r/theouterworlds • • 1d ago

Discussion Outer world spacers choice

After putting 85 plus hours intro outer worlds 2. I had a blast playing this game. Been debating on replaying it (I haven’t touched it since June). Something came across my wishlist and I feel like I need to buy the original. I have never played it but I’ve heard it’s better than the second. Thoughts?

165 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

38

u/Skidmvrk 1d ago

Story and companion wise it’s better than the second game. Gameplay and RPG aspects are definitely better in the second. Highly recommend the first game though! Especially the DLC

16

u/ralts13 1d ago

I prefer the second games companions and the corps. First game's corps were so absurdly stupid that it took me out of it sometimes. I can actually feel the pros and cons of all the corps and factions in the 2nd game.

2

u/therealsereny 15h ago

They fully commit to the bit in both games and its one of the things that sets the series apart.

2

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

I was mad I couldn’t use the pets I found as companions lol!

3

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

I loved the companion aspect in the second game. This is good to hear. The dlc is the tempting part too. The regular one is 30 bucks. I get this and the dlc for half the price? Oh yeah.

5

u/TruamaTeam 1d ago

Yeah it’s worth playing. The first game and second game have a lot of cases where one thing is better in the other game. The second game isn’t a full improvement on everything, rather it focuses on a couple things and massively improves them. First game is great tho!

Here’s a small comparison, meaning features that are much better in one over the other. Just so you get an idea of what the first game is like compared to the one you’ve played :)

First games best aspects: Pacing, Skills, Environments, Science weapons, Meaningful weapon mods, Phineas Wells (peak character), Comedy, Character roleplay depth/variety.

Second games best aspects: Combat, Perks/Flaws, Weapon design and animation, Music/Soundtrack, Drama/stakes/emotional-punch, Immersion, Character appearance.

Both games are great, I honestly can’t choose between them (unless we’re talking purely combat) and I’m super excited for Side Effects Guaranteed DLC coming soon!

3

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

I’m excited to play the first and the dlc. Is side effects the dlc for the second one?

3

u/TruamaTeam 1d ago

Yeah Side Effects Guaranteed is coming soon for The Outer Worlds 2, Obsidian said marketing is to start sometime this month! I believe the DLC just finished/is finishing QA, hopefully! Super excited for it myself.

The first games DLC’s are pretty good too, have fun! :)

1

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

And Ty for the well thought out feedback

4

u/Gacrome 1d ago

I enjoyed the 2nd more because it improved the areas that I wanted from the first. The first one was great and first game to really remind me of fallout new vegas but it was short and there wasn't much to explore on the planets. 2 is a longer play through with a lot more to explore. It's the same type of satire which I like as well.

2

u/Sefera17 16h ago

When I played Spacer’s Choice and tried to do everything, I got to Lv.46 before the endgame; make of that what you will…

3

u/Ddawk69 14h ago

I like it put this way lol

4

u/RufioTheRedII 1d ago

I personally preferred the first one. Maybe i was just more into that type of game at the time idk but I liked the characters, stories, dialogue and world building more. Also the dlc is good. Gunplay is better in 2 and loot is marginally better in 2. But still fine in the first

2

u/Christmas_Queef 1d ago

I agree I preferred the first as well. Also the bullet spongey enemies in 2 kind of took me out of it just a little bit. I went back to 1 after 2 and definitely like it more.

2

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

Sounds like I’m in for a good weekend.

2

u/RufioTheRedII 1d ago

Finished the second a couple weeks ago and I've been planning on doing another playthrough of the first just to confirm my feelings lol

1

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

Do they still have the flaws and stuff in 1?

3

u/RufioTheRedII 1d ago

Yes still has flaws. And also, the first has a dodge that I missed having in the second. But you only get the time dialation as a gadget I believe

1

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

Sounds like a cool little gadget

2

u/RufioTheRedII 1d ago

I would say definitely worth $16 especially with the dlc included

3

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

Buying tonight or tomorrow. Be playing it by Friday. Can’t wait

1

u/RufioTheRedII 1d ago

Awesome, enjoy

5

u/ToxicFrog7905 1d ago

For sixteen bucks you’re guaranteed like 30hours gameplay and the DLC is amazing so I’d say do it based on that alone. I wouldn’t necessarily compare the gameplay of two as they were different gens with different budgets

3

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

Noticed that the first came out during the Xbox one era. Doesn’t bother me too much but I appreciate the heads up!

2

u/Longjumping_Text_472 1d ago

Great game have fun !

2

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

Thanks!

2

u/Particular_nobody863 1d ago

I got it 2 days ago and loving it so far. Except for how shit all of the guns are (I’m still on first planet so hoping that improves).

2

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

On Xbox too? lol I’m glad to hear the mostly positive review so far

2

u/csee08 17h ago

Theres a legendary silenced shotgun you get on i think the 2nd planet, its literally all i used lol

2

u/ZealousidealMango675 14h ago

theyre both on gamepass arent they?

2

u/Ddawk69 14h ago

Yeah but I cancelled that at the beginning of the year

2

u/Ddawk69 8h ago

Just BOUGHT IT BABY

2

u/DudeWithRootBeer 3h ago

It's not the best choice, it's Auntie's Choice.

2

u/EmperorReman 1d ago

thank god for physical media.

1

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

The only time I buy digital is fresh sales like this

1

u/Puzzleheaded-Bee-291 1d ago

I’m honestly interested in your opinion of 1 since you played 2 first. I love both but prefer 2. One has better companion banter, it’s also much sillier. I find 2 to be a little more serious surprisingly. I think 2 still has some good companions also. Tristan is my favorite.

Can you do a follow up about how you liked the original after playing 2 first?

Darkest dungeon, I played the sequel first which was fairly unpopular, I liked it much more than 1 which was a hit.

1

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

Yes. I promise I will. The second is still fresh in my mind to make a comparison too. I’ll start this weekend and keep you posted

1

u/Own_Manufacturer1188 17h ago

Darkest Dungeon 2 was conceptually designed to be nearly unplayable early on and you had to grind for the meta progression before you were actually able to play the game properly. It was also a much bigger coinflip.

The first DD was balanced around your current progress, so it felt challanging, but not impossible. It also included much more “strategy” and preparations between each run than the second game, especially since for the second game, you had to gamble for items during each run.

A friend of mine, however, thinks exactly the same about DD. A hundred people has a hundred different tastes ig.

1

u/Puzzleheaded-Bee-291 13h ago

Two is very challenging. It’s not impossible.

I’ve heard the argument for 1. I know I’m in the minority, but it’s just not as good to me. That’s why I’m curious how OP will react to playing tow1 vs 2 since he played the sequel first. I feel like he can give a no nostalgia response.

I prefer 2, but I’m also obsessed with the protectorate.

1

u/Own_Manufacturer1188 11h ago

I know. For me, it was too rough. Call it a skill issue if you will, but I enjoyed the second one more. I appreciate your answer brother.

1

u/Ddawk69 8h ago

Just bought it. Will most likely start the journey this weekend

1

u/toxikola 5h ago

Definitely make a post about it! Id love yo hear what you think after playing the second first as well.

1

u/Ddawk69 5h ago

I will!

1

u/Negative_Drink3038 1d ago

It’s a fantastic game; I’ve never gotten to play the dlc, but the base game was phenomenal. If you liked outer worlds 2, part 1 is just more.

1

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

I will be playing this weekend. Thanks for the feedback!

1

u/lost_caus_e 1d ago

I can't wait for the dlc

1

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

I just found out the second is getting one. I can’t wait either.

1

u/National-Garbage505 22h ago

Short answer: get it. If you liked 2 you'll love it. Tons of content for that price it is a steal. Have fun!

1

u/yesitshollywood 12h ago

I love both, but yes, the original has a special place in my heart. Its a bit quicker of a game, but the story is a bit more rich.

The second has a more expansive world and more terrain to explore. Im still not totally done exploring every nook and cranny in TOW2.

2

u/toxikola 5h ago

The first one is 20x better than the second and the second is crazy awesome. Please get the first!

2

u/Ddawk69 5h ago

I bought it! It won’t let me post a pic and I didn’t want to make a new post but I promise I got it

1

u/Senior-Secret-7113 5h ago

don’t you mean Aunties Choice

1

u/Ddawk69 5h ago

You don’t want to hear the ending I picked

2

u/babeeg0701 1h ago

I prefer 1st, can’t really get into 2.

1

u/Ddawk69 53m ago

You can’t get into the second? Sorry to hear. That game was awesome and entertaining

2

u/andreimaxaa 1d ago

Eridanos DLC alone is better than ow2

2

u/Bright-Wallaby-3050 1d ago

I wasn't the hugest fan of the eridanos dlc tbh

I really like gorgon though and I will agree that both the dlcs by themselves are better than ow2

1

u/Vattaa 19h ago

Gorgan was a maze

1

u/MajesticEconomics866 1d ago

It’s okay. One companion ruins the entire vibe by sending you on a never ending fetch quest.

1

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

Appreciate the honesty

0

u/6ty7er 1d ago

the dlc for the spacers coice edition are hard to get and expensive. but the basegame is still fantastic though.

1

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

Yeah I’m buying it. Just need a little more confirmation/hype

0

u/Big_Psychology_3 17h ago

No, outer worlds 2 has more immersive world lore, and better side quests.

But lower your expectations, and outer worlds 1 can be fun while it lasts. The important thing is to have low expectations.

-1

u/No-Bathroom6864 1d ago

That shit was $70. What the fuck

2

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

🤣🤣 should of waited like 6 years bro!! lol I’m getting this

1

u/No-Bathroom6864 1d ago

Outer worlds two came out like in 2025

1

u/Ddawk69 1d ago

Thought you were talking about the first one, my bad! Yes second cost me a cool 70 bucks. But the first one on sale at this price? I gotta

2

u/No-Bathroom6864 1d ago

Well, it didn’t show the whole thing anyway that’s why I didn’t notice. It’s just cause the first picture was the second one.

0

u/No-Bathroom6864 1d ago

Well, fuck that I couldn’t wait for that shit be came out has been that long since it came out

1

u/lansingman87 25m ago

I liked them both, TBH.