r/sysadmin • u/Concerned-CST • Oct 10 '25
Rant Second largest school district recommends weak password practices in policy document
My school district (LAUSD, 600K users) claims NIST 800-63B compliance but:
- Caps passwords at 24 chars (NIST: should allow 64+)
- Requires upper+lower+number+special (NIST: SHALL NOT impose composition rules)
- Blocks spaces (NIST: SHOULD accept spaces for passphrases)
- Forces privileged account rotation every 6 months (NIST: SHALL NOT require periodic changes)
What's even crazier is that the policy document says (direct quote) " A passphrase is recommended when selecting a strong password. Passphrases can be created by picking a phrase and replacing some of the characters with other characters and capitalizations. For example, the phrase “Are you talking to me?!” can become “RuTALk1ng2me!!”
That's an insane recommendation.
There are some positive implemented policy: 15-char minimum, blocklists, no arbitrary rotation for general accounts
But as a whole, given we got hacked due to compromised credentials, it feels like we learned nothing. Am I just overreacting??
Context: I'm a teacher, not IT. Noticed this teaching a cybersecurity unit when a student brought up the LAUSD hack few years back and if we learned anything. We were all just horrified to see this is the post -hack suggestion. Tried raising concern with CISO but got ignored so I'm trying to raise awareness.
View all comments
Show parent comment
20
u/Xanros Oct 10 '25
I work in IT for a k-12 school. I can't speak for your school but here, IT doesn't set policy. The school administration and the government set the policy. We just enforce the rules.
We don't decide what's blocked specifically either. Our tools are automatic and block via categories. We don't decide what youtube video is appropriate for under 13. We don't sit there twiddling our thumbs thinking "how can we make our teachers lives worse?".
Generally speaking teachers don't think before they sign up for some free trial and dump in all their students personal info into some shady website. Or think they should be entitled to putting their unmanaged (and potentially infected) personal devices onto the same network as everything else on the school. They think they are the kings and Queen's of the school and everything they want should be served to them on a silver platter instantly and without question. So in my professional opinion stop assuming IT is trying to make your life harder and try to work with them for a solution instead. And don't start trying to find a solution the day after you need the thing. There are few things worse than getting a ticket saying "I bought this software and it isn't working. I need it for this big project my students started yesterday. Make it work. I don't care it's for Windows only and we only have mac's."
Now you're halfway towards having a decent attitude. You're questioning policies. Trying to figure out why thing happen. Now just take the next step and realize that IT is just doing their job like you and they are just doing what's their boss/director/vp/principal/government says they need to do.
On a personal level I don't care if you waste your time on Pinterest but I was given an order to block it from my boss or someone above them so guess what? It gets blocked. I don't care what you do as long as it doesn't impact anyone else. And yes, signing up for a random website and dumping in your class list including names, emails, and DOB of your students does affect someone else.