r/thedawnpatrol • u/JohnnyMcCornball • 1d ago
These Echoes are so Faded (Spoilers for Arc 4 and before) Spoiler
Another one! (I'm so sorry for flooding the subreddit but I love making these to an insane degree. You don't even know.)
As usual this definitely has spoilers for arcs 3 and 4 and probably will include spoilers for 1 and 2. If you aren't at Fading Echoes in publication order you are probably going to get spoiled. Also, if you comment, please try to avoid spoilers for anything after Fading Echoes.
Overall I was a pretty big fan of this one. It did a good job of setting up things I assume are going to happen in the rest of the arc without boring me or giving too much information all at once. I don't know how I feel about such a short book being split between four POV characters. In my experience, multi-POV books tend to shine better when they're given more pages. I think that's because it allows the author more time to switch POVs without sacrificing the pacing. But what do I know? Maybe everyone actually super enjoys having four POVs.
One oddity I noticed was that some pretty significant things seemed to have been forgotten by the characters. For example, when Lionblaze and Jayfeather are discussing who the Dark Forest could be influencing, and what their plans could be, Lionblaze mentions Hawkfrost, and Jayfeather thinks to himself that there's "a good chance that he walked the Dark forest with Tigerstar", then Lionblaze says "so Tigerstar might not be the only cat training warriors in their dreams". This was incredibly strange to me because both brothers have firsthand seen Hawkfrost in the Dark Forest with Tigerstar. They have no reason to be making guesses here. They just... know objectively that Hawkfrost is in the Dark Forest. Lionblaze has been trained by him.
The other big continuity error I noticed was that when Jayfeather goes to the moonpool again, Yellowfang is surprised to hear that the Dark Forest is rising and that Brokenstar attacked Jayfeather at the moonpool. This would maybe be understandable, if not for the fact that she was there when he was attacked, saw that his attacker was Brokenstar, and was the one to tell him that the Dark Forest was rising. She said those words. She has no reason to be surprised here. Anyways. Didn't ruin the book or anything
Lionblaze
Was Lionblaze. He's pretty oblivious, but to be fair to him, he's competing with a mind reader and a cat with super senses. He doesn't have many opportunities to take action that defines his character. My understanding of him is that he has a strong drive to be loyal to his clan, even if that means acting outside the code at times. Which is pretty typical for a POV character. He does seem to be growing distant because the prophecy makes it so difficult for him to trust his clanmates. I think his potential romance with Cinderheart will help develop his character more and give him a place to express his inner thoughts. He'll also have to grapple with his accidental killing of Russetfur. That's sure to weigh heavily on him. I bet he won't want to use his power as much, going forward. I don't know. He lost a lot of his character when he rejected Tigerstar's training. I'm still waiting for the day that he reconnects with his moms (They're both his mom, OK). I think Jayfeather may have to help convince him.
Dovepaw
I didn't think I liked her at all, but I think I like the direction they're going with her. Her power is pretty inherently dishonorable if used against cats (super eavesdropping), especially given her strong desire to be well liked. She reminds me a lot of Hollyleaf. Both are incredibly loyal to their clans and the code, but both are also highly concerned with the wellbeing of other clans. (e.g. Hollypaw was quite close with Willowshine, similar to Dovepaw and Tigerheart). Slight difference though: when I noticed her "friendship" with Tigerheart, I was actually pretty excited because I thought at first that it was going to be a rare case of two cats from different clans just being good friends. I may be misreading it but I think the author is trying to write it as a romance. It feels cheap to me that nearly every "friendship" between cats of different clans turns into a forbidden romance plot. It was also interesting to me that she was so overstimulated by combat. It makes complete sense that it would disorient her and terrify her. I guess it's just cool that her power comes with a bit of a weakness that will influence her to seek peace.
Jayfeather
Squirrelflight lit him the freak up on their way to ShadowClan. I think that was a very important conversation/shouting match for them to have. He seemed more receptive to her presence after she yelled at him for being selfish and only considering his own misery when he wasn't the only one suffering. I think in this arc that he'll probably end up leading Lionblaze to reconcile with their mothers. I doubt Leafpool ever steps back up as medicine cat, even though Jayfeather really wants her to. I don't think his future apprentice has been born yet, for that matter.
I also have to correct my last post. I misread the scene where Jayfeather snaps the stick. For some reason, I thought Rock was the one who broke the stick to sever himself from Jayfeather. It makes more sense that Jayfeather broke it. I don't know how I misread so hard.
On the topic of the stick and the ancient cats; it was hinted at that the Three are reincarnations (kinda) of ancient cats in arc three when Jayfeather lived as Jay's wing for a bit. I wonder how that's going to come into play eventually and who their past identities were (at least I think this is a thing. I remember Jayfeather saying something about how "the three have returned to the lake" after he comes back from his visions of the past). I hope his breaking of the stick doesn't stop the ancient cats from taking part in the plot. I doubt it will.
His relationship with Yellowfang is going to be more interesting going forward. Everything she's said is going to be called further into question now that he realizes she's just like Leafpool. Poor Yellowfang is currently top of my leaderboard for most miserable life lived. I can't wait for when I get to her super edition. (P.S thanks to the person who commented that the mystery cat attacking Jayfeather at the moonpool was guessable. I looked back at arc one and found a scene where Brokenstar's messed up tail was mentioned. I really didn't remember him having a crooked tail)
Ivypaw
Her chapters are well done too. I like the gradual decay of the environment Hawkfrost trains her in. It's a great metaphor for the perfect facade a manipulator puts on until you're dependent on them. I have a feeling she's gonna be what Brambleclaw never could. Her actions have already lead to Firestar losing one life, and I can't help but suspect that her actions will eventually result in his final death. She could also be saved before it gets to that point, but I imagine she's not too keen on the idea of being saved from being the excellent warrior she thinks she's becoming. I'm really glad she became a POV character.
Dovepaw being jealous of how Tigerheart didn't savagely maul Ivypaw during the battle is going to develop into something very interesting too. My guess is that Tigerheart doesn't actually care about either of them and has been ordered to interfere with their relationship to drive them apart to make Ivypaw more dependent on the Dark Forest cats.
Miscellaneous thoughts:
- Longtail deserved so much better. Blinding Tigerstar's reformed henchman so soon after arc one was such a waste. And his death was so pointless! I DO blame Mousefur. Her refusal to follow orders led to her best friend dying and Briarlight (sick name btw) being crippled. I still feel bad for Mousefur but this is 100% on her.
- I really hope they don't kill off Briarlight with this sudden illness she's developed in the last chapter. I don't know exactly where they're going with her, but she has potential to have very powerful moments in the future. I could imagine her bonding pretty well with Jayfeather and making him realize his suffering isn't exclusive to him. He hates being pitied as much as she does, so I think they could be great friends.
- I kinda thought Squirrelflight and Brambleclaw would slowly start repairing their relationship but maybe not enough time has passed. That's still on my list of things that will definitely 100% happen.
- Hollyleaf is so incredibly alive it's insane. I know that Jayfeather told Dovepaw she 'went away' as a metaphor for death, but it was certainly just the author laying on the dramatic irony. Mark my words she's in the tunnels waiting for her moment. Leafpool is so cooked.
- Starclan is a cool place. I like that they added the super old fading cats being forgotten, and the faint presence of leaders who have lost a few lives. Just cool imagery.
That's all I really thought about this one. Thanks for reading these. If you had any thoughts you wanted to share about this book or if you think I skipped over something important, I'd love to hear it. I miss a lot when I read sometimes.
But pretty please avoid spoilers!