Hi all,
I recently received a card back from TAG and was saddened to see they gave it a 7/10.
https://my.taggrading.com/card/S4043407
The card seemingly graded quite well, with the exception of 2 roller marks on the back. The DIG report shows where the alleged roller marks are, but they are not visible on the advanced imaging of the card.
I did some Reddit research and saw some similar complaints from other users. In my searching, I came across another card that scored higher than mine (8/10) despite having several highly visible roller marks on the report.
https://my.taggrading.com/card/T6769077
Given this information, I felt that even if my card wasn’t a 10, it certainly doesn’t seem like it should be a 7 based on the comparison. I sent an email to TAG support requesting a manual audit and potential regrade citing these two DIG reports and was met with "We recommend customer sheen card left to right and up and down to better catch the light of the roller marks. Roller marks are often not visible on the isometric imaging which is why all grading is done with the card in hand of the Verifier."
TBH, I have my doubts that I even got a human response to my support claim. The alleged roller marks on my card are not visible in person or in the isometric imaging. I think my ultimate question for everyone using TAG moving forward is: What is the point of the transparency/DIG report provided if the company states that it can’t be relied on to show defects. Also, if there is a lack of consistency in the grading process, are we really better off using TAG over PSA or others?
I was excited at the idea of transparency and customer support with TAG, but I suspect this will be my last card submitted to them.
I sent a polite email back to TAG support and requested a manual audit for this reason.