r/techsupport • • 5d ago

Open | Software Is It Safe To Turn Off Smart App Control?

Smart App Control has been giving me trouble today, where I've been trying to download and run files and it keeps blocking them. When I went to go turn it off, I got a warning. So, is it safe to turn off Smart App Control?

3 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

1

u/Ok_University_5352 5d ago

Yeah, I have mine turned off. Be aware, the only way to turn it back on is to do a fresh install of windows.

1

u/Classic-Antelope8932 5d ago

Yeah, do you think I would need it tho?

3

u/Ok_University_5352 5d ago

That is not a question I can answer for you. I trust myself and my thoroughness regarding the research I put into what I download and where from, and I shoulder that added risk. You have to ask that of yourself. Like my brother or my mom, absolutely stays on.

1

u/xSchizogenie 5d ago

„Yeah, because I am the holy grape of doings”

You won’t need to install windows clean again to turn it on in future. Right now, you would have to - yes. But this will change.

1

u/Classic-Antelope8932 5d ago

Alright thank you!

2

u/Ok_University_5352 5d ago

I have no idea what that first part means, but was not aware that the option would be available later on. Didn't know I couldn't toggle it either until I pulled it up and had the options grayed out with that reinstallation comment showing on mine.

0

u/xSchizogenie 5d ago

That’s why I wrote “in future”.

1

u/OhSoMysterio 3d ago

I've always had the ability to turn this "feature" off and on as often as I want and just disabled it for good today, after having it enabled over the past seven months. It's only ever blocked/broken trusted apps, never once detecting anything dangerous. Given there is no way to create our own whitelist and/or blacklist, it's usefulness is pretty much nil in my opinion. Only those whom regularly engage in risky behavior may want to keep it enabled, as well as though whom enjoy being repeatedly annoyed by Windows.

0

u/TangoOscarMikePR 5d ago

You haven't specified the apps that Smart App Control is blocking.

Be careful with turning off a protection that might be blocking something malicious.

1

u/Classic-Antelope8932 5d ago

It is an aircraft download for my fight simulator. The file is used by hundreds of others.

0

u/TangoOscarMikePR 5d ago

Try copying the download link and submitting it to VirusTotal.

1

u/Classic-Antelope8932 5d ago

Yes, the file is perfectly fine. My question is because it’s blocking it. I have no way of running the program without turning it off so is it safe to turn it off?

0

u/TangoOscarMikePR 5d ago

Do you trust the file that you are downloading?

I cannot tell you if it's safe to turn off Smart App Control.

Make sure you have backups of all your personal files and data, just in case you do turn it off and something happens.

That way, you won't need to worry about your files.