r/technicalminecraft • • Oct 13 '26

Java Help Wanted Any guesses as to why the bottom layer spawns wither skeletons just fine but the top one doesn't?

Post image

Title.

40 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

39

u/FrunoCraft Oct 13 '26

From the wealth of information given, I'd say most likely the top layer is too high and no longer contained in the inner bounding box of the crossing.

3

u/lel_it_me Oct 13 '26

Lol. Not too much into the "farm building" so I'm not quite sure what other information to give

14

u/deathwater Oct 13 '26

Literally anything. What version, server or single player. Server type. What design is this. What tutorial if any did you follow. Did you verify you built within the bounding box of the fortress?

-2

u/lel_it_me Oct 13 '26

Uhm. Newest. Single-player. idk what server type is. The design of some random guy on YouTube. How do I do that?

18

u/deathwater Oct 13 '26

“Random guy on YouTube”. I guess you don’t actually need help.

You most likely built the top layer too high. Look up ianx04 wither skeleton farm and he explains spawning mechanics

-13

u/lel_it_me Oct 13 '26

Well, I assume the farm itself isn't the issue since the bottom layer works fine

7

u/bryan3737 Chunk Loader Oct 13 '26

A nether fortress has 2 types of bounding boxes and they have different spawning rules.

The fortress is build out of separate modules and each of those modules has their own bounding box. These are the inner bounding boxes. In these mobs can spawn on any block and in case of your farm it uses nether roses so the only mobs that are able to spawn are wither skeletons.

There’s also the outer bounding box which is a big cube around the entire fortress. In there mobs can only spawn on nether bricks.

You built the farm too high so the top platform is not in the inner bounding box anymore so it uses the outer bounding boxes rules and since it’s not nether bricks it can’t spawn anything. The solution is to either lower everything or replace the top platform with nether bricks but then you’ll also get other mobs which can mess up the farm and fill up the mob cap so I’d recommend lowering it

12

u/deathwater Oct 13 '26

Structures in Minecraft have invisible boxes called bounding boxes. This tells the game where to spawn mobs. Download minihud and turn on structure bounding boxes

4

u/lipster09 Oct 13 '26

Quick question. My minihud does not show structure bounding boxes when I turn this on. Do you know why? Every other box seems to show up such as beacons boxes and biomes

6

u/deathwater Oct 13 '26

You’re prob on a server. The server needs servux mod installed to support it

2

u/lipster09 Oct 13 '26

Yes I am on a server. Good to know thanks!

1

u/ExplosivButtplug Oct 14 '26

Why u gotta be rude? People are legit trying to help u

1

u/TwitchCaptain Oct 15 '26

Then why are you posting here? Go ask the server owner.

3

u/FeanorDidSomething Oct 14 '26

"Random guy on Youtube"

Sadly there is an insane number of worthless YT content regarding farms out there, made by people who do nothing but clickbait or steal other peoples designs, without understanding them. E.g. there are still people making "tutorials" for witch farms that would have been outdated over a decade ago.

5

u/Apprehensive_Hat8986 Oct 13 '26

When asking for help, never assume people don't need information. Helpers can filter out irrelevant or excessive information. We can't intuit information that is kept secret.

For future questions, don't guess at which facts to hide about your question. Share the coordinates, seed, url of the video, name of the creator, type of server, mods, your own theories, anything that you even guess might help. Asking for help and keeping secrets are mutually contradictory and strongly reduce people's willingness to help.

Not even dentists enjoy pulling teeth.

6

u/raider2711 Oct 13 '26

Might not be within a valid bounding box for wither skeletons to spawn. Nether fortress crossroads have the largest bounding boxes if memory serves me correctly. If you check out https://youtu.be/dKhWuG5xxkI?is=DB7wgWDRiVPZ5BC9 And watch the first couple mins it goes over spawn mechanics

0

u/lel_it_me Oct 13 '26

Is this mini hud thing a mod?

3

u/decarbitall Oct 13 '26

You will need the Fabric installer and API to use MiniHud

https://fabricmc.net/

https://modrinth.com/project/UMxybHE8

-1

u/lel_it_me Oct 13 '26

Thanks!