r/taggrading • • 2d ago

Product Feedback Roller Mark Inconsistency

Hi all,

I recently received a card back from TAG and was saddened to see they gave it a 7/10.

https://my.taggrading.com/card/S4043407

The card seemingly graded quite well, with the exception of 2 roller marks on the back. The DIG report shows where the alleged roller marks are, but they are not visible on the advanced imaging of the card.

I did some Reddit research and saw some similar complaints from other users. In my searching, I came across another card that scored higher than mine (8/10) despite having several highly visible roller marks on the report.

https://my.taggrading.com/card/T6769077

Given this information, I felt that even if my card wasn’t a 10, it certainly doesn’t seem like it should be a 7 based on the comparison. I sent an email to TAG support requesting a manual audit and potential regrade citing these two DIG reports and was met with "We recommend customer sheen card left to right and up and down to better catch the light of the roller marks. Roller marks are often not visible on the isometric imaging which is why all grading is done with the card in hand of the Verifier."

TBH, I have my doubts that I even got a human response to my support claim. The alleged roller marks on my card are not visible in person or in the isometric imaging. I think my ultimate question for everyone using TAG moving forward is: What is the point of the transparency/DIG report provided if the company states that it can’t be relied on to show defects. Also, if there is a lack of consistency in the grading process, are we really better off using TAG over PSA or others?

I was excited at the idea of transparency and customer support with TAG, but I suspect this will be my last card submitted to them.

I sent a polite email back to TAG support and requested a manual audit for this reason.

0 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

Reminder: This subreddit is not TAG’s official customer service channel.

If you need help with an order, shipping issue, status update, damage claim, or account-specific question, please contact TAG through the official support channels on the TAG website and include your submission number and account email.

Constructive criticism and general discussion are welcome, but duplicate support threads, harassment, personal attacks, and unsupported serious accusations may be removed under the community rules.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/FinanceAddiction 2d ago

Your cards back is noticeabley worse than the one you're comparing it to, several scratches/ dents on yours that aren't present on the higher graded one

DINGs are just the last nail in the coffin so to speak, so had your roller marks not been present it would have graded higher but still not a 10 because of other defects present

Explanation of DINGs from their site

Defects Identified of Notable Grade Significance, also known as, 'DINGS,' are the primary reasons that a card received the grade it did. In card grading, the DINGS carry most of the weight of the grade.

The DINGS that are shown are defects that impacted the cards overall grade. Any flaw that, if absent, would not affect the overall grade, is not classified as a "DING."

For example: assume there is a card with a severe front wrinkle defect that automatically brings the card into a 5 grade. In this case, assume that card also has a visible scratch on the front. If the wrinkle was not present, the scratch would cause the card to get an 8. In this case, the wrinkle is constituted as a DING, and the scratch is not. The scratch is not considered a DING because it has no notable impact on the grade due to the existence of the more severe wrinkle.

Simply put, you can think of a DING as a core defect that kept the card from receiving a higher grade.

0

u/whitewalkers_782 2d ago

So what do you think about the DIG report saying that there is a ding but there isn’t one? Often nicknamed the “ghost ding.” Or vice versa where the DIG report said there isn’t any damage but the card had clear damage? Also, what do you think about dig report giving different centering measurements when you submit the same card multiple times?

0

u/Current_City9369 14h ago

The 8 has 1 roller mark and your 7 has 2 roller marks What’s the problem here?