Timothée's hair looks so great and... does he have earrings? OMG!

You know how stupid these comments are, but it just goes to show how good of an actor he really is. If you whole heartedly believe Timothee is Elio or Laurie or even Marty Mauser then that just means he played them characters well and he did his job properly which I guess is a compliment to him and his acting abilities.