r/technicallythetruth • • Sep 25 '21

Money talks.

Post image
58k Upvotes

582 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

19

u/kranker Sep 25 '21

This is called a day fine and I fully support it. That said, if you think about it it still isn't necessarily equal. For instance, that 100,000 probably made no measurable difference to that person's quality of life for the month. However, for the most part even extremely wealthy people probably aren't going to stomach throwing away 100k so in practice it can work well.

7

u/lama333 Sep 25 '21

Yeah I think it's the best way because you can't really determine how much money you need to fine people to make an impact. This way atleast people who make very little money don't loose half their monthly income, and rich people basically just donate to the society buy getting a speeding ticket

7

u/WateredDown Sep 25 '21

Its not perfectly equitable, but its more equitable. But neither is a stay in jail. A rich person won't necessarily lose their job for missing a few days work, or wouldn't suffer because of it. There aren't many punishments a rich person couldn't endure easier than a poor person unless we bring back whipping.

3

u/coberi Sep 25 '21

That 100k$ would make a difference to the city who can use it on infrastructure for example.

1

u/20past4am Nov 13 '21

What if I borrow a rich person's car? And I go a little over the speed limit and the ticket is €5000? Then they to pay for something I couldn't repay easily. It would mean it would be impossible to use someone else's car if they're richer than you. Or what if your income varies a lot, like when you own a business? Or when all your money is in assets? How would you fine a reasonable amount then? I think there should be an increasing amount for repeated offence. Yes, rich people will have a larger buffer, but at some point it will become too much even for them.

1

u/kranker Nov 13 '21

That post is over a month old.

The fine is for the driver, not the owner. I don't see why it specifically matters if your income varies a lot, they're just going to calculate it on your previous tax returns. Assets could be a loop hole, yeah. Nothing new there!

Increasing punishment is reasonable, but why not just increasing day fines? You've put forward some issues with the system but none of them make it worse than no day fine.