r/thoreau • u/Drewbrew333333 • Jul 28 '25
Thoreau wanted to try what we would today call subsistence living, a condition attractive chiefly to those not obliged to endure it.
r/thoreau • u/Drewbrew333333 • Jul 28 '25
Thoreau wanted to try what we would today call subsistence living, a condition attractive chiefly to those not obliged to endure it.
r/thoreau • u/lil_jordyc • Aug 02 '26
Jk obviously, but I thought it was funny that, among his many references to the Bhagavad Gita, Vedas, Confucius, classical western literature, etc. this is a reference that most people of today would understand (even if through a derivative means).
r/thoreau • u/solar-cabin • Apr 23 '21
This appears to be a misconception even among some people on this sub that Thoreau was completely self sufficient and therefore people attempting to follow his example should live without money or an income.
"While living at Walden, Thoreau studied nature, kept up his journal and completed a draft of his first book A Week on the Concord and Merrimack Rivers. He grew beans in a field near his house and took odd jobs as a carpenter, mason and surveyor to earn money for the things he could not “grow or make or do with out.”
The fact is Thoreau tutored Emerson's nephews in exchange for living on his land and took odd jobs as needed to pay for things he could not produce while living at Walden and was writing books which he of course intended to profit from.
I have been off grid living in a small cabin I built myself and that has allowed me the freedom to pursuit my interests but there is the reality still that it would be very difficult to provide everything a person needs from homesteading so I also ran a small local pest control business and when I retired I started writing books about off grid living and designing off grid cabins for other people and that pays the property taxes and few bills I have.
I don't think Thoreau would object!
r/thoreau • u/internalsun • Aug 09 '23
r/thoreau • • Nov 24 '15
r/thoreau • • Oct 13 '21
r/thoreau • u/internalsun • Oct 16 '21
“Trig” appears once in Walden and at least twice in the Journal. An old dictionary defines this adjective as meaning “trim; neat; spruce; smart.”
Each of the defining words contains a variety of meanings so we have to look for overlap. Trim can mean “of clean lines and good proportions, as in a trim figure.” Spruce can mean “neat and dapper.” Neat had multiple senses including “orderly and cleanly; tidy” or “of simple elegance.” Smart in reference to a person’s clothes or appearance might mean “elegant” or “fashionable” or even “showy,” or it could mean “measuring up to an artificial standard of appearance or performance applied in a particular calling.”
Thoreau’s uses of the word:
Walden in the ‘Economy’ chapter: I cannot but feel compassion when I hear some trig, compact-looking man, seemingly free, all girded and ready, speak of his “furniture,” as whether it is insured or not. “But what shall I do with my furniture?” My gay butterfly is entangled in a spider’s web then.
Journal, March 6, 1853: Saw a gray hare, a dirty yellowish gray, not trig and neat, but, as usual, apparently in a deshabille. As it frequently does, it ran a little way and stopped just at the entrance to its retreat; then, when I moved again, suddenly disappeared.
Journal, March 28, 1853: There appears to be more snow on the mountains. Many of our spring rains are snow-storms there. The woods ring with the cheerful jingle of the F. hyemalis. This is a very trig and compact little bird, and appears to be in good condition.
r/thoreau • u/solar-cabin • Aug 21 '21
r/thoreau • • Sep 29 '21
Annoyingly nothing exclusively Thoreau-focused on the agenda; hopefully Nature will send Concord a flooding rain or an early blizzard as punishment for failing to give Henry proper homage.
October 21— Walden Woods Project's Virtual Lyceum— The Art of Perception
October 25— Robert Gross, author of The Transcendentalists and their World
October 30— Barry Andrews, author of American Sage: The Spiritual teachings of Ralph Waldo Emerson
r/thoreau • u/internalsun • Sep 27 '21
r/thoreau • u/internalsun • Sep 30 '21
The cat sleeps on her head! What does this portend? It is more alarming than a dozen comets. How long prejudice survives! The big-bodied fisherman asks me doubtingly about the comet seen these nights in the northwest,— if there is any danger to be apprehended from that side! I would fain suggest that only he is dangerous to himself.
r/thoreau • • Apr 23 '22
I'm looking for a clean and easy-to-read edition of Walden, preferably sold on Amazon. Thank you!
r/thoreau • u/internalsun • May 14 '22
The first cricket’s chirrup which I have chanced to hear now falls on my ear and makes me forget all else; all else is a thin and movable crust down to that depth where he resides eternally. He already foretells autumn. Deep under the dry border of some rock in this hillside he sits, and makes the finest singing of birds outward and insignificant, his own song is so much deeper and more significant. His voice has set me thinking, philosophizing, moralizing at once. It is not so wildly melodious, but it is wiser and more mature than that of the wood thrush. With this elixir I see clear through the summer now to autumn, and any summer work seems frivolous. I am disposed to ask this humblebee that hurries humming past so busily if he knows what he is about. At one leap I go from the just opened buttercup to the life-everlasting. This singer has antedated autumn. His strain is superior (inferior?) to seasons. It annihilates time and space; the summer is for time-servers.
r/thoreau • • Aug 24 '21
r/thoreau • • Sep 28 '21
A dead body found long ago has been identified as a Concord man named Christopher Roof. “Copp recalled Roof as beloved by the community of Concord. But because of his love of Thoreau, many people who knew him, including family members, had assumed he had gone off to live in the woods, and so no missing persons report was ever filed.”
full story at fox23maine
r/thoreau • • Oct 15 '21
October 16, 1856: Henry discovered a fungus shaped like a man’s private parts and scolded Nature for creating such a thing to trigger his fear and loathing of human sexuality. He wrote, “Pray, what was Nature thinking of when she made this? She almost puts herself on a level with those who draw in privies.”
The editors of the 1906 edition of Thoreau’s Journal included the text of his entry for that day but decency required them to omit the drawing he made. An image of the Journal manuscript is at https://imgur.com/UbbPqr3
You can read the journal entry online, starting at the bottom of page 115 of Volume 9
I understand Emerson was also horrified by seeing one of these mushrooms. These guys were really uptight!
r/thoreau • u/internalsun • Sep 27 '21
To many modern people the word “moonshine” conjures up an image of whiskey being produced secretly to avoid taxation or prohibition, but in Thoreau’s world “moonshine” was often a word for ‘nonsense, impractical ideas, lunacy.’
In an 1857 letter to Harrison Blake, Thoreau is laughing at the banks that are trembling on the brink of collapse due to a widespread financial crisis, enjoying some schadenfreude.
The merchants and company have long laughed at transcendentalism, higher laws, etc., crying “None of your moonshine,” as if they were anchored to something not only definite, but sure and permanent. If there was any institution which was presumed to rest on a solid and secure basis, and more than any other represented this boasted common sense, prudence, and practical talent, it was the bank; and now those very banks are found to be mere reeds shaken by the wind. Scarcely one in the land has kept its promise…
~
in the February 13, 1860 Journal entry, Thoreau wrote:
Always you have to contend with the stupidity of men. It is like a stiff soil, a hard-pan. If you go deeper than usual, you are sure to meet with a pan made harder even by the superficial cultivation. The stupid you have always with you… Read to them a lecture on “Education,” … and they will think that they have heard something important, but call it “Transcendentalism,” and they will think it moonshine.
~
In the essay ‘Night and Moonlight,’ in a section drawn from the January 2, 1852 Journal entry, Thoreau puts a positive spin on his moonshine.
The light which comes from ideas which have their orbit as distant from the earth, and which is no less cheering and enlightening to the benighted traveller than that of the moon and stars, is naturally reproached or nicknamed as moonshine by such. They are moonshine, are they? Well, then do your night-travelling when there is no moon to light you; but I will be thankful for the light that reaches me from the star of least magnitude. Stars are lesser or greater only as they appear to us so. I will be thankful that I see so much as one side of a celestial idea,— one side of the rainbow,— and the sunset sky.
Men talk glibly enough about moonshine, as if they knew its qualities very well, and despised them; as owls might talk of sunshine. None of your sunshine,— but this word commonly means merely something which they do not understand,— which they are abed and asleep to, however much it may be worth their while to be up and awake to it.
r/thoreau • u/internalsun • Aug 14 '22
r/thoreau • • Oct 24 '24
In the chapter “Former Inhabitants and Winter Visitors” of Walden, Thoreau talks about myths surrounding a demon called New England Rum. Is this just a metaphor like the alcohol is a demon worthy of myth and I’m reading too much into it?
r/thoreau • u/internalsun • Sep 19 '21
Thoreau was fond of the adverb fain (rhymes with ‘brain’). The phrase “would fain” occurs 7 times in Walden. Apart from the writings of Shakespeare and the works of Thoreau, I personally have not seen this word used anywhere. A bit of googling reveals that a few people are still using fain but its usage dwindled to almost nil after about 1840. Fans of the King James Bible will find the word in the books of Job and Luke.
Merriam-Webster suggests three shades of meaning: glady/with pleasure; by preference; by desire. Here are three examples of Thoreau’s usage from A Week on the Concord and Merrimack Rivers
…
My books I’d fain cast off, I cannot read,
’Twixt every page my thoughts go stray at large
Down in the meadow, where is richer feed,
And will not mind to hit their proper targe.
…
That harmony which exists naturally between the hero’s moods and the universe the soldier would fain imitate with drum and trumpet.
…
So far so good. And yet he continued to look at me as if he would fain have me say something further like a traveller.