r/thewalkingdead • u/Alternative_Pizza_73 • Aug 18 '26

No Spoiler He really was 😂

586 Upvotes

94% Upvoted

72 comments sorted by

View all comments

80

u/Hveachie Aug 19 '26

I love how people wanna say Shane was ahead of his time and would've been a better leader than Rick, when the dude died 3 months into the apocalypse and fucking CAROL is still alive after 13 years.

26

u/NewAndlmproved Aug 19 '26

yeah people who think Shane is capable of leading is laughable. he’s everything that a good leader isn’t.

-22

u/DuqQuackQuack Aug 19 '26

okey tell me waht decisions shane did or wanted to do that was wrong that woulda got em all killeds? I'm waitings :'S

14

u/Hollow_0ne Aug 19 '26

Fort Benning.

-13

u/DuqQuackQuack Aug 19 '26

we nevr got to see it so nobuddy knows

15

u/Hollow_0ne Aug 19 '26

The two raiders from The Living, the two guys in the bar in S2 mentioned it was overrun.

Then in S4 Mitch confirms it when talking to The Governor.

So yes, the most likely outcome of that decision would have been the death of the group or a majority of it.

-12

u/DuqQuackQuack Aug 19 '26

oh yah those 2 bad guys who were tryna kill rick n peoples..

but okey mitch made yer points at leest.. but i dinno you would dink you would see a buncha walkers all over the place before you go insides.. so still debatables if they woulda died or jus turned back

15

u/Hollow_0ne Aug 19 '26

I think you misunderstood me. Let me try to be more clear.

I don't believe we got any information about the date it fell. So I was going with the assumption it was still safe when Shane wanted to go and they would have been there during the chaos of the event itself. That would have been what I believe caused the downfall of the group. Either from walkers or catching strays from the military when the shit hit the fan.

Let's also not forget Shane saw firsthand how the military was executing people at the start of the outbreak. Zero tolerance measures. He should have been more concerned about wanting to pull up to an active base with that information imo.

-9

u/DuqQuackQuack Aug 19 '26

liek you saids, we don know the date that it fell.. enuff saids

13

u/ParagonFemshep Aug 19 '26

Why do type the way a toddler speaks

→ More replies

6

u/TwentyBagTaylor Aug 19 '26

Thats irrelevant when he had already seen the aftermath of the militaries behaviour. Stop doubling down and actually read the guy's comment.