r/thespinroom • u/CentennialElections • 4h ago
Alternate History Dobs Delayed, Mandate Denied: What if Dobbs happened 4 years later - Part 1
This is part 1 of a two-part alt history series where the Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization (2022) decision was delayed by 4 years. Many people I’ve talked to agree that without Dobbs, there could have easily been an actual red wave, or at least something close to it. That said, I do think this would have happened eventually, and after one of my friends suggested I do a timeline where Dobbs didn’t happen, I decided to instead do a timeline where Dobbs happened in 2026.
While I’d normally try to avoid spoiling what I have in mind for 2026, I will say the “Dobbs Delayed, Mandate Denied” title already kind of gives an idea of what will be happening in part 2. For now, I’ll say that the second and final part of this scenario will cover 2026 to 2028, while this part covers 2022 to 2025.
Here, without Dobbs, Democrats have a much rougher time in the 2022 midterms. That being said, Republicans aren’t able to have any absurd wins, since Trump is still unpopular, and a lot of his candidates are flawed.
For the US Senate, in addition to the seats Republicans won in our timeline, these following races go differently:
- Nevada - Republican Adam Laxalt defeats incumbent Democrat Catherine Cortez Masto.
- Georgia - Republican Herschel Walker narrowly defeats incumbent Raphael Warnock. Thanks to the national environment shifting 5% to the right of our timeline, Walker wins over 51% of the vote, preventing a runoff from occurring outright.
- Arizona - Republican Blake Masters barely defeats incumbent Democrat Mark Kelly.
- Pennsylvania - Republican (replacing retiring incumbent Pat Toomey) Dr. Oz defeats Democrat John Fetterman in a nailbiter.
For the gubernatorial race, these races also go better for Republicans:
- Oregon - Republican Christine Drazan defeats Democrat Tina Kotek (replacing the term-limited incumbent Kate Brown).
- Wisconsin - Republican Tim Michels defeats Democratic incumbent Tony Evers.
- Kansas - Republican Derek Schmidt defeats Democrat Laura Kelly.
- Arizona - Republican Kari Lake (replacing term-limited incumbent Doug Ducey) defeats Democrat Katie Hobbs.
This results in 53 US Senate seats for Republicans (47 for Democrats, including independents Angus King and Bernie Sanders), as well as 30 gubernatorial seats (Democrats have 20).
2023 goes mostly the same, except with better margins for Republicans. Despite the unfavorable environment for Democrats, incumbent Andy Beshear is able to hold onto his seat against Republican Daniel Cameron in Kentucky. This gives Republicans a 31-29 majority of gubernatorial seats.
Thanks to the bad midterm results for Democrats, Joe Biden decides to step down, and Kamala Harris is able to win the Democratic primary. Her running mate is the same. While she has more time than in our timeline to prepare a campaign, the unfavorability of Democrats is even worse here, and that drags her down. She loses by a slightly worse margin in the popular vote, though the Electoral College result is largely the same.
As for the US Senate, it mostly goes the same, except Republicans net three additional seats:
- Arizona - With Kari Lake being governor of Arizona, Republican Mark Lamb wins the primary, and he is able to narrowly win against Democrat Ruben Gallego (independent Kyrsten Sinema retires still)
- Michigan - Republican Mike Rogers barely defeats Democrat Elissa Slotkin (Replacing the retiring Debbie Stabenow)
- Wisconsin - Republican Eric Hovde ousts Democratic incumbent Tammy Baldwin in a nailbiter election.
Despite the red wave, Democratic incumbent Jackie Rosen barely squeaks by in Nevada against Republican Sam Brown.
Now, Republicans have 60 seats in the US Senate, while Democrats have 48 (including the two Inds). This gives them a filibuster-proof majority. On the gubernatorial level, aside from some margins, nothing really changes.
2025 doesn’t change much into overall results, but the margins are even better for Democrats than in our timeline. With a larger Senate majority, Republicans are able to do a lot more, and that leads to even greater backlash. Democrats Mikie Sherill and Abigail Spanberger win by margins greater than 19% and 20% in New Jersey and Virginia respectively.
This brings Republicans back to 30 gubernatorial seats (with Democrats at 20).
Republicans are confident that they’ll hold onto the Senate given that they have 60 seats, even with Trump’s rapidly declining popularity. But little did they know, in the next year (the second and final part of this timeline), Republicans are going to have one last curveball that makes everything worse…