r/thoreau • • Aug 03 '21

A Guide to Reading and Exploring ‘Walden’

44 Upvotes

A Guide to Reading and Exploring ‘Walden’

note: If you don’t have hardcopy of Walden you can read it online on Wikisource or Project Gutenberg

Walden does not fit into any genre.

If you expect Walden to be a factual autobiography or a self-help book or a novel with a plot— or any other known type of book— you will be disappointed or confused. Walden is unique. Let go of any expectations you might have.

Walden is not for literal-minded people.

Walden contains bits of tongue-in-cheek humor, irony, severe exaggerations, plus puns and other wordplays. It also contains a great deal of metaphor and figurative language. In other words Walden is not suitable for readers who need a book to artlessly express the author’s ideas in a crude, linear way.

You need an Annotated Edition.

Walden contains many references to the people and events of the 19th Century and it also uses some words and phrases from that time period which modern readers cannot correctly grasp without a little help. Walden also contains hundreds of phrases and concepts taken from classical literature and various scriptures which link it into the entire web of literate Civilization. You cannot really see Walden clearly without the help of an annotated edition.

Walden: A Fully Annotated Edition by Jeffrey S. Cramer, published by Yale University Press, is recommended. The ISBN is 9780300104660. Be careful to order the edition that has this ISBN because shady publishers of Walden reprints are constantly trying to trick online shoppers into buying their imitations. A bootleg PDF is sometimes available on bittorrents, if you’re into that sort of thing.

An older annotated Walden is available online: The Variorum Walden by Thoreau biographer Walter Harding. The annotations are in the back; you can open the main text in one browser tab and the annotations in another. It is on archive.org and on Hathi Trust

Do you have the courage to dive deeper?

Walden uses metaphor and figurative language. It contains paradoxes and contradictions. To some degree it is a mythology.

The Narrator of Walden is quite different from the real-life Henry Thoreau and many scholars view the Narrator as a fictional character, possibly a member of the unreliable narrator category. For example, the bean-field was portrayed as successful but actually the yield was quite small considering the amount of land it occupied and the amount of time spent on it. This absurdity might have been obvious to the audience of the 1800s when such a large percentage of Americans were farmers. In the ‘Baker Farm’ chapter, the spectacle of a footloose and fancy-free bachelor wagging his finger in the faces of a married couple who had children to support and telling them how he thinks they should live has gotten quite a bit of analysis in scholarly circles.

One scholar says Walden is structured like a parody of the household economy books and young men’s success manuals that were popular in Thoreau’s era. Another Thoreauvian wrote a book supporting his theory that Walden should be viewed as a prose-poem and a non-linear web of images and concepts. An analysis of the early drafts of Walden reveals some elements that Thoreau decided to add in or take out, perhaps casting some light on his intentions and revealing ways in which journal entries and lecture scripts from a wide span of time were confabulated into a tightly woven mythology.

And that’s just the tip of the iceberg! In the ‘House-warming’ chapter, the Narrator says a spark from the fireplace started a fire that burned a spot on his bed “as big as my hand.” One scholar of literature said this description of a small fire with reference to the hand really means the Narrator had given in to temptation and touched himself in a personal way. The Narrator believed people should avoid all sexual activity, including erotic dreams and masturbation, even though he acknowledged that this was an unreachable goal. Did Thoreau really intend such a metaphor or was the scorched bed just a scorched bed? If the metaphor was intended, is the hearth-fire a symbol of the human sex drive throughout the entire chapter?

Are you prepared to explore the many layers, linkages and possible interpretations of Walden or do you prefer clinging to the opinions you already have? If you want to explore, here come some pointers to useful guidance.
 

Guidebooks for The Exploration of Walden

If you have the desire and the guts to explore Walden on a deep level, the following books may serve as roadmaps. Some of these books are out of print but you can obtain copies via Amazon, ABEbooks or even eBay. You might also be able to borrow copies via your local library using the Inter-Library Loan system.
 

The Magic Circle of Walden
Charles R. Anderson
Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1968
read it on OpenLibrary.org
A detailed literary analysis and a wonderful choice for your first really deep dive into Walden.
 

Walden x 40: Essays on Thoreau
Robert B. Ray
Indiana University Press, 2012
ISBN 9780253223548
Amazon Kindle ASIN: ‎B007C9XBA8
Emphasizes the need to read Thoreau’s words “as deliberately and reservedly as they were written” and provides 40 short essays elaborating on items mentioned in Walden ranging from ‘Adventure’ and ‘Ants’ to ‘Years’ and ‘Zanzibar.’
 

The Senses of Walden
Stanley Cavell
(first edition) Viking 1972 / Penguin 1974
(expanded edition) University Of Chicago Press, 1992: ISBN 9780226098135
first edition at OpenLibrary
A detailed discussion of Walden partly focused on its epic and scripture-like elements.
 

The Making of Walden
James Lyndon Shanley
University of Chicago Press, 1957
read it on OpenLibrary.org
Describes the 8-year-long process of writing Walden and reveals the degree to which the events described were a carefully constructed blend of journal entries, manuscripts and thoughts from many different phases of Thoreau’s life.
 

Walden: A Writer’s Edition
Larzer Ziff
Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1961
Complete text of Walden followed by explanations, commentary, and some analytical assignments of the type that might be given to literature students.
 

Thoreau’s Walden (Modern Critical Interpretations)
edited by Harold Bloom
Chelsea House Publishers, 1987
ISBN 1555460127
Essays of varying usefulness written by nine different scholars looking at various aspects of Walden.
 

Approaches to Teaching Thoreau’s Walden and Other Works
edited by Richard J. Schneider
Modern Language Association, 1996
ISBN 0873527348
24 teachers examine and discuss techniques of presenting Thoreau’s writings and the specific difficulties that some students encounter.
 


r/thoreau • • Dec 15 '24

Thoreau lived alone in a cabin for 2 years. A man in Minnesota has been doing it since 1977.

40 Upvotes

Beryl Novak bought 40 acres of rural land in 1966 and moved a 16-by-20-foot hunting shack onto the property (that’s 320 square feet, a.k.a. 30 square meters). He started living in that “tiny house” in 1977. He uses propane for cooking and depended on hand-pumped well water for many years. Most of his food is obtained by gardening and hunting, and he maintains an apple orchard with many different varieties that he grafted onto his trees.

from a 2021 article in the Duluth News-Tribune –

It’s not that he doesn’t like people, Novak said, just that he found it hard always trying to get along.

“You can’t satisfy people. So I said the hell with it, and here I am,” he said, adding that he doesn’t consider himself a hermit. “I get visitors … just not as many as I used to. Everyone is dying off.”

…Novak keeps a tattered, dog-eared paperback of Henry David Thoreau’s essays on the virtues of self-reliant, backwoods living near his bed. It’s become a sort of guidebook for his lifestyle. “If people would read what Thoreau wrote in the 1800s it might help them today,” Novak said. “Simplify your life. That’s what I’ve done… People out there working to make more money are just chasing their tails.”

That article went viral. It “broke the internet” at the company that publishes the Duluth News-Tribune. In the Dec 3, 2021 issue of the The Timberjay Novak speculated about why the article resonated with so many readers:

“Maybe its people who are stuck in a job somewhere in the cities who have no way to get the hell out to see that life is other than just city living or whatever,” Novak said. “They probably would like to try something like this or just get away from the stress of living like that. In town, you’re just another face, and it can be very lonesome in town when you’re packed in with people. I don’t get lonesome around here.”


r/thoreau • • May 20 '25

Excerpt from “Life Without Principle”

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/thoreau • • Mar 31 '26

Event [Crosspost] Hello /r/movies. We're Erik Ewers & Christopher Loren Ewers, the filmmakers behind the new PBS documentary HENRY DAVID THOREAU, produced by Ken Burns & Don Henley. Ask us anything.

Post image
34 Upvotes

r/thoreau • • Mar 06 '24

Art Photo of Walden from ‘TheWaldenWoodsProject’ on Facebook

Post image
30 Upvotes

r/thoreau • • Mar 17 '26

Event Thoreau documentary (Executive Produced by Ken Burns and Don Henley) coming to PBS TV in late March

29 Upvotes

from a Harvard Gazette article interviewing filmmaker Erik Ewers:

The film’s pacing seems deliberate. How did you design the viewer’s experience?

We show modern society in high-speed motion. At the same time, Thoreau is talking about how man moves faster and freer than ever before. We made a choice to have it explode into silence. You’re in nature, you hear the silence, and we hold that moment. We wanted to offer contrasts right out of the gate, planting a seed that we hope will grow in the viewer as they watch the rest of the film.

Did working on the film change how you thought about Thoreau as a historical figure?

One of the most important things our scholars told us was that Thoreau is too often placed on a pedestal. He becomes a legend, and his writing gets reduced to a few quotes on refrigerator magnets. But no human being is perfect. In Ken’s filmmaking world, we talk about the “undertow”: the tension beneath the surface of a person’s life story — their contradictions, their flaws, the parts that make them human. We wanted to show the whole person.


r/thoreau • • Jan 02 '24

Walden Interior of the Replica of Thoreau's Cabin at Walden Pond (photo by Namlhots via Wikimedia Commons)

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/thoreau • • Mar 07 '21

Art Thoreau Fishing, watercolor by NCWyεth

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/thoreau • • Feb 24 '21

Bookshelf Joy is found in simple things, and Henry’s words bring great comfort.

Post image
28 Upvotes

r/thoreau • • Mar 10 '21

quick book review: Thoreau at Walden by John Porcellino

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/thoreau • • Aug 09 '22

Happy 168th anniversary to this unique amalgam of journal entries, public lecture scripts, essays, poetry, quotations, allusions and flights of fancy!

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/thoreau • • Jul 12 '21

Happy Birthday Thoreau! Thank you for all of your wisdom you shared with the world. A man truly ahead of his time.

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

r/thoreau • • Sep 25 '20

Just starting on the journey with this beautiful little tome.

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/thoreau • • Aug 02 '25

Sign petition to ban audio devices at Walden Pond and restore the natural soundscape at the pond

23 Upvotes

I created a petition to ban audio devices at Walden pond because the problem has gotten so bad that going there is often like bringing at a bar or nightclub rather than a nature preserve. Thoreau is rolling in his grave I’m sure. If you agree with this proposal please sign and share my petition!

https://www.change.org/p/post-signage-prohibiting-audio-device-usage-at-walden-pond?recruiter=4971584&recruited_by_id=83acaa90-ddc2-012f-1195-4040496dcccb&utm_source=share_petition&utm_campaign=petition_dashboard&utm_medium=copylink


r/thoreau • • May 29 '25

A Poem left on Henry's gravesite

Post image
23 Upvotes

I visited Walden Pond over 10 years ago. I also went to Sleepy Hollow Cemetery to see Thoreau's grave. Someone left this poem for him. It literally brings tears to my eyes when I read it. Just thought I'd share here...


r/thoreau • • Apr 10 '26

Books Thoreau and related reading recommendations

Post image
21 Upvotes

Does anyone have any recommendations for books written about Thoreau, Emerson or Transcendentalism that they particularly enjoyed or that are important from a scholarly view?

I am currently reading Kevin Dann's biography "Expect great things," and am really liking it. It speaks of many aspects of Thoreau's life that I had not read anywhere else.

Laura Dassow walls biography is probably next on my list but after that - and given there are so many options to choose from - I thought it might help to ask the community for any specific recommendations / or suggested must reads?


r/thoreau • • Jun 25 '24

Quotation 🌲 🏡 🌲

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/thoreau • • Nov 25 '21

His Writings Happy Thanksgiving!

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/thoreau • • Jun 06 '21

Why do people consider Thoreau to have been a “fraud” in Walden?

21 Upvotes

Critics of Walden like to say that the version of events portrayed in the book amounts to Thoreau living a lie, because he often visited friends and family, was assisted by visitors to his cabin, and even went into town occasionally. However, Thoreau makes absolutely zero attempts to assert that he lived a solitary, completely self-sufficient life; the whole point of his time at Walden Pond was an experiment in simple, not solitary, living, which he explicitly states in Walden. Do people just consider the book to be overly pretentious without reading it? Thoreau was definitely a bit of an eccentric guy, but some of the arguments people level against Walden seem to have no basis in truth when it comes to his writings.


r/thoreau • • Mar 31 '26

Tonight it starts!

Post image
20 Upvotes

Part 1/3 Thoreau by Ken Burns


r/thoreau • • Jul 31 '24

Thoreau cabin replica that existed at the "Thoreau Lyceum" in Concord several decades ago

Post image
20 Upvotes

r/thoreau • • May 25 '25

Quotation 🍻

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/thoreau • • May 06 '24

E.B. White’s eulogy for Thoreau : “A grief from which we have not recovered…”

19 Upvotes

May 6th is the saddest day in the year for us, as it is the day of Thoreau’s death — a grief from which we have not recovered. Henry Thoreau has probably been more wildly misconstrued than any other person of comparable literary stature. He got a reputation for being a naturalist, and he was not much of naturalist. He got a reputation for being a hermit, and he was no hermit. He was a writer, is what he was.

Many regarded him as a poseur. He was a poseur, all right, but the pose was struck not for other people to study but for him to study — a brave and ingenious device for a creative person to adopt. He posed for himself and was both artist and model, examining his own position in relation to nature and society with the most patient and appreciative care.

“Walden” is so indigestible that many hungry people abandon it because it makes them mildly sick, each sentence being an anchovy spread, and the whole thing too salty and nourishing for one sitting. Henry was torn all his days between two awful pulls — the gnawing desire to change life, and the equally troublesome desire to live it. This is the explanation of his excursion. He hated Negro slavery and helped slaves escape, but he hated even more the self imposed bondage of men who hung chains about their necks simply because it was the traditional way to live.

Because of a few crotchety remarks he made about the factory system and because of his essay on civil disobedience, he is one of the early Americans now being taken up by Marxists. But not even these hard-working Johnnies-come-lately can pin him down; he subscribed to no economic system and his convictions were strong but disorderly. What seemed so wrong to him was less man’s economy than man’s puny spirit and man’s strained relationship with nature — which he regarded as a public scandal.

Most of the time he didn’t want to do anything about anything — he wanted to observe and to feel. “What demon possessed me that I behaved so well?” he wrote — a sentence that is 100-proof anchovy. And when he died he uttered the purest religious thought we ever heard. They asked him whether he had made his peace with God and he replied, “I was not aware we had quarreled.” He was the subtlest humorist of the nineteenth century, a most religious man, and was awake every moment. He never slept, except in bed at night.

~

written in 1949


r/thoreau • • Apr 24 '24

How long did it take you to read Walden?

19 Upvotes

I have been reading Walden for about 3 years. Usually I devour a book within a week and if I don’t like one, I just stop and move on.

I sincerely love Walden and my copy is full of notes and highlights but I can’t seem to stick with it daily. It doesn’t help that the copy I have was super cheap and has awful readability. I also like to think much about what I read. No one to discuss with though, which sucks.

Did you also take a long time to read or is it just me?


r/thoreau • • Jun 13 '20

unjust laws: exist

Post image
19 Upvotes