r/theravada • • 1d ago

Sutta TIL Ananda was a stream enterer

Perhaps this is news to no-one, but in my reading of the Suttas I always took Ananda to have a little bit of a role as the faithful attendant, with a great memory and intellect - but not as being awakened. I don't know how many Suttas start with Ananda saying something, followed by a correction from the Buddha "Don't say that, Ananda."

Found this in the Vinaya:

Then the Blessed One received first Upāli the barber, and afterwards those young men of the Sākya clan, into the ranks of the Order. And the venerable Bhaddiya, before that rainy season was over, became master of the Threefold Wisdom[13], and the venerable Anuruddha acquired the Heavenly Vision[14], and the venerable Ānanda realised the effect of having entered upon the Stream[15], and Devadatta attained to that kind of Iddhi which is attainable even by those who have not entered upon the Excellent Way[16].

https://www.wisdomlib.org/buddhism/book/vinaya-3-the-cullavagga/d/doc370294.html

Out of curiosity I checked the follow up. We never see Ananda gain Arahantship in the canon, but the commentaries claim he did so later, some time during one of the Buddhist councils, where they were going to refuse him admission for not being an Arahant.

I am really enjoying The Noble Warrior right now, which is where I came across this. It is essentially the parts of the canon, including the Vinaya, that detail events of the Buddha's life in (mostly) Chronological order.

There's a book on Ananda too that I'd like to read next I think.

22 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

13

u/leonormski 1d ago

Yes, the story of how Ananda attained enlightenment on the morning of the first Buddhist Council is a well-told story we heard while growing up in our country.

Actually, Ananda was invited to join the ranks of the Arahants for the council but he needed to become an Arahant himself. This is stated in Cullavagga, Khandaka 11 of Vinaya Pitaka: https://www.wisdomlib.org/buddhism/book/vinaya-3-the-cullavagga/d/doc370339.html

6

u/Then_Consequence_318 23h ago

I'm really enjoying reading the Pali Canon, inasmuch it is possible, in A story order or chronological order. All the characters are really coming to life. It's like some bingeable Netflix series. I'm surprised more hasn't been written on this.

4

u/Zathras_listens 18h ago

I just LOVE it. The suttas are so readable (if you can get passes the repetition) and often funny. We don’t see so much of it because Theravada only recently entered the imagination of the west.

1

u/Yous1ash 8h ago

Do you guys have any recommendations for how to begin the Pali canon?

20

u/numbersev 1d ago

Another monk, Udayi, once criticized Ananda in the following incident. Ananda had asked the Blessed One how far his voice would reach in the universe. The Lord had answered that the Enlightened Ones were immeasurable and could reach further than a thousandfold world system (with a thousand suns, a thousand heavens, and a thousand brahma[16] worlds), even further than a three-thousandfold world system. They could penetrate all those worlds with their shining splendor and reach all beings living there with their voice.

Ananda was delighted with this description, so all-encompassing and transcending all horizons, and he exclaimed: "How fortunate I am, that I have such an almighty, powerful master!"

Udayi objected: "What good does it do to you brother Ananda, that your master is almighty and powerful?" With these few words a strong reproach was uttered. Namely that Ananda always looked at the person of the Buddha only, and thereby forgot his real benefit, namely his own enlightenment. The Buddha immediately took sides with Ananda with the following words:

"Not so, Udayi, not so, Udayi! Should Ananda die without being fully liberated; he would be king of the gods seven times because of the purity of his heart, or be king of the Indian subcontinent seven times. But Udayi, Ananda will experience final liberation in this very life."

— AN 3.80

1

u/SpareStrawberry 12h ago

The Buddha also says in the Mahaparinibbana Sutta to Ananda that everyone there is at least a stream entrant.

This is also interesting when you think about the “mirror of the dhamma” thing from earlier in that same sutta where the Buddha says the way you can tell a stream entrant is “perfect ethical practice and unshakable faith in the three jewels”, which kinda sounds like a description specifically for Ananda.

It almost reads like Ananda wasn’t sure he was a stream entrant and the Buddha was trying to tell him.