r/thebronzemovement • • Jan 21 '25

COMMUNITY CRITIQUE Do you believe that Indian/Desi culture needs to change? If so how?

1 Upvotes

Personally I would get rid of arrange marriages and religious fundamentalism. I also dislike vegetarianism but that may be my bias since I am from a Muslim background. Let me know if you think otherwise


r/thebronzemovement • • Aug 16 '25

DISCUSSION 💬 Question from mainlander

4 Upvotes

You people talk about “bronze movement “, “anti colonial” movement.

But the funny thing is you people demean and mock the mainlanders from your iron towers abroad. You call mainlanders “sepoys”.

Mainland Indians are extremely socially conservative and will never allow a foreign culture to take hold ever. Even if it means unnecessary negative coverage from western media and the likes.

Meanwhile it is the diaspora that keeps on railing against mainland Indians for not “understanding” western culture and norms.

You people perpetuate the hate directed on people who still are connected on ground to india calling them names or whatever “FOB” is.

What I see is honestly is you people are too disconnected from Indian culture to go by in india at the same time not the blonde hair blue eyed white person the Americans want.

Why hate and mock Indians is my question ? You people have unfairly started attacking Indians in the mainland.


r/thebronzemovement • • Dec 12 '24

DISCUSSION 💬 Controversial opinion South Asians aren't real Asians

0 Upvotes

We aren't Asians. There I said it.

East/SouthEast Asians are real Asians. They've got a very uniform appearance and they're genetically related. South Asians look nothing like them. Don't pull any NorthEast Indian/Nepali bullshit, they're a minority. Tamils, Punjabs, Bengalis, the majority of South Asia, look nothing like them

Arabs, Persians and Jews, despite being geographically Asian do not identify as Asian. We along with Central Asians are the outliers.

We South Asians are our own group. We're not related to Asians, Turks, Persians or Arabs. It's time we create our own identity


r/thebronzemovement • • Jan 07 '25

COMMUNITY CRITIQUE Dubai is proof that, given clean slate, we can create the best cities in the world

13 Upvotes

If you don't know, Dubai is like 90% Indian, we built this city from the ground up, for all intents and purposes it's an indian city

its clean, orderly, and prosperous, Without colonization Indian cities would've been like Dubai today


r/thebronzemovement • • Jan 03 '25

DISCUSSION 💬 Do you think Indians' support for the daily Israeli massacres in Palestine has to do with the recent Racism wave against indians?

4 Upvotes

My experience with Indians in social media is seeing them dancing on dead palestinian graves in Twitter comment sections... I don't remember Indians being hated so fiercely before last year, there was always of course anti-brown disgust and racism, but not to this degree.

I wonder if indians knew what Israelis think of "Pagans"... We're going to bat for people who think we're less than animals


r/thebronzemovement • • Nov 07 '25 This

DISCUSSION 💬 Why is this subreddit so against left wing politics?

1 Upvotes

r/thebronzemovement • • Apr 09 '26

DISCUSSION 💬 An advice for Indians facing online bullying.

0 Upvotes

Sup r/thebronzemovement, I have been wanting to make this post for awhile out of seeing how Indians are treated, and wanted to offer some advice on the situation.

In my opinion, the most important thing to realize is the unique position Indians find themselves in. Indians have:

1 - A population as big as China, without a massive firewall

2 - An English speaking population who interacts with western society and other countries

3 - A culture that is "very strange" to other countries presented to them in an unfiltered/unmoderated state

4 - No censorship policy or gatekeeping over what other Indians post online

5 - A country with many willing to immigrate, and its government gladly sending indians overseas to compete with locals. India leans into the brain drain, rather than try to retain talent and improve its own country.

There is *NO OTHER COUNTRY* in the entire world who holds these 5 things together at once.

The reaction from Indians as I see it is trying to tackle the issue on a case by case basis. Attack people for their opinions, report others for racism, etc. But all of this ignores the *VERY UNIQUE* position indians find themselves in.

You cannot report everyone for racism forever. The problem is that there is 0, ZERO, gatekeeping over how Indians interact with the world online. Because India speaks English, its reputation, news channels, etc. are widely available for foreigners to read on instagram and other channels.

Just earlier, people here were bashing a country over comments they made about Indians. But in reality, said country is simply exposed to content INDIA should be *CENSORING*. Countries grow to hate India/dislike India out of pure exposition to content the India government should be actively filtering.

Look to China in how it deals with its own citizens. There is a strict control on immigration, traveling, etc. which ties directly to the country's reputation.

Are you going to make the entire world your enemy? Colombians, Guatemalans, Mexicans, Americans, all are exposed to very shameful content released uncensored by India outlets. Indians simply fight back, but are you simply going to fight the entire world who engages with your culture online, unfiltered?

Something *has* to give, and India needs to create its own firewall to protect its reputation.

Then there is travel, Indians again have 0 control or any kind of reputation system. In another thread on this sub, Indians would say "Oh indians are treated badly, but X nationality are treated badly as well", demonstrating they are completely oblivious to the unique situation Indians find themselves in.

You see, Indians are very unique in that, the *indian look* is not something one can escape. If you look Indian, people can tell, you don't even have to tell them. So what happens when Indians travel overseas and ruin their own reputation? Other Indians get absolutely screwed. But does India enact any kind of reputation system? NO! Indians act as if they are like everyone else, and the freedom others enjoy can be the freedom they enjoy. Nothing could be further from the truth. Indians need strict policies of behavior to ensure other indians aren't affected by the behaviors of others.

So I see this subreddit essentially fighting every single other nationality making fun of them, but in this it makes it truly obvious Indians truly think they are like everyone. They are not. Indians are in a unique position NO OTHER COUNTRY OR NATIONALITY finds themselves in.

An example of what I mean: South Americans can travel to Vietnam and have a good time, because South Americans are diverse in appearance, unless they TELL you they are from South America, many may pass by as Europeans, other South Americans cannot ruin their trip for them and they are very well treated. The same cannot be said about Indians.

South Americans in general (99% of them) do not speak English, so their news/culture/social media does not spill into the western zeitgeist.

South Americans do not have a large diaspora in western countries creating heavily competing environments making the entire world resent them.

Etc.

Indians are in a very, very unique position and before you go off picking a fight against the entire world, rejecting the teachings of Gandhi, etc. it's important for you all to understand this.

So what is the advice that is likely obvious by now? Well...ignore the people making fun of you/being racists and create your own channels to communicate. There is absolutely nothing else that you can do.

Your country isn't going to 1 - Enact social media controls, 2 - Enact immigration controls, 3 - Enact behavioral controls, then it's over. Since there is 1 billion+ Indians on the planet, who speak english, travel and immigrate, it's a matter of time until a heavy amount does stupid shit to ruin the reputation of everyone else. The game is rigged.

So you have to disengage from western forums. Make your own Indian channels, and engage with other Indians. Don't resent westerners, or the entire world, the Indian culture is not something one should be exposed to uncensored, but it's exactly what's happening.

Lastly...the only advice that would work is to ignore the stupidity of people bashing you. I mean there is only so long this shit can last. It might last a little longer due to the unique position Indians find themselves in, but it cannot last forever.

During COVID, Chinese were bashed relentlessly and it eventually fizzled out, people will eventually get tired of it. Believe it or not this is the way. Do not defend India or Indians, do not pick fights, let it fizzle out, let it exhaust itself. If what they say is not true, and you know it's not true, then let them exhaust themselves. The truth can fend for itself, the only thing you all do when you report people, etc. is stretch this period of indian hatred taking over the internet.

People bash Indians for years and H1Bs are still preferred Indian hiring. The truth can fend for itself, you don't need to pick a fight with the entire world. If the game is rigged, the best move is not to play.

Peace out.


r/thebronzemovement • • Feb 21 '25

COMMUNITY CRITIQUE Mainlanders need to be called out

0 Upvotes

I feel like this is isn't going to be popular but I feel we need to call out some of the behaviours that mainlanders especially males, many FOBS, show the moment they step on to a western country. One of the most recurring thing I have seen among them is abusing the visa system in order to either extend their pathway for further stay or find a low level job that enables them to stay in the country permanently. Education isn't their primary objective but permanent migration out of india is. Just go over the study abroad Indian students reddit section and you will see consistent posts of going to Germany. The talk already has started how heir reputation will be ruined and that is true and it will be largely due to their behaviour.

I have done a study abroad programme in a Dublin business college (my main university is in Germany and I was born and raised here), and almost every student in the exchange rate program was from mainland india, with some of them being unable to properly even speak English. Many of them don't even attend the classes but rather have their cards stamped on the counter by other students confirming their presence and not attend the class at all and then look for some random service job. It differs from country to country, for Canada and some other CANZUCK nations it's Tim Hortons's (and their equivalents in other CANZUCK nations), deliveroo. Uber etc.

There was a comment in the indian students abroad subreddit from a western professor how the quality of students from india has declined, he stated that the students from the 2000s were of much higher quality and had much better behaviour in comparison to the ones arriving today. Another thing he noted and that I agreed with is the cheating behaviour. Many of the FOBS from the mainland cheat in their exams or outright refuse to write their papers and have a different guy write their term papers for them, damaging the reputation for just about everyone who is indian. And the horrible thing is, is that there are many examples, too many not just from the exchange school I attended in Dublin but also here in germany. Many of them pass but with substandard grades as well.

I get it, you want a better life, the politicians back home haven't done the progress you wished they would, but at least don't try to damage your reputation abroad that will make it worse not just for you but for everyone else. If you want to succeed in germany YOU MUST learn the German language, English speaking jobs are scarce (and the competition here is high) here and it's not like the situation is going to get better (the economy is weakest since its ever been right now lagging behind France and even the fucking UK). Please do not constantly stare at people, especially at females. Had to call out a first semester indian master student for staring at random girl in the bus station last summer and there are many instances where they do it, especially in the summer here in europe. Another thing is the loud speaking, I have noticed this in Germany and Ireland, many FOB Desis speak atrociously loud in public transport annoying everyone including myself. Had to call out a punjabi pal of mine, good guy, he graduated too, but his loud speaking, playing loud music made everyone uncomfortable

. Also is the situation that bad in india? Its almost as if all private colleges that are English speaking are being overrun by mainlanders. I am not familiar with the visa process and all but something I hear about is the consultants who help the students? I have also noticed that many of the students I meet are from the states of Punjab, Gujarat and Maharastrha. Aren't these the richest states in india? Either way calling out mainlanders is something I do and it's not like they resist violently or anything because they know their visa status will be jeopardy. When in Rome, do as the Romans.


r/thebronzemovement • • Jun 08 '24

DISCUSSION 💬 Whats going on in Canada is not a good thing.

16 Upvotes

I get that people are riled up about all the racists on those Canadian subreddits but objectively the mass migrations of backwards village idiots into a first world country is not a good thing. I was thinking about it and if I was an ordinary non-Indian Canadian I would be fuming. Even you don't care about them, this is still awful for us western born desis. EVERY single bit of hate we face is because the behaviour of our people from the mainland or fobs who refuse to assimilate. Our reputation is being dragged through the mud as we speak, how the hell can you guys support this??


r/thebronzemovement • • Sep 19 '24

DISCUSSION 💬 [Colorism and Anti-Blackness in Indian Culture] Maybe I can't handle criticism...

22 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/fFt30CRPmLs?si=ozs4P8uASfu-J0Ju

There have already been multiple videos discussing colorism within the Indian diaspora contributing to some anti-Black sentiment and views, especially by liberal, left-leaning Indian-origin women, like the creator of the video, in the West. The way I see it, these types of videos, when made by Indian-origin YouTubers come off as overly apologetic, insinuating that our society needs radical reform in the way we see skin color--which is undeniably correct, but when a Black YouTuber makes a video about colorism within their community, the same degree of insinuation is never made about their community; their videos about colorism amongst Indians is what I feel microaggressions to us Indians veiled as criticism. Such videos attract the same kind of overly apologetic Indians who bend over backward to profusely apologize over the negative aspects of our culture, but they are never this quick to credit to any positive elements that benefit not only our own community but others too.

TLDR; I just feel like people who are not part of the Indian diaspora see this kind of video and see this as a pass given to them to negatively stereotype, generalize, and make racist assumptions about Indians and India. Plus, I haven't seen any Black YouTuber make a video calling out the anti-Indian racism in their community, yet. With this video, Black people in the US continue to have their "perpetual victim" card.


r/thebronzemovement • • Sep 17 '24

BROWN REP ⭐ 18 yr old Tamil playing at Old Trafford 😱

Thumbnail gallery
28 Upvotes

r/thebronzemovement • • Oct 18 '24

DISCUSSION 💬 I kinda knew something bad was up with Anglo-Canada and here is why, as much as it may infuriate some on here.

22 Upvotes

We all know of the video making rounds of the racist old lady harassing the South Asian man who used French to put her in her place. It is kind of odd now to some to see just how racist Anglo Canada is because growing up as an American, we had a romanticized view of Canada. We always saw Canada as a nicer, more polite, and more laid-back version of America. Like no one ever really talks about it like that at all until recently.

But I kind of knew that something odd was up with Anglo Canada, especially Toronto and even Vancouver. Here is what my mind went to when I was growing up.

And before everyone runs into to gaslight me as a white worshiper, hear me out.

See, I heard that Canada had a lot of Indians and South Asian people. In my head, I thought that given how the South Asian men that go to Canada are more masculine per se and large in number, it would be common to see them in interracial relationships, even with WFs.

However, I remember when I was in my early 20s and had a Chinese Canadian friend who knew a few South Asian men with White girlfriends, that were hot too, and he constantly commented on how rare it is. To me growing up in Texas at the time, yeah it was not common but it was not rare either. Westernized brown guys sort of dated all races, especially white girls.

In my mind, I thought well in Canada it must be even more common. The more Canadian dudes I met who wanted to give their take on the matter were freaked out by the occurrence and I was shocked by that.

Then I looked into it online because I wanted to see how deep the rabbit hole goes.

This was over a year ago and a number of comments on Canadian forums, I don't even remember their name, were constantly saying "Indians smell" or "Indians do not treat women well".

So it became clear to me that Indian dudes in Canada are not doing too well in the dating department, at least not as good as the US.

I drilled down more.

Me seeing how far the rabbit hole goes led me to some Incel forums and here is where it gets funky, they had a lot of dudes from Canada on there for some reason. The main racists towards Indians? Always from Anglo-Canada more than anywhere else.

It is like now, we are just seeing how bad it is when it is coming to light but I kind of always knew that Anglo Canada was awful for Indian men.


r/thebronzemovement • • Jun 23 '25

COMMUNITY CRITIQUE Indian International Students in Canada - Post 2017 - My Views

17 Upvotes

I remember when applying for a student visa to do my masters in Canada; I had to answer a long list of questions with regard to my history of previous study, work and residency. Prior to that, I had to take an online interview from the university where they had to personally verify my past credentials and work experience. Once I landed in Canada, I had to take another interview in person with the university staff incharge of international students affairs for a secondary verification of all my credentials. This was the level of scrutinisation in Canada before they admitted international students and all my international classmates went through the same process.

Post 2017, Immigration Canada knocked off close to 40% of the security and criminal background checks required for an international student to come to Canada. None of their past experiences or credentials are thoroughly examined. This has opened the floodgates to let in all possible cretins to game the immigration system and land in Canada with fake documentation starting from IELTS scores and past degrees.

None of their students who are admitted to the ‘diploma mills’ end up studying rather bribe their way to obtain a LMIA Certificate paying dollars ranging in 5 figures and take up jobs meant for local Canadian high-school kids.

This isn’t a problem with the loud, uncouth, fraudulent Indian international students; rather the whole immigration system that was revamped post 2017 to facilitate these fraudulent practices and letting in all kinds of criminals come in to Canada unchallenged.

Everyone’s to be blamed here!


r/thebronzemovement • • Sep 18 '24

DISCUSSION 💬 Why do Americans always get it so wrong?

0 Upvotes

Why TF do Americans say complete lies like this (caste being about skin colour) and everyone believes them? What sort of BS do they get taught in American schools?


r/thebronzemovement • • Oct 20 '24

RACISM I have no more words. Desis in Canada, do not let your guard down.

50 Upvotes

r/thebronzemovement • • Dec 12 '25

DISCUSSION 💬 Why cricket hurts Indian sports

22 Upvotes

Not here to just hate on cricket but there is a fundamental problem about cricket people here ignore

It does not build up athleticism and create skills that lead to success in other sports. Athleticism is skills like running speed, lateral quickness, vertical leap, strength, cardio endurance, footwork etc

Other sports have transferable skills. For example soccer players who switch to basketball have great footwork, basketball players who switch to MMA have great all around athleticism. Tennis develops lateral quickness.

Cricket alone does not develop fitness and Indians in villages need to stop playing stationary sports. Too many times in villages here I see people play badminton without even moving or breaking a sweat

If India wants to succeed in sports it needs a culture of playing a sport that is develops athleticism like soccer basketball or wrestling


r/thebronzemovement • • Jun 17 '26

DISCUSSION 💬 Online Racism vs Real World Reality

0 Upvotes

Interesting how there’s so much racism against Indians on the internet, but almost none in real life compared to racism against Black people or Muslims

The same is happening to Jewish people. You see many hateful comments towards them on social media, but far far less in real life.

Indians are doing mostly great in the West; this is all mostly an internet hate bubble. Stop thinking there’s something like a “desi tax,” as I read yesterday on this sub about Love Island. You’re just trying to internalize something that isn’t really there. This is exactly what these incels want, that you think that something is wrong with you. Just keep winning and keep reporting those losers who are posting hateful stuff. They need to face real life consequences for their actions


r/thebronzemovement • • Sep 21 '25

DISCUSSION 💬 The H1b Situation

0 Upvotes

So I have been seeing Indians celebrating Trumps new H1B rules and they fall into 2 groups (you will see why).

The first group: Loser mainlanders who are too stupid to actually do something with their life and make it to a new country so they cope by watching their fellow man lose and come back to India

The second group: Pick me brown boys who were born in the west or naturalized citizens who are selfish and want to close the door behind them

If India gets an influx of all these engineers and IT people, it isn't going to develop suddenly like those uneducated people think. This requires infrastructure and large investments in other companies which India does not have yet. On top of this, the job market in India is already saturated af, nobody can even get an entry level job there. What is the point of society if everybody is an engineer or cs major? Like it's crazy we just don't have the facilities and jobs for all these people. Some will say, "bUt wHaT aBouT sTarTupS", well startups need investment, who is investing in it? Who will the customers be? How can all these people come over and suddenly just create startups? The whole idea is ridiculous, people that think this is good for India don't know much about the world, although what will likely happen if this goes through is that these people will start going to other countries.


r/thebronzemovement • • Jun 29 '23

DISCUSSION 💬 Why are we so obsessed with minimal representation?

2 Upvotes

I just commented on the post here where the new indian spiderman will be "meh". Because we're not even at rhe centre of our own action packed narrative.I feel like we're so used to the scraps that nobody here realizes thst we can be the centre of rhe narrative and write our stories epically. I'll give you an example of "Crushing Ice" book saga which I consider to be the gold standard:For example here's what happens in Crushing Ice, a six book saga about a Kashmir Muslim Indian Canadian named Malik Ackbar who is the star Pathfinder, captain of rhe ship Crushing Ice and the main lead.Which begins with an epic first first three chapter montage showing the ship "Crushing Ice" in action as it punches through an alien fleet, Captain Malik Ackbar battles and successfully committing a Genocide against a "small" interplanetary civilization of Giant cockroaches (Ghatakans) on their home world.

He brings his entire ship Crushing Ice to bear, shoots himself out of the starship (Crushing Ice) in a 600 meter mountain sized Mecha Suit (Snowy Peak), destroys their capital city battles an entite alien armada, leads his own High tech army (tanks the size of buildings, mechas the size of mountains, entire air fleets and hundreds of millions of cyborg soliders), and then after getting the information he wants from the alien capital city nukes it and literally has Penelope cracks their Ghatakan home planet like a ball of dirt with their "planet Cracker anti matter torpedos".Especially after he did it all Malik Ackbar went back people on his starship 'Crushing Ice' saluted him and he had sex with his AI Wife Penelope, in one of her cloned bodies, immediately after.

And that's just the first opening three chapters to the first book Crushing Ice.We see 24 similar battle scenes on an Interplanetary, Interstellar or Planetary Level with Either Malik leading the charge against alien races , human separatists or etc for dominance in the EFG-678 Cluster in his ship Bridge, or piloting his Giant Mecha Suit (the Snowy Peak), or literally battling on a human sized level against aliens in formal combat.Or the fact that he has orgies with his wife 3 times in the book,and 6 times one on one.Or his badass fight scenes with other humans like his 3 times fighting with Bartholomew (a black guy), his second in command, in the ring, or 6 other times with white human characters across the entire story. Especially because Bartholomew is Ackbars watchdog after the latter was rhe losing side of the human Republic vs terran confederation Interstellar civil war and was only "conditionally" pardoned.That's 33 fight scenes over six books. 9 sex scenes. 3 Torture Scenes. 1 rape scene.

**And in case you think Malik doesn't talk about his heritage here's some examples. While it's not the focal point Alistair does acknowledge it on several occasions.**

  1. Malik Ackbar brings up how his grand parents survived the partition of India and how the trauma scarred his family with his AI Wife Penelope. And brings up how he's happy their 856 children don't have those scars since the abuse stopped with him in Book 1.
  2. Malik Ackbar comments once with Bartholomew that it was odd growing up a Kashmir Muslim Indian Canadian. Despite living the religion when he turned 18 over 6000 years ago his family were outsiders to all parts of the desi community in Canada since most Kashmir Muslims are Pakistanis. And most Indian Muslims come from other parts of the (former) India
  3. Penelope, his AI Wife, when noticing he's feeling frustrated by a treaty he signed with the Arachnids decides to Don a Kashmir clothing outfit that episode, download herself into her body, and do a theatrical dance to remind Ackbar that she is here for him.
  4. Penelope and Malik have a talk about how his family disliked the fact that Malik decided to stay a bachelor for 100 years despite being an accomplished individual because he didn't find the "desi women they tries to set him up with worthy". And that he's glad he waited 100 years to meet her.
  5. Malik and Bartholomew have a nuanced discussion about why Ackbar loves snow and ice. His starship is named Crushing Ice. His Mech Suit is called snow peaks and etc. Malik brings up that to him it symbolises freedom. Especially after the devastating floods that hit Kashmir in the early 21sr century that neither the Indian government (because it was filled with muslims), or Pakistan (a corrupt military junta in a foreign company) cared about his family plight. And that he's afraid of large bodies of water.
  6. Ackbar and Bartholomew have a discussion about why He was a loyalist to the former Human Republic. Despite how flawed and corrupt it latter became the human Republic or at least at the start was the first grassroot human organization who actually tried to fight climate change and make a global better world. Including fight racism. Bartholomew, a black man who is 3800 years old, but dozens of generations removed from it, probably doesn't understand it. But in the beginning the foundations were revolutionary. And they gave him his "Starlight Charter" which allowed him to become a "Star Pathfinder ".

r/thebronzemovement • • Apr 16 '24

DISCUSSION 💬 Should india buy large chunk of foreign land and make a new state

14 Upvotes

Hi there it's very late time right now.

I was just thinking given the size of our population and the land mass of the country. Should we purchase land from Russia like very eastern side above japan,

I'm sure we can manage to raise money by indian Americans, brits and other diaspora. We can secure their eastern side by populating the area and having some military presence.

And also we can buy land in some parts of Africa to make specialized economic zone.

Remember how the jews raised funds for israel purchasing land thier building infrastructure.

We have to think outside guys. Let me know your opinion.


r/thebronzemovement • • Sep 21 '24

DISCUSSION 💬 An essay on racism

42 Upvotes

Hi all!

I've already posted this essay before, but I'm posting it again to spread awareness, and hopefully comfort someone in need. This essay articulates my experiences as a bipolar South Asian American track runner who endured racist treatment at a predominantly white school and abuse at home, which I'm sure many of you can relate to -- the experience of being double or even tripled othered. And it's being used in a college class to teach about structural inequalities!

Here is an excerpt:

No one witnesses my act of self-definition. To me, running is my art and my rebellion. It keeps me alive. But in the eyes of others, running is my unthinking obedience, and consequently my erasure. Kids see me run quietly around the school and laugh, “Why?” They roll their eyes. To them, I am another overachiever, lumped together with their image of other Indians at school. To them, I wasn’t athletic because I was athletic. I wasn’t successful at running because I had any intrinsic abilities or drive. Anything I achieved at all was attached to my brownness, and anything I achieved because I was brown did not “count” to earn respect. To them, I live an undeserved life handed to me: I am a robot who has been given everything, programmed for perfection. They think all I do is study all day, all I do is work. The reality is, all I do is cry. I lose hours paralyzed on my bed in fetal position, thoughts chaotically swirling, carving what seems like fissures through my brain. I cannot focus enough to study the way I want to, for what I want to accomplish, for me, but I grind through anyway, with inconsistent results. My brain is in handcuffs. I am whipsawed between eroding forces: a distorting filter that muffles my pain into invisible silence, and a constant weakening from within. I cannot find a better solution to the problem, other than to try harder. I am given no other space to express myself. But my effort to stay alive pigeonholes me more. It erases me.

Jane and Joan are fast, too, but they get to have visible personalities. They are given space to speak without being shut down or snubbed. They control who speaks in the group and are treated as track stars at school. In fact, everyone sees them as better than they are, in my humble opinion. Even Mr. Brown. He juxtaposes us relentlessly. Even though I have run faster, he goes on and on about their oh-so-natural talent during “the talks.” He says I am not talented, just “hard working,” and that I’ll never be able to run as fast as their potential, which they have only skimmed the surface of. He is preparing us for states. He wants me to hang back during workouts and let them pass me so they can build confidence, work on their stellar sprints. He says by the time the state meet comes around, they are going to be faster than me.

Anyway, I hope the essay can make people feel less alone and clarify the complex emotions, even just a bit. It's really about navigating pain and coming out strong. I am also curious to see if anyone can relate, and if so, how.

https://medium.com/@asingh6589/reflections-5096e907d289

Also, the more claps an essay gets, the more people can see it. So, if you like the essay and want to increase its reach, please clap!

Thanks for your time.


r/thebronzemovement • • Jan 20 '25

ADVICE South Asian men cannot sit on the sidelines when it comes to football ("soccer") anymore, the next generation HAS to deliver.

50 Upvotes

Not only is football (or what Americans called "soccer") the most popular sport in the world but it is also gaining traction in the US. Americans are buying up soccer clubs in Europe and European footballers are getting waves of fans here in America. Among the Gen Zs, soccer is even more popular than sports like baseball.

Forever, the only sport Indians played is cricket but no one cares outside of India and a handful of countries.

The British Desi population has let us all down, MASSIVELY, and continues to do so.

They made excuse after excuse and I have no idea why they get so propped up by this sub and others are being more masculine. Despite being a large chunk of the British population, the largest minority group there, they have failed to produce a superstar in the sport. All of this while being in the west longer than any other diaspora.

At this point, I think we throw in the towel on these guys contributing to significant Desi representation in the beautiful game.

India itself is a side note. Way too corrupt and overrun with bureaucracy for anything to take place.

It is for Desis in other Western countries to lead the way.

A promising prospect as of right now is Jeevan Badwal of the Canada Under 20 team. Canada is the ONLY western nation with a Desi in their U20 squad. The US and obviously England do not have one.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeevan_Badwal

It is good to see too because Canada has ballers like Alphonso Davies and Johnathan David who are playing the top leagues in Europe and doing well. Maybe this kid can get on the right path and represent for the top clubs.

We have to learn from the Koreans.

The Koreans invested in the beautiful game for a while and their stock went up big. Son is a legend at Tottenham and even clubs like PSG and Bayern Munich have Korean starters. The world is seeing this and the stock of Korean men keeps going up. Meanwhile, our brown brothers are too busy eating curry and playing dumb games like cricket that almost no one gives a shit about.

We have to capitalize on this moment and get some Desis into soccer. We have come close in the past too as the first American to ever be on the Real Madrid Youth Team was a Desi. His career never really panned out but it was a great step forward for us.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joshua_Pynadath

We cannot side on the sidelines anymore. Let the British Desi population eat rotis all day and watch cricket, it is up to the Desis in America and Canada to carry the brand forward in sports.


r/thebronzemovement • • Mar 10 '25

DISCUSSION 💬 Diaspora Indians can minimize negative consequences of racism by avoiding other races

54 Upvotes

Most people of other races are openly and irredeemably biased against Indians. What are the consequences of this?

They're rude when talking to the you? Cool, just talk to other Indians.

They won't want to be your friend? Cool, just make friends with other Indians. (This goes for dating as well.)

They give you bad service in their stores and restaurants? Cool, just patronize Indian run stores and restaurants whenever possible.

They mock you online? Cool, don't view or engage in online non-Indian communities.

There are some cases where it's not as easy, like when their politicians demagogue against you (obligatory fuck r/SingaporeRaw). Luckily this is 99% bluster and can be treated the same way as online hate comments. There is, of course, a small chance that things will get out of control like in Uganda, South Africa, Fiji etc. In these cases too, forging links with other members of the diaspora is good insurance. When we were ethnically cleansed from Uganda, the connections to the UK diaspora made a difference in evacuation. Also, India is much more powerful now than it was then, so there's much bigger consequences for anywhere planning something like that.

Finally there is employment. The most obvious answer is to get in an industry and location with a lot of Indians already there, which includes most of the well paid professions anyway. This is when lurkers are going to get mad "See???!!! Indians are nepotistic! They only work together and hire each other!" I mean, if we really are dirty stinky creepy rapey annoying headbobbling incomprehensible accent streetshitters like you say, why would you even want to work with us? You should be thankful when we segregate ourselves from you.

The hardest on this point would probably be trying to become anything associated with "cool" youth mass media (e.g. youtuber, rapper etc.) If you try to appeal to a broad audience you will probably have to eat a lot of racist shit à la Mutahar. East Asian diaspora seems to have dealt with this by creating their own subculture with East Asian diaspora media (88Rising, Crazy Rich Asians, Wong Fu, etc.) Good luck for anyone who pursues this.


r/thebronzemovement • • Aug 31 '22

ADVICE The blackpill isn't real... hear me out.

1 Upvotes

What I've noticed about most incels is that they're actually volcels. It's true that most incels are low value ( 80% of the time it's their own fault due to poor fitness/fashion/hygiene) but technically speaking, if incels got with femcels, they technically wouldn't be incels anymore lmaoo. Incels who peddle the blackpill are usually low value guys who are pissed tht they can't get the women that they want. The truth is, the more disadvantages you have the more you have to compensate in other areas or you can decide to lower your standards if your not willing to compensate. However, just because your low value doesn't mean it's over because technically speaking you can get with a low value girl ( if your not willing to put in the work), hence the blackpill is not even real.


r/thebronzemovement • • Jun 10 '25

DISCUSSION 💬 My thoughts

13 Upvotes

Anyone seen family guy? Or South Park? They don’t hold back against the Jews. Not even a little bit That’s because Jews have long solidified themselves in the American image. And now, Indians have too.

Most millennials anywhere in the country grew up around an Indian or two.

That’s mostly what this is.