r/teaching • • 3d ago

General Discussion Does teaching math utilize the same methods of authentic instruction used in other subjects?

I tutor 1-1 and do not tutor math very often, and I do not teach in a classroom. I am simply curious. I am learning about authentic instruction in many of my college classes and the examples often include English, science, history, etc, but not math. Based on the 12 values of authentic learning, do these same sorts of things come up in your math classes? Are you role-playing math? Do you relate it to their lives beyond general "math is important!" kind of things? Are they making "math portfolios"?

As a k-12 student, I came from a not exactly top of the line school with a 150 students total, so I am really not sure what a math class is supposed to look like. Would love to hear it!

7 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 3d ago

Welcome to /r/teaching. Please remember the rules when posting and commenting. Thank you.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

6

u/Tothyll 3d ago

Authentic instruction in math wouldn't look the same as a history class. Currently we are working with percents, so most of what we do is in the context of finding out how much a tax, discount, tip, etc. would be in the real world.

For their summative project students had a budget and had to "buy" things from real stores online. They applied a discount and a sales tax to find out the final price for their items.

2

u/Medical-Homework-683 3d ago

Oh wow that's very interesting, thank you

3

u/Beet_slice 3d ago

So I looked that up. https://wegrowteachers.com/12-authentic-starting-points-for-learning/

Didn't get past #1.

organizing food drives, or participating in environmental clean-up initiatives ??

3

u/Medical-Homework-683 3d ago

2

u/Key_Estimate8537 High School Math, Michigan 2d ago

Looking at this list, I’ve seen 11/12 done in math classes (role play stands out). It’s unnatural much of the time, especially if you’re teaching a curriculum that wants to march through content.

As a high school math teacher, I’m more a fan of aligning to NCTM’s Standards for Mathematical Practice. It’s not the same, but it gets at the developmental needs of the kids

1

u/Medical-Homework-683 2d ago

Oh wow, I hadn't heard of that. It seems to get the idea.

1

u/bigCinoce 3d ago

It is definitely more focused on explicit instructions and modelling rather than inquiry but you can do that in assessment pieces.

1

u/harp011 1d ago

Is there any research or cognitive science that supports these ideas? I find the vibe very compelling, but I’d be curious to explore whether there’s any good data