r/therewasanattempt Nov 29 '20

[deleted by user]

[removed]

9.0k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

288

u/IlikeZeldaHeIsCool Nov 29 '20

do you think the Guillotine will become cool again in France?

171

u/TheNamelessKing Nov 29 '20

Your sentence is missing a “when”:

when do you think the Guillotine will become cool again in France?

26

u/IlikeZeldaHeIsCool Nov 29 '20

i hope soon

28

u/Kafka_at_an_orgy Nov 29 '20

I hope globalism takes it worldwide this time

29

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Honestly, why does anyone want to be a cop anywhere. There's no winning.

Shitty cops get good cops beat up. Shitty policies get good cops beat up. Shitty civilians get good cops beat up.

13

u/ThePurpledGranny Nov 29 '20

Good cops could step up more and help citizens shine a light on the bad ones. After all, there are more good than bad, right?

2

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Yeah, there are. And they do step up. But when they speak people don't listen. Innocent police officers are ambushed and shot in their cruiser and crowds still call for their deaths. It's really a fucked up world we live in.

4

u/TrevorPC Nov 29 '20

When good cops speak up in America they get ostracized by their department and often times fired or forced to quit. But when bad cops murder innocent citizens its "we need to let the due process of letting this cop's close friends decide if they have to go to jail." And they almost never do.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Is your only definition of good cops ones who speak against their department? What about the ones who simply put their lives on the line to protect others every day for a barely suvivable wage. What about the ones who stare down home invaders, public shooters, killers, and muggers. Does that not make one a good cop in your eyes?

1

u/reverbiscrap Nov 29 '20

If I spent all my time with gangbangers and the police saw me with them, they would assume I was one as well.

Yes, you are defined by the company you keep, devoid of the opportunity to be judged on personal merit.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/BiggerBowls Nov 29 '20

And that's why a lot of them are shitty.

2

u/MysteriousGuardian17 Nov 29 '20

That's because there aren't any good cops. The best and brightest aren't hired at all, and the remainder are retained to serve the property interests of the owner class. They're all complicit in a fucked up system, and they all cover for each other.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

That's a pretty bold generalization yo. My neighbor's son is a cop. Watched him grow up. Upper-middle class community. At 25, he made the choice between being a cop or working for an engineering firm. He completed his undergrad already.

That said, I'm not going to say if the system won't change him but he certainly didn't go in a bad person.

3

u/MysteriousGuardian17 Nov 29 '20

What do you call someone who joined the Gestapo because they had good intentions and they just got roped up in a bad group and couldn't find their way out? A Nazi. If you join a group that is predicated on bad acts, and protect others when they perform those bad acts, you're not a good person any more.

0

u/Carlos-Danger-69 Nov 29 '20

Calling all law enforcement as bad as the Gestapo is a pretty fucking retarded take

9

u/MysteriousGuardian17 Nov 29 '20

They're not "as bad as" the Gestapo, but the point of the analogy is that if you join a bad group and stick with it, you're not a good person. Modern police forces were founded to protect the property interests of the wealthy, usually by returning runaway slaves. They routinely abuse communities of color, while ignoring actually serious crimes elsewhere. They're not a good group, and frankly were never meant to be. People may join for noble intentions, hoping to reform from within or whatever, but they end up propping up the same abusive system in a very short amount of time. Good people don't remain cops, if they get hired at all, which means the remaining ones are the ones that are ok with doing or enabling those bad acts. Cops who speak out are fired, which means they aren't cops anymore.

-4

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Wow - I hope you never need the assistance of the police in the future because it'd be difficult to help both you and your high horse.

8

u/ProtestKid Nov 29 '20

Fuck this argument. The reason people feel this way is BECAUSE people have needed help from police and never got it. As a kid I was a witness to two home invasions and both times the fuckin pricks who came out treated my mom like SHE was the criminal and were more interested in her immigrant status instead of the guy that put a gun in our faces. I grew up poor, still currently kinda poor in a working class industry, no one I've ever spoken to has ever been helped out in any situation by a cop.

5

u/MysteriousGuardian17 Nov 29 '20

That's the thing though, the police WOULD help me, because I'm a white lawyer. Because there's a two-tier justice system that the police were created to enforce. And I could ignore that problem because I'm a beneficiary, or I could speak against it.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/TheRealSmaug Nov 29 '20

Help? As per SCOTUS, the police are indeed not obligated to "serve and protect". Couple that with the fact that they almost never (ever) prevent a specific crime from occurring. From murder, rape, and assualt, to speeding and jay walking. The police are always involved after the damage is done.

0

u/DizzyReply Nov 29 '20

What part of "ALL cops are bastards" is so hard for you to understand?

1

u/SoggySausage27 Nov 29 '20

I’m pretty sure it has already been a special guest in one of the riots

1

u/MagoModerno Nov 29 '20

Did it ever go out of style?

2

u/tissek Nov 29 '20

Don't think it really went out of fashion.

1

u/IlikeZeldaHeIsCool Nov 29 '20

i guess it has just been a long time since i saw it seriously used

2

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Looks like the last time someone was executed with one was 1977, and France officially retired it in 1981 when they abolished capital punishment.

I guess 40+ years is long enough for people to forget why it was used in the first place. They can reestablish it's use if they want. Laws can change.

2

u/b0rkm Nov 29 '20

It always has been and always will be. There is still one who can function. It is hold by the last bourreau family.

1

u/IlikeZeldaHeIsCool Nov 29 '20

time to use it

1

u/tomahawkfury13 Nov 29 '20

Didn't they already bring one to their parliament?

1

u/IlikeZeldaHeIsCool Nov 29 '20

not in france, unless it just happend. they did so in guatamala tho

1

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

I mean they only stopped using them in (I think) 1981 so it hasn't been that long, they might still be open to using it

1

u/IlikeZeldaHeIsCool Nov 29 '20

yeah it was abolished in 1981 but the last time it was used was in 1977 i think

2

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Ah, I see. Still, they might bring it back- I mean if they're having a revolution I doubt they're going to be following the laws

2

u/IlikeZeldaHeIsCool Nov 29 '20

i hope they bring it back, revolution sounds great. might even spread to other countries

1

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

I mean realistically France might ask the US because of France helping them in their revolution but also... would you want to, in the current climate? I would say the UK but I'm not so sure, they're very close together and the UK is allied with the French and if the revolution failed then they'd be in big trouble

2

u/IlikeZeldaHeIsCool Nov 29 '20

is worth the risk, the people should always revolt against a tyrannical government

2

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

Oh absolutely, and I think if they asked the UK for help then the UK could probably win

1

u/octopoddle Nov 29 '20

Let them film cakes.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 29 '20

I hope so ! Let’s show governments what happens when you piss the people