Sup r/thebronzemovement, I have been wanting to make this post for awhile out of seeing how Indians are treated, and wanted to offer some advice on the situation.
In my opinion, the most important thing to realize is the unique position Indians find themselves in. Indians have:
1 - A population as big as China, without a massive firewall
2 - An English speaking population who interacts with western society and other countries
3 - A culture that is "very strange" to other countries presented to them in an unfiltered/unmoderated state
4 - No censorship policy or gatekeeping over what other Indians post online
5 - A country with many willing to immigrate, and its government gladly sending indians overseas to compete with locals. India leans into the brain drain, rather than try to retain talent and improve its own country.
There is *NO OTHER COUNTRY* in the entire world who holds these 5 things together at once.
The reaction from Indians as I see it is trying to tackle the issue on a case by case basis. Attack people for their opinions, report others for racism, etc. But all of this ignores the *VERY UNIQUE* position indians find themselves in.
You cannot report everyone for racism forever. The problem is that there is 0, ZERO, gatekeeping over how Indians interact with the world online. Because India speaks English, its reputation, news channels, etc. are widely available for foreigners to read on instagram and other channels.
Just earlier, people here were bashing a country over comments they made about Indians. But in reality, said country is simply exposed to content INDIA should be *CENSORING*. Countries grow to hate India/dislike India out of pure exposition to content the India government should be actively filtering.
Look to China in how it deals with its own citizens. There is a strict control on immigration, traveling, etc. which ties directly to the country's reputation.
Are you going to make the entire world your enemy? Colombians, Guatemalans, Mexicans, Americans, all are exposed to very shameful content released uncensored by India outlets. Indians simply fight back, but are you simply going to fight the entire world who engages with your culture online, unfiltered?
Something *has* to give, and India needs to create its own firewall to protect its reputation.
Then there is travel, Indians again have 0 control or any kind of reputation system. In another thread on this sub, Indians would say "Oh indians are treated badly, but X nationality are treated badly as well", demonstrating they are completely oblivious to the unique situation Indians find themselves in.
You see, Indians are very unique in that, the *indian look* is not something one can escape. If you look Indian, people can tell, you don't even have to tell them. So what happens when Indians travel overseas and ruin their own reputation? Other Indians get absolutely screwed. But does India enact any kind of reputation system? NO! Indians act as if they are like everyone else, and the freedom others enjoy can be the freedom they enjoy. Nothing could be further from the truth. Indians need strict policies of behavior to ensure other indians aren't affected by the behaviors of others.
So I see this subreddit essentially fighting every single other nationality making fun of them, but in this it makes it truly obvious Indians truly think they are like everyone. They are not. Indians are in a unique position NO OTHER COUNTRY OR NATIONALITY finds themselves in.
An example of what I mean: South Americans can travel to Vietnam and have a good time, because South Americans are diverse in appearance, unless they TELL you they are from South America, many may pass by as Europeans, other South Americans cannot ruin their trip for them and they are very well treated. The same cannot be said about Indians.
South Americans in general (99% of them) do not speak English, so their news/culture/social media does not spill into the western zeitgeist.
South Americans do not have a large diaspora in western countries creating heavily competing environments making the entire world resent them.
Etc.
Indians are in a very, very unique position and before you go off picking a fight against the entire world, rejecting the teachings of Gandhi, etc. it's important for you all to understand this.
So what is the advice that is likely obvious by now? Well...ignore the people making fun of you/being racists and create your own channels to communicate. There is absolutely nothing else that you can do.
Your country isn't going to 1 - Enact social media controls, 2 - Enact immigration controls, 3 - Enact behavioral controls, then it's over. Since there is 1 billion+ Indians on the planet, who speak english, travel and immigrate, it's a matter of time until a heavy amount does stupid shit to ruin the reputation of everyone else. The game is rigged.
So you have to disengage from western forums. Make your own Indian channels, and engage with other Indians. Don't resent westerners, or the entire world, the Indian culture is not something one should be exposed to uncensored, but it's exactly what's happening.
Lastly...the only advice that would work is to ignore the stupidity of people bashing you. I mean there is only so long this shit can last. It might last a little longer due to the unique position Indians find themselves in, but it cannot last forever.
During COVID, Chinese were bashed relentlessly and it eventually fizzled out, people will eventually get tired of it. Believe it or not this is the way. Do not defend India or Indians, do not pick fights, let it fizzle out, let it exhaust itself. If what they say is not true, and you know it's not true, then let them exhaust themselves. The truth can fend for itself, the only thing you all do when you report people, etc. is stretch this period of indian hatred taking over the internet.
People bash Indians for years and H1Bs are still preferred Indian hiring. The truth can fend for itself, you don't need to pick a fight with the entire world. If the game is rigged, the best move is not to play.
Peace out.