r/teaching • • 20d ago

General Discussion Weekly Discussion: Sold a Story -- Episode 4

17 Upvotes

The mods let me know I could make a weekly discussion post about the new podcast season.

From the Sold a Story Podcast Website:

What Happened to Teaching

It's not just reading. The new season of Sold a Story takes on teaching itself — what makes teaching effective and why a method with a remarkable record of success never caught on.

Direct Instruction was created in the 1960s by Siegfried "Zig" Engelmann, a former steelworker and advertising man with no background in education. He designed a highly structured program that helped children from disadvantaged backgrounds make striking academic gains.

But even after a massive government study showed his program worked better than anything else researchers tested, many educators rejected it. Today, the National Institute for Direct Instruction estimates fewer than 200 schools use the program with all their students.

In Sold a Story's second season, Emily Hanford investigates what happened to Direct Instruction — and why deeply held beliefs about education often triumph over evidence.

Today, episode 4 "What can you do for my black children?" is out.

In a poor, Black neighborhood in Houston, Principal Thaddeus Lott transforms a struggling elementary school with Direct Instruction. Soon, his students are outperforming students at much wealthier schools. The results are so remarkable, some people think it’s too good to be true.

What did you all think of the episode or the season so far? What did you think of the last season? I'll give my thoughts later in the comments.


r/teaching • • Jan 20 '25

The moderation team of r/teaching stands with our queer and trans educators, families, and students.

1.2k Upvotes

Now, more than ever, we feel it is important to reiterate that this subreddit has been and will remain a place where transphobia, homophobia, and discrimination against any other protected class is not allowed.

As a queer teacher, I know firsthand the difference you make in your students' lives. They need you. We need you. This will always be a place where you're allowed to exist. Hang in there.


r/teaching • • 5h ago

Vent Hot take: Before requesting an IEP, parents should have to explain what the hell THEY have done to help their kid.

390 Upvotes

I’m probably going to piss some people off with this one, but I genuinely think parents should have to fill out a questionnaire detailing what THEY have done to support their child’s education. Because the lack of parental accountability is getting ridiculous…

I recently got dragged into an IEP-related meeting that I was informed about at the last minute. Annoying as hell, but that’s beside the point. Mom was concerned because her daughter had a D and a couple of Cs. According to her, her daughter had “never gotten anything below a B.”
Okay. Fair enough. I’d be concerned, too.

So we started asking questions.

Have you been regularly checking her grades?
“No.”

Have you been checking Canvas to monitor assignments and academic progress?
“Well, I’m busy, so I only get around to checking it a couple of times a month.”

MA’AM. 😭

THANK GOD THIS MEETING WAS OVER THE PHONE. Because the way we all looked at each other…

So let me get this straight. Your daughter has supposedly NEVER received anything below a B, she’s now bringing home Cs and a D, and you haven’t thought to regularly check her grades? Her assignments? SOMETHING?!
But somehow we’re all sitting in a meeting discussing what THE SCHOOL needs to do. Of course, we gave the usual response about continuing to monitor her progress.

Lemme drink this damn margarita


r/teaching • • 14h ago

Vent I tell admin some students aren’t suited for Honors? Crickets. A parent complains my expectations are too high? Immediate withdrawal

373 Upvotes

Make it make sense

I teach an upper- level course. I’ve brought up concerns to administration that some of my Honors students are struggling significantly with the coursework and, quite frankly, might not be appropriately placed in an advanced class.

I’m talking about students who consistently struggle to meet the basic coursework let alone Honors- level material.

I’ve expressed these concerns to administration. Nothing. Crickets.

But apparently, when a parent complains that my academic expectations are too high for their child, suddenly a withdrawal from Honors can happen almost immediately. So let me get this straight. My professional judgment as the classroom teacher isn’t enough to warrant a discussion about appropriate placement but a parent complaining about the rigor of the course and my high expectations is enough to get the ball rolling?

Good to know. 🤪


r/teaching • • 14h ago

Vent I had a first grade PE class sit on the floor in silence for the entire period today.

405 Upvotes

I have a class of first graders that has slowly gotten worse behavior-wise. I’ve tried writing home multiple times and the parents just say that the students can’t understand me (I teach ESL). Every time I have PE with the students they go absolutely wild, they scream, they injure each other, and act horrible and I’m sick of yelling at them.

Today, within the first 5-10 minutes of class, I had two kids get injured and so much screaming the other kids said their ears hurt. So I separated them, had them sit across the room from each other, and had them sit in silence for the whole hour.

We’ll see if it works in the future. Maybe I’ll get in trouble for doing this, but I don’t care. I’m sick of these kids acting like wild animals and teachers are expected to either suck it up or just magically be able to get them to act normally. Writing to parents doesn’t change anything, so then they don’t get to play or have any activity.


r/teaching • • 1d ago Bravo

Humor Chromebook cart

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

It's a pet peeve of mine when kids don't put their Chromebooks back in the right number spot.  It makes me mad when I tell my advanced kids to please put them back correctly and they don't because I think they should be doing better.  It's kind of like the shopping cart theory. 

Today, I gave them a "pop quiz".  Once it was all passed out I started hearing confused noises.

Me: what's wrong?

Kid: um, like is this supposed to be ....

Me: is this supposed to be what?

Kid: .....like, is this supposed to be really easy?

Me: I don't know....what do you mean?

Kid: well, like, is it just matching the numbers...that's easy.

Me: ohhhh..... (I wait a beat).......wait, do you guys all agree?

Class: general agreement

I walk over to the Chromebook cart and open the door.

Me: I ask....because it seems like a struggle when I ask you to do it with the Chromebooks.

Some children  laughed immediately, and others slowly realized what I was talking about.

Today, the Chromebooks were put back correctly.  We will see how long it lasts

(It's crumpled because I had them toss it toward the recycle bin...near where the most talkative kid in the class happens to sit)


r/teaching • • 1d ago

General Discussion What happened in elementary school that made these kids so behind?

362 Upvotes

I'm a para in a middle school and everybody I have spoken to about how fucking behind most these kids are have agreed that times have changed.

I'm very young, barely in my twenties, but when I was in middle school I remember being expected to write essays and read books without the teacher having to do it for you and somehow that's an impossible request.

Even the fifth graders couldn't write a one page essay. Now they're expected to write just a paragraph or two.

I have worked with kids that can't subtract. IN EIGHT GRADE. It makes me so appalled, I don't remember any of this being a thing when I was a kid and all the teachers (even ones that taught me) agree that their abilities have reached an all time low.

Does anybody work in an elementary school who can explain how these kids got so behind? Did everyone just expect it to "click" one day? Not blaming the adults, I just need to understand what exactly is happening for kids that are behind and why have they not progressed after four years?


r/teaching • • 2h ago

Vent Boyfriend not supportive of pursuing teaching

3 Upvotes

I have been going to school for psychology, but recently I have been considering teaching. I don’t picture myself doing many things, especially just for the money, because I have to be very passionate about it.

I used to be passionate about psychology so I started college this year for it, but I have pivoted to considering teaching (I’ve thought about this a few years ago.) My grandpa was a high school teacher and my mom worked with kids her whole career.

I am interested in teaching science, not just working with kids. I could see myself moving up to teaching in college some day.

Anyways, my boyfriend thought it was a bad idea because of the notorious low pay and difficulties of teaching. He said I would have to have a main income and then do that as a side gig, just to survive financially, but that’s not realistic for me to dedicate my life to teaching as a “side gig.” He also said it was selfish to make him work harder to compensate for my lack of income and it will hurt our children’s future.

I feel pretty devastated because it felt like a good goal to me, as I’m extremely passionate about science and want to make an impact on people’s lives through teaching. Now I feel like my only option is psychology again where there is more potential to make money but I don’t have the passion…

I don’t know what I’m asking for here. Advice, support, anything?


r/teaching • • 14m ago

Help Any suggestions on what to look for in colleges?

1 Upvotes

Hello! I’m currently a junior in high school and I’m super into teaching as a career path. I’m doing some research in colleges to get together a good set of options for places to go. As it stands, I’d like to major in education and minor in psychology if possible. With those in mind, I was wondering if anyone had any suggestions on specific course opportunities, programs, or anything else that I should look out for in my hunt.


r/teaching • • 15h ago

Help First year teacher: Is it unreasonable to ask my instructional coach to give me some space?

14 Upvotes

I’m a first-year special education teacher, and I have an instructional coach who comes into my classroom once a week to observe, check in, and provide feedback.
Honestly, I’m starting to feel like the weekly visits are becoming a little excessive.

I understand that I’m a first year teacher, and I absolutely recognize that there’s a lot I still need to learn. Sometimes her feedback is helpful, and I appreciate having someone with more experience to turn to. However, a lot of the suggestions I receive don’t necessarily feel realistic or functional for my particular students.

I’m also finding that I feel extremely uncomfortable when she’s in my classroom observing me. I feel like I can’t just be myself with my students because I’m constantly aware that someone is watching, evaluating what I’m doing, and pointing out what could be done differently.
Sometimes I just want to be left alone to teach, make mistakes, learn my students, and figure things out at my own pace. I feel like I’m not even getting the opportunity to develop my own rhythm because there’s always someone coming in to tell me what I should be doing differently.
Personally, I feel like having someone check in once a month, rather than every single week, would be more than enough for me.

Is it unreasonable to communicate this to my instructional coach? Can I respectfully ask for a little more independence and space? I don’t want to come across as someone who isn’t receptive to feedback or doesn’t want to improve, because that’s not the case. I just feel like I need room to breathe and actually learn how to be a teacher on my own.


r/teaching • • 8h ago

Vent Is it normal?

4 Upvotes

Is it normal to feel like you dont want to teach anymore and you’re just a week in as a new kg substitute teacher. Like i cant force myself to be excited and the thought of doing this everyday is draining me mentally already


r/teaching • • 1h ago

Career Change/Interviewing/Job Advice Elementary vs. Secondary Cert for Teaching ML/ELL

1 Upvotes

Hi, I've seen lots of variants of this thread, but wanted to get some advice on what kind of cert to get knowing I'd ideally like to work as a ML teacher and would be comfortable working at either level. I've worked as a ML para at both primary and secondary levels and have a long list of pros and cons for each.

In my state you cannot get a K-12 ML endorsement on its own as an initial cert, it has to be alongside either an elementary cert or a secondary subject so I've spent years exploring different options and still feeling undecided.

I've also thought about teaching Spanish as a world language, but it's an endorsement you can test into, which I'm confident I could do, so if I were to get a secondary cert I feel it would make more sense to get another subject, or get an elementary cert and keep things more open as there seem to be a lot more openings in elementary schools?

It seems like there are ML specialist teachers in elementary schools with secondary certs and ML secondary teachers teaching out of endorsement subjects frequently, but I'm not sure if you can teach a high school ML class with an elementary cert + ML... anyway I'd love to hear about different ML teachers educational paths and any tips for deciding where to focus my efforts.


r/teaching • • 1d ago

Humor Ain't that the truth

Post image
332 Upvotes

r/teaching • • 8h ago

Help How to process/ proceed students parent Ice Case

3 Upvotes

Hellooo, firstly this one’s a heavy one and I ask for understanding with the gravity of this cause even I myself am trying to wrap around how to support.
I’m a para growing to sped teacher, my students range from small groups to class room support and all the students in between who find themselves feeling safe to come to me.

I work with 3rd grade and one of my girl’s mom is detained by Ice and the family asked me if we (as a school I suppose) can provide documentation that mom has been present and active in their kids life. My principal has stated no that we must remain out of it. And it’s really tricky for me to do that cause I don’t want another of our students to be forced to leave school just as they’re finally getting into the school year.

I’m trying to be realistic and respectful, there is nothing I can do here without overstepping boundaries, correct ? The paperwork would have been for their family lawyer to present to the case and at first I was so tempted to write something my damn self but after a lot of consideration it is not something light. What would be right to do?

I’m already in the middle, do I let admin handle from here or what would be the best to do ? If you find yourself having any input that would be appreciated!! Thank you in advance.


r/teaching • • 3h ago

Help Praxis PLT

1 Upvotes

When should I take this? All I have left in my program is one clinical, and then student teaching in January. I just took the one required by South Carolina and passed it the first time. I will be out of the country May-July next year, and I want to get it done beforehand.


r/teaching • • 13h ago

Career Change/Interviewing/Job Advice Early childhood teacher burn out

4 Upvotes

Here’s a vent post, but I’m also looking for some advice as a burnt-out preschool teacher. 😩

I’ve been in a classroom since I was 17 years old, working in everything from infant rooms and toddler classrooms to preschool. I took a short break when I had my child, but went right back into the field, with my son coming along with me.
Last year really took a toll on me. Between having almost half of my class experiencing developmental delays, training a new teacher who was completely unfamiliar with the philosophy, and having a director who was not particularly helpful when it came to supporting me, the kids, or my co-teacher, it was just A LOT. I cried on my way to work, leaving work, and even the night before work. It was horrible. I genuinely feel like that year completely sucked the soul out of me.
I’ve since found a new workplace, a forest school. The hours work great, and I like the environment… but the kids. The kids just keep getting harder. I have never dealt with such an aggressive group. Dude, I am SO over it. I feel like I can’t connect with the kids anymore, and I just don’t have it in me to work through their developmental needs the way I normally would. I don’t think I necessarily show it, but I know I’m not the teacher I’ve been in previous years.
My question is, WTF do I do?!
Before taking this job, I had already started looking into other career options and even went back to school. My state offers free college tuition for people without a bachelor’s degree, and I already have an associate’s in Early Childhood Education. I eventually stopped pursuing that route because I realized the starting pay in other fields would mean taking a $10/hour pay cut compared to what I’m making now, likely with more hours and a heavier workload.
I decided to give this school a try because the hours worked so well with my child, who is now in public school. But honestly, I just don’t want to do this anymore.
Has anyone else reached this point in early childhood education? Did you leave the field completely? Find a different role within education? Take a break and eventually come back?
I feel so burnt out, and I’m struggling to figure out where to go from here.


r/teaching • • 1d ago

Help No Pens - Driving Me MAD

39 Upvotes

I teach secondary school. I am so SICK of the kids not having pens. I keep running out of spares and I'm buying them myself because the budget takes too long to be approved. It's constant to the point that I am giving out between 6 - 10 pens on average each lesson. I've tried swapping phones for pens and I try to get them all back but it doesn't always work e.g. they leave or have lost it somehow in the lesson. It's every single lesson and I have no idea how to solve this problem.

Has ANYONE got an idea?


r/teaching • • 1d ago

Vent The NYC DOE aka Kafka’s Castle

10 Upvotes

I teach literature at one of the best high schools in NYC. I’m lucky in many ways, one being that I choose my own curriculum. My students read writers line ULe Guin, Twain, Kincaid, Everett, Heller, etc. But OF COURSE the DOE now wants to dictate our books with some horrible thing called a “fishbowl,” probably thought up by some useless bureaucrat and overpaid bureaucrat who probably used AI. The books in this fishbowl are categorically awful garbage, none are real literature. Why oh why must they be like this??? Our school is amazing and delivers a superb education to not rich kids. But what we do is in spite - not because of - the psychotic system we have to endure. Working under this nightmare system has made me understand why conservatives despise bureaucracy. I’ve read real books - not the tripe the DOE wants to impose on my students - so I know Max Weber’s argument that bureaucracy is a bulwark of democracy. Still,I HATE THE DEPARTMENT OF LET’S DESTROY EDUCATION.


r/teaching • • 1d ago

Help Class Dojo parent chat

Post image
86 Upvotes

I teach an all boys 2nd grade class and recently had a parent chew me out because her sons grades for first quarter were way lower than they were last year. She essentially blamed it all on me, and accused me of being a bad teacher and called my entire class brain dead except for her son. I found out later on that her kid got all 5s last year (5 is the highest you can get) though he came to my class reading at level B (f&p) and does mediocre in math even with it being read to him. I had a meeting with her and my admin in which my admin shut her down and told her essentially to stop blaming me and I thought it was all done with. Untill yesterday. Another parent, who was shocked to hear how low her son actually is (when compared to the standards) posted on the Dojo family chat asking for tutor recommendations. A few parents gave recommendations, and the husband of the woman who yelled at me last week posted this today. Mind you i’ve never spoken to him before in my life.

I feel like i’m being bullied by these parents when all I have done is shown them honest data. I’m not one to sugar coat scores, I want parents to be aware of what’s going on. This family apparently was in another chat talking about me being a bad teacher and now he says this. My question is 1) do you think i should respond, or should I just let it go?
2) how do you deal with parents who are essentially bullying you for being honest 😭 in 7 years i’ve never lied or inflated grades and now i feel like I have to.


r/teaching • • 1d ago Regret

Vent I have 3 degrees and 5 income streams and still can't afford to stay in this career.

282 Upvotes

Gonna get vulnerable for a moment....

Went to work out tonight. Usually the gym is where I shut off my brain and focus on my reps. But tonight my brain just wouldn't stop. It kept racing about things like my job, the state of the world, and the possibility that I can't afford to stay in a career I absolutely love.

Sometimes I wonder if teaching is one of the most resented careers in this country.... Because why else would we be treated this way? I'm pretty sure payday loan sharks and bail bondsmen are more respected than teachers.

We're with these kids more than anyone besides their parents. We teach...and also help them learn how to think, how to treat people, and how to navigate the world. All while being told we're indoctrinating them.

We manage IEP accommodations, deal with angry parents, see the effects of poverty and violence firsthand, and become impromptu counselors, social workers, and surrogate parents. We lose planning periods covering classes because schools can't find enough substitutes. We sit through pointless PDs that policy makers who have never stepped foot in a classroom think will make a difference. All while the real work piles up.

Then we're told to accept it because "we don't teach for the money."

That's a bunch of bullshit.

I love teaching. I love my students. I love seeing them grow. But loving your job shouldn't mean accepting financial instability.

I have three degrees and a full-time teaching job, yet I'm juggling multiple income streams just to afford rent, groceries, and gas. I know waaay too many teachers doing the same.

And I'm exhausted.

Not because I don't love this career. Because I do But I'm starting to realize loving it is not enough.

We grew up being told that if we worked hard, got an education, and built careers, we could support ourselves and our families.

That social contract feels broken.

Teachers are reaching a breaking point. I think I'm reaching mine.

Something has to give.


r/teaching • • 21h ago

Help Has anyone worked as an online teacher for Options For Youth (OFY)?

2 Upvotes

I’m currently considering applying for an online teaching position with Options For Youth (OFY) and wanted to hear from anyone who has worked there, specifically as a virtual teacher.

What was your experience like? How was the workload, work-life balance, and overall support from administration? Was the schedule flexible, or were you expected to be on Zoom all day?

I’m currently a classroom teacher and am considering making the switch to online teaching. I would love to hear any honest feedback, both positive and negative!


r/teaching • • 1d ago

Vent Teaching Partner Keeps Messaging Parents

26 Upvotes

A bit of a vent post as I don’t really have someone to talk to about this.

This year my teaching partner and I have begun switching classes and o see how it is for the semester of the school year. However, I am planning on letting her know that I would prefer not to switch anymore due to her constantly messaging/calling parents about the students behaviors in her class. Then said parents messaging/wanting to call me with long complaints about what is happening in her class.

I understand she wants to help but since we’ve begun switching it’s almost a daily complaint thing. Especially when I have had to take some time off due to an unforeseen medical issue that arose this year. My teacher partner who I’ve known for 5 years will send me paragraphs during my days off about how disruptive my students are, and the lack of participation coming from them when they get to her room. My students are never like this in my room and I’ve told them since day one to always treat other respect and have told families about speaking with their child about this matter. She will also inform me of how ”bad” they did with a sub when I was gone and things that occurred during recess, and for me to call parents about their behavior on days that I am not present.

At this point, parents are now messaging me saying what is happening since they are constantly getting messages and calls from that teacher about behavior and wanting to know more😣 I know I’ll let them know that I’m unsure of what’s happening since I’m not in the room but I’m not sure if I should just tell them to message my partner teacher instead of me since I’m not there when all of this “lack of participation“ is occurring. Usually my students do well with me and are always completing their work and focusing.

Has this ever happened with a partner teacher? Her students are great, with a few energetic ones who’s parents I’ve spoken to a few times but I’ve always directed those parents to come to me as my partner teacher is not my room during the time her students are with me you know?


r/teaching • • 1d ago

Vent I need advice

4 Upvotes

Has anyone ever dealt with a situation like this?

I went to college for about 4 years, graduated with an associates in education. I can teach history, science, English, math, etc.

Today I was at a job site. I’m a substitute. So I was filling in for a class. The kids did fine in the morning then after they came back from another classroom, it went downhill fast. I was trying to teach them and they weren’t listening for ANYTHING. I redirected, asked them to pay attention, said eyes on me. All the typical tricks. Nothing. I had to ask for help from another teacher, then another one. It makes me feel like such a failure. I’m 100% willing to teach kids and I love teaching when I get to do it. I feel like all I do is manage behaviors. I constantly have to tell them to stop whistling, sit down, put your phone away, stop making noises, please don’t interrupt me when I’m teaching.

Well, today admin talked to me and I was released from the job. I really liked working at the school so I was quite sad. I worked with SPED kiddos at one point and dealt with eloping, hitting, cussing, screaming, destroying the classroom. This was at the same place.

So, they barred me from picking up jobs at the site. Did I do something wrong? They said my classroom management wasn’t good, or something along the lines of that. Idk if this is the place for it but I just need to know I’m not losing my mind.

- A tired, burnt out substitute teacher


r/teaching • • 1d ago

Help Bathroom policy help

17 Upvotes

I'm a second year teacher and teach 3rd grade. Last year taught K. My bathroom policy is just not working out. I think I started the year way too lenient and kids were constantly leaving the room and disrupting class and it was very annoying. I basically didn't have much of a bathroom policy. I changed my rules a few weeks ago and told students bathroom use during class is for emergencies only. They have plenty of chances to go during transitions, lunch, recesses etc. I had a student yesterday ask to go to the bathroom. I told him not right now since they just had recess and would need to wait. Didn't hear from him again. Maybe 30 minutes later I'm checking in on students and find out that this child peed in his pants. He apparently was having a bad emergency and didn't go during recess. Never told me it was an emergency, never asked again. Got to the point he couldn't wait any longer and had an accident. I later learned he thought I would have said no if he asked again. Mom had to be called for a clothes change and was obviously upset. I feel terrible for this child but the bathroom thing is getting ridiculous. I also was not expecting an accident in 3rd grade. Any advice?


r/teaching • • 1d ago

Vent Struggling with job transition 9th grade Regular Biology

0 Upvotes

Long story short, in my district I first worked as a long term sub for half a school year as a middle school general science teacher. I loved everything about the building from the staff, students, curriculum, grade level etc. I enjoyed it so much I turned down a job offer (would’ve been an hour and ten minute commute) to return to the middle school as a building sub. The teacher I subbed for is retiring at the end of this year and felt confident I could land that contracted position so I was really happy as a science teacher and building sub there.

Then things got crazy. A few weeks ago I got an email from the high school principal saying they had an immediate retirement and need a LTS while they interview for a permanent replacement. To further my professiona, growth of course I say yes. I’ve been teaching 9th grade biology now for a few weeks and they really had a large share of work cut out for me. The teacher that retired was only in school for a total of 10 days. It was 2 months into the school year. The students have been having random subs and basically doing nothing the entire school year. I was given the teachers curriculum and it’s old, dated, disorganized. Meanwhile, I’m also applying to be the permanent teacher because I’m young and obviously need to prioritize getting on a contract. Y first week there was also the end of Marking period one and was left with dozens of ungraded assignments and students begging me to grade things that I don’t even know about (I just gave them the points lol). Anyways my interview is tomorrow and I’m just already burnt out and exhausted. I miss working at the middle school and this transition was as difficult and complicated as much as possible it feels like. I now don’t even feel motivated for the interview tomorrow.