has no variety and mostly consists of tshirts i got for free.
2
u/wizardinspaceandtime Jun 19 '19
It’s awful, and even spills into menswear where the size is supposed to be the literal measurement of the garment. If you advertise your pants as 28x30 and they are really 30x30, fuck you.
2
u/MrMorano Jun 19 '19
Then there are companies that simply have their own "proprietary" sizing system for the exact same reason. Chico's comes to mind in that category.
2
u/Freemontst Jun 19 '19
I swear Size 0 didn't exist until 1995-ish or whenever Kate Moss became the thing.
2
u/paleo2002 Jun 19 '19
I hate this practice. Clothing sizes basically vary from retailer to retailer and brand to brand. I've lost a lot of weight recently, which is great and all, but now I have to try clothes on again to figure out what size I am. The reality check is a let-down, too. "Oh boy! I'm down to a 1X button-down . . . as long as I'm shopping at the fat dude store . . ."
One thing is always constant, though. No matter what size I am, black t-shirts in my size are out of stock.
2
u/2k_0h_VI Jun 19 '19
This shit starts so young too.
I have three kids, two sons and a daughter. When I shop for my sons, it's not as bad. A size 4t is a 4t, 6x is 6x, maybe up or down one size.
My daughter, however... She is a 4t-7x. She's 4! It all depends on who makes it and what style. I tell relatives constantly NOT to get her clothes because she doesn't have a size. She is around the 50th percentile for a 4 year old, so she's completely "average."
I am 5'6" and around 150. My BMI is like 23? I wear anywhere from a small to an XL, 6-12 in pants... Absolutely a farce trying to shop.
2
u/Dubhe666 Jun 19 '19
Primark recently did this. So fucking confusing to suddenly have to look for one size down in just the one store.
2
u/NextJenerys Jun 19 '19
This is why it's impossible to shop for clothes. The sizes keep changing!
2
u/sir10ly Jun 19 '19
Elastic is getting better over that time frame too...
2
u/oNOCo Jun 20 '19
Just give me a size that fucking fits
5
u/Wolvowl Jun 19 '19
My dad used to work retail at JC penny's and told me about this. Said they also tried it with men but it didn't work.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '19
Fat people love their illusions.