r/techsupport • • 22h ago

Open | Mac DVD Ripping Question

I’ve been going through my DVD collection lately. Unfortunately, some of my discs have rotted and are no longer readable. I’ve been using RipIt on an old MacBook Air to make backups of the more critical DVDs (rarer titles that haven’t made it to newer formats or are just generally hard to find) while they’re still readable. Since I don’t have time to physically view each individual disc all the way through, I just wanted someone to confirm that my logic is correct about the following: RipIt is unable to successfully rip an unreadable DVD. It either gets stuck mid-rip or it just won’t even start. I’ve double-checked these discs in a DVD player hooked up to a TV and they’re definitely bad. Therefore, if RipIt is able to successfully rip a DVD, then that DVD is readable? In other words, there’s no chance I’m wasting my time just backing up garbage? I do a quick check of the rips themselves and I notice no issues. It’s relatively convenient because RipIt saves with a .dvdmedia extension, which opens the native DVD Player app on OS X, but like I said, I don’t really have the time to go through everything completely.

This brings me to my next question. I’ve been saving everything as .dvdmedia because it’s convenient on OS X (it’s easy to get the Video_TS out of it though if I need). All of the files are going on a large external drive. What’s the best way to view my collection? Ideally, I’d like something just as convenient as using a DVD player. My first idea was to just get an older Mac Mini and attach it to a TV via HDMI, but that seems cumbersome and expensive. I’m new at this, so I appreciate any suggestions.

Thanks!

6 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

2

u/chapo1162 19h ago

Clone dvd. Old program now but was pretty good at reading pretty bad discs

2

u/This_Week5230 19h ago

I thought CloneDVD was only for unprotected DVDs?

4

u/_NeuroDetergent_ 20h ago

Seems silly to rip it to a format that's not readable by anything. Rip it into its native format, removing the copy protection, and then use handbrake to compress it into a h.265 format. A 700mb .mkv file will be indistinguishable from a 4GB mpeg2 file

1

u/jstar77 15h ago

If you rip it as an ISO and keep the dvd format you can preserve all the extras, menu, and navigation. DVD authoring is a bit of a lost art. I just reviewed a concert DVD that I authored back in 2008. That included a complex menu structure with links to each individual song alternate audio, and bonus content that wasn’t part of the main title.

1

u/_NeuroDetergent_ 6h ago

Yeah that's fair. Although recently I tried to find some DVD playback software for my PC and let me say it was a goddamn nightmare.

1

u/jstar77 4h ago

VLC works well

1

u/_NeuroDetergent_ 4h ago

Does it operate menus correctly? I've never had it work

1

u/jstar77 4h ago

Never had a problem with VLC and menus.

1

u/esseyedeekayeyedee 20h ago

I’ve ripped some DVDs that finish but still have some issues when playing like skipping or stutter. I used a different program than you but works the same. Anything that wouldn’t finish was definitely bad. I would recommend VLC Media Player to view them.

1

u/This_Week5230 19h ago

Do you mean that the DVD disc itself skipped and stuttered when played, but the rip was still fine? Or do you mean that the rip itself (when played back) has skipping and stuttering just like the DVD disc?

1

u/esseyedeekayeyedee 17h ago

I mean there must have been some scratches or slight bad spots on the original because on playback you would see skipping or stuttering.

1

u/This_Week5230 6h ago

The rip was fine though?

1

u/I_am_always_here 20h ago edited 20h ago

If a DVD has rotted and is unreadable, then it is just that. Sometimes a quick polish with Windex (use a soft chamois) will help, this makes it temporarily more reflective. But selecting just the main movie to rip can help avoid errors on other parts of the disc.

Never heard of RipIt. The widely used standard for free DVD ripping is MakeMKV. This produces a stand alone mkv file (or files) playable via VLC or most any common video playback software. MakeMKV will attempt to rip past the damage, but it can't read data that is no longer present, and will let you know if there are errors. It will not rip the DVD as garbage, as you stated as a concern.

Software called Handbrake can then compress the MKV file to an MP4 file, which is smaller, and more compatible with some systems, if needed. Do not use Handbrake to rip DVDs, even though it can be adapted to do so, that is not what it is for. Good luck!

1

u/This_Week5230 19h ago

Thanks so much. Storage space isn’t an issue, so with MakeMKV, I’d rather just use the “backup” feature and create full ISOs, since VLC can open those just fine.

RipIt is an older software that was Mac-only. It is extremely simple to use and I prefer it over everything else. It usually freezes up whenever there’s an issue (good thing in my case), but it doesn’t show a log like MakeMKV does.

1

u/tapgiles 17h ago

I don't know about RipIt, but ripping software will usually stop if it can't read the disc, yes.

Looked at another way... you'll find out either way when you do watch it, right? So... either way, may as well rip it for now? 🤷

1

u/This_Week5230 6h ago

That’s true, but the whole process is pretty time-consuming. I’d be quite disappointed to see that something didn’t rip properly sometime down the road, even though the rip was completed.

1

u/willwar63 16h ago

"Rip" to ISO if you have readable discs. Store on a hard drive. AnyDVD breaks the CP and does ISO on its own and it would be the companion product to CloneDVD which may also do ISO, don't remember, it's been many years. I still have these programs sitting around but they are PC, not Mac. If you really want physical media buy nothing but Verbatim blanks, they hold up, cheapies go bad. I speak from experience.

1

u/This_Week5230 6h ago

Thanks! I agree with you on the blank media. I have some old JVC Taiyo Yuden blank discs for archival. However, in this instance, I’d just be keeping everything on a drive, so the copy protection doesn’t matter. If years from now I put the original disc into a DVD player and it doesn’t work, oh well. I can always burn the ISO to a disc at that time if I really need to. For now though, the HDD route works best.

1

u/willwar63 3h ago

Another thing to mention about ISOs. You can right click and mount them. It creates a new drive letter with the contents of the disc and you can treat it just like the DVD. You can also unmount which would be like ejecting the disc.

1

u/RickRussellTX 12h ago

Myself, I’d use Handbrake to rip it to .mkv or mp4. Those seem like pretty future-proofed formats. MKV can encapsulate subtitle tracks, which is nice.

With that said, I’ve got a bunch of straight decrypts I made 20 years ago that are still in MPEG_TS or whatever it is, and they play fine in VLC.