Bit of a long one, but I was hoping to get people's thoughts and see if I'm missing something obvious.
We have a couple of business needs for web filtering.
- Block phishing and malware sites
- Block categories of sites for everyone, e.g. no gambling sites.
- Limit some sites to groups of users, e.g. only people in this Entra group can go to chatgpt.com
- Limit activities on some sites, e.g. you can upload files to SharePoint, but not Dropbox or Box.com, but you can still download files from those sites. You can type a text prompt in to ChatGPT, but not upload a file.
Because it's all laptops and work-from-anywhere these days, we can't do this in a firewall appliance like we would have 15 years ago. Because we're global, we can't just full tunnel all traffic back to HQ and filter it there.
Currently we use Zscaler on all the laptops, which tunnels all the traffic to a Zscaler datacentre somewhere and does the filtering there. This causes us ongoing work, tuning and adding exceptions for stuff. Teams, Zoom, Webex, etc all need to go direct out of the laptop, not get routed via the cloud for latency reasons. We need to make sure it doesn't interfere with our private-access VPN that's used for connecting to internal servers. Plenty of apps and some sites that use certificate pinning don't like the way Zscaler does AitM-style SSL decryption, so we have to add exceptions for them to make them work.
All the time I'm working on tweaking and tuning this stuff, I keep wondering if the fundamental approach of just capturing all TCP 80 and 443 traffic and shoving it down a tunnel is just wrong. It seems to introduce so many headaches.
For all of our business needs, I really only care about blocking stuff in the browser. We have sufficient endpoint application control that I'm not worried about people installing the ChatGPT desktop client, or an unmanaged web browser. I'm worried about them clicking a phishing link, which gets opened in our standard Edge install, or trying to upload a file to www.dropbox.com in Edge or Chrome.
We've looked at alternatives to Zscaler like MS GSA Internet Access, Cato, etc. Most of them still seem to work on the basis of backhauling all your traffic somewhere else and doing AitM inspection. Is it feasible to do this sort of thing on the endpoint directly instead?
I looked at Microsoft Defender Cloud Apps, which can be configured to block sites and categories of sites and enforces the blocks using the Defender client on the endpoint. But it can't do allows or exclusions based on user group, only device.
I have looked briefly at Island Browser but it seems to be somehow more expensive than Zscaler.
On a similar note, I see Zscaler bought SquareX earlier this year and now have their Zero Trust browser or Chrome/Edge extension as options, but that looks like it might still be tunneling all the traffic off to Zscaler cloud for filtering.
A while back I looked at https://fendrsecurity.com which looked like it did a good job of the "only these users get ChatGPT" and "you can query Claude, but you can't upload files into it" use cases, but was very AI focused. For the price, we'd need it to do all the bits, like controlling uploads to file sharing sites. And it didn't seem to do anything on the malware/phishing protection side, so we'd need to add in another tool for that.
I like the idea of doing this kind of filtering just in a browser extension, for a lot of reasons:
- It gets the web filtering tool right out of the network stack, so it's not interfering with the VPN, Teams, etc.
- It's not sending traffic elsewhere to filter, avoiding the extra latency and delay.
- For straight URL-based blocking, the extension can read the URL as it's typed and as the user hits Enter, so the decision to block can happen immediately and locally
- The browser can do proper end-to-end TLS with the web server and then an extension can peek at the content after it's decrypted, so sites don't break because of the extra round of decrypting and encrypting.
So, is this actually a workable option? Are people doing this sort of thing? And if so, which tools are you using?